Sunday August 18th, 2019 11:45PM

Security for EPA chief comes at a steep cost to taxpayers

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Environmental Protection Agency chief Scott Pruitt's concern with his safety came at a steep cost to taxpayers as his swollen security detail blew through overtime budgets and at times diverted officers away from investigating environmental crimes.

Altogether, the agency spent millions of dollars for a 20-member full-time detail that is more than three times the size of his predecessor's part-time security contingent.

EPA spokesman Jahan Wilcox cited "unprecedented" threats against Pruitt and his family as justification for extraordinary security expenses such as first-class airfare to keep him separate from most passengers — a perk generally not available to federal employees.

But Pruitt apparently did not consider that upgrade vital to his safety when taxpayers weren't footing the bill for his ticket. An EPA official with direct knowledge of Pruitt's security spending said the EPA chief flew coach on personal trips back to his home state of Oklahoma.

The EPA official spoke on condition of anonymity for fear of retaliation.

New details in Pruitt's expansive spending for security and travel emerged from agency sources and documents reviewed by The Associated Press. They come as the embattled EPA leader fends off allegations of profligate spending and ethical missteps that have imperiled his job.

President Donald Trump offered a full-throated defense of Pruitt in a tweet Saturday night, saying the EPA chief is "doing a great job" and downplaying the ethical questions swirling around Pruitt. He called the security spending "somewhat more" than Pruitt's predecessor and said Pruitt had received death threats "because of his bold actions at EPA."

Shortly after arriving in Washington, Pruitt demoted the career staff member heading his security detail and replaced him with EPA Senior Special Agent Pasquale "Nino" Perrotta, a former Secret Service agent who operates a private security company.

The EPA official knowledgeable about Pruitt's security spending says Perrotta oversaw a rapid expansion of the EPA chief's security detail to accommodate guarding him day and night, even on family vacations and when Pruitt was home in Oklahoma.

Perrotta also signed off on new procedures that let Pruitt fly first-class on commercial airliners, with the security chief typically sitting next to him with other security staff farther back in the plane. Pruitt's premium status gave him and his security chief access to VIP airport lounges.

The EPA official said there are legitimate concerns about Pruitt's safety, given public opposition to his rollbacks of anti-pollution measures.

But Pruitt's ambitious domestic and international travel led to rapidly escalating costs, with the security detail racking up so much overtime that many hit annual salary caps of about $160,000. The demands of providing 24-hour coverage even meant taking some investigators away from field work, such as when Pruitt traveled to California for a family vacation.

The EPA official said total security costs approached $3 million when pay is added to travel expenses.

Wilcox said Pruitt has faced an unprecedented number of death threats against him and his family and "Americans should all agree that members of the President's cabinet should be kept safe from these violent threats."

A nationwide search of state and federal court records by the AP found no case where anyone has been arrested or charged with threatening Pruitt. EPA's press office did not respond Friday to provide details of any specific threats or arrests.

Pruitt has said his use of first-class airfare was initiated following unpleasant interactions with other travelers. In one incident, someone yelled a profanity as he walked through the airport.

But on weekend trips home for Sooners football games, when taxpayers weren't paying for his ticket, the EPA official said Pruitt flew coach.

The source said Pruitt sometimes used a companion pass obtained with frequent flyer miles accumulated by Ken Wagner, a former law partner whom Pruitt hired as a senior adviser at EPA at a salary of more than $172,000. Taxpayers still covered the airfare for the administrator's security detail.

Walter Shaub, who until last year ran the federal Office of Government Ethics, said it is a potential ethics violation for Pruitt to accept the airline tickets, even if Wagner didn't pay cash for them. Federal officials are barred from accepting gifts from employees that have a market value of more than $10.

"It would be a very serious ethics problem, indeed, if Pruitt accepted airline tickets from a subordinate," Shaub said.

The EPA administrator has come under intense scrutiny for ethics issues and outsized spending. Among the concerns: massive raises for two of closest aides and his rental of a Capitol Hill condo tied to a lobbyist who represents fossil fuel clients.

In his tweet Saturday night, Trump appeared dismissive of the travel and rental issues: "Rent was about market rate, travel expenses OK."

At least three congressional Republicans and a chorus of Democrats have called for Pruitt's ouster. A review of Pruitt's ethical conduct by White House officials is underway, adding to probes by congressional oversight committees and EPA's inspector general.

Pruitt, 49, was closely aligned with the oil and gas industry as Oklahoma's state attorney general before being tapped by Trump. Trump has praised Pruitt's relentless efforts to scrap, delay or rewrite Obama-era environmental regulations. He also has championed budget cuts and staff reductions at the agency so deep that even Republican budget hawks in Congress refused to implement them.

EPA's press office has refused to disclose the cost of Pruitt's security or the size of his protective detail, saying doing so could imperil his personal safety.

But other sources within EPA and documents released through public information requests help provide a window into the ballooning costs.

In his first three months in office, before pricey overseas trips to Italy and Morocco, the price tag for Pruitt's security detail hit more than $832,000, according to EPA documents released through a public information request.

Nearly three dozen EPA security and law enforcement agents were assigned to Pruitt, according to a summary of six weeks of weekly schedules obtained by Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island.

Those schedules show multiple EPA security agents accompanied Pruitt on a family vacation to California that featured a day at Disneyland and a New Year's Day football game where his home state Oklahoma Sooners were playing in the Rose Bowl. Multiple agents also accompanied Pruitt to a baseball game at the University of Kentucky and at his house outside Tulsa, during which no official EPA events were scheduled.

Pruitt's predecessor, Gina McCarthy, had a security detail that numbered about a half dozen, less than a third the size of Pruitt's. She flew coach and was not accompanied by security during her off hours, like on weekend trips home to Boston.

Pruitt was accompanied by nine aides and a security detail during a trip to Italy in June that cost more than $120,000. He visited the U.S. Embassy in Rome and took a private tour of the Vatican before briefly attending a meeting of G-7 environmental ministers in Bologna.

Private Italian security guards hired by Perrotta helped arrange an expansive motorcade for Pruitt and his entourage, according to the EPA official with direct knowledge of the trip. The source described the Italian additions as personal friends of Perrotta, who joined Pruitt and his EPA staff for an hours-long dinner at an upscale restaurant.

Perrotta's biography, on the website of his company, Sequoia Security Group, says that during his earlier stint with the Secret Service he worked with the Guardia di Finanza, the Italian finance police.

The EPA spent nearly $9,000 last year on increased counter-surveillance precautions for Pruitt, including hiring a private contractor to sweep his office for hidden listening devices and installing sophisticated biometric locks for the doors. The payment for the bug sweep went to a vice president at Perrotta's security company.

The EPA official who spoke to the AP said Perrotta also arranged the installation of a $43,000 soundproof phone booth for Pruitt's office.

At least five EPA officials were placed on leave, reassigned or demoted after pushing back against spending requests such as a $100,000-a-month private jet membership, a bulletproof vehicle and $70,000 for furniture such as a bulletproof desk for the armed security officer always stationed inside the administrator's office suite.

Those purchases were not approved. But Pruitt got an ornate refurbished desk comparable in grandeur to the one in the Oval Office.

Among the officials who faced consequences for resisting such spending was EPA Deputy Chief of Staff for Operations Kevin Chmielewski, a former Trump campaign staffer who was placed on unpaid administrative leave this year.

The prior head of Pruitt's security detail, Eric Weese, was demoted last year after he refused Pruitt's demand to use the lights and sirens on his government-owned SUV to get him through Washington traffic to the airport and dinner reservations.


Follow Associated Press environmental reporter Michael Biesecker at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, College Sports, AP Business, AP Sports - College Football
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Reed builds 3-shot lead over McIlroy at Masters
Reed takes 3-shot lead over McIlroy at Masters, stoking memories of their Ryder Cup duel
9:08PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Confident McIlroy ready to seize shot at career Grand Slam
Rory McIlroy took advantage of several fortuitous bounces to shoot a 7-under 65 in the third round of the Masters, matching his best score ever at Augusta National
8:56PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Security for EPA chief comes at a steep cost to taxpayers
EPA chief Scott Pruitt's concern with his safety came at a steep cost to taxpayers as his swollen security detail blew through overtime budgets and at times diverted officers away from investigating environmental crimes
8:54PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Canada mourns: 15 die when truck, hockey team bus collide
Canadian police say 15 people were killed in a bus crash involving a junior hockey team in western Canada
8:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
Giroux's hat trick helps Flyers clinch playoff berth
Claude Giroux earned his first career hat trick in the regular season and the Philadelphia Flyers clinched a playoff berth in their final regular-season game with a 5-0 victory over the New York Rangers
7:33PM ( 1 hour ago )
15 die when truck collides with hockey team's bus in Canada
Canadian police say 15 people were killed in a bus crash involving a junior hockey team in western Canada
7:01PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Sports
AP reports EPA's Pruitt spent millions on security, travel
President Donald Trump's environmental chief's ambitious domestic and international travel has led to rapidly escalating costs
4:15PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP sources: EPA chief spent millions on security and travel
AP sources: EPA chief Scott Pruitt's concern with personal security came at a steep cost to taxpayers
5:17AM ( 15 hours ago )
Marines killed in California crash include new dad, Iraq vet
Four Marines killed when their helicopter crashed on a training mission in the Southern California desert have been identified as men in their 20s and 30s from the South and the Midwest.
10:09PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Football
White House sends mixed signals on trade fight; markets dive
President Donald Trump's treasury secretary says he's "cautiously optimistic" that the U.S. and China could reach an agreement before any tariffs go into place
8:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
Brazil's da Silva in police custody after tense showdown
Former Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva blasted critics and maintained his innocence while also saying he would turn himself in to police to begin serving a 12-year sentence
8:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
1 critically injured in fire at Trump Tower in New York
Officials say one person has been critically injured in a raging apartment fire at Trump Tower in New York City
7:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Gaza buries journalist killed while covering mass protests
Hundreds attended funeral of well-known Palestinian journalist in Gaza who was killed covering the mass protests along the Israel border
3:38PM ( 5 hours ago )
Air France strike sees 30 percent of flights cancelled
Some 30 percent of Air France flights have been cancelled as strikes over pay rises appear to be intensifying
3:35PM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Blood donors rush to help Muenster hospital
Outside Muenster University Hospital, a long queue has formed of people wanting to give blood after the hospital put an urgent call out for donations
2:58PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Senate rivals try to score points on Messer campaign commute
Indiana Senate candidate Luke Messer faces logistical difficulties as he tries to balance family life in the Washington, D.C., area with running a high-stakes campaign back in Indiana
2:51PM ( 6 hours ago )
Rep. Cramer: US direction, soul at stake in Senate contest
North Dakota Republican Congressman Kevin Cramer is telling party activists that "the direction of the nation and the soul of the Senate" is at stake in his contest to unseat incumbent Democratic Sen. Heidi Heitkamp
1:36PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP News Guide: The ongoing teacher protest in Oklahoma
Oklahoma teachers are expected to enter a second week of massive demonstrations pushing state lawmakers to increase education funding
12:13PM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Governors could be powerless to deny Trump troop request
Governors may be powerless to deny Trump's request to send National Guard troops to Mexico border
6:54PM ( 1 day ago )
GOP Rep. Farenthold resigns after sexual harassment claims
Republican Rep. Blake Farenthold of Texas has resigned abruptly from Congress, saying it is time for him to "move along and look for new ways to serve.''
6:44PM ( 1 day ago )
Teacher group demands more cash after lawmakers approve $40M
Oklahoma lawmakers approved $40 million more for public schools Friday, but the head of the largest teacher's union in the state said it was going to take more money to end a walkout that has led to school closures for five days straight
6:41PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
Philadelphia to cheer NCAA champs Villanova with parade
Philadelphia is getting the chance to celebrate yet another sports championship with a parade, this time for Villanova University's Wildcats
12:02AM ( 2 days ago )
WNBA coaches, GMs tab A'ja Wilson for top pick in mock draft
A'ja Wilson likely first pick in the WNBA draft next week, according to panel of coaches and general managers
9:53AM ( 3 days ago )
Raptors-Celtics, Cavs-76ers are big East games this week
Philadelphia wants to open its first playoff series at home
9:43AM ( 3 days ago )
College Sports
Ship hits historic mansion on Istanbul's Bosporus Strait
A cargo ship has crashed into a historic mansion on Istanbul's Bosporus strait, severely damaging the building
7:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
Ingraham due back at Fox following tweet backlash, vacation
Fox News Channel host Laura Ingraham is expected back at work Monday following backlash by advertisers upset over her tweet mocking a Parkland, Florida, school shooting survivor
3:36PM ( 5 hours ago )
Photos reveal, recognize black work camps during Depression
The University of Michigan has acquired a trove of photos capturing a place and time largely overlooked by history: black Civilian Conservation Corps camps during the Great Depression
12:34PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Business
Villanova students gear up to welcome home NCAA champs
Students at Villanova University are gearing up to welcome home their men's basketball team, which is returning with its second NCAA championship in three years
12:37PM ( 4 days ago )
Believe the hype! Penn State tops Utah for NIT championship
Shep Garner hit the 3-pointer that brought cousin Flavor Flav to his feet and helped bring Penn State an NIT championship in an 82-66 win over Utah
10:41AM ( 1 week ago )
APNewsBreak: Key design change stymied bridge cost, schedule
Documents obtained by The Associated Press show construction of the pedestrian bridge that collapsed and killed six people in the Miami area was behind schedule and millions over budget
7:10PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Reed builds 3-shot lead over McIlroy at Masters
Reed takes 3-shot lead over McIlroy at Masters, stoking memories of their Ryder Cup duel
9:08PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Confident McIlroy ready to seize shot at career Grand Slam
Rory McIlroy took advantage of several fortuitous bounces to shoot a 7-under 65 in the third round of the Masters, matching his best score ever at Augusta National
8:56PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Justify wins Santa Anita Derby by 3½ lengths for Baffert
Justify won the $1 million Santa Anita Derby by 3½ lengths over Bolt d'Oro
8:42PM ( 32 minutes ago )
1 killed in fire at Trump Tower in New York
Fire officials say a man has been killed in in a raging apartment fire at Trump Tower in New York City
8:34PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Putting woes stifle Johnson, Spieth, Thomas at Masters
Dustin Johnson, Jordan Spieth and Justin Thomas blame putting woes on being mostly stagnant at Masters
8:19PM ( 55 minutes ago )