mcloudyn.png
Friday August 23rd, 2019 1:27AM

Mueller team would hardly be first lawyers to question Trump

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Donald Trump was in a roomful of lawyers, venting about unfair treatment in the media that he said had understated his net worth and damaged his brand.

It was December 2007, a decade before Trump would become president and routinely excoriate reporters for "fake news." This time, the businessman was facing a daylong deposition in his lawsuit against a journalist he'd accused of downplaying his wealth.

Had he, one lawyer wanted to know, ever lied about his real estate properties? I try not to, Trump said. Ever exaggerated? Who wouldn't, he replied.

"You always want to put the best possible spin on a property that you can," Trump explained. "No different than any other real estate developer, no different than any other businessman, no different than any politician."

That exchange and others like it could be instructive as Trump braces for the possibility of an interview with special counsel Robert Mueller's team of investigators, who are looking into potential coordination between Russia and his presidential campaign, and into possible obstruction of justice.

The Associated Press reviewed hundreds of pages of depositions taken of Trump in the past decade, including in contract and defamation lawsuits. The interviews, taken together, not only reflect his deep experience in providing sworn statements to lawyers but also offer clues to a rhetorical style that could again be on display in the event Trump is questioned by Mueller.

The transcripts reveal a witness who is by turns voluble, giving expansive answers far beyond the questions asked; boastful, using unrelated queries to expound on his wealth or popularity; unapologetic, swift to defend incendiary comments or criticized actions; and occasionally combative, once deriding a lawyer for "very stupid" questions.

The garrulous style belies the "just the facts, ma'am" approach many defense lawyers advocate.

"On the one hand, you generally tell witnesses not to volunteer, to answer the question as asked," said New York lawyer Gary Naftalis. "Don't answer a question that isn't asked. You always tell the witness not to guess or speculate or try to fill in the blanks."

Yet there's an unmistakable deftness, too, a tendency by Trump to pass blame for certain decisions, to deflect probing questions to lawyers or accountants and to answer others with hedged, vague or non-responsive language that frustrates interrogators.

Though the possibility of a Mueller interview has been broached, it's not clear when such a conversation would occur, or if Trump's lawyers would work to narrow the scope of questioning or to avoid a face-to-face interrogation. Trump has said it "seems unlikely" he'll be interviewed, but his lawyers have cooperated throughout the probe, and Mueller has indicated interest in speaking with the president.

The stakes would certainly be higher than what Trump has faced in the past, and the questioning, unlike past interviews focused on real estate and business, would delve into areas outside of his life's work.

He'd almost certainly be asked about the firing of former FBI Director James Comey, a decision he's offered different explanations for, and about multiple one-on-one interactions that Comey has documented but Trump has disputed. Investigators would likely want to discuss an incomplete, perhaps misleading previous statement regarding a Trump Tower meeting Trump relatives had with Russians.

But it would hardly be the first time he's been asked to reconcile conflicting statements or been pressed about controversial actions.

That was the theme of a contentious 2007 deposition with lawyers for journalist Timothy O'Brien, whom Trump sued over a book he felt had maligned him.

How could he explain an assertion in his own book that placed his debt at $9.2 billion? A mistaken figure written by someone else. A bank's estimation that he was worth $1.2 billion instead of roughly $3.5 billion, as he maintained? Impossible, the bank didn't fully scour his assets. A statement that a golf club was zoned for 50 home sites, not 75? Another mistake, by another person.

In a 2013 deposition involving a failed Florida condominium project, Trump was asked why his bio said he was developing a project he actually was not. He blamed the wording on an employee.

"I have a woman that does it," he said, then added, "But you know, developing, the word develop, it can be used in a lot of different contexts."

In other instances, as when asked about overstating in an interview the number of units sold in a Las Vegas tower, he's suggested he didn't intend to be taken so literally: "But I also want to put the building in good light. I'm being asked a question. Would you like me to say, 'Oh, gee, the building is not doing well, blah, blah, blah, come by, the building' — nobody talks that way. Who would ever talk that way?"

His penchant as president for putting a glossy spin on criticized decisions — he told The Wall Street Journal last week "everybody" wanted Comey fired although employee surveys indicate otherwise — is also manifest in his depositions.

He said investors suing him over a failed condo project were lucky they didn't close on the properties and saved money. Dissatisfied Trump University students were fortunate he offered refunds, he said.

In 2016, he answered a question about a restaurateur's decision to withdraw from his hotel over derogatory comments on immigrants by observing, unprompted, that he had vanquished his political opponents.

"I obviously have credibility because I now, as it turns out, became the Republican nominee running against, we have a total of 17 people that were mostly senators and governors, highly respected people. So it's not like, you know, like I've said anything that could be so bad."

For all Trump's experience parrying lawyer questioning, it's impossible to say how he'd fare with Mueller. One attorney not part of the case, Peter Zeidenberg, said he thought Trump's disposition would make it "white knuckles the entire time."

"If you're asked a question and you don't really answer it, and you sort of go off on tangents that don't really respond to your question," said Washington defense lawyer Justin Dillon, "that might work sometimes if your questioner is not skilled enough to bring you back to the question that was asked."

But, he added, "They're not going to let the B-team question Donald Trump."

___

Associated Press writers Chad Day and Desmond Butler contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
GOP still struggling with Trump's remarks on Africa
Republicans are still struggling to get their stories straight nearly a week after a meeting in which President Donald Trump is said to have made vulgar remarks that have been criticized as racist
1:55AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Mueller team would hardly be first lawyers to question Trump
An AP review of statements made under oath by Trump gives clues about how he might handle questions from Mueller's team of investigators
1:34AM ( 32 minutes ago )
House panel subpoenas Bannon in Russia probe showdown
Former White House chief strategist Steve Bannon has been subpoenaed by the House Intelligence Committee
1:01AM ( 1 hour ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Ex-Congressman Dennis Kucinich to launch bid for governor
Former U.S. Rep. Dennis Kucinich is preparing to make the Democratic primary for Ohio governor a five-way race
12:06AM ( 2 hours ago )
'Mama warrior' in Miami aids children of deported migrants
A determined "mama warrior" in South Florida is helping immigrants with a legal tool that lets her act on behalf of children whose parents are detained or deported
12:05AM ( 2 hours ago )
Bencic loses to Kumkhum; 15-year-old Kostyuk into 3rd round
Two days after her upset win over Venus Williams, Belinda Bencic is out of the Australian Open following a loss to Thai qualifier Luksika Kumkhum.
11:38PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Frigid temperatures trail storm dropping more snow on South
A wintry mix of snow, sleet and freezing rain has blanketed a large swath of the South, trailed by a blast of frigid air that could approach record low temperatures
10:55PM ( 3 hours ago )
Japan public TV sends mistaken North Korean missile alert
Japan's public broadcaster mistakenly sent an alert warning citizens of a North Korean missile launch and urging them to seek immediate shelter, then retracted it minutes later, days after a similar error in Hawaii
10:54PM ( 3 hours ago )
Tillerson warns military action on NK unless diplomacy works
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson is warning that if North Korea does not choose to negotiate on giving up its nuclear weapons it could trigger a military response
10:07PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Immigration deal distant as leaders try to avert shutdown
Disgruntled conservatives threatened late Tuesday to scuttle Republican leaders' plans to prevent a weekend government shutdown, saying GOP leaders now lacked the votes to push their proposal through the House
11:08PM ( 2 hours ago )
Asian shares track weakness on Wall St; China shares higher
Asian shares track weakness on Wall Street; China shares higher
10:01PM ( 4 hours ago )
Autonomous cars loom, but the Detroit auto show goes on
Autonomous cars loom, but the North American International Auto Show in Detroit goes on, with the introduction of new small cars, SUVs and the all-mighty pickup truck, which dominated the show
7:34PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business
GOP still struggling with Trump's remarks on Africa
Republicans are still struggling to get their stories straight nearly a week after a meeting in which President Donald Trump is said to have made vulgar remarks that have been criticized as racist
1:55AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Conservatives balk at GOP plan to avert government shutdown
Disgruntled conservatives are threatening to scuttle Republican leaders' plans to prevent a weekend government shutdown
1:26AM ( 39 minutes ago )
House panel subpoenas Bannon in Russia probe showdown
Former White House chief strategist Steve Bannon has been subpoenaed by the House Intelligence Committee
1:01AM ( 1 hour ago )
No. 2 Wozniacki saves 2 match points, advances to 3rd round
Second-ranked Caroline Wozniacki fended off two match points and rallied from 5-1 down to win the last six games in the third set and avoid a second-round upset at the Australian Open
12:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
2 Koreas talk about Olympic cooperation ahead of IOC meeting
The two Koreas are meeting again to discuss North Korean participation in next month's Winter Olympics in South Korea
12:26AM ( 1 hour ago )