clearn.png
Friday May 24th, 2019 1:28AM
6:31PM ( 6 hours ago ) Weather Alert

Supreme Court sides with immigrants over bad legal advice

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — When a lawyer advises that a plea deal is the best option and won't result in deportation, most immigrants facing criminal charges agree to plead guilty.

But what if the lawyer is wrong, and deportation is certain?

The Supreme Court ruled 6-2 Friday that immigrants in those circumstances can have a second chance in court and risk going to trial, even if the prosecution's case is very strong.

The justices sided with South Korean native Jae Lee, who has lived most of his life in the United States. Lee pleaded guilty to drug charges in 2009 after his lawyer mistakenly assured him he would not be deported.

In fact, Lee, who had been living in the Memphis, Tennessee, area, pleaded guilty to the kind of serious crime that makes deportation near-automatic for noncitizens.

He was sentenced to a year in prison, but has been behind bars for 7½ years while fighting to withdraw his plea and take his chances at trial, John Bursch, Lee's Supreme Court lawyer, said.

Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the court that Lee can withdraw the guilty plea on drug charges that his lawyer advised him to enter.

"But for his attorney's incompetence, Lee would have known that accepting the plea agreement would certainly lead to deportation. Going to trial? Almost certainly," Roberts wrote.

But in this case, he continued, "that 'almost' could make all the difference."

Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissented. Thomas wrote that the decision "will have pernicious consequences for the criminal justice system" because plea deals negotiated in good faith may not remain final.

The federal appeals court in Cincinnati had ruled that the evidence against Lee was overwhelming and that he would have been convicted had he rejected the plea offer and gone to trial. Other appeals courts around the country have sided with immigrants in similar circumstances, the position the Supreme Court adopted Friday.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Local/State News, Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Depp's 'assassin' comments the latest in celebrity anger
Johnny Depp wants to know the last time an actor assassinated a president
11:19AM ( 8 minutes ago )
China: Political solution in Syria speeds refugees' return
China's foreign minister is calling for a political solution to end Syria's six-year crisis saying that once the country's security conditions begin to improve refugees will start returning to their country
11:12AM ( 15 minutes ago )
EU leaders boost support for Libya to halt migrant exodus
European Union leaders are pledging to boost their support for conflict-ravaged Libya as the number of people fleeing Africa from there for better lives in Europe continues to rise
11:06AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Merkel says no breakthrough yet on Brexit issue
German Chancellor Angela Merkel says that British Prime Minister Theresa May's pledges not to immediately force out EU citizens are a "good start but not yet the breakthrough."
9:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Malta's leader says British offer needs study
Malta's leader says Prime Minister Theresa May's offer to guarantee the rights of European and British citizens affected by Brexit could contain some pitfalls but needs to be studied in detail
9:42AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: May insists her offer on EU citizens was fair
British Prime Minister Theresa May says that despite criticism from some EU leaders, her proposal on the rights of EU citizens in Britain after the nation leaves the bloc was "fair and serious."
9:37AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Depp's 'assassin' comments the latest in celebrity anger
Johnny Depp wants to know the last time an actor assassinated a president
11:19AM ( 8 minutes ago )
China: Political solution in Syria speeds refugees' return
China's foreign minister is calling for a political solution to end Syria's six-year crisis saying that once the country's security conditions begin to improve refugees will start returning to their country
11:12AM ( 15 minutes ago )
EU leaders boost support for Libya to halt migrant exodus
European Union leaders are pledging to boost their support for conflict-ravaged Libya as the number of people fleeing Africa from there for better lives in Europe continues to rise
11:06AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Jury deadlocks in cop's murder retrial; judge says try again
Jurors in the murder retrial of a white Ohio police officer charged in the fatal traffic stop shooting of an unarmed black motorist say they are deadlocked, but a judge told them to keep deliberating
10:59AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Officials: 35 killed in 3 bomb attacks in 2 Pakistani cities
Officials: at least 35 people killed, nearly 100 wounded in 3 bomb attacks in 2 Pakistani cities
10:52AM ( 35 minutes ago )