Friday February 28th, 2020 7:57PM

Threatened medical deduction seen as valuable, versatile

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Several million people unlucky enough to face big medical bills not covered by their insurance would lose a valuable and versatile deduction under the House GOP tax bill. Groups representing older people and patients are trying to save it.

"Anybody who is paying for the cost of nursing home care is paying a great deal of money, and they are going to lose that deduction, and their taxes are going to go up," said Thomas DeCoursey, a retired lawyer from Kansas, in his 70s.

He relies on the deduction to help offset costs associated with nursing home care for his wife, who has Alzheimer's. Some of his own medical expenses also factor in. DeCoursey estimates that in a couple of years their annual costs will pass $100,000.

"There are a lot of people in my shoes," said DeCoursey, who lives in Leawood, a well-to-do Kansas City suburb that voted for President Donald Trump last year.

About 9 million households — 6 percent of tax filers — claim the medical expense deduction, said Gordon Mermin, a senior researcher at the nonpartisan Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. The annual cost to the U.S. Treasury is about $10 billion, which ranks it as a modest tax break. Those who benefit tend to be middle-income and upper-middle-income people.

"For the people who claim it, it is not a trivial benefit," said Mermin.

The medical expense deduction is also versatile. In addition to nursing home care, not generally covered by medical insurance plans, it can be used for:

—Fertility treatments.

—Transportation expenses to a top hospital, like a comprehensive cancer center.

—Laser surgery to correct vision problems.

—Some long-term care insurance premiums.

—Installing specialized medical equipment in a patient's home or vehicle.

—Dental procedures.

—Bills from out-of-network doctors.

"When you are faced with large medical costs and don't have a lot of options, this is one that helps people," said Barbara Collura, president of RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association. Most insurance plans do not cover fertility treatments, which can cost from $15,000 to $30,000.

Advocacy groups pushing back against repeal may get help from the Senate.

House Republicans defend their approach.

In a statement, Ways and Means GOP spokeswoman Lauren Aronson said the bill would allow people to "keep more of the money they earn for expenses that arise throughout their lives — such as medical bills — rather than providing a myriad of provisions that many Americans may only use once in their lifetimes, and only if they go through the hassle and frustration of itemizing."

Republicans say doing away with, or curbing, tax breaks creates a big pot of revenue, which can then be used to lower tax rates. Proponents say the lower rates and higher standard deduction in the GOP bill would compensate for the loss of particular tax breaks.

An argument against the medical deduction is that it can't be easily claimed.

Taxpayers have to have enough deductions to itemize in the first place.

Then there's another step. Taxpayers can only deduct medical expenses that exceed 10 percent of their income, in most cases. Take a hypothetical single man under 65 making $45,000 a year. If he had $4,000 of qualifying medical expenses, he could not deduct any of it.

Independent analyst Greg Rosica, a tax partner at the Ernst & Young accounting firm, said tax legislation has to be looked at in its totality, not through the lens of individual tax breaks.

"It is a change," he said of the potential loss of the medical deduction. "It's not necessarily the loss of something, but it's something that's being replaced and changed."

Democrats have jumped on the issue, arguing that the medical expense deduction would be sacrificed to reduce taxes for the wealthy.

"One of the challenges Republicans have with this provision is that people can understand it," said Rep. Richard Neal of Massachusetts, senior Democrat on the tax-writing Ways and Means Committee. "Some of this tax stuff is arcane; this is not."

AARP, the seniors lobby, is among the groups urging Congress to keep the deduction, saying the vast majority of those who claim it are older people.

"For people who are sick, many of whom are going to be older Americans, this medical expense deduction makes their health care more affordable," said Cristina Martin Firvida, AARP's lead lobbyist on financial security issues. "To them, it is a very big deal."


Associated Press multimedia journalist Kevin S. Vineys contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Senior Health, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Democrats try to look forward but are still haunted by 2016
Democrats try to look forward but are still haunted by 2016. A year after a devastating defeat to Donald Trump, the party is still trying to move on
3:47AM ( 3 minutes ago )
South Korean police on alert over Trump protests
South Korean police are on high alert as critics of U.S. President Donald Trump protested in Seoul as he arrived in the country amid public concerns over North Korea's nuclear threats
3:36AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Threatened medical deduction seen as valuable, versatile
Groups representing older people and patients push back on repeal of medical deduction
3:35AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Sony pulls festival premiere of 'All the Money,' with Spacey
Sony Pictures is pulling the film "All the Money in the World" from the AFI Fest following the allegations made against co-star Kevin Spacey
12:47AM ( 3 hours ago )
Trump reviews military forces in South Korea amid tensions
President Donald Trump is meeting with U.S. and South Korea military forces at the start of his visit to South Korea on Tuesday
12:30AM ( 3 hours ago )
Standup comedian says he won't seek 3rd term as Ohio mayor
A veteran standup comedian acquitted of all charges after he was accused of abusing his power as mayor of a small Ohio city says he won't seek a third term
12:22AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
House tax panel adopts GOP changes after day of bickering
A key House panel has approved late changes to the Republicans' sweeping tax plan
8:45PM ( 7 hours ago )
The Latest: House panel backs late changes to tax proposal
A key House panel has approved late changes to the Republicans' sweeping tax overhaul plan
8:12PM ( 7 hours ago )
Attorney: Sen. Paul attack was over 'trivial' dispute
An attorney for the man accused of assaulting U.S. Sen. Rand Paul says the attack was not motivated by political differences but by a dispute "most people would find trivial
8:07PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Must-do bills in a divided Congress could lead to shutdown
An early December government shutdown is a real possibility, since a divided Congress can't agree on military spending, Democrats insist on help for young immigrants and President Donald Trump's position can change with each lawmaker he talks to
5:42PM ( 10 hours ago )
Fiji calls for urgency in talks to implement climate accord
Fiji's prime minister has called for a sense of urgency and told negotiators that "we must not fail our people" as he opened two-week talks on implementing the Paris agreement to fight climate change
11:14AM ( 16 hours ago )
The Latest: US will continue participation in climate talks
A senior U.S. diplomat says Washington will continue to take part in talks about implementing the Paris climate accord, despite President Donald Trump's threat to pull out of the pact
10:27AM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Health
Businesses brace for the unexpected on Trump's Asia tour
Some businesses in Asia are bracing for the unexpected as President Donald Trump traverses the region and meets with the leaders of major U.S. trading partners
12:10AM ( 3 hours ago )
Asian stocks rise after Wall Street gains, oil surges
Asian stock markets have gained after Wall Street rose and turmoil in Saudi Arabia sent crude prices to two-year highs
10:36PM ( 5 hours ago )
California inmates sought in brazen courthouse escape
California authorities say two inmates staged daring escape from a courthouse in Silicon Valley
9:18PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business
Democrats slam GOP budget on taxes, health care cuts
The Republican-led Senate rejected Democratic attempts to spare health programs for the poor and elderly from cuts, absorbing political hits as the price for advancing a budget plan that's a crucial step in the GOP's drive to rewrite the tax code
5:12PM ( 2 weeks ago )
Cochran's illness shows risks to GOP leaders of aging Senate
Top Republicans already coping with a razor-thin majority also have an aging Senate
4:12PM ( 2 weeks ago )
Trump lashes 'Liddle Bob Corker' as senators call for calm
President Donald Trump is lashing out at Bob Corker as 'Liddle Bob Corker,' continuing a feud with the Tennessee senator who called the White House and 'adult day care center' and warned Trump could put the nation on the path toward World War III
4:04PM ( 3 weeks ago )
AP Health - Senior Health
Analysis finds wealthy benefits under House GOP tax bill
A nonpartisan analysis finds that the wealthiest Americans would benefit from the largest tax cuts under the House Republican overhaul
6:07PM ( 9 hours ago )
The Latest: Proposed changes in tax overhaul bill anger Dems
Unexpected amendment to change House GOP tax bill anger Democrats
5:59PM ( 9 hours ago )
The Latest: Tax bill in Senate looks largely like House's
Analysts say Senate Finance Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch's tax bill will largely resemble the measure a House committee is voting on this week
4:29PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
South Korean police on alert over Trump protests
South Korean police are on high alert as critics of U.S. President Donald Trump protested in Seoul as he arrived in the country amid public concerns over North Korea's nuclear threats
3:36AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Voters in New Jersey and Virginia elect new governors
Voters in Virginia, New Jersey picking new governors in contests that could be an early referendum on President Donald Trump
3:07AM ( 43 minutes ago )
Air Force admits fault in reporting shooter's past crimes
The gunman who killed 26 people at a small town Texas church was able to buy weapons because the Air Force did not submit his criminal history to the FBI as required by military rules
2:51AM ( 59 minutes ago )
Rodney Crowell, Kelsea Ballerini honored by ASCAP
Singer songwriters Rodney Crowell and Kelsea Ballerini and hit country songwriter Ashley Gorley were honored at the ASCAP Country Music Awards in Nashville, Tennessee on Monday
2:43AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump projects optimism ahead of South Korea talks
President Donald Trump projected optimism ahead of talks with South Korea's leader Tuesday
2:42AM ( 1 hour ago )