sunny.png
Thursday October 17th, 2019 1:56PM

GOP tax plan may offer little aid for many in middle class

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — How much of the House GOP tax plan is tailored to benefit America's middle class? That's uncertain based on the details that have been provided so far.

What is clear is that many of the benefits for the middle class could dwindle over time, even while companies and wealthy individuals could enjoy lasting tax advantages.

The plan promises tax savings next year of $1,182 for a typical household of four with gross income of $59,000, leaving their tax bill at $400.

"We are focused on increasing paychecks in a major way," said Rep. Kevin Brady, the Republican chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee.

But the proposal's conflicting provisions and phase-outs of certain benefits suggest that taxes could rise for some middle class earners over time. And for many, the income gains being touted by President Donald Trump are unlikely to materialize.

Some of these complications arise because under the budget instructions, the planned tax cuts can't increase the national debt by more than $1.5 trillion over the next decade. Anything above $1.5 trillion would force Republicans to amend their plan to generate more revenue — a change that would likely prove difficult.

Trump has frequently said that this would be the biggest tax cut in U.S. history. But outside analyses show that that's not the case.

The tax plan's primary beneficiaries would be wealthier Americans, who would enjoy lower tax rates despite the elimination of some breaks, a repeal of the so-called alternative minimum tax and the termination of the estate tax.

"With the details they've presented to us so far, it looks like the tax cut benefits the wealthy and major corporations," said Martin Sullivan, chief economist at Tax Analysts and a former staff economist at the Treasury Department. "In fact, if you have a large family, given the facts that we have now, that you would pay more in taxes."

Here's why:

A married couple making less than $90,000 would be taxed at a 12 percent rate, instead of the current 15 percent. The size of their standard deduction would nearly double to $24,000.

But that same couple would lose personal exemptions — deductions that largely benefit families with multiple children. The child tax credit would rise to $1,600 from $1,000 — short of the $2,000 that Sullivan said would be needed to make many families whole.

The tax plan would also repeal the deduction of substantial medical costs, including what families might spend on nursing home care. Nor could people with student loans deduct the interest paid on the debt anymore.

And the plan would cap the deduction of state and local taxes. It also would use a less generous measure of inflation, so that more middle class taxpayers would creep into a higher bracket over several years.

All told, nearly 70 percent of the tax cuts would go to businesses over 10 years, according to an analysis by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. The rest of the tax cuts appear to favor the wealthy.

Gary Cohn, the president's top economic adviser, said Thursday at the Economic Club of Washington that the objective was to help the middle class. But he declined to say whether the wealthy would benefit.

"The hard part about taxes is everyone has got their own unique set of circumstances," Cohn said.

The plan is already showing some splintering along ideological lines.

The conservative Tax Foundation's analysis of how different families would fare under the plan suggested that the largest cuts as a percentage of taxes paid would go next year to sample couples earning between $48,000 and $85,000. Even a married couple with two children earning $165,000 would receive a reduction.

But liberal groups stressed the analysis of nonpartisan groups that the benefits would flow largely flow to major companies and the top 1 percent of earners over time as tax breaks such as a new family credit would expire after five years.

"Tax cuts for the well-off are forever," said Gene Sperling, a former top economic aide in the Obama and Clinton presidencies. "Tax cuts for the middle class are a small, a maybe and some-time thing that can be cut off in their plan."

The overarching promise made to the middle class by Trump and congressional Republicans is that lower taxes would fuel faster economic growth, which, in turn, would cause incomes to rise. Kevin Hassett, chair of Trump's White House Council of Economic Advisers, estimates that lowering the corporate tax rate to 20 percent from 35 percent would lead to an average income gain of $4,000 a year.

But most mainstream economists have disputed that claim. Kent Smetters, faculty director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, estimates that the income growth after a decade would range between $500 to $1,500.

Some tax experts say the tax overhaul might also hurt those who aspire to be middle class. The bottom half of taxpayers now pay no net income tax, according to Treasury Department figures. Many receive refunds via the Earned Income Tax Credit. The plan unveiled Thursday would require eligible taxpayers to provide their Social Security Number to receive this benefit, thereby creating a possible delay in receiving a refund as the IRS enforces this provision.

David Kamin, a former Obama White House official who now teaches law at New York University, said the plan seems to have "no significant help of any kind for about the bottom 35 percent of income earners."

He added that the proposal could also "run up deficits significantly that would eventually have to be paid for and could threaten programs that do help low and middle income Americans whether that be health care coverage, Social Security, or investments like in infrastructure."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Financial Markets, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Tillerson to make 1st trip to Myanmar amid Rohingya crisis
Top U.S. diplomat Rex Tillerson will make his first trip to Myanmar this month to discuss the humanitarian crisis in Rakhine State
1:17PM ( 11 minutes ago )
McCain says no more defense industry execs for top DOD posts
Sen. John McCain is warning the Trump administration not to nominate any more defense industry executives for senior Defense Department positions
1:12PM ( 15 minutes ago )
GOP tax plan may offer little aid for many in middle class
House Republicans say their tax plan would help middle class, but benefits still skewed toward wealthy and business
1:08PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Defense calls Menendez prosecution 'speculation' in closing
Attorneys for Sen. Bob Menendez and a wealthy friend are making closing arguments to the jury at the pair's bribery trial
12:45PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Russia hackers had targets worldwide, beyond US election
A digital hit list obtained by The Associated Press reveals an espionage campaign that not only disrupted the U.S. presidential election, but also sought to spy on thousands of targets around the world
12:44PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Spain judge jails Catalan ministers, mulls leader's arrest
Spanish prosecutor seeks international arrest warrant for the former president of Catalonia and four of his ministers after they failed to appear in a Madrid court for questioning, while a judge has sent other ex-officials to jail
12:38PM ( 50 minutes ago )
AP National News
Bin Laden files back up US claims on Iran ties to al-Qaida
CIA release of bin Laden files renews interest in Iran's support of network leading up to Sept. 11 terror attacks
11:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
Spain prosecutor seeks arrest warrant for ex-Catalan leader
A Spanish prosecutor is seeking an international arrest warrant for the former president of Catalonia and four of his regional ministers after they did not comply with a summons ordering them to appear in a Madrid court
11:38AM ( 1 hour ago )
GOP tax plan slashes corporate rate, cut for wealthy
House Republicans are set to unveil their sweeping tax overhaul Thursday, making major changes, yet looking to preserve current tax rules for retirement accounts popular with middle-class Americans and to keep a top tax rate for the wealthiest earners.
11:33AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online National News
Virginia gov's race: Campaign charged with racial overtones
Virginia governor's race shapes up as one of the most racially charged in a state with a painful racial past
12:54PM ( 34 minutes ago )
UK's May replaces defense chief as harassment scandal widens
The resignation of Britain's defense secretary amid a growing sexual harassment scandal is a sign that the U.K.'s corridors of power are not always a comfortable place for women
12:35PM ( 53 minutes ago )
After long debate, work to begin on Eisenhower memorial
After years of public controversy and debate, work is finally beginning on a massive memorial to President Dwight Eisenhower
11:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Losses for tech and consumer products companies hit stocks
US stocks are slipping as consumer products and technology companies move lower
12:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
Google and AutoNation partner on self-driving car program
Google is partnering with AutoNation, the country's largest auto dealership chain, in its push to build a self-driving car.
11:56AM ( 1 hour ago )
Weinstein's ex-company wants sworn testimony from producer
Attorneys for the company co-founded by film mogul Harvey Weinstein say they want to depose him in a lawsuit he filed seeking his employment file and emails
11:50AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
UK central bank raises rates for first time in a decade
The Bank of England is poised to raise its main interest rate for the first time in a decade to keep a lid on a rise inflation caused by Brexit
9:55AM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Bank of England latest to ease crisis measures
Bank of England Governor Mark Carney says the global economy is "firing on most cylinders" and that, as a result, it's no surprise that many central banks are easing up on some of their crisis-era stimulus measures
9:07AM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Bank of England chief says rate hike was due
Bank of England Governor Mark Carney says that the decision to raise interest rates was "straightforward" and that now was the "time to ease our foot off the accelerator"
8:57AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
The Latest: House GOP eyes mortgage interest deduction
House Republicans are proposing to place new limits on the tax deduction for mortgage interest in their soon-to-be-released overhaul
9:50AM ( 3 hours ago )
House GOP set to unveil tax overhaul; keeps retirement rules
House Republicans are set to unveil their sweeping tax overhaul Thursday, making major changes, yet looking to preserve current tax rules for retirement accounts popular with middle-class Americans and to keep a top tax rate for the wealthiest earners.
4:33AM ( 8 hours ago )
House GOP's evolving tax bill leaves retirement plan intact
House Republicans are working furiously working to finish a tax bill. And they've now decided to keep the income tax rate for the wealthiest earners.
10:38PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Tillerson to make 1st trip to Myanmar amid Rohingya crisis
Top U.S. diplomat Rex Tillerson will make his first trip to Myanmar this month to discuss the humanitarian crisis in Rakhine State
1:17PM ( 11 minutes ago )
McCain says no more defense industry execs for top DOD posts
Sen. John McCain is warning the Trump administration not to nominate any more defense industry executives for senior Defense Department positions
1:12PM ( 16 minutes ago )
US attorney general confident in terror prosecutions
U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions is expressing confidence in the ability of the justice system to prosecute terrorists
1:07PM ( 21 minutes ago )
The Latest: Police: Walmart suspect has minor prior record
Police say a man suspected of fatally shooting three people inside a Colorado Walmart has a minor criminal record
1:04PM ( 24 minutes ago )
The Latest: Appeals planned over Catalan officials' jailing
Lawyers for nine former members of the Catalan regional government ordered jailed say the defendants are serene and want the people of Catalonia to stay calm
1:04PM ( 24 minutes ago )