Saturday July 4th, 2020 11:09AM

Experts: Unusual factors in ex-Texas cop's murder conviction

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Every case is unique, as is every jury. But experts say several factors seemed to stack up against former Texas police officer Roy Oliver this week when, in an extremely rare outcome, he was convicted of murder for a shooting that occurred while he was on duty.

Criminal justice experts tell The Associated Press that fewer than 90 officers have been charged with murder or manslaughter for such shootings since 2005. Less than half were convicted or pleaded guilty to lesser charges.

Even more rare is a guilty verdict on a murder charge: That has happened only five other times in the last 13 years in cases involving non-federal law enforcement officers — and four of those convictions were overturned, according to Bowling Green State University criminologist Phil Stinson.

Criminologists have long said jurors are inclined to believe police testimony, and prosecutors have a high bar when trying to convince jurors that a law officer didn't fear for his or her life in the moments before a fatal shooting. But in Oliver's case, experts say, several factors worked against him.

Here is a look at some of those factors and the case:


Dallas County jurors weren't swayed by Oliver's claims that he was protecting his partner when he fired into a car full of black teenagers as it left a house party in Balch Springs last year. The shooting in the Dallas suburb killed 15-year-old Jordan Edwards, who was sitting in the front passenger seat.

The shooting occurred after Oliver, who is white, and his partner responded to reports of underage drinking at the party. Oliver initially said he opened fire as the car aggressively moved toward his partner.

But the police chief later said body camera footage contradicted the officer's version of events. Oliver was fired from the Balch Springs Police Department days later.

On Tuesday, Oliver was convicted of murder. On Wednesday, he was sentenced to 15 years in prison and fined $10,000. His attorneys have said they'll appeal.


University of Pittsburgh law professor David Harris said a major blow to Oliver's case came from his partner, Officer Tyler Gross. Gross told jurors that while responding to the house party, he didn't fear for his life and never felt the need to fire his weapon. He also said he didn't feel like the vehicle that Edwards and his friends were riding in was trying to hit him.

Harris said that likely eroded jurors' trust in Oliver's testimony.

"To have a partner testify differently is an unusual thing to happen in itself, but to have a partner say he wasn't in fear ... that is a major blow to that guy saying he had a reasonable fear for his or his partner's life," Harris said.

Juries in such trials are told they have to consider how police make split-second decisions. Jurors then have to decide whether an officer was fearful in that brief moment, added Cara Rabe-Hemp, a professor of criminal justice at Illinois State University. In Oliver's case, she said, it appeared the jury was not willing to accept the reasonableness of his claim of fear.


Prosecutors also showed jurors the police bodycam video that contradicted Oliver's original version of events, which experts said also likely played a role in the jury's perception of whether Oliver was being truthful about feeling threatened.

Harris said most police departments have some policy prohibiting officers from shooting at moving vehicles because, if the driver is shot, the vehicle can become an unguided missile with no one to stop it. The video showed the car moving away from officers.

"It's a really incredibly reckless thing to do, under the best of circumstances," Harris said.

Officers are often told to move out of the way rather than try to stop a car coming at them. Harris said a jury likely would see Oliver's actions as disregarding safety of others and acting recklessly.


In several cases where officers were charged in fatal shootings, prosecutors had to overcome jurors' tendency to blame the victim if the victim was in the midst of committing a crime or had a criminal history, the experts said.

Rabe-Hemp pointed to the case of Philando Castile, a Minnesota man who was fatally shot after calmly telling an officer that he was legally carrying a gun during a traffic stop in July 2016. Defense attorneys were able to convince a jury that the presence of the weapon caused the officer, Jeronimo Yanez, to react in fear. Yanez was acquitted.

But in Oliver's case, defense attorneys had very little to point to. Edwards was unarmed — investigators found no weapons in the vehicle — and prosecutors told jurors he was an "innocent child" whose last words were "duck, get down."

"It didn't seem reasonable that this officer would be fearful. I think that alone really altered that outcome," Rabe-Hemp said.

Harris said Edwards' age and character also were likely factors in the verdict.

"Every life is valued, but some lives get devalued. It shouldn't be like that, but it is," Harris said. "In this case, you had a 15-year-old kid, who wasn't up to no good. ... In many cases, juries do victim blame. But you couldn't make that happen here."


This story has been corrected to reflect that the name of the school where criminologist Phil Stinson works is Bowling Green State University, not Bowling Green University.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Experts: Unusual factors in ex-Texas cop's murder conviction
Criminal justice experts say murder conviction of ex-Texas police officer for an on-duty shooting was extremely rare, but jurors had some unusual factors to consider
11:27PM ( 3 minutes ago )
White ex-Texas cop gets 15 years in black teenager's death
White former police officer in Texas sentenced to 15 years in prison after being convicted of murder in the shooting of an unarmed, black teenager who was in a car leaving a house party
11:23PM ( 7 minutes ago )
US soldier pleads guilty to trying to help Islamic State
A Hawaii-based soldier is pleading guilty to charges of attempting to support the Islamic State group
11:20PM ( 10 minutes ago )
U.S. News
The Latest: More than 7,500 pay respects to Sen. John McCain
Authorities say more than 7,500 people have paid their respects to U.S. Sen. John McCain at a public viewing at the Arizona Capitol
11:06PM ( 24 minutes ago )
The Latest: American teen Kenin beats No. 30 seed at US Open
The Latest: 19-year-old American Sofia Kenin beats No. 30 seed Maria Sakkari of Greece to reach US Open's 3rd round
11:00PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Kanye West apologizes for saying slavery was 'a choice'
Kanye West apologizes on a Chicago radio station for calling slavery 'a choice'
10:50PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Several in line to honor McCain overcome by heat
Authorities say several people waiting outside the Arizona Capitol to pay their respects to U.S. Sen. John McCain have been overcome by extreme heat
8:57PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: 3 New Mexico compound defendants released
Authorities have confirmed three of the defendants accused of child neglect charges in the New Mexico compound case have been released from jail after a judge dismissed charges against them due to a missed deadline by prosecutors
8:55PM ( 2 hours ago )
UN: Ortega's Nicaraguan govt behind widespread repression
A new U.N. report on four months of unrest in Nicaragua describes a comprehensive government repression effort extending from the streets to the courts
8:52PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Pope's cover-up crisis turns battle lines into first salvo
Pope's cover-up crisis turns ideological battle lines into first salvo
6:02PM ( 5 hours ago )
Trump warns of 'violence' if Republicans lose fall elections
President Donald Trump urged evangelical leaders this week to get-out-the-vote and warned of "violence" if Republicans lose control of Congress
5:46PM ( 5 hours ago )
Racism quickly becomes an issue in Florida governor's race
Florida Democratic nominee for governor Andrew Gillum says Florida will reject racism and misogyny in November, while Republican nominee Ron DeSantis began his campaign by saying voters won't "monkey" up the election by supporting Gillum
5:45PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Utah biodiesel execs linked to polygamous group stay jailed
Prosecutors say two executives of a Salt Lake City biodiesel company linked to a polygamous group could flee to Turkey if they are released ahead of trial on charges in a $511 million tax credit scheme
5:35PM ( 5 hours ago )
Black candidates win primaries for governor in 3 states
Three black candidates will be on the ballot for governor in November, after surviving Democratic primaries in Georgia, Florida and Maryland
5:04PM ( 6 hours ago )
The Latest: Hundreds honor John McCain at public viewing
Several hundred people are paying their respects to Sen. John McCain as they walk by his closed, flag-draped casket at the Arizona Capitol
4:53PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
The Latest: Vietnamese residents pay respects to McCain
A group of more than 80 Vietnamese residents came from Southern California on two buses to pay their respects to the late Sen. John McCain at a public viewing in Arizona
5:28PM ( 6 hours ago )
The Latest: Franklin dressed in blue for last public viewing
The Latest: Second day of Aretha Franklin viewing draws those with personal connections to the Queen of Soul
1:49PM ( 9 hours ago )
Rumors fueled far-right protest after killing in German city
German authorities say far-right protests in the eastern city of Chemnitz were fueled by rumors and false information
1:39PM ( 9 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
White ex-Texas cop gets 15 years in black teenager's death
White former police officer in Texas sentenced to 15 years in prison after being convicted of murder in the shooting of an unarmed, black teenager who was in a car leaving a house party
11:23PM ( 8 minutes ago )
US soldier pleads guilty to trying to help Islamic State
A Hawaii-based soldier is pleading guilty to charges of attempting to support the Islamic State group
11:20PM ( 10 minutes ago )
'Real hero': Crowds brave Arizona heat to honor John McCain
Thousands of people paid their respects to U.S. Sen. John McCain on Wednesday, standing for hours in the broiling Arizona sun before filing past the flag-draped casket that his tearful wife, Cindy, lovingly pressed her face against
11:14PM ( 17 minutes ago )
US leaker Chelsea Manning to be barred from Australia
Convicted leaker Chelsea Manning will not be allowed to enter Australia for a speaking tour scheduled to start Sunday, tour organizer says
11:12PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Review board says Baltimore detective likely killed himself
A review board says the gunshot wound that killed a Baltimore police detective hours before he was to testify about police corruption was most likely self-inflicted
11:06PM ( 24 minutes ago )