Tuesday July 7th, 2020 9:00PM

Objections blunt momentum for foreign lobbying law overhaul

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A push to give the Justice Department more enforcement authority over the lucrative and at times shadowy world of foreign lobbying is stalled amid opposition from pro-business groups, nonprofits and privacy advocates.

Organizations that range from the influential U.S. Chamber of Commerce to the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers have raised objections to legislation that would sharpen the teeth of the Foreign Agents Registration Act. The law, enacted 80 years ago to expose Nazi propaganda, requires people to disclose when they lobby in the U.S. on behalf of foreign governments or political entities.

While there's bipartisan support for cracking down on unregistered foreign agents, several of the changes proposed in congressional bills could backfire by sweeping in a host of unintended targets, according to critics. That pushback has effectively kept the legislation from advancing as lobbying groups press for revisions.

One of the most contentious provisions would eliminate a popular loophole that permits lobbyists representing foreign commercial interests to be exempt from the law, known as FARA. That shift, one business group has warned, could extend the rigorous disclosure requirements to U.S. subsidiaries of global companies, stigmatizing them as foreign agents even though they employ thousands of Americans.

Congressional interest in fortifying the law comes in the aftermath of Russia's meddling in the 2016 election and a special counsel investigation that's drawn greater attention to the inner workings of international influence peddling.

Most recently, Paul Manafort, the former Trump campaign chairman, admitted in a plea deal that he'd failed to register as a foreign agent when he directed a lobbying operation for Ukrainian interests. Prosecutors said he concealed millions of dollars in income for the work from the IRS.

Earlier this year, federal prosecutors unveiled an indictment against a Russian troll farm accused of interfering in the 2016 election through bogus Facebook posts that revealed how foreign parties can weaponize social media to influence public opinion.

Yet criminal cases under FARA have been rare, with fewer than a dozen since 1966 as the Justice Department generally emphasized voluntary compliance over prosecution. Lawmakers supporting the bills say a 2016 inspector general's report found that the department lacked the tools it needed to properly enforce FARA. A violation of the law is punishable by a fine or up to five years in prison.

But the defense lawyers association and the Center for Democracy and Technology, a civil-liberties group, have declared that Fourth Amendment privacy protections would be undermined by a section of the bill that would expand the Justice Department's power to investigate possible violations of the law.

And an alliance of nongovernmental organizations called InterAction has urged lawmakers to repair vague and outdated provisions in the current law before passing a new one that strengthens the government's hand. These groups fear that the law, if not repaired, could leave nonprofits open "to possible politicized enforcement actions and attack," according to an open letter more than 40 members and partners of InterAction wrote earlier this year.

The House version of the bill, sponsored by Rep. Mike Johnson, R-La., seemed to be on the fast track to passage in the GOP-led House after a committee approved it in January by a comfortable margin. Yet eight months later, it hasn't moved any further.

Johnson described the objections as "overblown" and said he's hopeful the full House will vote on his bill before the end of the year. The House is in recess and won't return until after the Nov. 6 elections.

"People in Washington are resistant to change," Johnson said. "The longer we wait to enact these reforms the more critical they become."

An identical Senate bill, by Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, is bottled up in the Foreign Relations Committee. Grassley charged last year that there has been "rampant disregard" of the law by foreign agents and "lackluster enforcement by federal authorities."

President Donald Trump invoked the law in a Sept. 13 tweet that attacked former Secretary of State John Kerry for meeting with Iran's foreign minister, who was his main interlocutor during the Iran nuclear deal negotiations. Trump called the meetings illegal and questioned whether Kerry, now a private citizen, had registered as a foreign agent.

But Trump's broadside appeared to be off base. Meetings between a private U.S. citizen and foreign official are not against the law and not necessarily inappropriate or a violation of federal regulations. Further, FARA provisions don't extend to activities conducted entirely overseas.

"What we are currently seeing is a lot of confusion over the vagueness of FARA and concern that the breadth of the law can lead to its politicized use," said Nick Robinson, legal adviser at the International Center for Not-for-Profit Law.

Lobbyists that register under FARA must report specific meetings, phone calls and other details of contacts with members of Congress or federal officials to the Justice Department, which then posts the material online .

The loophole targeted for elimination permits lobbyists representing foreign commercial interests to get an exemption provided that they register under the less-demanding Lobbying Disclosure Act. The quarterly reports filed with the House and Senate under the 1995 Lobbying Disclosure Act also are made public but require much less information.

U.S.-based subsidiaries of international companies say the change may lead officials to avoid meeting with companies bound by FARA, putting them at a disadvantage with their domestic competitors.

The legislation is supposed to target foreign governments or political parties but may "catch these companies in the crosshairs," said Nancy McLernon, president of the Organization for International Investment, a lobbying group that represents the U.S. operations of global businesses including BP America, Honda North America, Nestle USA and Samsung.

"No one wants to be labeled a foreign agent," she said. "It sounds like a spy for a foreign government."

The legislation also would allow the Justice Department to demand that individuals and businesses turn over material relevant to federal investigations into alleged violations of FARA. Backers of the bill say the department's FARA registration unit has long sought the use of administrative subpoenas to better enforce the law. The bill, they added, includes safeguards to ensure this authority isn't abused.

But the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, in a sharply worded letter to the leaders of the House Judiciary Committee, said the investigative procedures proposed in the bill amount to an "expansion of unchecked law-enforcement authority." The department would be able "to compel the production of documents and force the testimony of the targets of criminal investigations, without any prior showing of probable cause or court approval," the association's letter said.

The letter was written in January. Spokesman Ivan Dominguez said the association's position has not changed.


Contact Richard Lardner on Twitter at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP World News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
UN Ambassador Haley resigning; she gives no reason
U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley is resigning. She gives no reason.
11:45AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Objections blunt momentum for foreign lobbying law overhaul
Objections from pro-business groups, nonprofits and privacy advocates have blunted momentum for legislation that would give the Justice Department more authority to enforce a foreign lobbying law
11:44AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Bulgaria: Man held in connection with TV reporter's slaying
Bulgaria's interior ministry says a man was taken into custody Tuesday in connection with the slaying of television reporter Viktoria Marinova, whose body was found dumped after she highlighted possible government corruption
11:43AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Hurricane Michael gains strength, takes aim at north Florida
'Monstrous' Hurricane Michael gaining strength over warm tropical waters, forecast to quickly intensify into a major hurricane in coming hours as it heads toward north Florida
11:02AM ( 52 minutes ago )
Hundreds attend vigil to honor 20 victims of limousine crash
A ceremony for the victims of the upstate New York limousine crash that killed 20 people ended with participants lifting candles above their heads to signal unity and perseverance
10:58AM ( 56 minutes ago )
Holt 1st with postseason cycle, Red Sox rout Yankees 16-1
Brock Holt hits for cycle in Boston's 16-1 demolition of Yankees in Game 3
10:56AM ( 59 minutes ago )
AP National News
Kanye West to visit Trump, discuss prison reform, violence
Rapper Kanye West has been invited to the White House to have lunch with President Donald Trump and meet with Jared Kushner to talk about manufacturing, prison reform, preventing gang violence and reducing violence in Chicago
9:44AM ( 2 hours ago )
Officials: 4 men remain missing in West Texas flooding
Four men remain missing after a West Texas RV park was overrun by raging floodwaters and authorities are awaiting daybreak to resume their search
9:15AM ( 2 hours ago )
Kavanaugh to hear his 1st arguments as Supreme Court justice
After bitter battle for confirmation, Brett Kavanaugh to hear his first arguments as a Supreme Court justice
8:52AM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Justices won't disturb conviction in triple killing
The Supreme Court is rejecting an appeal from a man convicted of joining a New Orleans police officer in the killing of her fellow officer and two other people during a 1995 robbery
10:00AM ( 1 hour ago )
Justices reject appeal of Kavanaugh environmental ruling
The Supreme Court is declining to review an environmental ruling written by Brett Kavanaugh in his former role as an appeals court judge
9:52AM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Lines outside court for Kavanaugh's first day
People hoping to see Justice Brett Kavanaugh's first day on the Supreme Court bench are waiting in long lines outside the court
8:49AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Cuomo says limo shouldn't have been on road; victims mourned
Friends and family have joined hundreds of other mourners at a vigil for the victims of Saturday's limousine crash that killed 20
9:33PM ( 14 hours ago )
Brazil leans toward unsparing vision of far-right Bolsonaro
The man who looks likely to become Brazil's next president promised nothing short of a complete overhaul of Latin America's largest nation
9:14PM ( 14 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump says he has no plans to fire Rosenstein
President Donald Trump has declared a reprieve for Rod Rosenstein, saying he has no plans to fire his deputy attorney general
9:06PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Stocks are mixed as tech recovers, material producers sink
U.S. stock indexes are mixed in early trading as markets continue to absorb the shakeout from last week's rapid rise in interest rates
11:23AM ( 32 minutes ago )
The Latest: Mob investigator on case of journalist's death
Bulgaria's Interior Ministry says top investigators have been assigned to solve the "brutal" slaying of a Bulgarian journalist
10:59AM ( 56 minutes ago )
US stock indexes are mixed as rising-rate shakeout extends
U.S. stock indexes are mixed in early trading as markets continue to absorb the shakeout from last week's rapid rise in interest rates
10:13AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
UN Ambassador Haley resigning; she gives no reason
U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley is resigning. She gives no reason.
11:45AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Bulgaria: Man held in connection with TV reporter's slaying
Bulgaria's interior ministry says a man was taken into custody Tuesday in connection with the slaying of television reporter Viktoria Marinova, whose body was found dumped after she highlighted possible government corruption
11:43AM ( 12 minutes ago )
Google poised to unveil new Pixel phones, other services
Google is expected to introduce two new Pixel phones along with other devices designed to increase usage of its advertising-driven services
11:39AM ( 16 minutes ago )
South African finance minister resigns after graft testimony
South Africa's finance minister resigns after testifying in corruption inquiry
11:34AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Elie Wiesel bust unveiled in Romania to mark Holocaust day
A bust of Romania-born writer Elie Wiesel has been unveiled in Bucharest on the country's national Holocaust remembrance day
11:32AM ( 24 minutes ago )