cloudyn.png
Friday December 4th, 2020 6:41AM

Supreme Court keeps a lower profile, but for how long?

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court began its term with the tumultuous confirmation of Justice Brett Kavanaugh, followed by a studied avoidance of drama on the high court bench — especially anything that would divide the five conservatives and four liberals.

The justices have been unusually solicitous of each other in the courtroom since Kavanaugh's confirmation, and several have voiced concern that the public perceives the court as merely a political institution. Chief Justice John Roberts seems determined to lead the one Washington institution that stays above the political fray. Even Roberts' rebuke of President Donald Trump, after the president criticized a federal judge, was in defense of an independent, apolitical judiciary.

The next few weeks will test whether the calm can last.

When they gather in private on Jan. 4 to consider new cases for arguments in April and into next term, the justices will confront a raft of high-profile appeals.

Abortion restrictions, workplace discrimination against LGBT people and partisan gerrymandering are on the agenda. Close behind are appeals from the Trump administration seeking to have the court allow it to end an Obama-era program that shields young immigrants from deportation and to put in place restrictive rules for transgender troops.

There already are signs that the conservative justices, apart from Roberts, are willing to take on controversial cases that are likely to produce the ideological and partisan divisions that their colleagues seem eager to avoid.

In recent weeks, three conservative justices accused the court of ducking its job of deciding important cases, especially when lower courts have disagreed on the outcome. Their criticism, written by Justice Clarence Thomas and joined by Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch, came after a recent decision to avoid a case involving funding for Planned Parenthood.

Then, on the Friday before Christmas, the court divided 5-4 in refusing to allow the Trump administration to enforce new restrictions on asylum seekers. Roberts joined the four liberals. The three conservatives who were displeased by the Planned Parenthood case outcome again noted their disagreement, this time joined by Kavanaugh.

The two votes can't be used to draw any firm conclusions about what may be happening behind closed doors at the court, as the cases arrived in different circumstances. In the Planned Parenthood case, the justices were considering whether to grant full review, a process that takes only four votes. The asylum case was an emergency appeal from the administration. At least five of the nine justices would have had to vote in the administration's favor.

But Lawrence Solum, a professor of constitutional law at Georgetown University's law school, said Roberts seems to have two reasons to limit the court's involvement in hot-button cases: his preference for taking small steps in the law and his concern for the court's reputation.

"It's clear that 5-4 decisions will be perceived by many, many lawyers, many politicians and large numbers of the public at large as ideological decisions," Solum said. "So given Roberts' desire to preserve the legitimacy of the court, he could be highly motivated to avoid decisions like that in the next immediate period in the history of the court. Whether that's one year, or two years or five years, who knows?"

The court arrived at this point after an unusual chain of events that began with the death of Justice Antonin Scalia in February 2016. Senate Republicans refused to act on President Barack Obama's nomination of Merrick Garland, allowing Trump to put Gorsuch on the court in 2017. To this day, Democrats say the seat was stolen from them.

Then, over the summer, Justice Anthony Kennedy's retirement meant that Trump would also get to replace the court's swing vote with a more reliable conservative. Kavanaugh's track record as an appellate judge suggested he was that man, but his confirmation was nearly derailed by allegations of sexual assault, which Kavanaugh denied.

The accusations against Kavanaugh turned the confirmation process into a national spectacle that culminated in a hearing with Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey Ford, who accused him of assault when they were in high school. Republicans said the allegation was unproven and confirmed Kavanaugh in a rare Saturday session. Spotlighting how emotional the debate had become, a crowd of demonstrators gathered at the Supreme Court building after the Kavanaugh vote, with some climbing the stone statues that line the steps.

One result of the Kavanaugh turmoil has been the most serious discussion in decades of limiting the court's powers, including possibly increasing the number of justices, Solum said. "It suggests that the legitimacy of the court is at issue now in perhaps a way it hasn't been until recently."

Roberts is not only the chief justice, but he has essentially taken Kennedy's place as the swing vote — the conservative justice nearest the court's center. The Supreme Court will go only as far as Roberts is willing in either direction.

He can try to keep the court entirely out of some cases, though that requires him to be able to persuade at least one other conservative justice to go along. That's what happened in the Planned Parenthood case, when Kavanaugh voted to deny review. "The difficult confirmation battle may lead to a bit of caution," said John McGinnis, a Northwestern University law school professor.

When the justices do plunge into controversy, Roberts will be able "to write or insist that decisions be narrowly drawn," McGinnis said.

Roberts has been chief justice for more than 13 years, but he is only 63 and could lead the court for an additional two decades or more. That allows Roberts, who began his legal career as a lawyer in the Reagan administration, to take a long view, McGinnis said, and await a time when political tensions and concerns about the court's reputation subside.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Supreme Court keeps a lower profile, but for how long?
The Supreme Court term began with the tumultuous confirmation of Justice Brett Kavanaugh, followed by a studied disdain for drama and ideological division. But will that calm last?
4:00PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Deep underground, new NYC train hub slowly takes shape
Deep under Manhattan's Grand Central Terminal, work on one of the world's priciest commuter projects is slowly taking shape
3:57PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Lawyer: McCarrick repeatedly touched youth during confession
The Vatican's sexual abuse case against ex-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick has expanded significantly after a man has testified that the retired archbishop sexually abused him for years starting when he was 11, including during confession.
3:56PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
From duct-taped shoes to $11M: Man leaves surprise donations
A Washington state social worker built up an $11 million estate that he left to children's charities and came as a surprise to those closest to him
2:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
California's Jerry Brown caps 5 decades on political scene
California Gov. Jerry Brown will leave office Jan. 7 after a record 16 years leading the nation's most populous state
2:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
NYC utility probes electric flash that lit sky in eerie blue
Utility Con Edison is working to figure out what caused a high-voltage equipment failure that unleashed an otherworldly flash of bright blue light in the night sky over New York City
2:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Syria claims it has entered a disputed Kurdish-held town
Syria military claims it entered flash-point Kurdish-held town to avert Turkish offensive, US-led coalition denies move
1:18PM ( 2 hours ago )
Protests as Congo leader warns of Ebola vote 'disaster'
Protests erupt as Congo's leader warns of 'disaster' if Sunday's vote is allowed in Ebola zone
1:07PM ( 3 hours ago )
N. Carolina governor reshapes board amid congressional probe
North Carolina's governor is trying to move fast to reassemble the disbanding state elections board investigating ballot fraud allegations in a still-unresolved congressional race
12:47PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Pelosi taps Florida Democrat to lead climate change panel
Pelosi appoints Florida Rep. Kathy Castor to lead special committee on climate change, replacing panel eliminated by Republicans
1:38PM ( 2 hours ago )
Utah gears up to implement nation's lowest DUI limit
New Year's Eve revelers in Utah could find themselves with more than a hangover as 2019 dawns: If they drink and drive, they could end up on the wrong side of the nation's newest and lowest DUI threshold.
11:44AM ( 4 hours ago )
Shutdown to close DC museums and galleries by midweek
Government shutdown to close DC museums, galleries and National Zoo by midweek
11:39AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Trump threatens to shut border if no wall money
President Donald Trump is threatening to close the U.S. border with Mexico if Democrats in Congress don't agree to fund the construction of a border wall
8:15AM ( 7 hours ago )
Shutdown solution seems unlikely before Dems take House
A shutdown solution appears elusive as Democrats get ready to take House control
1:00AM ( 15 hours ago )
Furious Iraqi lawmakers demand US troop withdrawal
'A violation of national sovereignty:' Trump's surprise trip to Iraq infuriates Iraqi politicians who demand withdrawal of U.S. forces.
11:54PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
More volatility: US stocks extend gains after early wobble
U.S. stocks are rebounding after an early wobble, building on gains from a two-day winning streak in a week of volatile trading
2:38PM ( 1 hour ago )
Browns owners agree to buy Columbus Crew, keep team in Ohio
Browns owners agree to buy Columbus Crew, keeping longtime MLS franchise in Ohio
1:56PM ( 2 hours ago )
Markets Right Now: US stocks waver in midday trading
Stocks are wavering between small gains and losses as the market continues to churn amid the volatile trading that has gripped the market throughout December
12:10PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
Deep underground, new NYC train hub slowly takes shape
Deep under Manhattan's Grand Central Terminal, work on one of the world's priciest commuter projects is slowly taking shape
3:57PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Lawyer: McCarrick repeatedly touched youth during confession
The Vatican's sexual abuse case against ex-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick has expanded significantly after a man has testified that the retired archbishop sexually abused him for years starting when he was 11, including during confession.
3:56PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Suspect in California officer's shooting death is captured
Authorities say the man accused of killing a California police officer during a traffic stop has been captured
3:55PM ( 19 minutes ago )
More volatility: US stocks wobble on another turbulent day
U.S. stocks wavered between small gains and losses Friday, struggling to maintain the momentum from a two-day winning streak following a week of volatile trading
3:48PM ( 25 minutes ago )
North Carolina governor reshapes board amid ballots probe
North Carolina's governor is trying to move fast to reassemble the disbanding state elections board investigating ballot fraud allegations in a still-unresolved congressional race
3:36PM ( 37 minutes ago )