Monday December 9th, 2019 2:11PM

Obama's health insurance overhaul a winner in midterms

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The personality looming over the 2018 midterms was President Donald Trump. The issue was health care, the top concern for voters as they decided how to cast their ballots.

This week's election showed a nation increasingly — if belatedly — in step with former President Barack Obama's approach to it.

Health care was the top issue for about one-fourth of voters, ahead of immigration and jobs and the economy, according to VoteCast, a nationwide survey of more than 115,000 voters and about 22,000 nonvoters conducted for The Associated Press by NORC at the University of Chicago.

Those most concerned with health care supported Democratic candidates overwhelmingly, helping the party claim the House.

While Republicans' hold on the Senate grew, putting Democrats in control of the lower chamber makes it even less likely that Trump will be able to undo Obama's overhaul, which created subsidized coverage for some lower-income people, allowed states to expand Medicaid coverage for others with the federal government picking up most of the cost, and barred insurers from discriminating against people with pre-existing medical conditions.

The law was one of Obama's key legislative accomplishments, but it proved unpopular after Democrats passed it without a single Republican vote. A backlash propelled the GOP to take control of the House in 2010 and the Senate in 2014, significantly narrowing what Obama could accomplish.

But by last year, "Obamacare" was popular enough that a GOP-controlled Senate blocked an effort to scrap the overhaul.

That vote was a factor in the only Senate race where a Republican incumbent lost a re-election bid.

In Nevada, where the majority of voters said they disapproved of Trump's handling of health care, Democratic challenger Jacky Rosen attacked incumbent Republican Sen. Dean Heller for supporting Trump's effort to repeal the health care law.

"In time, changes will be made," Mike Leavitt, health secretary under President George W. Bush, told the AP. "But repealing the statute is now not possible, even in the mind of the most ardent opponent."

The health care impact of the election goes beyond Congress.

Voters in the Republican-dominated states of Idaho, Nebraska and Utah all passed ballot measures to expand Medicaid, which could bring coverage for an additional 363,000 low-income adults, adding to the 12 million already covered by the expansion elsewhere. Under the Affordable Care Act, federal taxpayers pick up most of the bill for the expansion. Starting in 2020, states will have to contribute 10 percent of the cost.

"For all the people who have been slipping through the cracks in our health care system in Utah, there is finally good news," RyLee Curtis, campaign manager for Utah Decides Healthcare, said Wednesday on a conference call with reporters. "Help is on the way."

Advocates, however, were disappointed by the outcome in Montana, where voters rejected a measure that would have made that state's Medicaid expansion permanent with financing from a tobacco tax. The debate isn't over, but it will move to the state legislature instead.

Jonathan Schleifer, executive director of The Fairness Project, which campaigned for the expansion measures, said states including Missouri, Florida and Oklahoma could be pursued for future ballot measures.

Democrats picked up governorships Tuesday in two states that may now expand Medicaid — Kansas and Wisconsin.

In Kansas, health care tied with immigration as voters' top issue. In Wisconsin, which did not join the federal Medicaid expansion but does allow more adults into the program already, it was the biggest concern identified by about one-third of voters.

In both states, about 7 in 10 of voters who said health care was their main concern voted for the Democrat for governor.

That helped put Tony Evers over the top in his race against incumbent Republican Scott Walker in Wisconsin and pushed Laura Kelly to victory in a close race against Republican Kris Kobach in Kansas.

Kelly got big cheers in her victory speech when she called for a Medicaid expansion, which she said was important "so that more Kansans have access to affordable health care, our rural hospitals will stay open and the tax dollars we've been sending to Washington will come back home."

Medicaid was also a key issue in Maine, where voters last year approved a ballot measure to expand but where the current governor, Republican Paul LePage, refused to implement it. Democrat Janet Mills campaigned on implementing it and defeated Republican Shawn Moody, who campaigned against expansion.

Tuesday's election results were far less clear on where Americans stand on a move to universal health coverage, an idea that a growing number of Democratic candidates, including several considering presidential bids, have been backing.

In his campaign for governor in Florida, Democrat Andrew Gillum called health care for all a "north star" that the state should aspire to while offering up the intermediate step of expanding Medicaid as a must-do in the nation's third most populous state. The majority of Florida voters in the AP survey disapproved of Trump's handling of health care, and 3 in 5 also said it should be the government's responsibility to provide coverage.

There, health care was tied with immigration as voters' top concern and Republican Ron DeSantis, a former member of Congress closely aligned with Trump, won.

Meanwhile in Colorado, Jared Polis, a Democrat, was elected governor while promoting a single-payer health system for the state. Voters there rejected a ballot measure to create such a system two years ago.

Charles Idelson, a spokesman for National Nurses United, a group pushing for single-payer health coverage, said the number of supporters of the concept is increasing at all levels of government after the election despite what he called "vilification of that issue and the demagoguery of that issue" by Republicans in campaign ads.

Kathleen Sebelius, health secretary under Obama, told the AP she expects House Democrats to start designing a framework for covering all Americans and for that to be a major issue in 2020 elections.

"One of the things this election clearly demonstrates is that health care for all is a unifying principle for the Democrats," she said. "We have been working toward that goal since 1965, when Medicare and Medicaid were passed."


Mulvihill reported from Philadelphia. Follow him at


For AP's complete coverage of the U.S. midterm elections:

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Williams runs wild, Texas A&M routs NC State 52-13 in Gator
Trayveon Williams ran for 236 yards and three touchdowns, smashing a 30-year-old school record and carrying No. 21 Texas A&M to a 52-13 victory against beat North Carolina State in the Gator Bowl
11:09PM ( 5 days ago )
Harden's 43 points, triple-double lead Rockets over Memphis
James Harden had a triple-double of 43 points, 10 rebounds and 13 assists to lead the Houston Rockets to their fifth straight win, 113-101, over the Memphis Grizzlies on Monday night
10:53PM ( 5 days ago )
Deadline passes without Russian turnover of data to WADA
Deadline passes without Russian turnover of data, samples to WADA
10:43PM ( 5 days ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Animal advocates: Fatal zoo mauling shows need for crackdown
Animal welfare advocates say fatal mauling of intern illustrates need to crack down on unaccredited exhibitors
9:36PM ( 5 days ago )
The Latest: House Dems unveil plan to re-open government
House Democrats have unveiled a package of bills that would re-open the federal government without approving funding for President Donald Trump's border wall with Mexico
9:31PM ( 5 days ago )
Human waste, trash overwhelm some national parks in shutdown
Human feces, overflowing garbage, illegal off-roading and other damaging behavior in fragile areas were beginning to overwhelm some of the West's iconic national parks
8:52PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Trump says he's ready to negotiate with Dems
President Donald Trump says he's "ready, willing and able" to negotiate an end to the partial government shutdown that has now stretched into its 10th day
5:27PM ( 5 days ago )
House Democrats have a plan to re-open government
House Democrats are introducing legislation to re-open government, but without extra money for President Donald Trump's border wall
3:30PM ( 5 days ago )
Mattis' final words from Pentagon: 'Hold fast' with allies
Jim Mattis ended one of history's more turbulent tenures as defense secretary by re-emphasizing a key difference with President Donald Trump and encouraging Pentagon employees, civilian and military, to "hold fast" in defense of the nation
3:26PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Congress News
Elizabeth Warren makes big move toward 2020 presidential run
Sen. Elizabeth Warren is taking the first major step toward running for president
4:27PM ( 5 days ago )
Bangladesh prime minister denies accusations of rigged vote
Bangladesh Prime Minister-elect Sheikh Hasina is trumpeting her accomplishments and dismissing opposition claims that an election giving her a record fourth term in power was rigged
3:29PM ( 5 days ago )
Congo cuts internet after presidential poll beset by delays
As votes are counted Monday in Congo's long-delayed presidential election, the internet was cut across the vast Central African country, apparently to prevent social media speculation about the results
1:35PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Elections
The Latest: Congo counts ballots after day of voting snags
Election officials in Congo are counting ballots from Sunday's presidential election after a day in which numerous problems hampered voting across the vast Central African nation
5:08PM ( 6 days ago )
Afghan official: New date for presidential polls is July 20
Afghanistan's Independent Election Commission says presidential polls initially scheduled for April, will now be held July 20 to allow time to fix technical problems that surfaced during October parliamentary elections
12:05PM ( 6 days ago )
The Latest: Congo polls remain open for whoever is in line
The Latest: Congo polls remain open for those in line; frustration, optimism amid the wait
11:24AM ( 6 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
US stocks end dismal, volatile year on a bright note
Wall Street closed out a dismal, turbulent year for stocks on a bright note Monday, but still finished 2018 with the worst showing in a decade.
9:52PM ( 5 days ago )
Prosecutors: Fires may mean PG&E violated criminal sentence
Federal prosecutors say a California utility's role in igniting wildfires last year could allow a judge to find that it violated terms of its criminal conviction in a deadly gas pipeline explosion
9:13PM ( 5 days ago )
NASA spacecraft enters orbit around asteroid, sets records
A NASA spacecraft has gone into orbit around an ancient asteroid, setting a record
8:32PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Bangladesh opposition calls election 'farcical'
Bangladesh opposition alliance leader Kamal Hossain has called the country's general election "farcical," and says any outcome will be rejected
3:22PM ( 6 days ago )
Congo on Sunday faces a troubled, long-delayed election
Congo on Sunday faces a troubled, long-delayed election; 'We will contest the results'
1:26PM ( 1 week ago )
In Iowa, Democrats see 2020 as head vs. heart moment
In Iowa, Democrats see presidential race as test of head vs. heart
5:34AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Independence decree presented to Ukrainian Orthodox bishop
The Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople has presented a decree of independence to the Metropolitan bishop of the nascent Orthodox Church of Ukraine.
3:42AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Gaga, 'A Star Is Born' poised to dominate Golden Globes
Lady Gaga is poised to win not just one but two awards when the 76th annual Golden Globes get under way Sunday night
3:21AM ( 43 minutes ago )
Nevada inmate whose execution called off found dead in cell
Officials say a Nevada death-row inmate who declared he wanted to die, but whose execution was postponed twice, has been found dead in his cell from an apparent hanging
3:17AM ( 47 minutes ago )
Police: Man, 20, charged with capital murder in girl's death
Authorities in Texas have charged a 20-year-old man in the shooting death of a 7-year-old black girl who was killed while riding in a vehicle with her family
2:18AM ( 1 hour ago )
Former Defense Secretary Harold Brown dies at 91
Former Defense Secretary Harold Brown, who guided American military during the Carter administration, dies at 91
2:14AM ( 1 hour ago )