Tuesday March 19th, 2019 1:07PM

Group backing private Medicare is funded by insurance giants

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A group gaining influence in Washington as a champion for Medicare beneficiaries is bankrolled by major health insurance companies that are trying to cash in on private coverage offered through the federal health insurance program.

The Better Medicare Alliance claims a far-flung network of seniors, with a Facebook community of more than 380,000 and 110,000 signed up to receive email alerts. Its website displays profiles of "BMA Seniors" who describe private Medicare plans in glowing terms. The Associated Press found that one of the featured seniors, David Kievit, died in March at age 91.

The multimillion-dollar budget for the alliance isn't supplied by seniors, but by UnitedHealthcare, Aetna and Humana, according to the group's president and its federal tax returns. The three insurance giants together account for close to 50 percent of all enrollees in private "Medicare Advantage" plans and stand to benefit as that part of Medicare keeps growing.

The organization's website and Facebook page don't say where its money comes from, making it easy to miss the industry tie.

Since its establishment in December 2014, the alliance has built its profile. It lobbies Congress and the administration and sponsors research. It has reported spending $370,000 so far this year on lobbying Congress primarily, according to disclosure records. Among other issues, the alliance is seeking the repeal of a tax on health insurers imposed by the Obama-era health care law.

President and CEO Allyson Schwartz enjoys credibility among Democrats, having helped pass the Affordable Care Act as a Democratic congresswoman from Pennsylvania. And Republicans have long been fans of private Medicare plans, giving the alliance a foothold in both political parties.

David Lipschutz, a senior policy attorney for the Center for Medicare Advocacy, a nonprofit legal organization that represents Medicare beneficiaries, called the Better Medicare Alliance an "Astroturf group." The term refers to an organization that casts itself as a grassroots movement to mask their corporate interests.

"They represent themselves as representing Medicare beneficiaries, but they really represent the interests of the insurance industry," Lipschutz said.

Schwartz rejects any suggestion that the organization is a front for the insurance industry. She said during an interview with the AP that the alliance's funding sources "are well known," even though the names and addresses of donors were blacked out of copies of the alliance's tax returns that it provided to AP.

Federal rules permit nonprofits like the Better Medicare Alliance to shield the identities of donors. Critics say that's problematic because the public has no way of knowing whether the anonymous donors have a specific interest in a matter before the administration, Congress or the courts.

"I don't know that this entity is representative of the people who receive this type of insurance, or is it representing the interests of the businesses that offer this type of insurance," said Daniel Borochoff, the president of CharityWatch, a national watchdog group. He reviewed alliance tax documents for AP and said it appears to be "akin to a trade organization."

The alliance has received $19.9 million in donations over the last three years, accounting for 99.9 percent of its total revenue during that period, according to the organization's tax returns for 2015 through 2017. Schwartz said when asked that the money came from UnitedHealthcare, Aetna and Humana.

"You can ask any nonprofit organization about their funders and say, 'Do they tell you what to do? Does that dictate what you do?'" Schwartz said. "You pay attention to your funders, but you ought to be making your own decisions. We do."

She said BMA has 125 "allies" that include the insurance companies, local agencies that serve seniors, patient advocacy groups, and nurse and doctor associations that all back Medicare Advantage. They include the American Medical Group Association and Meals on Wheels America.

"Our job is to find the common ground," Schwartz said.

Medicare Advantage is a growing business for insurers. About 22 million Medicare beneficiaries, or close to 2 in 5, are expected to be covered by a Medicare Advantage plan next year. The private plans promise coordinated care and generally offer lower out-of-pocket costs. They limit choice of doctors and hospitals and employ other restrictions such as prior authorization for services.

UnitedHealthcare has 25 percent of the Medicare Advantage enrollees, Humana has 17 percent and Aetna has 8 percent, according to an analysis of government data by the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation.

Schwartz earned just over $600,000 last year in base salary, bonus pay and other compensation, an increase of $52,000 from 2016. The alliance's board of directors determined her salary following a compensation survey of comparable nonprofits, according to the tax returns, but she makes more than the top executives who run other Medicare-related organizations.

Max Richtman, president of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, earned $391,185 in 2017, according to the organization's latest tax return. The group advocates against cuts to retirement security programs.

James Firman, president of the National Council on the Aging, was paid $343,558, according to the organization's tax return that covers the year between July 1, 2016 and June 30, 2017, the latest available. The council is a decades-old advocacy group.

Among the senior profiles on the Better Medicare Alliance's website is one of Kievet, a World War II veteran who died in March. There's a photo of him wearing his veteran's cap, along with a brief first-person article.

His family was startled to see his photo there, said his son, John Kievit, who lives near Houston.

"I'd like to see the article updated, at least," he said.


Follow Richard Lardner on Twitter at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Senior Health, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Report says 16.7M faulty Takata air bags still on US roads
More than three years after the government took over management of recalls involving dangerous Takata air bag inflators, one third of the recalled inflators still have not been replaced
4:57PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Cardinals agree to 2-year deal with reliever Andrew Miller
Left-handed reliever Andrew Miller has agreed to terms with the St. Louis Cardinals on a two-year deal with a vesting option for 2021
4:56PM ( 12 minutes ago )
North Carolina asked feds to open vote fraud case last year
North Carolina's top elections official pleaded nearly two years ago for the Justice Department to charge those people now at the center last month's ballot fraud allegations
4:54PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: VP Pence at Capitol for potential tie-breaker
Vice President Mike Pence has arrived at the Capitol in case he is needed to break a tie on a procedural measure to avert a partial government shutdown
4:18PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Group backing private Medicare is funded by insurance giants
A group seen as a champion for Medicare Advantage beneficiaries is funded by insurance giants that stand to benefit as that part of the federal health insurance program grows
4:15PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Trump call with Turkish leader led to US pullout from Syria
President Donald Trump's decision to withdraw American troops from Syria was made hastily, without consulting his national security team or allies, say U.S. and Turkish officials
3:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
State audit slams San Diego response to Hepatitis A outbreak
State audit finds city and county of San Diego failed to quickly contain a Hepatitis A outbreak last year that became among the largest of its kind seen in the United States in decades
3:53PM ( 1 day ago )
Stem cell shots linked to bacterial infection outbreak
Health officials are reporting an outbreak of bacterial infections in patients who got injections of stems cells derived from umbilical cord blood
3:03PM ( 1 day ago )
Glaxo, Pfizer to merge consumer health care divisions
GlaxoSmithKline and Pfizer are merging their consumer health care divisions, creating a business with combined sales of 9.8 billion pounds ($12.7B)
1:18PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Health
Markets Right Now: Stocks end miserable week down 7 percent
Another day of big losses is leaving the stock market with its worst weekly drop in more than seven years.
4:17PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Police: Colorado woman likely killed at home; fiance charged
The fiance of a Colorado woman who has been missing since Thanksgiving Day has been arrested and accused of killing the mother of his child
4:08PM ( 1 hour ago )
Austrian leader says tax could deter investment in Romania
Austrian Chancellor Sebastian Kurz has warned that Austrian companies could pull out of Romania after the government unveiled a surprise plan to levy extra taxes on banks and energy companies
3:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Elderly man evicted over medical marijuana hits another snag
A 78-year-old New York man who was evicted from federally subsidized housing because he uses medical marijuana says the conflicting state and federal marijuana rules that left him homeless are now threatening his medical care
7:24PM ( 1 week ago )
Medicare expands access to in-home support for seniors
Some Medicare Advantage insurance plans to offer broader array of in-home support services next year
12:01PM ( 1 month ago )
Sandra Day O'Connor announces likely Alzheimer's diagnosis
Sandra Day O'Connor, the first woman on the Supreme Court, says she has the beginning stages of dementia and "probably Alzheimer's disease." O'Connor made the announcement in a letter Tuesday
5:50PM ( 1 month ago )
AP Health - Senior Health
End of an era: Germany closes its last black coal mine
Germany has closed the last of its black coal mines, ending an industry that fueled the country's industrial revolution and its post-war economic recovery
1:20PM ( 3 hours ago )
Stock indexes sink again, adding to days of huge losses
Stock indexes falling again at midday Friday after days of big losses that have left major indexes down 11 percent in December
12:50PM ( 4 hours ago )
Death toll in Czech mine explosion increases to 13
A spokesman for a mining company says the death toll in a methane explosion that hit a coal mine in northeast Czech Republic has increased to 13
9:48AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Mnuchin says market's negative reaction to Fed 'overblown'
Treasury Secretary Mnuchin says market's negative reaction to Fed 'completely overblown'
2:32PM ( 1 day ago )
US stocks slide again following several days of steep losses
US stocks are falling again, adding to the steep losses in recent days as investors remain concerned that economic growth around the world and in the U.S. could slow dramatically over the next few years.
1:07PM ( 1 day ago )
Global stocks plunge after Wall Street fall on rate hike
Global stocks plunge after Fed raises US interest rates, Wall Street tumbles
3:43AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
Appeals court agrees to hear case involving Trump DC hotel
Federal appeals court agrees to hear lawsuit accusing Donald Trump of profiting off the presidency
10:52PM ( 18 hours ago )
Holiday gift: Boston College walk-on Herren gets scholarship
Boston College freshman walk-on Chris Herren Jr. awarded full scholarship by coach Jim Christian after practice
4:20PM ( 1 day ago )
How taxpayers can deal with new state, local deduction caps
A new rule caps the state and local taxes you can deduct on your federal tax return; tax pros say there are a few ways to cope
11:08AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Anthony Jones rushes for 3 scores, FIU beats Toledo 35-32
Comeback complete: Anthony Jones rushes for 3 scores, FIU rallies past Toledo 35-32 in Bahamas Bowl
5:01PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Report says 16.7M faulty Takata air bags still on US roads
More than three years after the government took over management of recalls involving dangerous Takata air bag inflators, one third of the recalled inflators still have not been replaced
4:57PM ( 12 minutes ago )
North Carolina asked feds to open vote fraud case last year
North Carolina's top elections official pleaded nearly two years ago for the Justice Department to charge those people now at the center last month's ballot fraud allegations
4:54PM ( 14 minutes ago )
The Latest: VP Pence meets with Schumer, Ryan at Capitol
Vice President Mike Pence is making the rounds on Capitol Hill ahead of a midnight deadline to avert a partial government shutdown
4:51PM ( 18 minutes ago )
A decade-long rally on Wall Street looks like it's ending
The nearly 10-year stock market rally looks like it's fading after another day of big losses Friday left the U.S. market with its worst week in more than seven years
4:39PM ( 29 minutes ago )