Wednesday April 24th, 2019 10:04PM

APNewsBreak: Key design change stymied bridge cost, schedule

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

MIAMI (AP) — Construction of the pedestrian bridge that collapsed and killed six people in the Miami area was behind schedule and millions over budget, in part because of a key change in the design and placement of one of its support towers.

Documents obtained by The Associated Press through a public-records request show that the Florida Department of Transportation in October 2016 advised Florida International University and its contractors to move one of the bridge's main support structures 11 feet (3 meters) north to the edge of a canal, widening the gap between the crossing's end supports and requiring some new structural design.

The span's signature, 109-foot-tall (33-meter-tall) pylon was to be built atop a base at the span's northern end. It was designed for basic support and to contribute to the aesthetics of the bridge, which was touted as an architectural marvel that would connect the rapidly growing university to the nearby community of Sweetwater. In their winning 2015 proposal, designers said the bridge provided "spectacular views" for both pedestrians using the bridge and drivers passing beneath it. They added that the tower could serve as a safety feature because it would have an "eagle-eyed location" for additional lighting and security cameras.

Videos of Thursday's collapse show that the concrete, prefabricated segment of the bridge started crumbling on the same end of the span where the tower redesign occurred, two days after an engineer on the project reported cracks in the same location. The segment that failed had been placed atop the pylon's footing, and the taller tower section was to be installed later.

U.S. Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao has ordered her department's inspector general to conduct an audit of the bridge, according to a news release Tuesday from the U.S. Department of Transportation. The agency awarded millions of dollars to the project.

It is still unclear if the design change contributed to the failure. But emails between the school, contractors, Sweetwater city officials and permitting agencies show a project that was behind schedule, which had officials worried that further delays could jeopardize the federal funding.

When the bridge collapsed, the project was already running about $2.6 million over its $9.4 million initial budget, cost-tracking documents from February show. Originally scheduled to be completed in July, the finish date had been pushed back to January 2019.

Difficulties began in late 2016, when the Florida Department of Transportation emailed project officials saying they wanted more room to allow for future widening of the U.S. highway under the bridge, according to the documents. The new position of the tower would be on the north side between the road and the canal.

"This ... places the current location of the pylon in conflict with the extra travel lane and would require bridge design modifications," Alfred Reyna, a transportation department employee working on the bridge project, wrote in an email.

After weeks of back and forth, it was decided to move the pylon 11 feet to the north, sitting near the edge of the canal. According to documents, initial costs for the new design were $204,540, with another $402,723 for construction changes. The final cost was not divulged.

"The city attorney is advising us not to speak about anything to do with the bridge," said Sandra Antonio, a spokeswoman for the city of Sweetwater, which was working with FIU. The tower was to be located on the Sweetwater side.

Don Silver, a spokesman for Munilla Construction Management, or MCM, the Miami-based construction management firm that won the bridge contract, said the National Transportation Safety Board forbade engineers or contractors from talking about the project pending its investigation. MCM collaborated with Tallahassee-based FIGG Bridge Design on the bridge project, which also declined comment.

A spokeswoman for FIU, Maydel Santana, declined comment on the pylon redesign, but did confirm Tuesday that the bridge was expected to be completed early in 2019 and the grant ran out on Sept. 30, 2019. She also said the school was cooperating with the NTSB's investigation.

While the NTSB probe has just begun, multiple engineers who reviewed the documents obtained by the AP said moving the tower after the bridge's initial design invited errors.

Henry Petroski, a Duke University civil engineering professor, said even seemingly minor changes in a bridge's design can lead to failures.

"Once a design is completed, subsequent modifications tend to be suggested and approved without the full care that went into the original design. This has happened time and again in bridges and other engineering structures," he said.

The documents show that further time pressures were put on the tower redesign due to a bottleneck at the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The Corps was in charge of permitting certain aspects of the new tower's footing and other elements but had stopped due to federal budget cuts. Documents show the contractors wouldn't begin work until the Corp's permits were finished, and FIU worried delays could jeopardize federal funding.

Kenneth Jessell, FIU's senior vice president for financial affairs, in 2017 worried the delays would jeopardize federal TIGER funds for the university's massive transportation redesign, of which the bridge was a key part.

In the news release announcing the audit, Transportation Secretary Chao said she wants to know whether the parties involved in the design, construction and testing of the bridge complied with standards required of projects that receive federal funding.

Bridge engineers who reviewed photographs of the collapse said it was ill-advised to move the pylon after completing the initial design, but that more analysis was warranted before it could be known whether this played a role in the collapse.

Robert Bea, a University of California, Berkeley engineering professor, said the tower base may have been more flexible after it was moved closer to the canal. This could have created more stress on the section that collapsed when crews removed temporary supports so traffic could resume, he said.

"At this time, I do not think the movement of the footing for the pylon to the north was a primary factor in the failure. However, the movement of the footing led to the requirement for one of the temporary steel supports to be relocated to be able to travel on the highway," he said.


Associated Press writer Adriana Gomez Licon in Miami contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, College Sports, AP Business, AP Sports - College Football
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: New Jersey investigating Facebook, data firm
New Jersey's top law enforcement officer has launched an investigation after reports that a British data analysis firm captured information from 50 million Facebook users without their consent
6:08PM ( 6 minutes ago )
New blast sends bombing investigators to Texas FedEx center
New bomb blast sends investigators to FedEx center near San Antonio
6:07PM ( 7 minutes ago )
APNewsBreak: Key design change stymied bridge cost, schedule
Documents obtained by The Associated Press show construction of the pedestrian bridge that collapsed and killed six people in the Miami area was behind schedule and millions over budget
6:06PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Helio Castroneves tests new Indy car in break from new gig
Helio Castroneves was back running laps at Barber Motorsports Park in Alabama, getting valuable laps and reuniting with his Penske teammates
4:58PM ( 1 hour ago )
New Patriots' CB Jason McCourty to play with twin brother
Seeing double: New Patriots cornerback Jason McCourty excited about 'dream' opportunity to play alongside his twin brother Devin
3:39PM ( 2 hours ago )
Roberts says Turner's broken wrist won't need surgery
Los Angeles third baseman Justin Turner's broken left wrist is expected to heal without surgery, according to Los Angeles manager Dave Roberts
3:09PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Sports
Cincinnati commiserates again, this time over 'Black Sunday'
They're commiserating about 'Black Sunday' in the chili parlors around town. Top-seeded Xavier and second-seeded Cincinnati both blew double-digit leads and lost in the second round of the NCAA Tournament. Sports fans have seen this ending many times
4:48PM ( 1 day ago )
DeVoe, Clemson rout cold-shooting Auburn to reach Sweet 16
Gabe DeVoe scored 22 points and Elijah Thomas had 18 points and 11 rebounds for Clemson, which closed the first half with a 25-4 run that helped it beat cold-shooting Auburn 84-53 and advance to the Midwest Region semifinal
10:40PM ( 1 day ago )
Jets sign Bridgewater, Williamson, Long; re-sign Claiborne
The New York Jets have signed former Minnesota Vikings quarterback Teddy Bridgewater to a one-year contract
5:01PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Football
Cops: Police kill restaurant gunman after 5-hour standoff
Authorities in New Jersey say police fatally shot an armed man who holed up in a restaurant near Princeton University in a five-hour standoff with officers
5:54PM ( 20 minutes ago )
The Latest: Attorney: Officer should not have been charged
An attorney for a Minneapolis police officer says the officer shouldn't have been charged with a crime in the fatal shooting of an unarmed Australian woman
5:50PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Storms strike college, leave trail of damage across South
Severe storms scatter damage around the Southeast amid reports of tornadoes, destructive hail and high winds
5:41PM ( 33 minutes ago )
AP National News
$500K bond for shooting suspect's brother in school trespass
A judge has set an unusually high $500,000 bond and imposed a host of other restrictions for the brother of the Florida school shooting suspect
5:19PM ( 55 minutes ago )
Breaking up with Facebook? It's harder than it looks
Facebook's latest privacy scandal is leading some users to reconsider their relationship status with the social network
5:17PM ( 57 minutes ago )
Needs go unmet 6 months after Maria hit Puerto Rico
Needs go unmet 6 months after Hurricane Maria hit Puerto Rico
5:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Judge temporarily blocks most restrictive abortion law in US
The most restrictive abortion law in the United States has been blocked, less than 24 hours after Mississippi's governor signed it
4:53PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: McCaul: Latest blast could lead to more evidence
The chairman of the U.S. House Homeland Security committee says he thinks the latest package explosion in Texas will lead to more evidence, "hopefully fingerprints and surveillance photos."
4:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
Rocket attack on Syrian capital kills 35 people
As Syrian government focuses on eastern Ghouta, IS seizes neighborhood in Damascus
3:58PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Oklahoma's Trae Young leaving for NBA after freshman season
Oklahoma star Trae Young is leaving for the NBA after a standout freshman season that ended with him leading the nation in scoring and assists
11:45AM ( 6 hours ago )
Leagues, casinos lobby states for cut of legal sports bets
More than a third of U.S. states are considering legislation to legalize sports gambling as leagues, casinos angle for the biggest possible cut
2:40AM ( 15 hours ago )
Loyola returns home for Sweet 16 prep as talk of Chicago
Loyola-Chicago is getting ready to face Nevada after two breathtaking victories, a run that has captivated college basketball and turned a 98-year-old team chaplain into a quasi-celebrity
2:22AM ( 15 hours ago )
College Sports
The Latest: States seek answers from Facebook on users' data
The top prosecutors in Massachusetts and New York have sent a letter to Facebook demanding the social media giant protect its users' private information
5:27PM ( 47 minutes ago )
Cambridge Analytica: We designed Trump campaign strategy
Cambridge Analytica chief executive Alexander Nix has said in comments that were secretly recorded by Britain's Channel 4 news that his company played a major role in securing Donald Trump's narrow White House victory
5:25PM ( 48 minutes ago )
FedEx beats profit forecasts, raises 12-month outlook
FedEx profit soars on tax reduction, higher rates and strength in its ground-shipping business
5:19PM ( 55 minutes ago )
AP Business
Tebow (1 for 18) sent to minor league camp by Mets
Tim Tebow was reassigned by the New York Mets to their minor league camp after he went 0 for 4 with four strikeouts in an exhibition against the Houston Astros
9:13AM ( 6 days ago )
Barkley, Griffin shined but Brown didn't at NFL combine
Crazed, dazed and fazed: the NFL scouting combine featured plenty of surprising performances
1:18PM ( 2 weeks ago )
Trump, press trade good-natured if barbed jokes at Gridiron
Trading good-natured barbs with the press, Trump tells Gridiron roast: 'Nobody does self-deprecating humor better than I do'
11:11PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Sports - College Football
The Latest: New Jersey investigating Facebook, data firm
New Jersey's top law enforcement officer has launched an investigation after reports that a British data analysis firm captured information from 50 million Facebook users without their consent
6:08PM ( 6 minutes ago )
New blast sends bombing investigators to Texas FedEx center
New bomb blast sends investigators to FedEx center near San Antonio
6:07PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Senators push for better security for 2018 election season
Leaders of the Senate Intelligence Committee recommend better information-sharing in states, cities to head off new election interference
6:02PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Zuckerberg asked to testify; data firm's CEO suspended
The head of Trump-affiliated data-mining firm Cambridge Analytica has been suspended, while government authorities are bearing down on both the firm and Facebook over allegations the firm stole data from 50 million Facebook users to manipulate elections.
6:01PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Teen shoots girl in Maryland school, killed in confrontation
A teenager with a handgun shot and critically wounded a girl inside a Maryland school and the shooter was killed when a school resource officer confronted him moments after the gunfire erupted
5:55PM ( 18 minutes ago )