sunny.png
Friday July 19th, 2019 7:49PM

Fox News wins appeals ruling over media monitoring company

By The Associated Press

NEW YORK (AP) — A media monitoring company is cheating Fox News out of revenue by failing to pay for some content it resells, a federal appeals court said Tuesday in a decision closely watched in the news broadcasting industry.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against TVEyes Inc., a Fairfield, Connecticut-based company distributing television clips and snippets of transcripts to its customers.

"The success of the TVEyes business model demonstrates that deep-pocketed consumers are willing to pay well for a service that allows them to search for and view selected television clips, and that this market is worth millions of dollars in the aggregate," the appeals court said.

It said TVEyes was depriving Fox of licensing revenues and it should be left up to Fox whether it wants to create a similar service itself or license it to others.

"At bottom, TVEyes is unlawfully profiting off the work of others by commercially redistributing all of that work that a viewer wishes to use, without payment or license," the 2nd Circuit said in an opinion written by Judge Dennis Jacobs.

Attorney Dale Cendali, who represented Fox News, called it "a significant win in the field of fair use law."

"We cannot emphasize enough the practical effect this win should have for content holders of all stripes," Cendali said.

In a statement, TVEyes said it was disappointed by the ruling and was evaluating it and considering its options.

"We continue to believe that TVEyes offers an irreplaceable public service to its customers, including elected officials and government agencies, the military, law enforcement and the news media itself, within the bounds of the law," the company said.

The appeals court said the company, which enables customers for about $500 monthly to sift through large quantities of television clips to find what interests them, was unlawfully profiting off the work of others because its product was only modestly transformative, not enough to be considered fair use of the television content.

However, the appeals court noted that Fox News did not challenge the media monitoring company's creation of a text-searchable database. The company's clients include journalists, government and political organizations, law enforcement, the military, for-profit companies and nonprofits, the court said.

District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan, sitting temporarily on the 2nd Circuit three-judge panel, wrote separately that he agreed with the majority's conclusion but thought it went too far in finding the TVEyes product "modestly transformative."

"It does no more than repackage and deliver the original works. It adds no new information, no new aesthetics, and no new insights or understandings. I therefore doubt that it is transformative," Kaplan said.

The majority opinion from the three-judge panel said some claims by TVEyes were similar to those made by Google Inc. when it successfully defended its creation of a text-searchable database of millions of books. But the 2nd Circuit noted that it was testing the boundaries of fair use when it ruled that Google's service was "transformative" — a legal requirement that enables a user of content to overcome copyright objections.

"We conclude that defendant TVEyes has exceeded those bounds," the panel said.

It said Google's snippet function was designed to ensure users viewed a tiny piece of a book's contents while TVEyes enables customers to see 10-minute long segments, likely allowing them to access all the Fox programming they seek.

TVEyes records all television broadcasts as they happen, drawing from over 1,400 channels around-the-clock. It then enables a client to search video clips no more than 10 minutes long for mentions of a particular term. The 2nd Circuit said the service lets clients measure the frequency of discussion of a subject or to learn for marketing or public relations purposes how a product is mentioned in the media.

In a written submission prior to the ruling, Google had urged the 2nd Circuit to rule in favor of TVEyes, saying the issues were of "particular importance to Google."

"This Court's approach to TVEyes' technology matters a great deal to Google and other innovators working to take search in new directions," it said.

In another written submission, the nonprofit National Association of Broadcasters told the court that services like TVEyes "drains away advertising and licensing revenue critical to broadcasters' ability to fulfill their public-interest obligation to meet the needs of the communities they serve."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Entertainment, AP Online TV News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Congressman says FBI should have stopped gunman
Rep. Steve Scalise says people at the FBI should be held accountable after it didn't act on a tip about the man who later allegedly killed 17 people at a Florida high school.
1:19PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Ex-presidents, friends, family pay respects to Billy Graham
A second former U.S. president has visited the Rev. Billy Graham's boyhood home in North Carolina to pay respects to the pastor
1:07PM ( 28 minutes ago )
The Latest: Powell stays out of dangerous political waters
The Latest: Powell stays out of dangerous political waters despite pressure from Democrats
1:04PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Dior's '60s flower power celebrates women's rights in Paris
The subzero temperatures didn't dampen Paris Fashion Week, which began with bright flower-power at Dior.
12:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Challenge to Murdoch: US giant Comcast also bids for Sky
The U.S. media firm Comcast is launching a bid to take control of Sky in a direct challenge to mogul Rupert Murdoch.
11:40AM ( 1 hour ago )
Lewinsky calls Clinton affair a 'gross abuse of power'
Lewinsky says affair that led to impeachment proceedings 'constituted a gross abuse of power'
11:17AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Heather Locklear arrested for alleged domestic violence
California authorities say Heather Locklear has been arrested for investigation of domestic violence and fighting with sheriff's deputies
3:49PM ( 21 hours ago )
The Latest: Slain student buried in Dwyane Wade's jersey
A student who was slain in the Florida high school shooting was a fan of basketball player Dwyane Wade and was buried in his jersey
11:22AM ( 1 day ago )
CBS launching a 24-hour streaming sports news network
CBS is launching a 24-hour streaming sports news network
9:48AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online TV News
The Latest: Powell remarks on economy weigh on stock market
The Latest: Fed Chairman Powell says new forecast on rates will take into account positive economic data
12:48PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Treasury yields rise, stocks dip following Fed testimony
Treasury yields rose Tuesday, and U.S. stocks were down modestly after the head of the Federal Reserve said that he's feeling more optimistic about the economy
12:30PM ( 1 hour ago )
US consumer confidence rises to highest level since 2000
US consumer confidence rises in February to highest level since 2000
12:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Ford and Miami to form test bed for self-driving cars
Ford is making Miami-Dade County its biggest test bed yet for self-driving cars
11:25AM ( 2 hours ago )
FedEx bucks corporate trend, sticks with NRA
FedEx bucks corporate trend, sticks with NRA and the reaction is immediate
9:21AM ( 4 hours ago )
Macy's tops 4Q expectations, optimistic outlook
Macy's beats 4Q net income expectations, misses revenue forecasts
9:13AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
The Latest: Congressman says FBI should have stopped gunman
Rep. Steve Scalise says people at the FBI should be held accountable after it didn't act on a tip about the man who later allegedly killed 17 people at a Florida high school.
1:19PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Ex-presidents, friends, family pay respects to Billy Graham
A second former U.S. president has visited the Rev. Billy Graham's boyhood home in North Carolina to pay respects to the pastor
1:07PM ( 28 minutes ago )
The Latest: Powell stays out of dangerous political waters
The Latest: Powell stays out of dangerous political waters despite pressure from Democrats
1:04PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Administration pressed to expand mental health treatment
Administration says it's exploring ways to help states expand inpatient mental health treatment using federal funds from Medicaid
1:02PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Sessions: Justice Dept can ban bump stocks with regulation
Attorney General Jeff Sessions says Justice Department officials believe they can ban rapid-fire bump stock devices without action from Congress.
12:59PM ( 37 minutes ago )