Monday October 19th, 2020 10:32PM

Government accuses Harvard of 'outright racial balancing'

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — In its latest push to end the use of race in college admissions, the Trump administration on Thursday accused Harvard University of "engaging in outright racial balancing" and sided with Asian-American students who allege the Ivy League school discriminated against them.

Harvard denied the bias claim and said it would defend the right to consider race as a factor in admissions.

The Justice Department weighed in on a lawsuit filed in 2014 by Students For Fair Admission, which argues that one of the world's most prestigious universities discriminates against academically strong Asian-American applicants in favor of others who may be less qualified.

The agency said in a "statement of interest" that Harvard has failed to demonstrate that it does not discriminate on the basis of race and that its use of personal qualities in determining worthy applicants "may be infected with racial bias."

The Supreme Court permits colleges and universities to consider race in admissions decisions, but says that must be done in a narrowly tailored way to promote diversity and should be limited in time. Schools also bear the burden of showing why their consideration of race is appropriate.

In Harvard's case, Justice Department officials said, the university hasn't explained how it uses race in admissions and has not adopted meaningful criteria to limit the use of race.

"No American should be denied admission to school because of their race," Attorney General Jeff Sessions said.

Sessions said Harvard's use of a "personal rating," which includes highly subjective factors such as being a "good person" or "likability," may be biased against Asian-Americans. Sessions said the school admits that it scores Asian-American applicants lower on personal rating than other students. Sessions also argued that Harvard admissions officers monitor and manipulate the racial makeup of incoming classes.

Harvard said it was disappointed the department was "recycling the same misleading and hollow arguments that prove nothing more than the emptiness of the case against Harvard."

"Harvard does not discriminate against applicants from any group, and will continue to vigorously defend the legal right of every college and university to consider race as one factor among many in college admissions, which the Supreme Court has consistently upheld for more than 40 years," the university said in a statement. "Colleges and universities must have the freedom and flexibility to create the diverse communities that are vital to the learning experience of every student."

Edward Blum, president of the group that sued Harvard, hailed the administration's action. "We look forward to having the gravely troubling evidence that Harvard continues to keep redacted disclosed to the American public in the near future," he said.

The department's court filing opposes Harvard's request to dismiss the suit before trial.

"Harvard's failure to provide meaningful criteria to cabin its voluntary use of race, its use of a personal rating that significantly harms Asian-American applicants' chances of admission and may be infected with racial bias, and the substantial evidence that Harvard is engaging in outright racial balancing each warrant denial" of Harvard's request, the department said.

The department is separately investigating Harvard's admissions policies.

There was no immediate comment on the move from the Education Department.

The filing follows a July decision by the those departments to abandon Obama-era guidelines that instructed universities to consider race in their admissions process to make the student body more diverse. Democrats said the Trump administration was taking away protections for minorities.

The Center for Equal Opportunity, a conservative think tank, cited Harvard's own analysis of its admissions data and said it "demonstrates that being African American, Native American, or Hispanic was a 'plus' factor in the competition for admission, but being Asian American proved to be a 'minus.'"

But Kristen Clarke, president of the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, criticized the Justice Department for "signaling abandonment of the agency's long-standing historical mission of working to address racial discrimination and promote diversity."

She said the department's filing "ignores the well-documented racial bias embedded in grades and standardized test scores."

Shaun Harper, head of the Race and Equity Center at the University of Southern California, said that grades and test scores alone should not be the only factors when deciding whether to admit a student.

"Is the DOJ saying that it is in favor of Harvard being 100 percent Asian-American because if we are looking just at GPAs and test scores, it could very well be that those with the absolute higher scores would be Asian-Americans," Harper said. "Is this what the DOJ is saying it wants?

Several other groups also filed court documents siding with Harvard.

More than 500 scholars who study college access and Asian-American studies asserted that the suit has failed to present any evidence of racial discrimination.

Also siding with Harvard were more than a dozen prominent economics professors from various colleges who defended a study Harvard presented finding no evidence of discrimination. A separate brief supporting Harvard was filed by the Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund and 20 other Asian-American groups.


Binkley reported from Boston.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Report: Chris Berman's wife was intoxicated at time of crash
A state police report has concluded that the wife of longtime ESPN broadcaster Chris Berman had a blood-alcohol level three times the legal limit when she rear-ended another man's car, killing them both
10:24PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Trump cancels pay raise due to federal workers in January
Trump cancels pay raises for most federal employees set to take effect in January, citing budget.
9:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
Man charged with making death threats over Trump editorials
A California man has been charged with threatening to kill Boston Globe employees over the newspaper's coordinated series of editorials condemning President Donald Trump's suggestion that journalists are the enemy
9:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
U.S. News
10 injured after explosion, roof collapse at Chicago plant
Authorities say 10 people were seriously injured when an explosion caused a section of roof to collapse at a Chicago water reclamation plant, trapping two of the injured people inside
10:32PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Mayfield sharp as Browns roll over Lions 35-17
Baker Mayfield threw for 138 yards in a dominant first half for Cleveland, and the Browns wrapped up the preseason with a 35-17 victory over the Detroit Lions
10:27PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Trump stumps for Republican Senate hopeful Braun in Indiana
President Donald Trump is seeking to turn up the pressure on Sen. Joe Donnelly in Indiana, saying the state must defeat the vulnerable Democrat because "Joe's not going to vote for us on anything."
10:18PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump allies fret over West Wing vacancies as threats loom
President Donald Trump's aides and allies are increasingly convinced that the West Wing is wholly unprepared to handle the expected assault from Democrats if they win the House in November
10:02PM ( 45 minutes ago )
At least 4 killed in head-on bus crash in New Mexico
Authorities say at least four people were killed and others were seriously injured in a head-on crash involving a commercial passenger bus and a semi-truck along Interstate 40 in New Mexico, near the Arizona border
9:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Hospital expecting more patients from bus crash
Officials say nine of the passengers from a deadly head-on bus crash in New Mexico are being treated at an Albuquerque hospital
9:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Veteran AP reporter, editor Robert Barr dies at age 71
Robert Barr, a longtime reporter and editor for The Associated Press in London who covered major news events ranging from the Lockerbie bombing in 1988 to the death of Stephen Hawking this year, has died after a brief battle with cancer
7:09PM ( 3 hours ago )
Anger at migrant crime, politicians simmers in German city
Anger over the suspected killing of a man by two refugees has sparked days of protests in this eastern German city, raising fresh concerns about the anti-migrant sentiment that has seen the rise of a far-right party for the first time in decades
6:04PM ( 4 hours ago )
Man charged with making death threats over Trump editorials
Federal prosecutors say a California man has been charged with threatening to kill Boston Globe employees over a Globe-coordinated series of newspaper editorials condemning President Donald Trump's suggestion that journalists are the enemy
5:32PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Wildlife groups scramble for new way to block grizzly hunts
Wildlife advocates scrambled Thursday to find a new way to block grizzly bear hunts set to begin this weekend after a judge said he wouldn't immediately restore federal protections on the bears living in and around Yellowstone National Park
6:09PM ( 4 hours ago )
At least 8 injured after Chicago explosion, roof collapse
Fire crews are responding to a report of people trapped inside a Chicago water reclamation plant after a fire and possible explosion caused the building's roof to collapse
4:48PM ( 5 hours ago )
Judge declines to issue quick ruling on protecting grizzlies
Wildlife advocates have pressed a Montana judge to restore federal protections for a group of about 700 grizzly bears and block hunting that's set to begin this weekend, but the judge says won't make an immediate ruling
4:46PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Mourners remember McCain at Arizona church service
Sen. John McCain was eulogized Thursday as "a true American hero" and a terrible driver with a wicked sense of humor before an estimated 3,500 mourners who crowded into an Arizona church after a motorcade bearing his body past people waving American flags
2:04PM ( 8 hours ago )
Mourners gather for Arizona church service for McCain
People are lining the streets and mourners are gathering at a Baptist church as a motorcade carrying Sen. John McCain's body makes its way from the Arizona Capitol for a second day of memorial services for the maverick politician
1:07PM ( 9 hours ago )
Trump teases about successor to White House counsel
President Donald Trump is teasing that he knows who will succeed White House counsel Don McGahn
12:49PM ( 9 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: Trump again threatens to get involved in DOJ
President Donald Trump is once again threatening to intervene in the Justice Department if it fails to take the actions he's demanding
9:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Trump says Braun will be a 'truly great' senator
President Donald Trump is giving Republican Senate candidate Mike Braun a boost as he campaigns by his side in Indiana
8:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: McCain returns to DC ahead of Capitol ceremony
Sen. John McCain's casket has arrived in Maryland ahead of ceremonies Friday at the U.S. Capitol
7:55PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Pence honors McCain at American Legion gathering
Vice President Mike Pence has paid tribute to the late Sen. John McCain, saying America will always remember his lifetime of service to the United States
2:31PM ( 8 hours ago )
Gillum, Nelson: A team approach for Florida Dems?
Andrew Gillum says he can win the Florida governor's by attracting new voters to the polls instead of simply trying to corral support from the usual electorate
7:06AM ( 15 hours ago )
Top Trump lawyer latest to leave White House
The coming exit of top Trump lawyer McGahn continues the churn of top officials, as the administration sets records for turnover and the White House struggles to fill key vacancies
6:08AM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Canada says trade talks with US still going
Canada's top trade negotiator says she and her U.S. counterpart will be carrying on urgent discussions well into Thursday night to overhaul the North American Free Trade Agreement
9:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
Indian currency decree did little to root out 'black money'
India's central bank says nearly all the currency removed from circulation in a surprise 2016 move to root out untaxed stockpiles of cash re-entered the financial system
9:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
Microsoft to contractors: Give new parents paid leave
Microsoft says it's requiring contractors to offer their employees at least 12 weeks paid leave to care for a new child
6:54PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Man charged with making death threats over Trump editorials
A California man has been charged with threatening to kill Boston Globe employees over the newspaper's coordinated series of editorials condemning President Donald Trump's suggestion that journalists are the enemy
9:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Judge blocks Saturday's grizzly hunts in Wyoming, Idaho
Thx muchoA judge temporarily blocked the opening of the first grizzly bear hunts in Wyoming and Idaho in more than 40 years, as he considers whether the government was wrong to lift federal protections on the animals
8:55PM ( 1 hour ago )
Dallas police group head: Convicted officer held accountable
The head of a Dallas police employee organization says a former suburban officer convicted in the shooting death of an unarmed black teenager was held accountable
8:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump cancels pay raise due to federal workers in January
Trump cancels pay raises for most federal employees set to take effect in January, citing budget.
9:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
Friends call John McCain hero, maverick at Arizona funeral
A former vice president, an NFL star and other friends remembered Sen. John McCain as "a true American hero" as well as a terrible driver with a wicked sense of humor
8:25PM ( 2 hours ago )