Sunday February 23rd, 2020 11:57AM

Paris riots over fuel taxes dim hopes for climate fight

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

PARIS (AP) — The "yellow vests" in France are worrying greens around the world.

The worst riots in Paris in decades were sparked by higher fuel taxes, and French President Emmanuel Macron responded by scrapping them Wednesday. But taxes on fossil fuels are just what international climate negotiators, meeting in Poland this week, say are desperately needed to help wean the world off of fossil fuels and slow climate change.

"The events of the last few days in Paris have made me regard the challenges as even greater than I thought earlier," said Stanford University environmental economist Lawrence Goulder, author of the book "Confronting the Climate Challenge."

Economists, policymakers and politicians have long said the best way to fight climate change is to put a higher price on the fuels that are causing it — gasoline, diesel, coal and natural gas. Taxing fuels and electricity could help pay for the damage they cause, encourage people to use less, and make it easier for cleaner alternatives and fuel-saving technologies to compete.

These so-called carbon taxes are expected to be a major part of pushing the world to reduce carbon dioxide emissions and try to prevent runaway climate change that economists say would be far more expensive over the long term than paying more for energy in the short term.

But it's not so easy for people to think about long-term, global problems when they are struggling to get by.

Macron said the higher tax was his way of trying to prevent the end of the world. But the yellow vest protesters turned that around with the slogan: "it's hard to talk about the end of the world while we are talking about the end of the month."

The resistance to the fuel tax is a personal blow to Macron, who sees himself as the guarantor of the 2015 Paris climate accord, its strongest defender on the global stage. He has positioned himself as the anti-Trump when it comes to climate issues.

The French government quietly fears a Trump-led backlash against the accord could spread to other major economies whose commitment is essential to keeping the deal together.

The fuel tax was not originally Macron's idea; it dates back to previous administrations. But he vigorously defended it and won the presidency in part on a promise to fight climate change.

So what went wrong?

Yale University economist William Nordhaus, who won this year's Nobel prize for economics, said the tax was poorly designed and was delivered by the wrong person. "If you want to make energy taxes unpopular, step one is to be an unpopular leader," he said. "Step two is to use gasoline taxes and call them carbon taxes. This is hard enough without adding poor design."

Macron, like French presidents before him, made environmental and energy decisions without explaining to the public how important they are and how their lives will change. He's also seen as the "president of the rich" — his first fiscal decision as president was scrapping a wealth tax. So hiking taxes on gasoline and diesel was seen as especially unfair to the working classes in the provinces who need cars to get to work and whose incomes have stagnated for years.

The French government already has programs in place to subsidize drivers who trade in older, dirtier cars for cleaner ones, and expanded them in an attempt to head off the protests last month. But for many French, it was too little, too late.

The French reaction to higher fuel prices is hardly unique, which highlights just how hard it can be to discourage fossil fuel consumption by making people pay more. In September, protests in India over high gasoline prices shut down schools and government offices. Protests erupted in Mexico in 2017 after government deregulation caused a spike in gasoline prices, and in Indonesia in 2013 when the government reduced fuel subsidies and prices rose.

In the United States, Washington state voters handily defeated a carbon tax in November.

"Higher taxes on fuel have always been a policy more popular among economists than among voters," said Greg Mankiw, a Harvard economist and former adviser to President George W. Bush.

Even proponents of carbon taxes acknowledge that they can disproportionally hurt low-income people. Energy costs make up a larger portion of their overall expenses, so a fuel price increase eats up more of their paycheck and leaves them with less to spend. And because energy costs are almost impossible to avoid, they feel trapped.

It is also not lost on them that it is the rich, unbothered by fuel taxes, who are hardest on the environment because they travel and consume more.

"The mistake of the Macron government was not to marry the increase in fuel taxes with other sufficiently compelling initiatives promising to enhance the welfare and incomes of the 'yellow vests,' said Barry Eichengreen, an economist at the University of California, Berkeley.

Now the question is "How can we address the climate problem while also avoiding producing political upheaval," Goulder said.

The key is giving a good chunk of money back to the people, Wesleyan University environmental economist Gary Yohe said.

Many economists back proposals that would tax carbon, but then use that money to offer tax rebates or credits that would benefit lower-income families.

The protests, while sparked by fuel prices, are also about income inequality, populism and anti-elitism, experts say, not just about carbon taxes.

"Is it a death knell for the carbon tax or pricing carbon? I don't think so," economist Yohe said. "It is just a call for being a little bit more careful about how you design the damn thing."


AP science writer Seth Borenstein reported from Washington. AP economics writer Christopher Rugaber contributed from Washington and Frank Jordans contributed from Katowice, Poland.


Read more stories on climate issues by The Associated Press at .


Follow Seth Borenstein on Twitter at @borenbears and Angela Charlton at @acharlton .


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Israeli media: Early elections called for April 9
Israeli media are reporting that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government has agreed to hold early elections on April 9.
7:51AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Sudan soccer fans clash with police, call on Bashir to leave
Sudanese soccer fans call on Bashir to step down, clash with police
7:38AM ( 35 minutes ago )
Cause of Indonesia tsunami pondered amid search for missing
Indonesian government workers and volunteers searched debris-strewn beaches for survivors and bodies, while families tried to identify their loved ones and grieved for the dead from a nighttime tsunami that struck beaches along an Indonesian strait
7:34AM ( 39 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Mattis leaving Pentagon sooner than planned, Shanahan tapped
Mattis' stepped-up departure shifts focus to acting Pentagon chief, plans for permanent replacement
5:38AM ( 2 hours ago )
White House: Trump would accept less money for border wall
White House official says it's 'very possible' partial shutdown will stretch into next year
5:29AM ( 2 hours ago )
Indonesia tsunami survivors sought as families mourn dead
Indonesian government workers and volunteers searched debris-strewn beaches for survivors and bodies, while families tried to identify their loved ones and grieved for the dead from a nighttime tsunami that struck beaches along an Indonesian strait
5:20AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Eagles stay alive with 32-30 win over Texans
Jake Elliott kicked a 35-yard field goal as time expired and the Philadelphia Eagles beat the Houston Texans 32-30 to keep their playoff hopes alive
11:50PM ( 8 hours ago )
Saints narrowly upend Steelers and take top NFC seed
Drew Brees' late 2-yard touchdown pass to Michael Thomas lifted New Orleans to a 31-28 win over Pittsburgh that earned the Saints the top seed in the NFC and damaged the Steelers' playoff hopes
10:26PM ( 9 hours ago )
London airport open, but location of drone culprit up in air
London's Gatwick Airport is operating without problems, but the drone operators who brought flights to a standstill over multiple days remain at large and a potential threat
9:56PM ( 10 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
French prime minister defends police targeted by protesters
Paris police are investigating alleged anti-Semitic comments by yellow vest protesters in the city subway toward a woman whose father died at Auschwitz
5:34AM ( 2 hours ago )
Turkey-backed Syrian fighters prepare to replace US forces
A spokesman for Turkish-backed Syrian forces says they are preparing to deploy in eastern Syria alongside Turkish troops once American forces withdraw
5:24AM ( 2 hours ago )
Tsunami hits without warning in Indonesia, killing over 220
Witnesses say a deadly tsunami that killed at least 222 people along Indonesia's Sunda Strait came with no warning
5:55PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP World News
European, Asian markets mostly lower in light trading
European and Asian markets are mostly lower in light trading as a partial U.S. government shutdown stemmed holiday cheer
4:09AM ( 4 hours ago )
Asian shares mixed on US partial shutdown, Wall Street slump
Asian stocks mixed as Wall Street slump, partial U.S. government shutdown stem holiday cheer
1:46AM ( 6 hours ago )
Treasury Secretary talks to bank CEOs amid Wall St. jitters
U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin calls major bank CEOs in apparent attempt to stabilize jittery markets
7:20PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business
School bus driver shortage creates headaches for districts
School districts throughout the U.S. are struggling to find school bus drivers, a challenge that has worsened with low unemployment and a strong economy
11:03AM ( 21 hours ago )
Trump aide: White House, central bank tension not unusual
A White House official says tension between a president and the interest-rate setting Federal Reserve is "traditional as part of our system."
10:48AM ( 21 hours ago )
Lebanese, some in yellow vests, protest political gridlock
Hundreds of Lebanese are protesting against deteriorating economic conditions as politicians are deadlocked over forming a new government
10:41AM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
FDA casts shadow on hemp win, calling CBD products illegal
The hemp industry still has work ahead to win legal status for hemp-derived cannabidiol, or CBD oil, as an ingredient in food or dietary supplements despite the big farm bill President Donald Trump signed this week designating hemp as an agricultural crop
3:23AM ( 2 days ago )
A decade-long rally on Wall Street looks like it's ending
The nearly 10-year stock market rally looks like it's fading after another day of big losses Friday left the U.S. market with its worst week in more than seven years
9:02PM ( 2 days ago )
Fiance accused of killing Colorado woman missing for month
A mystery surrounds why and how a Colorado woman was killed vanishing for a month
8:01PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Industries
Austrian leader says tax could deter investment in Romania
Austrian Chancellor Sebastian Kurz has warned that Austrian companies could pull out of Romania after the government unveiled a surprise plan to levy extra taxes on banks and energy companies
3:56PM ( 2 days ago )
US aircraft carrier enters Persian Gulf after long absence
First US aircraft carrier enters Persian Gulf after American withdrawal from Iran deal; ends longest absence since at least 9/11
2:44PM ( 2 days ago )
Tech stocks drop again as huge losses pile up on Wall Street
More misery for technology stocks pulled major indexes lower on Wall Street Friday, worsening what's turning into the worst month for the market in a decade.
2:43PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Sudan soccer fans clash with police, call on Bashir to leave
Sudanese soccer fans call on Bashir to step down, clash with police
7:38AM ( 37 minutes ago )
Cause of Indonesia tsunami pondered amid search for missing
Indonesian government workers and volunteers searched debris-strewn beaches for survivors and bodies, while families tried to identify their loved ones and grieved for the dead from a nighttime tsunami that struck beaches along an Indonesian strait
7:34AM ( 41 minutes ago )
The Latest: Searchers look for victims; tsunami toll now 280
Thousands of soldiers, police and government personnel as well as volunteers are working to find victims of an Indonesian tsunami that killed at least 280 people
6:50AM ( 1 hour ago )
Pakistan's former PM sentenced to 7 years for corruption
A court in Pakistan has sentenced former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif to seven years in prison for corruption and acquitted him in a second case
6:24AM ( 1 hour ago )
A taste of home: Syrian TV-chef opens restaurant in Berlin
Syrian TV chef known as the 'queen of cooking' opens restaurant in Berlin hoping to provide a taste of home for the thousands of new arrivals who have fled the country's brutal civil war
6:07AM ( 2 hours ago )