sunny.png
Sunday May 26th, 2019 2:37PM

Moving past the wall: Trump plan takes on legal immigration

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

The most contentious piece of President Donald Trump's new proposal to protect the so-called Dreamers has nothing to do with them. It's the plan's potential impact on legal immigration that sparked fierce Democratic opposition Friday and appeared to sink chances for a bipartisan deal in Congress.

The proposal outlined Thursday by the White House would end much family-based immigration and the visa lottery program, moves that some experts estimate could cut legal immigration into the United States nearly in half.

The plan would protect some 700,000 young immigrants from deportation and provide a pathway to citizenship, an offer the White House described as a concession to Democrats. But it also represented a victory for immigration hawks and a seismic shift for immigration policy in the U.S., which has long centered on the question of how to stop illegal border crossings, not how to curb legal immigration.

"It's an enormous change in rhetoric and position," said Alex Nowrasteh of the conservative Cato Institute. "Forever, people have talked about illegal immigration and now this anti-legal immigration position is standard for much of the Republican Party."

The Senate's top Democrat, Chuck Schumer of New York, dismissed the plan Friday as a "wish list" for hard-liners. He acknowledged the bipartisan common ground on protections for the immigrants now shielded by the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA. But he accused Trump of using them as "a tool to tear apart our legal immigration system and adopt the wish list that anti-immigration hardliners have advocated for years."

Democrats forced a government shutdown last weekend in attempt to expedite negotiations over the Dreamers, who are set to lose protection from deportation in March. Trump's proposal was the first detailed public offer from the White House.

On Friday, the president accused Schumer of complicating the talks. "DACA has been made increasingly difficult by the fact that Cryin' Chuck Schumer took such a beating over the shutdown that he is unable to act on immigration!" Trump wrote on Twitter.

By including curbs to legal immigration in his proposal, Trump elevated ideas that have been advocated by a slice of hardliners for decades, although with little momentum in Washington. Trump has framed the proposals as an attempt to prioritize immigrants with specific skills rather than family connections.

The U.S. takes in about 1 million legal immigrants annually, and nearly 13 percent of the country's residents were born overseas, the highest share in nearly a century. Immigration hawks argue that the influx drives down native-born Americans' wages and strains public resources.

"When you're bringing in the equivalent of a major metropolitan area every year, that has an impact on every aspect of life," said Ira Mehlman of the Federation for American Immigration Reform, which is the other major group advocating for fewer immigrants.

But many economists and businesses say there's little data showing that immigration is bad for the economy, and much showing it is a net benefit. Though a few have found immigrants can depress some workers' wages, most believe there's little negative impact on on U.S. workers. In fact, because native-born U.S. citizens are having fewer and fewer children, some warn the U.S. faces a looming worker shortage and that immigrants are essential to keep the country growing.

A panel from the National Academy of Sciences in 2016 found that immigration had a small negative impact on some native-born workers who hadn't graduated high school but also had many important benefits, such as fueling growth, innovation and entrepreneurship.

"At the end of the day. We're either going to believe the data coming from businesses that are trying to grow the nation's economy, or we can believe press statements," said Ali Noorani of the National Immigration Forum, which supports increasing immigration. "Ultimately, this is not a question about economics. This is about the cultural anxiety coursing through the country that has been given an outlet by saying 'immigrants are taking our jobs.'"

Trump tapped into that anxiety to win the election, pledging to build a wall along the southern border and make Mexico pay for it. He also vowed to end former President Barack Obama's program to protect people brought to the U.S. as children and now living here illegally. But when he announced an end to DACA in September, he asked Congress to come up with a way to make the program permanent, arguing the young immigrants don't deserve deportation.

Democrats offered to fund Trump's border wall, then later retracted the offer. The administration then added to its list of demands, including changes to the family-based immigration system and an end to the lottery for visas for people from countries under-represented in the U.S. to its list of demands.

The plan would eliminate hundreds of thousands of family-related visas. Immigrants would only be allowed to sponsor their spouses and underage children to join them in the U.S., and not their parents, adult children or siblings.

But rather than shift those open slots to immigrants under a skills-based system, they would be applied to the backlog of immigrants waiting for a U.S. visa. Then, when that backlog is ended, the slots would be eliminated.

Nowrasteh of Cato estimates that the result could be a 40 percent to 45 percent reduction in overall immigration over time. The numbers depend on how the visas are applied to the backlogs — the immigration backlogs are so immense in some categories it could take decades to whittle them down. It'd take more than 130 years, he estimates, for all Mexicans waiting for a legal visa to get one.

Still, some immigration hawks were disappointed with the plan, arguing it could take decades before the reductions kick in. "The cuts in immigration don't happen for 15 years," complained Roy Beck of Numbers USA.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Local/State News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business, AP Business - Economy
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Moving past the wall: Trump plan takes on legal immigration
The most contentious piece of President Donald Trump's new proposal to protect the so-called Dreamers has nothing to do with them
6:33PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Wynn Resorts shaken by misconduct claims against founder
Wynn Resorts is denying multiple allegations of sexual harassment and assault by founder Steve Wynn detailed in a Wall Street Journal report that sent shares of the casino company tumbling more than 10 percent Friday
6:29PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Sheriff says no other suspects sought in deputy's death
Authorities say two men who were nearby when a Colorado sheriff's deputy was shot and killed were interviewed and released
6:27PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Michigan St athletic director retires over Nassar sex abuse
Michigan State athletic director retires over sex abuse by gymnastics doctor
5:48PM ( 56 minutes ago )
Why it matters: The report that Trump tried to fire Mueller
President Donald Trump is dismissing as "fake news" a new accusation that he tried to fire the special counsel investigating him, but he could face legal and political blowback
5:46PM ( 58 minutes ago )
World Series winner looking to cash in on Super Bowl bets
Big World Series betting winner looking to cash in on Super Bowl bets
5:45PM ( 58 minutes ago )
AP National News
Wynn shaken by sexual misconduct allegations against founder
Wynn Resorts is denying multiple allegations of sexual harassment and assault by founder Steve Wynn detailed in a Wall Street Journal report that sent shares of the casino company tumbling more than 10 percent Friday
5:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
Police say Canadian billionaire, wife apparently murdered
Police say they believe Canadian billionaire businessman Barry Sherman and his wife were both murdered
4:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump turns again on immigration; allies bash 'Amnesty Don'
President Donald Trump's loyalists are lashing out against his proposal to create a path to citizenship for nearly 2 million "Dreamer" immigrants
4:23PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
ESPN's Jemele Hill leaving her job at 'Sportscenter'
ESPN says Jemele Hill will leave her job as 'Sportscenter' anchor to write for company's web site The Undefeated, and be a network commentator
4:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
Court civility: NBA plan aims to smooth player-ref relations
Court civility: NBA rolls out plan aimed at lowering heat, improving player-ref relations
4:27PM ( 2 hours ago )
Relations between Trump, global elites seem to thaw at Davos
The relationship between President Donald Trump and the global elites assembled in Davos seemed to thaw during the nationalist president's appearance at the World Economic Forum
3:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Trump: Schumer muddling immigration negotiations
President Donald Trump is blaming Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer for complicating negotiations over the fate of hundreds of thousands of young immigrants brought to the country illegally as children
1:47PM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump declares America open for business under his tenure
Trump declares America open for business under his tenure
1:00PM ( 5 hours ago )
UK Brexit chief pledges host of new trade deals for Britain
Britain's top Brexit official says the U.K. will be able to strike new trade deals outside the European Union as soon as it leaves the bloc next year _ even though it will remain bound to EU customs and market rules for some two years after 2019
11:50AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Wynn Resorts shaken by misconduct claims against founder
Wynn Resorts is denying multiple allegations of sexual harassment and assault by founder Steve Wynn detailed in a Wall Street Journal report that sent shares of the casino company tumbling more than 10 percent Friday
6:29PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Sheriff says no other suspects sought in deputy's death
Authorities say two men who were nearby when a Colorado sheriff's deputy was shot and killed were interviewed and released
6:27PM ( 16 minutes ago )
The Latest: Snyder considers inquiry into Michigan State
Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder is considering whether to launch an inquiry of Michigan State University in the wake of the sentencing of one of the school's sports doctors who sexually assaulted women and girls
6:27PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Sessions: Justice Department may be fair game for criticism
Attorney General Jeff Sessions says his own Justice Department may be fair game for criticism amid Republican complaints of anti-Trump bias
6:14PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Cavs guard Dwyane Wade excused for "personal matter"
Cavaliers guard Dwyane Wade excused from team to deal with personal matter
6:10PM ( 34 minutes ago )