Monday March 18th, 2019 10:05PM

Supreme Court's voter roll decision may have limited impact

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

ATLANTA (AP) — A U.S. Supreme Court ruling has cleared the way for states to take a tougher approach to maintaining their voter rolls, but will they?

Ohio plans to resume its process for removing inactive voters, which was affirmed in Monday's 5-4 ruling, after the November elections. It takes a particularly aggressive approach that appears to be an outlier among states.

Few appear eager to follow.

"Our law has been on the books. It hasn't changed, and it isn't changing," said Oklahoma Election Board spokesman Bryan Dean.

At issue is when a state begins the process to notify and ultimately remove people from the rolls after a period of non-voting. In most states with similar laws, like Oklahoma, that process begins after voters miss two or more federal elections.

In Ohio, it starts if voters sit out a two-year period that includes just one federal election. They are removed from the rolls if they fail to vote over the following four years or do not return an address-confirmation card.

Opponents of the laws say their intent is to purge people from the rolls, particularly minorities and the poor who tend to vote Democratic. Supporters say voters are given plenty of chances to keep their active status and that the rules adhere to federal law requiring states to maintain accurate voter rolls.

Democrats and voting rights groups have expressed concern that other states will be emboldened by the ruling and adopt more aggressive tactics to kick voters off the rolls. In addition to Oklahoma, Georgia, Montana, Oregon, Pennsylvania and West Virginia have laws similar to Ohio's.

But even Republican-led states where officials are concerned about voter fraud may be wary when it comes to following the Ohio model.

One hurdle is likely to come from local governments, where election administrators would have to deal with disgruntled voters and manage an increase in the number of people placed on inactive voter lists, said Myrna Perez, who has studied voter list practices in her role as deputy director of the Brennan Center's Democracy Program.

"Using one election as an indicator is going to lead to a whole lot of false positives," she said. "There are plenty of states that clean their voter rolls successfully without being as aggressive as Ohio."

West Virginia is more lenient in targeting inactive voters than Ohio. Among other things, it requires counties in the year following a presidential election to mail an address confirmation to people who have not voted in any election during the previous four years.

Julie Archer of the watchdog West Virginia Citizen Action Group said the process appears to be working as it should.

"There is not a need to do something more aggressive," she said.

The controversy over Ohio's approach arose from apparently conflicting mandates in the National Voter Registration Act, which became law in 1993. It requires states to maintain accurate voter registration lists but also says they should protect against inadvertently removing properly registered voters.

Since 1994, Ohio has used voters' inactivity after two years — encompassing one federal election cycle — to trigger a process that could lead to removal from the voter rolls. That process has been used under both Democratic and Republican secretaries of state, but groups representing voters did not sue until 2016, under current Republican Secretary of State Jon Husted.

The legal action followed what the lawsuit called "a massive statewide purge" of voters in the summer of 2015.

In Pennsylvania, the process isn't triggered unless people have failed to vote for five years, or two general election cycles. The state has no plans to change that, Department of State spokeswoman Wanda Murren said.

The existing system hasn't been drawing complaints, said Ray Murphy, a spokesman for Keystone Votes, a liberal coalition that advocates for changes to Pennsylvania election law. But he said the group will watch the Legislature closely for any signs that lawmakers will want to follow Ohio's more stringent method.

Ballot access is a frequent battleground for Democrats and Republicans, but it's not always a neatly partisan issue.

In Oregon, for example, Republican Secretary of State Dennis Richardson last year expanded the period for removing people from the rolls from five years of non-voting to 10 years.

"A registered voter should not lose their voting rights solely because they haven't participated recently," he said in a written statement following Monday's Supreme Court ruling.


Associated Press writers Tom James in Salem, Oregon; Sean Murphy in Oklahoma City; John Raby in Charleston, West Virginia; Julie Carr Smyth in Columbus, Ohio; and Mark Scolforo in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, contributed to this report.


Follow Christina Almeida Cassidy on Twitter at

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Elections, General Election News, AP Online - Georgia News
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Lawmakers looking at what comes next after Trump-Kim summit
Confusion, skepticism and a bit of optimism are ricocheting around Capitol Hill after President Donald Trump's historic summit with North Korea's Kim Jong Un.
6:48PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Supreme Court's voter roll decision may have limited impact
The U.S. Supreme Court's decision to affirm a tough voter-removal law in Ohio may not have a wide ripple effect in the states
6:46PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Spieth in mini-slump heading to Shinnecock Hills, US Open
Jordan Spieth is in a mini-slump heading to Shinnecock Hills but is optimistic ahead of US Open
6:34PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump sees 'new future' for North Korea, but path unclear
Trump, Kim commit to 'complete denuclearization' amid questions about whether Trump gave away too much
6:13PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Call reveals frantic effort to save Bode Miller's daughter
A 911 call reveals people pleading for help as they try desperately to save Olympic skier Bode Miller's 19-month-old daughter from drowning in a backyard swimming pool
6:02PM ( 47 minutes ago )
APNewsBreak: Border agent shot, wounded on Arizona ranch
The U.S. Border Patrol says one of its agents has been wounded in a shooting in southern Arizona near the U.S.-Mexico border
5:52PM ( 58 minutes ago )
AP National News
North Dakota's Cramer faces primary ahead of Heitkamp match
North Dakota Rep. Kevin Cramer carries the hopes of Republicans for a big Senate pickup this fall
6:13PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Mueller worries Russia could use court case to spy on probe
Special counsel Robert Mueller's team is worried that Russian intelligence services will use a criminal case in Washington to gather information about its investigation
5:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Democrats in tight primary contest for Nevada governor nod
Nevada voters are deciding a competitive Democratic primary race for governor Tuesday, a contest that became the state's most closely watched after President Donald Trump helped clear a likely path to the GOP nomination for vulnerable Sen. Dean Heller
5:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
In pro-Trump ND, Democrat Heitkamp has no time for resisting
Sen. Heidi Heitkamp, a first term Democrat running for re-election in North Dakota, is walking a fine line between her pro-President Donald Trump record and her Democratic leanings, but she dismisses her party's resistance movement as unproductive.
12:43PM ( 3 days ago )
Ex-Colorado official: No bias in same-sex wedding cake case
A former Colorado civil rights commissioner whose remarks on religion were the basis of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling for a baker who refused to make a wedding cake for a gay couple insists she has no religious bias
5:00PM ( 6 days ago )
Things to Know: 8 states cast midterm primary votes Tuesday
Eight states cast midterm primary ballots, with implications for control of the House and Senate and for several governor's races
2:27AM ( 6 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Polls open as Nevada voters weigh familiar names in primary
Nevada's Dean Heller is considered the vulnerable Republican senator seeking re-election this year, but he has an easy primary battle Tuesday thanks to President Donald Trump
11:05AM ( 7 hours ago )
Nevada tea party favorite Angle makes longshot primary bid
Tea party favorite Sharron Angle is trying Tuesday to unseat the incumbent Republican in the GOP's strongest congressional district in Nevada, where two other Democrat-held open seats will be up for grabs in November
10:49AM ( 8 hours ago )
Trump a factor in SC races as 5 states hold primaries
Trump figures to be a factor in Republican elections in South Carolina, one of five states holding primaries
7:47AM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Elections
Election to give New Mexico district its first congresswoman
Female candidates are slated to make history in a closely watched Congressional race in New Mexico
7:13PM ( 4 days ago )
Prospect of Native congresswoman galvanizes American Indians
Native Americans from Washington state to Oklahoma are celebrating the possibility of the first American Indian woman in Congress
2:37AM ( 5 days ago )
Will Paul Ryan's retirement be a chance to change the House?
A bipartisan group is urging lawmakers to seize on Speaker Paul Ryan's upcoming retirement as a chance at meaningful changes, and says House members should use their influence to demand changes that would make governing less partisan.
5:09PM ( 6 days ago )
General Election News
Spieth in mini-slump heading to Shinnecock Hills, US Open
Jordan Spieth is in a mini-slump heading to Shinnecock Hills but is optimistic ahead of US Open
6:34PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Don't tell Koepka that Shinnecock and Erin Hills different
Brooks Koepka scoffs when told this week's U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills will be a far different challenge than the tournament he won last year at Erin Hills
6:32PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Julio Jones misses Falcons' minicamp but has Quinn's support
Julio Jones remains in coach Dan Quinn's good graces even after the wide receiver missed the opening day of the Falcons' mandatory minicamp
6:27PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Frustrated AMA adopts sweeping policies to cut gun violence
The American Medical Association has adopted sweeping measures aimed at reducing gun violence, a problem it considers a public health crisis.
6:24PM ( 26 minutes ago )
How do you count deaths from a hurricane?
Puerto Rico's hurricane death count revives debate about how to count disaster-related deaths
6:24PM ( 26 minutes ago )