sunny.png
Wednesday May 22nd, 2019 2:54PM

NCAA goes back to court, defending its amateurism rules

By The Associated Press

The NCAA will be back in court Tuesday in California, defending its amateurism rules against plaintiffs who say capping compensation at the value of a scholarship violates federal antitrust law.

The claim against the NCAA and the 11 conferences that have participated at the highest level of college football was originally brought by former West Virginia football player Shawne Alston and later merged with similar lawsuits, including a notable case brought by former Clemson football player Martin Jenkins.

Plaintiffs say the NCAA illegally restricts schools from compensating football and basketball players beyond what is traditionally covered by a scholarship. That includes tuition, room and board and books, plus a cost of attendance stipend to cover incidentals such as travel. The plaintiffs want compensation to be determined conference-by-conference in the hopes of creating a free market.

"The court has already ruled in our favor that the caps on compensation are anti-competitive and are a restrain on trade," said Steve Berman, a Seattle-based lawyer who is one of the lead attorneys for the plaintiffs. "Normally, firms with market power can't agree to set prices. In this case the price being payments to athletes. Now it's the NCAA's burden at this trial to show that the restraint is justified by some pro-competitive justification."

The NCAA counters that altering amateurism rules would lead to pay-for-play, fundamentally damaging college sports and harming academic integration of athletes.

"As was demonstrated in the O'Bannon case, the NCAA will show that our rules are essential to providing educational opportunities to hundreds of thousands of student-athletes across the country," NCAA general counsel Donald Remy said in a statement.

"We are proud that many student-athletes can receive a college education debt-free, access to resources that ensure greater academic success, and an experience that will pay dividends for a lifetime. Allowing paid professionals to replace student-athletes on college campuses would change the face of college sports as we know it."

The bench trial will be heard and decided by Judge Claudia Wilken of the Northern District of California in Oakland. Wilken is the same judge who ruled on the so-called O'Bannon case, which challenged the NCAA's right to use athletes' names, images and likenesses without compensation. The case produced a mixed ruling that eventually went to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Wilken ruled schools should be permitted, but not required, to compensate athletes for use of their name, image and likeness, with payments capped at $5,000 per year. The appeals court overturned that and said payments "untethered" to education were not required by schools.

Wilken also ruled the NCAA is required to allow schools to factor in their federally determined cost of attendance into the value of an athletic scholarship. That is now common practice in major college sports, though schools were already moving toward NCAA legislation allowing for cost of attendance when Wilken made her ruling.

The plaintiffs will argue implementation of cost-of-attendance stipends prove paying athletes even more would not hurt college sports.

"This shows that fans don't really care about payments to student-athletes," Berman said. "As for academic integration, that is a falsity as athletes aren't integrated now and indeed schools are building lavish factices where they say the athlete never has to leave. Check out the YouTube video of the new Clemson facility."

The Alston case is set to last about two weeks and Wilken's ruling could come as soon as December or possibly January. But don't expect it to end there.

"Judge Wilken has shown less deference to the NCAA than most judges, but this case and the fate of the NCAA's economic model will likely ultimately rest in the hands of the Ninth Circuit and the Supreme Court," said Gabe Feldman, director of Tulane University's sports law program.

___

More AP college football: https://apnews.com/tag/Collegefootball and https://twitter.com/AP_Top25

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP Online Basketball, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, College Sports, AP Business, AP Sports - College Football, AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Saban makes official what "everybody knows": It's Tua's job
Nick Saban made official what most college football observers already assumed: Tua Tagovailoa is Alabama's starting quarterback
2:58PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Steelers RB Bell a no-show as opener vs. Browns looms
The Pittsburgh Steelers are beginning preparations for their Week 1 opener against Cleveland without All-Pro running back Le'Veon Bell. Bell has yet to sign his one-year franchise tender, leaving his status for Sunday's visit to the Browns in doubt
2:57PM ( 9 minutes ago )
German authorities take aim at far-right party's youth wing
German authorities announced efforts Monday to tighten their surveillance of the far-right party Alternative for Germany, or AfD, amid growing concern that it is closing ranks with extremist groups
2:50PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Real Madrid teen bitten on head in youth game
Real Madrid's Brazilian teenager Vinicius Junior bitten on head in youth game
2:18PM ( 49 minutes ago )
The Latest: Djokovic's 4th-round US Open match set to start
The Latest: Novak Djokovic's 4th-round U.S. Open match is set to start
2:15PM ( 51 minutes ago )
The Latest: Nishikori into quarterfinals in US Open return
The Latest: 2014 runner-up Nishikori into quarterfinals in US Open return
1:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
Mighty Fine: North Texas QB completes nation-best 40 passes
North Texas' Mason Fine, nation's top returning passer, is off to another impressive start
3:36AM ( 11 hours ago )
No. 25 LSU off and running with 33-17 win over No. 8 Miami
Nick Brossette ran for 125 yards with two touchdowns, grad transfer quarterback Joe Burrow was solid in his first college start and No. 25 LSU made a season-opening statement with a 33-17 win over No. 8 Miami
1:08AM ( 13 hours ago )
Gruden explains Raiders' decision to trade Khalil Mack
Jon Gruden wanted to coach Khalil Mack, but he believes trading him was the right move for the Raiders
9:37PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Online Football
Tottenham's Son avoids military duty with Asian Games gold
Tottenham forward Son Heung-min will get to skip military service after winning a gold medal with South Korea at the Asian Games
12:54PM ( 2 days ago )
The Latest: Isaiah Thomas says Franklin 'shifted the world'
The Latest: Former NBA star Isaiah Thomas eulogized Aretha Franklin as someone who offered her advice and friendship and someone who "shifted the universe."
5:04PM ( 2 days ago )
NBA player J.R. Smith charged with breaking fan's phone
NBA player J.R. Smith has been accused of breaking the cellphone of a fan who tried to take video of him in the middle of the night on a New York City street
4:13PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Basketball
Will Joe run? Biden feels the push to take on Trump in 2020
Will Joe run? Biden is feeling the push to take on Trump, and sizing up the 2020 competition
2:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
$30 million poured into effort to energize young voters
The liberal group NextGen America is pouring more than $30 million into an effort to mobilize young voters in battleground states
12:13PM ( 2 hours ago )
Iraq's new parliament meets as rival blocs vie for majority
Iraq's newly-elected parliament is meeting for the first time as rival factions compete over the right to name a new government
11:27AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: British envoy says Myanmar case hurt rule of law
Britain's ambassador says the verdict against two Reuters journalists has undermined media freedom in Myanmar
7:05AM ( 8 hours ago )
Kavanaugh's life seems scripted for a Supreme Court role
Kavanaugh's life seems carefully scripted for a Supreme Court role
12:57AM ( 14 hours ago )
Congress must consider Kavanaugh nomination, pay the bills
Top priorities: Congress must consider Kavanaugh nomination, pay the bills
12:24AM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
After familiar loss, Michigan insists things are different
Michigan defensive end Chase Winovich insists this season will be different for Wolverines
12:50PM ( 1 day ago )
Tagovailoa shines, No. 1 Alabama routs Louisville 51-14
Tua Tagovailoa throws for 2 touchdowns, helping No. 1 Alabama open season with 51-14 rout of Louisville
10:41AM ( 1 day ago )
Florida gets Mullen era off to rousing start with 53-6 win
Feleipe Franks threw five touchdowns passes in the first half and Florida got the Dan Mullen era off to rousing start with a 53-6 victory against overmatched Charleston Southern
12:19AM ( 1 day ago )
College Sports
The Latest: Brazil's Temer promises to rebuild museum
Brazilian President Michel Temer says public and private banks and companies have agreed to help rebuild the National Museum that caught fire
12:04PM ( 3 hours ago )
China's JD.com: founder returns to Beijing after US arrest
A Chinese e-commerce giant says its billionaire founder, Liu Qiangdong, has returned to China after earlier being arrested in the U.S. on suspicion of criminal sexual conduct
11:41AM ( 3 hours ago )
Myanmar court sentences Reuters reporters to 7 years in jail
A court in Myanmar has sentenced two Reuters journalists to seven years in prison on charges of illegal possession of official documents
10:35AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
No. 10 Nittany Lions survive 45-38 in OT vs Appalachian St
No. 10 Nittany Lions survive 45-38 in OT vs Appalachian St
7:50PM ( 1 day ago )
Maryland stuns No. 23 Texas 34-29 for interim coach Canada
Maryland emerged from a trying offseason with an emotionally charged 34-29 upset of No. 23 Texas, shaking off a lengthy weather delay to provide Matt Canada a satisfying victory in his debut at the Terrapins' interim coach
6:51PM ( 1 day ago )
Meyer-less No. 5 Ohio State routs Oregon St 77-31 in opener
With coach Urban Meyer serving a suspension, No. 5 Ohio State beat Oregon State 77-31 in the opener for both teams
6:35PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Sports - College Football
RPI replaced with new evaluation tool for NCAA Tournament
The NCAA has a new ranking system to replace RPI when evaluating college basketball teams for the NCAA Tournament
5:21PM ( 1 week ago )
Loyola celebrity nun Sister Jean celebrating 99th birthday
Sister Jean is celebrating her 99th birthday months after gaining national attention as chaplain of the Loyola-Chicago basketball team that reached the NCAA Final Four
12:38PM ( 1 week ago )
UConn greats expect program to climb back to elite status
Don't tell Jim Calhoun or his former players that UConn is no longer an elite basketball program
2:47PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
Saban makes official what "everybody knows": It's Tua's job
Nick Saban made official what most college football observers already assumed: Tua Tagovailoa is Alabama's starting quarterback
2:58PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Steelers RB Bell a no-show as opener vs. Browns looms
The Pittsburgh Steelers are beginning preparations for their Week 1 opener against Cleveland without All-Pro running back Le'Veon Bell. Bell has yet to sign his one-year franchise tender, leaving his status for Sunday's visit to the Browns in doubt
2:57PM ( 9 minutes ago )
German authorities take aim at far-right party's youth wing
German authorities announced efforts Monday to tighten their surveillance of the far-right party Alternative for Germany, or AfD, amid growing concern that it is closing ranks with extremist groups
2:50PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Aaron Judge begins taking cage swings off tee in his rehab
Yankees slugger Aaron Judge took his first swings off a tee since breaking his right wrist July 26, a significant early step in what he hopes is a return to the field in a couple of weeks.
2:49PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Trump attacks union leader on Labor Day
President Donald Trump is starting his Labor Day with an attack on a top union leader
2:34PM ( 33 minutes ago )