Tuesday March 19th, 2019 7:15PM

Democrats eye Trump's tax returns but expect a long fight

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Getting President Donald Trump's tax returns is high on the list of Democratic priorities now that they have won the House.

By law, the leaders of tax-writing committees in the House and Senate can obtain tax returns and related information from the Internal Revenue Service. Democrats will control the House panel next year.

Yet there's no guarantee that the Trump administration will provide the president's returns. That sets up the possibility of a legal battle over the request that could take years to resolve.

Trump broke with political tradition in 2016 by refusing to release his income tax filings. He says he won't release them because he's under audit, and he claimed at a press conference this week that the filings are too complex for people to understand.

The Democrats tried and failed several times to obtain Trump's returns as the minority party in Congress. Now, having gained some control, they see them within their grasp.

Eyes are on Rep. Richard Neal of Massachusetts, who is now the senior Democrat on the powerful Ways and Means Committee and will become its chairman in January.

When asked Wednesday whether the committee under his control would ask for the documents, Neal said, "Yes, I think we will."

If the Trump administration refuses and mounts a legal challenge, Neal said, "Then I assume that there would be a court case that would go on for a period of time."

A legal fight could potentially even stretch beyond the 2020 presidential election, suggested Andy Grewal, a professor at the University of Iowa College of Law.

Grewal has maintained that a request for Trump's returns, if made for "purely political purposes," may exceed the limits of Congress' authority.

Starting with the 2016 campaign, Trump broke with political tradition by repeatedly refusing to release his income tax filings. Those filings are deemed sacredly secret for citizens, but traditionally not for presidents. Trump has said he hasn't released them because his taxes are under audit by the IRS — even though experts and IRS officials say such audits don't bar taxpayers from releasing their returns.

Asked about releasing his filings, Trump reaffirmed that justification during a post-election news conference Wednesday. "They're under audit. They have been for a long time," the president said. "They're extremely complex. People wouldn't understand them."

Giving a slight opening, Trump said that if the audit was completed, "I would have an open mind to it. I would say that." But, he added, "Nobody turns over a return when it's under audit."

In 2017, more than a million people signed a petition to the White House urging Trump to make the returns public.

Questions loom: Was the swaggering longtime businessman and real estate mogul really worth $10 billion when he entered the White House, as he has claimed? Are there conflicts of interest lurking? How has his global panoply of properties and other assets been valued for taxation purposes? What are the sources of his income and to whom might he be beholden as a result? Does Trump stand to gain personally from the sweeping Republican tax law enacted late last year, which he championed, and, if so, how specifically?

Among the sought-after details: Trump's charitable giving, the type of deductions he claimed, how much he earned from his assets and what strategies he deployed to reduce his tax bill.

House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi declined during a press conference Wednesday to specifically address the question of Trump's returns, saying only that Congress has "a constitutional responsibility to have oversight" and citing examples such as the government's environmental policy that would be ripe for Congress to investigate.

The high interest — Democrats would say the urgency — in lifting the veil on Trump's taxes ramped up last month when The New York Times published an extensive report suggesting that the Trump family cheated the IRS for decades, undervaluing reported assets and using dubious tax maneuvers and outright fraud in some cases.

A lawyer for Trump disputed the Times' findings of possible tax fraud or evasion and said that parts of the report were "extremely inaccurate." The newspaper said its report was based on more than 100,000 pages of financial documents, including confidential tax returns from Trump's father and his companies.

That could spur the Democrats on the Ways and Means Committee to ask for Trump's returns going back many years.

By law, the chairmen of the House panel, the Senate Finance Committee and the Joint Committee on Taxation can make a written request for any tax returns to the Treasury Secretary, who oversees the IRS. The law says the Treasury chief "shall furnish" the requested information to the members of the committee for them to examine behind closed doors.

The IRS, with custody of Trump's returns, has been headed since Oct. 1 by a commissioner who worked as a private tax attorney for nearly four decades representing individuals and companies in cases before the agency. During the 2016 campaign, the commissioner, Charles Rettig, defended Trump's refusal to release his filings. He promised at his Senate confirmation hearing to uphold the IRS' political independence from the White House.

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin "will review any request with the Treasury general counsel for legality," the department said in a statement Thursday.

Trump's attorney Rudy Giuliani has said the Democrats could have a hard time proving their demand was intended for pursuing legitimate congressional oversight, not a political scavenger hunt.

If the administration refuses to hand over the returns, the Democrat-led committee might punch back with subpoenas, move to hold officials in contempt of Congress or sue the administration. There's no roadmap or historical precedent for the situation.

Some observers anticipate that the Trump Justice Department would file a lawsuit against the House to block release of the returns. In that case, the administration might try to prove that the Democrats' demand was politically motivated, as Giuliani indicated.

The University of Iowa's Grewal is among the experts who believe the administration may seek to make that case.

But Joe Thorndike, director of the tax history project at publisher Tax Analysts, says he doubts that argument could succeed. "It's not unreasonable for a member of Congress to be concerned about the president's tax returns," he said.

George Yin, a professor of law and taxation at the University of Virginia who formerly was chief of staff for the Joint Committee on Taxation, asserts that Congress has the clear right to obtain and release a president's tax returns to the public without his or her consent — provided the disclosure would be in the public interest.

Not so fast, says Ken Kies, another former chief of staff for the joint tax panel, who's now a tax lobbyist. "I'd be really uncomfortable about that," he said.

The federal tax code authorizes the lawmakers who obtain tax returns to file a detailed report on them to the full U.S. House, which essentially would put the information into the public domain. But lawmakers and committee staff could be subject to criminal penalties, including prison sentences, for unauthorized disclosure of tax material.

"I would never take possession of those tax returns if I were (Neal)," said Janice Mays, a former chief counsel and staff director for the Ways and Means Committee who is managing director of tax policy services at consulting firm PwC. "I would visit the IRS and inspect them there."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Democrats eye Trump's tax returns but expect a long fight
Getting President Donald Trump's tax returns is a top priority for Democrats now that they've won the House, but there's no guarantee he will turn them over.
1:07AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Conservatives push for change after GOP loses the House
Conservatives are blaming the GOP establishment for midterm losses, and angling for changes
12:59AM ( 29 minutes ago )
Roethlisberger throws for 5 TDs, Steelers rip Panthers 52-21
Ben Roethlisberger threw for 328 yards and five touchdowns, James Conner ran for 65 yards and a score before leaving late with a possible concussion and the Steelers pounded the Carolina Panthers 52-21 for their fifth straight victory
12:56AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Possible recounts loom in tight Florida gov, Senate contests
Possible recounts loom in Florida races for governor, US Senate as Republicans hold razor-thin leads in both contests
12:43AM ( 45 minutes ago )
Imelda Marcos convicted of graft, court orders her arrest
Former first lady Imelda Marcos convicted in one of many corruption cases against her; she's likely to appeal to avoid jail and losing her seat in Congress
12:13AM ( 1 hour ago )
Wildfire devastates California town of Paradise
Cal Fire captain says entire community destroyed, couple of thousand structures destroyed after wildfire strikes Northern California city
12:12AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Wildfire destroys most of California town of Paradise
Cal Fire Capt. Scott McLean says: "Pretty much the community of Paradise is destroyed, it's that kind of devastation"
11:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
Expert: Acosta video distributed by White House was doctored
An expert says a video tweeted by the White House of an interaction between CNN reporter Jim Acosta and a White House intern appears to have been manipulated
11:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
Florida faces prospect of recounts in governor, Senate races
Florida faces prospect of recounts in razor-thin races for governor and the U.S. Senate, potentially prolonging battle in two the nation's most closely watched midterm races
11:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online National News
Georgia's Kemp says he's governor-elect, Abrams fights on
Republican Brian Kemp says he's Georgia's governor elect and resigns as secretary of state, but Democratic rival Stacey Abrams fights on
11:09PM ( 2 hours ago )
Tens of thousands of people flee fast-moving wildfire
Tens of thousands of people flee fast-moving Northern California wildfire as officials report hundreds of structures destroyed
10:04PM ( 3 hours ago )
Some survived shootings in Vegas, California bar - except 1
Some of the people who survived the Las Vegas massacre last year found themselves in another mass shooting, this time at a Southern California bar
10:02PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Florida staring at possibility of recounts in key races
Democrat Andrew Gillum's campaign says it's prepared for a recount in the Florida governor race he conceded to Republican Ron DeSantis on Tuesday night.
9:51PM ( 3 hours ago )
Pelosi unveils plans to establish new House diversity office
Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi wants to establish a House diversity office to recruit and hire employees to work in congressional offices
9:11PM ( 4 hours ago )
Delaware politicians bury a hatchet in post-election ritual
Burying the hatchet: Following the nation's rancorous midterm elections, Delaware politicians are gathering for a time-honored, post-campaign ritual to settle their partisan differences, if only for the moment
9:11PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Women split vote as GOP gets Tennessee's 1st female senator
Women voters were split on electing Republican Marsha Blackburn as Tennessee's first female U.S. senator
6:04PM ( 7 hours ago )
APNewsBreak: Govt Olympic funds not usable for abuse probes
APNewsBreak: Government Olympic funds cannot be used for sex-abuse investigations
5:45PM ( 7 hours ago )
LGBT triumphs: 2 governorships, at least 9 seats in Congress
LGBT candidates scored a raft of notable election victories _ winning two governorships, at least nine seats in Congress, and their first-ever legislative seats in Indiana, Kansas and Nebraska
5:42PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Asian stock markets sink after Wall Street rally fades
Asian stock markets have fallen after a post-election Wall Street rally faded and the U.S. Federal Reserve suggested it will raise interest rates
10:35PM ( 2 hours ago )
Fire kills at least 7 at dormitory-style housing in S. Korea
A fire at a low-cost dormitory-style housing facility in central Seoul has killed at least seven people and injured 11 others
9:22PM ( 4 hours ago )
Chinese leaders struggle to dispel stock market gloom
China's stock market gloom defies government efforts to restore confidence after 30 percent price plunge
8:10PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
New Tesla chairwoman's biggest challenge is controlling Musk
Australian telecommunications executive Robyn Denholm brings much-needed financial and auto industry expertise to her new role as Tesla's board chairwoman, but her biggest unknown is whether she can rein in a CEO with a proclivity for misbehavior
5:17PM ( 8 hours ago )
Oil prices sink again as post-election stock surge fades
US stocks fall as the market's big rally from a day earlier fades, while oil prices fall for the ninth day in a row
4:51PM ( 8 hours ago )
Ford buys electric scooter sharing company Spin
Ford Motor buys electric scooter sharing company Spin, expanding its presence in alternative forms of transportation
4:48PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Conservatives push for change after GOP loses the House
Conservatives are blaming the GOP establishment for midterm losses, and angling for changes
12:59AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Roethlisberger throws for 5 TDs, Steelers rip Panthers 52-21
Ben Roethlisberger threw for 328 yards and five touchdowns, James Conner ran for 65 yards and a score before leaving late with a possible concussion and the Steelers pounded the Carolina Panthers 52-21 for their fifth straight victory
12:56AM ( 33 minutes ago )
Democrats promise congressional action on gun control
Democrats are promising congressional action on gun control
12:56AM ( 33 minutes ago )
US immigration officials aim to restrict asylum at border
The Trump administration says it will deny asylum to migrants who enter the country illegally
12:54AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Migrants decide to depart Mexico City with or without buses
Thousands of Central American migrants decided to depart Mexico City early Friday and head toward the northern city of Tijuana, opting for the longer but likely safer route to the U.S. border
12:53AM ( 36 minutes ago )