Sunday August 18th, 2019 12:01PM

Trump seems likely to win travel ban case at Supreme Court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump appears likely to win his travel ban case at the Supreme Court.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Anthony Kennedy both signaled support for the travel policy in arguments Wednesday at the high court. The ban's challengers almost certainly need one of those two justices if the court is to strike down the ban on travelers from several mostly Muslim countries.

The travel ban case is the court's first comprehensive look at a Trump policy — one of considerable importance to the president and highly controversial since it was first rolled out a week after Trump took office.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor was the most aggressive questioner of Solicitor General Noel Francisco in his defense of the Trump policy, and the three other liberal justices also raised questions about it.

The justices voted in December to allow the policy to take full effect pending their full consideration. Wednesday was the first time they took it up in open court.

The Trump administration is asking the court to reverse lower court rulings that would strike down the ban.

The Supreme Court is considering whether the president can indefinitely keep people out of the country based on nationality. It is also looking at whether the policy is aimed at excluding Muslims from the United States. A decision is expected by late June.

Kennedy challenged lawyer Neal Katyal, representing the policy's opponents, about whether the ban would be unending. He said the policy's call for a report every six months "indicates there'll be a reassessment" from time to time.

"You want the president to say, 'I'm convinced that in six months we're going to have a safe world,'" Kennedy said, seemingly rejecting Katyal's argument.

His only question that seemed to favor the challengers came early in the arguments, when he asked Francisco whether Trump's campaign trail call to keep Muslims from entering the United States should be considered in evaluating the administration's ban. Francisco told the justices that they shouldn't look at Trump's campaign statements.

Kennedy pressed on that point. Speaking of a hypothetical "local candidate," he asked if what was said during the candidate's campaign was irrelevant if on "day two" of his administration the candidate acted on those statements.

Francisco held his ground saying the presidential oath of office "marks a fundamental transformation."

From the other side, Sotomayor told Francisco she doubted that the president has "the authority to do more than Congress has already decided is adequate" under immigration law. She and Justice Elena Kagan also questioned Francisco closely about whether the ban discriminates against Muslims.

With Katyal at the lectern, Justice Samuel Alito said it seemed wrong to call the travel policy a Muslim ban when it applies to just five of 50 mostly Muslim countries, 8 percent of the world's Muslim population and just one country — Iran — among the 10 largest with Muslim majorities. "Would a reasonable observer think this is a Muslim ban?" Alito asked.

People waited in line for seats for days, and on Wednesday morning opponents of the ban demonstrated outside the court holding signs that read "No Muslim Ban. Ever" and "Refugees Welcome," among other things. In another sign of heightened public interest, the court took the rare step of making an audio recording of the proceedings available. The last time the court did that was for gay marriage arguments in 2015.

The justices are looking at the third version of a policy that Trump first rolled out a week after taking office, triggering chaos and protests across the U.S. as travelers were stopped from boarding international flights and detained at airports for hours. The first version was blocked by courts and withdrawn. Its replacement was allowed to take partial effect, but expired in September.

The current version is indefinite and now applies to travelers from five countries with overwhelmingly Muslim populations — Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen. It also affects two non-Muslim countries, blocking travelers from North Korea and some Venezuelan government officials and their families. A sixth majority-Muslim country, Chad, was removed from the list this month after improving "its identity-management and information sharing practices," Trump said in a proclamation.

Trump's campaign pledge to shut down Muslims' entry into the U.S., his presidential tweets about the travel ban and last fall's retweets of inflammatory videos that stoked anti-Islam sentiment all preceded the justices' questioning of Francisco, defending the ban, and Katyal, the former acting solicitor general under President Barack Obama.

The administration has argued that courts have no role to play because the president has broad powers over immigration and national security, and foreigners have no right to enter the country. Francisco also has said in written arguments that Trump's September proclamation laying out the current policy comports with immigration law and does not violate the Constitution because it does not single out Muslims.

The challengers, backed by a diverse array of supporting legal briefs, have said that Trump is flouting immigration law by trying to keep more than 150 million people, the vast majority of them Muslim, from entering the country. They also argue that his policy amounts to the Muslim ban that he called for as a candidate, violating the Constitution's prohibition against religious bias.

The case is Trump v. Hawaii, 17-965.


Associated Press writer Jessica Gresko contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Local/State News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, AP World News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Germans don skullcaps to protest anti-Semitism
Germans of various faiths donned Jewish skullcaps and took to the streets in several cities to protest an anti-Semitic attack in Berlin and express fears about growing hatred of Jews in the country
12:02PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Macron tells Congress of 'special' US-French bond
French President Emmanuel Macron extolled the "special bond" between the United States and France during his speech in front of a joint meeting of Congress
12:01PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Police: Man killed deputy, stole his car and robbed store
Maine authorities are searching for a man believed to be armed and dangerous who they say fatally shot a sheriff's deputy, stole his cruiser and robbed a convenience store
11:58AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
EPA security chief also worked for owner of tabloid company
Security chief for the head of the EPA has worked on the side as a private investigator for the owner of a tabloid news company with close ties to Trump
11:32AM ( 32 minutes ago )
Latest: Mayor: Dallas police officer dies day after shooting
The mayor of Dallas says a police officer has died a day after a shooting that also wounded another officer and a home improvement store employee
11:29AM ( 35 minutes ago )
Trump travel ban is focus of Supreme Court's last arguments
President Donald Trump's ban on travelers from mostly Muslim countries is the focus of the last scheduled arguments in front of the Supreme Court this term
11:15AM ( 49 minutes ago )
AP National News
Jury to deliberate after Cosby painted as predator, victim
Jurors at Bill Cosby's sexual assault retrial are poised to start deliberating after a marathon day of closing arguments
9:12AM ( 2 hours ago )
APNewsBreak: Hoops panel says ban cheats, end 1-and-done
A panel tasked with reforming college basketball says the NCAA should work to end the one-and-done era and punish coaches and programs that cheat more harshly
9:11AM ( 2 hours ago )
Waffle House suspect's ex-bosses asked FBI to keep, help him
The co-owner of a Colorado crane company where the suspect in a deadly weekend shooting at a Nashville restaurant once worked says she had urged federal officials to keep him in custody after he was arrested at the White House last year
7:53AM ( 4 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Thousands protest in Armenia as political talks called off
Armenia's acting prime minister says talks with the opposition have been called off because of "preconditions and demands" from the opposition
11:14AM ( 51 minutes ago )
Melania Trump takes her moment to sparkle in the spotlight
The state dinner at the White House was a big moment in fashion and in public life for first lady Melania Trump
10:57AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Emmert hopes NCAA can enact changes by August
NCAA President Mark Emmert hopes legislation to implement some recommendations made by the Commission on College Basketball can be voted on in August
10:31AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Russia's Supreme Court rules against Navalny
Russia's Supreme Court has upheld a criminal conviction of opposition leader Alexei Navalny and his brother
10:38AM ( 1 hour ago )
Democrat vying for House upset in Arizona GOP stronghold
Emergency room physician Dr. Hiral Tipirneni hopes to ride wave of Democratic victories in bid for House seat in Arizona Republican stronghold
9:06PM ( 14 hours ago )
Newcomer hopes for upset in race for Arizona's US House seat
A Democratic newcomer is looking to pull off an upset victory for an open U.S. House seat in Arizona that has been held by Republicans since the early 1980s
6:57PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Elections
South African workers criticize Ramaphosa in protest
Thousands of South African workers demonstrate around the country against a proposed minimum wage, in challenge to President Cyril Ramaphosa
11:05AM ( 1 hour ago )
Kuwait expels Philippines ambassador amid dispute
Kuwait's news agency: Philippines ambassador given week to leave country amid dispute between the countries
10:58AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Danish inventor to appeal murder sentence
Danish inventor Peter Madsen has been sentenced to life in prison for torturing and murdering Swedish journalist Kim Wall on his private submarine.
10:57AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP World News
Political overtone at Catalan celebration of patron saint
Hundreds of Catalans are leaving yellow roses at a central Barcelona square in support of jailed separatists they view as political prisoners in their campaign to break away from Spain
12:09PM ( 1 day ago )
Mexico holds its first presidential debate for July election
The first of Mexico's presidential debates has opened with fire, with front-runner Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador defending the idea of an amnesty to fight drug violence and reviving his 2006 campaign slogan of "the poor come first."
12:13AM ( 2 days ago )
Hillary Clinton, not on ballot, is star of GOP midterm plan
She's not on the ballot, but Hillary Clinton starring in GOP 2018 midterm strategy
4:23PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Police: Man killed deputy, stole his car and robbed store
Maine authorities are searching for a man believed to be armed and dangerous who they say fatally shot a sheriff's deputy, stole his cruiser and robbed a convenience store
11:58AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Chemical weapons inspectors visit second site in Syria town
Chemical weapons inspectors collect new samples from Syrian town hit with suspected chemical attack
11:51AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Dallas mayor: 1 officer has died after Home Depot shooting
The mayor of Dallas says a police officer has died a day after a shooting that also wounded a second officer and a Home Depot store employee
11:43AM ( 23 minutes ago )
Germans don skullcaps to protest anti-Semitism
Germans of various faiths donned Jewish skullcaps and took to the streets in several cities to protest an anti-Semitic attack in Berlin and express fears about growing hatred of Jews in the country
11:42AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Commission: Independent probes needed in complex NCAA cases
It's time for independent investigations for complex cases involving potential NCAA rules violations
11:41AM ( 24 minutes ago )