clear
Thursday December 13th, 2018 1:27AM

Congress could negate stronger state efforts on privacy

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Congress wants to pass national rules governing how companies can use consumers' data — though a major goal might simply be to block states from enacting stronger protections on their own.

It will be tricky to reconcile the concerns of privacy advocates who want people to have more control over the usage of their personal data — where they've been, what they view, who their friends are —and the powerful companies that mine it for profit.

The approach being pondered by policymakers and pushed by the internet industry leans toward a relatively light government touch. That's in contrast to stricter European rules that took effect in May and the California law that takes effect in 2020. Other states are also considering more aggressive protections.

During a Senate hearing Wednesday, several Democratic senators warned that a national law could simply be used to override state efforts. Calling that pre-emption the "Holy Grail" for the industry, Democratic Sen. Brian Schatz of Hawaii said it won't get the bipartisan support it needs if it's just to replace California's law with a "non-progressive federal law."

Senior executives from AT&T, Amazon, Apple, Google, Twitter and Charter Communications all told a U.S. Senate committee Wednesday that they support a federal proposal that could negate "inconsistent" state privacy laws.

Apple, which doesn't rely on advertising for revenue, was the most vocal at setting conditions for that support. Bud Tribble, Apple's vice president of software technology, said the bar would have to be "high enough in the federal legislation" to provide meaningful consumer protections.

The Senate Commerce Committee hearing comes amid increasing anxiety over safeguarding consumers' data online and recent scandals that have stoked outrage among users and politicians.

An early move in President Donald Trump's tenure set the tone on data privacy. He signed a bill into law in April 2017 that allows internet providers to sell information about their customers' browsing habits. The legislation scrapped Obama-era online privacy rules aimed at giving consumers more control over how broadband companies like AT&T, Comcast and Verizon share that information.

Allie Bohm, policy counsel at the consumer group Public Knowledge, says examples abound of companies not only using the data to market products but also to profile consumers and restrict who sees their offerings: African Americans not getting access to ads for housing, minorities and older people excluded from seeing job postings.

The companies "aren't going to tell that story" to the Senate panel, she said. "These companies make their money off consumer data."

What is needed, privacy advocates maintain, is legislation to govern the entire "life cycle" of consumers' data: how it's collected, used, kept, shared and sold.

Meanwhile, regulators elsewhere have started to act.

The 28-nation European Union put in strict new rules this spring that require companies to justify why they're collecting and using personal data gleaned from phones, apps and visited websites. Companies also must give EU users the ability to access and delete data, and to object to data use under one of the claimed reasons.

A similar law in California will compel companies to tell customers upon request what personal data they've collected, why it was collected and what types of third parties have received it. Companies will be able to offer discounts to customers who allow their data to be sold and to charge those who opt out a reasonable amount, based on how much the company makes selling the information.

Andrew DeVore, Amazon's vice president and associate general counsel, told the Senate panel Wednesday that it should consider the "possible unintended consequences" of California's approach. For instance, he says the state law defines personal information too broadly such that it could include all data.

The California law doesn't take effect until 2020 and applies only to California consumers, but it could have fallout effects on other states. And it's strong enough to have rattled Big Tech, which is seeking a federal data-privacy law that would be more lenient toward the industry.

"A national privacy framework should be consistent throughout all states, pre-empting state consumer-privacy and data security laws," the Internet Association said in a recent statement . The group represents about 40 big internet and tech companies, spanning Airbnb and Amazon to Zillow. "A strong national baseline creates clear rules for companies."

The Trump White House said this summer that the administration is working on it, meeting with companies and other interested parties. Thune's pronouncement and one from a White House official stress that a balance should be struck in any new legislation — between government supervision and technological advancement.

The goal is a policy "that is the appropriate balance between privacy and prosperity," White House spokeswoman Lindsay Walters said. "We look forward to working with Congress on a legislative solution."

_

Matt O'Brien reported from Providence, Rhode Island.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Engineers search for cause in cracked beam at transit hub
San Francisco officials are struggling to find the source of unusual cracking in support beams that shut down a $2 billion transit center
2:51AM ( 2 hours ago )
Kavanaugh school scrutiny underscores today's teens worries
The firestorm surrounding President Donald Trump's pick for the Supreme Court over the nominee's behavior in the 1980s has reinforced a warning today's high school students have grown up hearing: What they say and do now will live well past graduation
2:47AM ( 2 hours ago )
Anita Hill says #MeToo movement can create lasting change
Anita Hill says her pivotal Senate testimony about sexual harassment sparked a wave of awareness nearly three decades ago, but without clear leadership the reckoning failed to cement into lasting change
2:40AM ( 3 hours ago )
U.S. News
Cyclone warning as gale-force winds batter Greece
Severe gale-force winds have shut more schools in Greece, including southeast of Athens, while meteorologists warn of a high probability of a tropical-like cyclone forming in the Ionian Sea to the southwest of the Greek mainland
5:14AM ( 27 minutes ago )
Trump says his past accusers influence thinking on Kavanaugh
Trump acknowledges accusations against his Supreme Court nominee have a personal side for him
4:52AM ( 49 minutes ago )
High drama in Senate as Kavanaugh-Ford hearing nears
Senators to listen to a woman accuse Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh of sexually assaulting her, then weigh his denial
4:11AM ( 1 hour ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Fed raises rates for 3rd time this year with 1 more expected
Fed raises rates for 3rd time this year amid strong economy, signals another hike in 2018, 3 more next year
1:33AM ( 4 hours ago )
Trump says he prefer not to fire deputy attorney general
Trump's meeting with Rosenstein may or may not happen as first planned, but president says he'd prefer not to fire him
12:28AM ( 5 hours ago )
Latest: Foul play against suspect's missing uncle, aunt eyed
A Houston police spokesman says foul play is now suspected in the disappearance of the aunt and uncle of a suspect in several California homicides
11:04PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP National News
Some black Americans see racial comeuppance in Cosby saga
Some black Americans see racial comeuppance, hypocrisy in Cosby sentence
11:03PM ( 6 hours ago )
Cracked $2 billion transit hub tarnishes San Francisco's rep
San Francisco officials are struggling to find the source of unusual cracking in support beams that shut down a $2 billion transit center meant to be a bold statement from a fast-developing city
10:50PM ( 6 hours ago )
California tightens rules for concealed weapons, bump stocks
Gov. Jerry Brown has signed a new law requiring that Californians undergo at least eight hours of training, including live-fire exercises, before carrying concealed weapons.
9:58PM ( 7 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Make-or-break Senate hearing day for Kavanaugh, accuser
With high drama in the making, Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanagh is heading into a charged public Senate hearing that could determine whether Republicans can salvage his nomination and enshrine a high court conservative majority
10:35PM ( 7 hours ago )
Via arms and trade, Russia plots long-term Syrian future
Russia is selling weapons and reviving trade with Syria as it looks toward a post-war future
10:35PM ( 7 hours ago )
UN court asked to probe Venezuela; leader defiant in speech
International Criminal Court is asked by 6 nations to investigate Venezuela for alleged crimes against humanity; its president strikes defiant tone at UN
9:26PM ( 8 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Lessons from Thomas-Hill hearings likely to guide senators
Lessons learned from Thomas-Hill hearings in 1991 will likely guide senators as they listen to Ford and Kavanaugh testimony
12:29AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Kavanaugh fending off 3rd accusation
Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh is fending off a third accusation of sexual misconduct as he prepares for a public Senate hearing
9:37PM ( 8 hours ago )
Trump says he believes nuclear deal with N.Korea possible
President Donald Trump said he has given up nothing, other than his time during a June summit in Singapore, and yet stands on the cusp of denuclearizing North Korea
7:58PM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Congress sends bill to Trump to avert government shutdown
Congress has approved a bill keeping the government open through Dec. 7, as lawmakers move to avert a government shutdown looming in less than five days
6:45PM ( 10 hours ago )
Trump to world leaders: China out to meddle in 2018 election
President Donald Trump tells world leaders that China is trying to interfere in the upcoming U.S. congressional elections because it opposes his tough trade policies
6:38PM ( 11 hours ago )
The Latest: Avenatti wants FBI probe before client interview
The lawyer for a third woman accusing Brett Kavanaugh of sexual misconduct says he won't agree to a Senate Judiciary Committee request to interview her immediately
6:28PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Whiff of offense: Ks top hits, lowest average since '72
Strikeouts are likely to exceed hits over a full season for the first time in major league history, and the overall batting average has dropped to its lowest level since 1972, the year before the designated hitter
2:36AM ( 3 hours ago )
Asian shares mixed after US Fed lifts interest rate
Asian shares mixed after US Fed lifts interest rate, Japan OK's trade talks with US
1:26AM ( 4 hours ago )
Australian broadcaster's chairman quits over politics claims
The chairman of the Australian Broadcasting Corp. has resigned over allegations he pressured the independent national broadcaster to fire 2 political journalists because the conservative government disliked them
12:43AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
Uber agrees to $148M settlement with states over data breach
Uber has agreed to pay $148 million and take steps to tighten data security after the ride-hailing company failed for a year to notify drivers that hackers had stolen their personal information, Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan announced Wednesday
6:18PM ( 11 hours ago )
A US privacy law could be good for Google - but bad for you
A US privacy law could be good for Facebook and Google - but bad for you
4:49PM ( 12 hours ago )
Congress could negate stronger state efforts on privacy
Congress is working to come up with a new set of national rules governing how companies can use consumers' data, in part hoping to block a push by California and other U.S. states to do it on their own
12:50PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
Facebook unveils Quest, its new virtual-reality headset
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg is off to a slow start in his mission to bring virtual reality to the masses, so perhaps it's appropriate his company's next VR headset will be called Quest
4:30PM ( 13 hours ago )
Fox plans to sell stake in Sky to Comcast for $15B
21st Century Fox will sell its remaining stake in British pay TV provider Sky after Comcast won a bidding war for the stake that Fox didn't already own
12:23PM ( 17 hours ago )
The Latest: Chairman says bipartisan desire for privacy law
Executives of a half-dozen U.S. internet titans have been summoned by a Senate panel to explain their privacy policies as interest grows in Congress for the government to step in to protect consumers.
10:46AM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Technology News
Engineers search for cause in cracked beam at transit hub
San Francisco officials are struggling to find the source of unusual cracking in support beams that shut down a $2 billion transit center
2:51AM ( 2 hours ago )
Kavanaugh school scrutiny underscores today's teens worries
The firestorm surrounding President Donald Trump's pick for the Supreme Court over the nominee's behavior in the 1980s has reinforced a warning today's high school students have grown up hearing: What they say and do now will live well past graduation
2:47AM ( 2 hours ago )
Anita Hill says #MeToo movement can create lasting change
Anita Hill says her pivotal Senate testimony about sexual harassment sparked a wave of awareness nearly three decades ago, but without clear leadership the reckoning failed to cement into lasting change
2:40AM ( 3 hours ago )
Living with fear: Vegas shooting survivor, wife march on
Every time Chris Gilman leaves her home at the foot of Mount Rainier in Washington, she fights the gnawing urge to turn around and check that someone isn't about to shoot her
2:36AM ( 3 hours ago )
Texas police questioned man days before California killings
Houston police did not flag for arrest or deportation a man now charged in a series of Southern California killings, despite a history of violence and six deportations
2:31AM ( 3 hours ago )