rain.png
Wednesday July 17th, 2019 4:42PM

Indian currency decree did little to root out 'black money'

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW DELHI (AP) — Nearly all of the currency removed from circulation in a surprise 2016 attempt to root out illegally hoarded cash re-entered the financial system, India's reserve bank said, indicating the disruptive move did little to slow the underground economy.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi's currency decree, which was designed to destroy the value of billions of dollars in untaxed cash stockpiles, caused an economic slowdown and months of financial chaos for ordinary, cash-dependent Indians.

Modi announced in a November 2016 TV address that all 500-rupee and 1,000-rupee notes, then worth about $7.50 and $15, would be withdrawn immediately from circulation. The banned notes could be deposited into bank accounts but the government also said it would investigate deposits over 250,000 rupees, or about $3,700. The government eventually released new currency notes worth 500 and 2,000 rupees.

In theory, the decree meant corrupt politicians and businesspeople would suddenly find themselves sitting on billions of dollars in worthless currency, known here as "black money."

"A few people are spreading corruption for their own benefit," Modi said in the surprise nighttime speech announcement of the order. "There is a time when you realize that you have to bring some change in society, and this is our time."

But even as the decree caused turmoil for those in India who have always depended on cash — the poor and middle class, and millions of small traders — the rich found ways around the currency switch. In the months after the decree, businesspeople said that even large amounts of banned currency notes could be traded on the black market, though middlemen charged heavy fees.

The reserve bank said in its Wednesday report that 99.3 percent of the $217 billion in notes withdrawn from circulation had been returned. Some officials had originally predicted that number could be as low as 60 percent.

"Frankly, I think demonetization was a mistake," said Gurcharan Das, a writer and the former head of Proctor & Gamble in India. He said that while it did broaden the country's tax base, it was a nightmare for the immense, cash-dependent informal economy.

"You can't overnight change that in a country which is poor and illiterate. Therefore, for me it's not only an economic failure but a moral failure as well," Das said.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
US lawmakers call for China sanctions over Muslim camps
A group of U.S. lawmakers have urged the Trump administration to impose sanctions including asset freezes and visa bans on Chinese officials and companies allegedly tied to the mass internment of ethnic minority Muslims in camps in a far western region
4:03AM ( 26 minutes ago )
China blames local officials for protest over mosque razing
Chinese authorities have blamed a rare public protest by Hui Muslims on local officials' recklessness, but they didn't settle the community's concerns a large mosque in the northwestern region would be razed
3:46AM ( 44 minutes ago )
After church service, McCain to depart Arizona for last time
The celebration of Sen. John McCain's life as a former prisoner of war and maverick politician enters a second day with a church service and a military salute before his casket departs his adopted state of Arizona for the U.S. Capitol
3:34AM ( 55 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Scaffolding collapse sends 2 plunging to deaths near Disney
Officials say they don't know what caused scaffolding to collapse, sending two construction workers falling to their deaths as they were pouring concrete on the seventh floor of a 16-story hotel under construction near Disney World
12:06AM ( 4 hours ago )
Asian stocks mixed as weak dollar weighs on US economic data
Asian stocks mixed as weak dollar shakes positives from US economic data, trade talks with Canada
11:44PM ( 4 hours ago )
'Real hero': Crowds brave Arizona heat to honor John McCain
Thousands of people paid their respects to U.S. Sen. John McCain on Wednesday, standing for hours in the broiling Arizona sun before filing past the flag-draped casket that his tearful wife, Cindy, lovingly pressed her face against
11:14PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
Stocks rise again as technology companies and Amazon jump
Technology companies lead the way as US indexes shake off a slow start and rise for the fourth day in a row
4:38PM ( 11 hours ago )
Canada stunned and worried about Trump trade threats
Canadians are stunned by the repeated broadsides from what has long been their closest ally and some have even begun boycotts
3:46PM ( 12 hours ago )
Britain, Nigeria sign defense pact to counter Boko Haram
Britain, Nigeria sign defense pact to counter Boko Haram, Islamic State-linked extremists
1:42PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Utah biodiesel execs linked to polygamous group due in court
Prosecutors say two executives of a Salt Lake City biodiesel company linked to a polygamous group could flee to Turkey if they are released ahead of trial on charges in a $511 million tax credit scheme
1:42PM ( 14 hours ago )
Global stocks mixed after Wall Street gain
Asian stocks advance, Europe lower after Wall Street gain
6:34AM ( 21 hours ago )
Asian stock markets rise after Wall Street gain
Asian stock markets rise after Wall Street gains
1:04AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Industries
Rebuilding is a struggle after California wine country fires
Homeowners in Northern California wine country are facing a major hurdle to rebuilding after the most destructive set of blazes in state history. Many were underinsured before the 2017 fires and now face delays as they scramble for money to rebuild
2:25PM ( 1 day ago )
California wine country fires leave homeowners struggling
Homeowners in Northern California wine country are still reeling after last year's most destructive set of blazes in state history. Many have found themselves underinsured, which has delayed claims settlements and construction.
1:30AM ( 2 days ago )
Global stocks push higher after Fed's Powell reassures
World stocks rise as Fed's confidence in U.S. growth soothes trade worries
8:08AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
US lawmakers call for China sanctions over Muslim camps
A group of U.S. lawmakers have urged the Trump administration to impose sanctions including asset freezes and visa bans on Chinese officials and companies allegedly tied to the mass internment of ethnic minority Muslims in camps in a far western region
4:03AM ( 27 minutes ago )
China blames local officials for protest over mosque razing
Chinese authorities have blamed a rare public protest by Hui Muslims on local officials' recklessness, but they didn't settle the community's concerns a large mosque in the northwestern region would be razed
3:46AM ( 44 minutes ago )
After church service, McCain to depart Arizona for last time
The celebration of Sen. John McCain's life as a former prisoner of war and maverick politician enters a second day with a church service and a military salute before his casket departs his adopted state of Arizona for the U.S. Capitol
3:34AM ( 56 minutes ago )
Florida's high-stakes race for governor quickly turns nasty
Florida governor's race turns nasty in the hours after a far-left Democrat and a Trump-endorsed Republican win their respective primaries
3:24AM ( 1 hour ago )
Gillum, Nelson: A team approach for Florida Dems?
Andrew Gillum says he can win the Florida governor's by attracting new voters to the polls instead of simply trying to corral support from the usual electorate
3:09AM ( 1 hour ago )