Wednesday January 16th, 2019 11:49PM

Democrats test liberal messages in midterm House elections

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

A single-payer health care advocate in South Texas. A gun restriction supporter in Dallas. Cheerleaders in Arkansas and Iowa for public option health care.

Weeks into the primary season, with five more states voting Tuesday, Democrats' midterm class is shaping up to test what liberal messages the party can sell to the moderate and GOP-leaning voters who will help determine control of the House after the November election.

It's not one size fits all, with every candidate checking every box wanted by the activists driving the opposition to President Donald Trump and the GOP Congress, and Democratic voters typically aren't tapping the most liberal choices in targeted districts. But, taken together, the crop of nominees is trending more liberal than many of the "Blue Dog" Democrats swept away in Republicans' 2010 midterm romp.

That means voters now represented by a Republican will be asked to consider some or all of the mainstream Democratic priorities that may have been considered "too liberal" in the past: more government involvement in health insurance, tighter gun laws, a path to citizenship for people in the country illegally, reversing parts of the GOP tax law, support for LGBTQ rights.

"You have ballpark 60 districts as diverse as Kansas and Staten Island. One bumper-sticker message will be self-defeating," said former congressman Steve Israel of New York, who led Democrats' national House campaign in 2012.

The question is whether that path results in Democrats gaining the 23 new seats they need for a majority.

The next test will come with Tuesday's primaries in five states: Maine, Nevada, North Dakota, South Carolina and Virginia.

A key measure of Democrats' leanings will come in suburban northern Virginia, where vulnerable Republican Barbara Comstock has a half-dozen Democrats vying to knock her out of Congress in November. The field spans from establishment favorite Jennifer Wexton, a state senator who touts her bipartisan deal-making in Richmond and says the U.S. should move cautiously toward universal health insurance, to political newcomers with calls for a $15-hour minimum wage and a more immediate move to single-payer, government health insurance.

Israel disputes that the current House slate represents a notable leftward shift nationally, and national party leaders have still angered liberals with some of their recruitment choices.

Still, resistance leaders are confident of their influence. "We are seeing grassroots action and organizing in a meaningful way," said Maria Urbina, national political director of Indivisible, founded after Trump's 2016 election. "We see the party apparatus coming in behind some of this action on the ground."

To be clear, not every surviving candidate is a carbon copy of Bernie Sanders, the 2016 presidential candidate whose insurgent campaign emboldened the left with his calls for universal health insurance, a $15-hour minimum wage and tuition-free college. But the influence of Sanders' inspired base is palpable, as winning nominees have adopted pieces, if not the whole, of an agenda that has become more typical within the party since it lost the House majority eight years ago.

At least to date, it's staved off a Democratic version of the 2010 tea party rise, when GOP leaders, even as they marched in lockstep opposition to then-President Barack Obama, watched archconservative outsiders defeat incumbent Republicans and fundamentally reshape the party's identity on Capitol Hill. The Democratic path seems to be more incremental evolution.

A key indicator is the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee's "Red to Blue" program, the party's top candidates for flipping Republican seats. Twenty candidates with that designation have faced primaries already; only one of them — among the party's most conservative choices — has lost. (About two dozen more Red to Blue candidates have upcoming primaries, and the DCCC could add to its list.)

On health care, at least two of the Red to Blue hopefuls past their primaries call explicitly for single-payer health insurance, four more want a government-run public option, and several others generically call for expanded coverage under the Democrats' 2010 health insurance overhaul. Eighteen were endorsed by End Citizens United, signifying their pledges to block corporations and wealthy individuals from spending unlimited amounts on campaigns.

A leftward shift on health care is clear in Arkansas, where state Rep. Clarke Tucker dominated a primary as the more centrist choice — he's among the Democrats saying he wouldn't back California's Nancy Pelosi for speaker — in a congressional district Trump won by almost 21 points.

A cancer survivor, Tucker does not support single-payer, but he does say all Americans, regardless of age, should be able to buy Medicare coverage. That's quite a leap from 2010, when then-Sen. Blanche Lincoln, a self-declared Arkansas centrist, joined other moderate Democrats to back the Affordable Care Act only after a public option was scrapped. She lost her 2010 re-election bid in a landslide anyway.

Beyond national Democrats' favored candidates, environmental lawyer Mike Levin won a November ballot spot in a Southern California district championing single-payer. He beat three other candidates who support Medicare-for-all health insurance. Together, the four Democrats received more votes than the eight-member Republican primary field in a district that retiring Rep. Darrell Issa has represented since 2001.

"I know that with a bold progressive agenda and with the continued mobilization of the progressive base in California 49, we're going to win come November," Levin said.

In some instances, the liberal arguments come from candidates who can sell themselves as trustworthy messengers, even if the message is stereotyped as out of place.

So Abby Finkenauer in an expansive northeast Iowa district and Colin Allred in metro Dallas can forcefully advocate for ideas like paid family leave, long a goal of the American labor movement. Finkenauer plays up her working-class roots as she also stakes out liberal positions on abortion rights. Allred still looks every bit the NFL defender he was before becoming a civil rights attorney. He's outspoken about LGBTQ rights while endorsing a $15 minimum wage and a partial semi-automatic gun ban — all notable contrasts with the Republican congressman, Pete Sessions, he's trying to defeat in November.

Republicans, meanwhile, say bring it on.

"Wacky, far-left positions," said Courtney Alexander of the Congressional Leadership Fund, a GOP super PAC aligned with Speaker Paul Ryan, "aren't going to fly in suburban swing districts this fall."


Sign up for "Politics in Focus," a weekly newsletter showcasing the AP's best political reporting from around the country leading up to the midterm elections:


Follow Barrow and Beaumont on Twitter at and

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, General House Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Singapore Postcard: Tasting coconut, chicken rice and spice
The tiny city-state of Singapore is hosting its largest media contingent ever for the Trump-Kim summit and it's feeding the pack well
7:03AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Trump expresses optimism amid final Kim summit preparations
President Donald Trump says he thinks "things can work out very nicely" with North Korea as he prepares for Tuesday's historic summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un
7:00AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Pope begins purge in Chilean church over sex abuse scandal
Pope Francis has accepted the resignation of the bishop at the center of Chile's clerical sex abuse scandal and two others as he launches the purge of a church that has imploded under an avalanche of accusations of abuse and cover-up
6:59AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Pompeo offers North Korea security assurances
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo says the United States is prepared to take actions to provide North Korea with 'sufficient certainty' that denuclearization 'is not something that ends badly for them'
6:07AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Trump calls Abe, Moon ahead of Kim summit
President Donald Trump called the leaders of South Korea and Japan Monday ahead of his summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un
5:58AM ( 1 hour ago )
A theme of tolerance, inclusion at this year's Tony Awards
An intimate musical about cultural understanding was a top winner at the Tony awards, on a night where tolerance and inclusion were constant themes
5:25AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Kim Jong Un could give up ICBMs but keep some nuclear forces
After years of effort to develop nuclear missiles that can target the U.S. mainland, North Korean leader Kim Jong Un could decide to get rid of them _ but still keep the country's shorter-range weapons
2:04AM ( 5 hours ago )
North Korea gets first big dose of Trump summit news
North Koreans have gotten their first big dose of news from Singapore as Kim Jong Un's summit with President Donald Trump draws near
1:49AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump forecasts 'nice' outcome from Kim summit
President Donald Trump says he thinks "things can work out very nicely" with North Korea on the eve of his historic summit with Kim Jong Un.
1:25AM ( 5 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Elite Gurkhas from Nepal deployed to secure Trump-Kim summit
To protect the Trump-Kim summit, Singapore has enlisted the help of fearsome Nepalese fighters whose large curved knives, according to custom, must "taste blood" whenever they're drawn
3:42AM ( 3 hours ago )
Trump doubles down on criticism of longtime ally Canada
Trump takes more swipes at Canada and its prime minister over trade issues as he settles in for a summit with North Korea in Singapore
12:46AM ( 6 hours ago )
Now a candidate, Romney appears to embrace Trump presidency
In wake of Trump, no other Republican leader may demonstrate the transformation of the modern-day GOP better than Mitt Romney
12:08AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Mitt Romney and Donald Trump? 'It's really complicated'
How will Mitt Romney fit in Donald Trump's Republican Party? 'It's really complicated' says a Romney confidant
5:26PM ( 13 hours ago )
Lawmakers want to question Brexit backer on Russia meetings
The chairman of the British Parliament's media committee says a millionaire backer of the successful campaign to leave the European Union has questions to answer about his contacts with Russian officials
11:23AM ( 19 hours ago )
The Latest: Senator says Kim already can claim some success
A top Democratic senator says the North Korean leader has already achieved some success just by bringing the American president to the table
10:40AM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
No voter registration point of pride, unease in North Dakota
North Dakota is the only state in the nation without voter registration, a system longtime residents prize for its simplicity
12:55PM ( 18 hours ago )
The Latest: FIFA presidential election period set to open
The next FIFA presidential election period formally starts this week in Moscow
12:27PM ( 18 hours ago )
Manafort faces new charges in Russia probe
Special counsel Robert Mueller brings new obstruction charges against President Donald Trump's campaign chairman and a longtime associate
12:41AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections
The Latest: Trump says Russia should be allowed in G-7
President Donald Trump is calling for Russia to be reinstated to the leading group of industrialized nations, now known as the Group of Seven
9:14AM ( 2 days ago )
AP names Steven Sloan as news editor overseeing politics
The Associated Press has named Steven Sloan as news editor overseeing political coverage, including the 2018 midterm elections and the 2020 presidential campaign
6:58AM ( 3 days ago )
Democrats spar in cutthroat primary race for Nevada governor
The fiercest primary election battle in Nevada this year is a race between two southern Nevada Democrats vying to become the swing state's first Democratic governor in almost two decades
2:10AM ( 3 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
Eyes are on Nevada's Sen. Heller, but 2 House seats are open
Holding on to a pair of Democratic U.S. House seats that will be up for grabs in Nevada are key to the party's effort to gain control of Congress
7:54PM ( 3 days ago )
Eyes are on Nevada's Sen. Heller, but House seats may be key
A pair of Democratic U.S. House seats that will be up for grabs in Nevada in November could be key to the party's effort to cut into GOP majorities in Congress
3:55PM ( 3 days ago )
House GOP in eleventh-hour attempt for immigration accord
House leaders try pushing fractured Republicans toward consensus on immigration
10:59AM ( 3 days ago )
General House Election News
Global markets higher ahead of Trump-Kim meeting
Global stock markets are mostly higher as Donald Trump prepared to meet North Korean leader Kim Jong Un following the American president's outburst at Canada's prime minister over trade
4:57AM ( 2 hours ago )
3 Gulf Arab states pledge $2.5B to Jordan after protests
3 Gulf Arab states have pledged $2.5 billion to Jordan as economic protests over austerity measures have roiled the kingdom
1:40AM ( 5 hours ago )
Asian markets higher ahead of Trump-Kim meeting
Asian markets are mostly higher as Donald Trump prepared to meet North Korean leader Kim Jong Un following the American president's outburst at Canada's prime minister over trade
1:29AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business
DOJ offers new briefing as lawmakers dispute Trump spy claim
The Justice Department is offering lawmakers a new look at classified documents next week on the FBI's use of an informant in the Russia probe
2:47PM ( 3 days ago )
Google stops political ads in Washington following lawsuit
Google has stopped accepting political ads in Washington on the same day changes to the state's campaign-finance reporting requirements and enforcement procedures take effect
2:17PM ( 3 days ago )
Woman thanks Trump for 'mercy' in commuting her sentence
A woman whose life sentence was commuted by President Donald Trump is thanking him for "having mercy."
12:54PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Singapore Postcard: Tasting coconut, chicken rice and spice
The tiny city-state of Singapore is hosting its largest media contingent ever for the Trump-Kim summit and it's feeding the pack well
7:03AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Trump expresses optimism amid final Kim summit preparations
President Donald Trump says he thinks "things can work out very nicely" with North Korea as he prepares for Tuesday's historic summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un
7:00AM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Iran tells Kim: Don't trust Trump
Iran says North Korea should be wary of negotiating with President Donald Trump following his withdrawal from the landmark 2015 nuclear agreement
6:31AM ( 39 minutes ago )
Iran's top leader seeks to clarify position on Israel
Iran's supreme leader has sought to clarify his position on Israel after being accused of calling for its destruction
6:28AM ( 43 minutes ago )
The Latest: Singapore says Trump will return for state visit
Singapore says President Donald Trump has accepted an invitation to return for a state visit this fall
6:27AM ( 43 minutes ago )