clearn.png
Friday August 23rd, 2019 10:42PM

Big vote totals don't convert to wins for House Democrats

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

McLEAN, Va. (AP) — By almost any measure, Democrats crushed Republicans in Virginia's elections last week, sweeping all three statewide offices and knocking out more than a dozen incumbent GOP legislators.

Add up the votes in all 100 House districts, and Democrats beat Republicans by a 10-point margin, 54 percent to 44 percent. That's an even wider margin than Democrat Ralph Northam's victory over Ed Gillespie in the gubernatorial race.

By one critical measure, though, the GOP held its own: Republicans are poised to keep a slender 51-49 majority in the House of Delegates, assuming they hold onto slim leads in three races that appear to be headed for recounts.

Democrats and some activists say gerrymandering insulated Republicans from the will of the people.

"You have this tsunami of an election ... and it's weird we live in a democratic republic where the elections don't matter," said Brian Cannon, executive director of One Virginia 2021, which advocates for a nonpartisan redistricting process.

Cannon said the districts in Virginia are drawn to give Republicans a huge head start. He estimated that if Republicans had the same 10-point advantage Democrats won on Tuesday, the GOP would have won 66 seats or more.

House Democratic Caucus Leader David Toscano agreed.

"Without doing an elaborate statistical analysis, I can't tell you that all of it is gerrymandering," Toscano said. "But I can tell you that a lot of it is gerrymandering. Republicans consciously tried to pack as many Democrats as they could into certain districts in the last redistricting. That was clearly by design."

Republicans, of course, disagree. Parker Slaybaugh, a spokesman for House Republican Leader Kirk Cox, points out that Northam won in 58 of 100 districts. If the districts were drawn to dilute Democratic influence, Northam would have won in fewer districts, he argues.

Challenges to Virginia's state House boundaries, which were redrawn after the 2010 Census so that each district would represent roughly 80,000 voters, are active in state and federal court. Nationally, the Supreme Court is weighing a case out of Wisconsin that could have a significant effect on how lines are drawn after the next census in 2020.

Interestingly, in the federal court case, Virginia Republicans defended themselves against allegations of racial gerrymandering — which is illegal under federal law — by admitting that the lines were drawn to create a partisan advantage, which is more of a gray area under federal law. In the Wisconsin case, the justices are considering if redistricting can be too partisan.

National analyses have shown that Virginia's House of Delegates districts produce inordinately high numbers of "wasted votes," which can be a function of gerrymandering, said Rebecca Green, a professor of election law at the College of William and Mary.

Wasted votes occur in two ways: when a person votes for a losing candidate, or when one district is so overwhelmingly Democratic or Republican that a person's candidate gets far more than the majority necessary to win. The plaintiffs say that maps drawn to create an enduring and unfair pattern of wasted votes violate the constitutional rights of members of the disadvantaged party.

"The premise behind gerrymandering is to try to maximize the wasted votes of your opponent," Green said, by "packing" one party's voters into a district to clear the field in a neighboring district, or by "cracking" a party's majority in one area by splitting it into multiple districts where they get outvoted.

In Virginia, the allegations of gerrymandering have largely focused on packing a small number of districts with Democratic voters. A federal lawsuit has accused Republicans of packing black voters into a handful of heavily Democratic districts to make the surrounding districts favorable to Republicans.

Some "wasted votes," though, are function of demographics, not gerrymandering. In heavily Democratic Arlington County, for instance, it would be impossible to draw the lines in a way to make districts competitive for Republicans.

"It's a mix" of demographics and gerrymandering that results in Republicans keeping control of the House even when they lose badly in the collective popular vote, Cannon said.

Democrats have been complicit in the gerrymandering, Toscano acknowledged. Some Democrats who benefited from those packed districts supported the redistricting map because it made their lives easier in seeking re-election.

Going forward, Toscano said there is an opportunity to create a nonpartisan redistricting process because the legislature is so evenly divided that neither side can easily push through a partisan plan.

"Hopefully Republicans will see that it's in their best interest," he said. "Now is the perfect time to do it."

Cannon agreed that the time has come. He said the legislature needs to turn the process over to a nonpartisan panel. Even if the parties are evenly divided, he said politicians left to their own devices will simply craft maps designed to protect incumbents if they lack the political strength to favor one party over another.

"It is a populist wave in this country, whether it's the Tea Party or the anti-Trump resistance," he said. "People don't like incumbent protection plans. They don't like seeing politicians rigging the system."

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General House Election News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Big vote totals don't convert to wins for House Democrats
Democrats' big wins at the polls in Tuesday's elections were not enough to gain control of the House of Delegates, and some say gerrymandering is to blame.
4:52AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Survivors of Iran quake await badly needed aid, 3 days later
Survivors of Iran quake await badly needed aid, 3 days after the powerful temblor killed more than 530 people
4:48AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Tillerson says US considers individual sanctions for Myanmar
U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson says U.S. considering individual sanctions for Myanmar violence against Rohingya Muslims
4:47AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Louisiana man convicted of 1971 rape to be freed from prison
It has been nearly 50 years since a Louisiana man was sentenced to life in prison in the kidnapping and rape of a nurse but after a judge overturned his conviction he is expected to walk out of prison Wednesday morning a free man
3:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
Allen leads No. 1 Duke past No. 2 Michigan State 88-81
Grayson Allen scores career-high 37 points as No. 1 Duke tops No. 2 Michigan State 88-81
3:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
Obama health mandate now target of GOP in big tax bill
The Obama health care law's requirement that Americans get insurance coverage is now pinned as a target of Republican lawmakers, as they look to end the individual mandate to help pay for deep tax cuts.
3:43AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Democrat gets out of the way as Roy Moore scandal churns
Democrat Doug Jones adopts fierce, keep-your-head-down strategy as scandal re-shapes Alabama Senate election
4:11AM ( 54 minutes ago )
Russian lawmakers approve bill targeting foreign media
Russian lawmakers have unanimously approved a bill allowing the government to register international media outlets as foreign agents
3:06AM ( 2 hours ago )
Sessions denies lying on Russia, pleads hazy memory
Sessions defends himself against allegations that he misled members of Congress about Russia, citing a hazy memory of events
3:03AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
House to adopt mandatory anti-sexual harassment training
Speaker Paul Ryan has announced the House will require anti-harassment and anti-discrimination training for all members and their staffs
8:34PM ( 8 hours ago )
House passes bill to renew flood insurance program
The House has passed legislation that will increase flood insurance premiums for many property owners to help firm up a program under stress from ever-more frequent and powerful storms
6:45PM ( 10 hours ago )
As Roy Moore scandal churns, a Democrat gets out of the way
Democrat Doug Jones adopts fierce, keep-your-head-down strategy as scandal re-shapes Alabama Senate election
6:42PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Jones says he's not to blame for Moore claims
Alabama Democratic Senate candidate Doug Jones says he's tired of people blaming his campaign for reports of sexual misconduct by his Republican opponent, Roy Moore
3:07PM ( 13 hours ago )
The Latest: McConnell has spoken to Trump, Pence on Moore
Two GOP sources say Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has spoken to both President Donald Trump and Vice President Mike Pence in recent days about the Alabama Senate race and the allegations against GOP candidate Roy Moore
2:23PM ( 14 hours ago )
Sessions defends himself to Congress, says he never lied
Attorney General Jeff Sessions defends himself against allegations that he misled members of Congress about Russia
2:09PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Elections
Moore threatens lawsuit over story that threatens campaign
Alabama Republican Roy Moore says a lawsuit will be filed over the newspaper report carrying allegations that he had sexual contact with a 14-year-old girl four decades ago
5:58AM ( 1 day ago )
Latest: New Jersey winner: Victory sends a message to Trump
New Jersey's next governor, Democrat Phil Murphy, says victory sends a message to Trump that the country is 'better' than president's politics of division
11:11PM ( 1 week ago )
Latest: Virginia gov's race winner: 'The doctor is in'
Democrat Ralph Northam, a physician by trade and winner of Virginia's acrimonious governor's race, says 'the doctor is in' to heal divisions, political rancor
10:42PM ( 1 week ago )
General Election News
Utah's Curtis is sworn in as newest Republican House member
Republican John Curtis of Utah became the newest member of Congress late Monday
7:18PM ( 1 day ago )
Texas may swap US House seniority for staunch conservatism
Three veteran Texas Republicans are bowing out of Congress, meaning the country's largest red state will be trading a serious chunk of House seniority for new perspectives that may prove to be even more conservative
6:06PM ( 1 day ago )
Utah's Curtis set to be sworn in as newest GOP House member
Republican John Curtis is set to become Utah's newest member of Congress amid an intense push by GOP leadership to score a major legislative victory before the end of the year
1:46PM ( 1 day ago )
General House Election News
Survivors of Iran quake await badly needed aid, 3 days later
Survivors of Iran quake await badly needed aid, 3 days after the powerful temblor killed more than 530 people
4:48AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Tillerson says US considers individual sanctions for Myanmar
U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson says U.S. considering individual sanctions for Myanmar violence against Rohingya Muslims
4:47AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Australians endorse gay marriage, ensuring Parliament bill
Australians supported gay marriage in a postal survey that ensures Parliament will consider legalizing same-sex weddings this year
4:36AM ( 30 minutes ago )
Zimbabwe army has Mugabe, wife in custody, controls capital
Zimbabwe's army says it has President Robert Mugabe and his wife in custody and is securing government offices and patrolling the capital's streets following a night of unrest that included a military takeover of the state broadcaster
4:20AM ( 46 minutes ago )
Alabama GOP gets increasing heat about Moore
Washington Republicans are cranking up pressure on Alabama's GOP to keep a defiant Roy Moore from being elected to the Senate next month
4:20AM ( 47 minutes ago )