Wednesday January 16th, 2019 11:50PM

GOP risks fallout from Justice Department move on health law

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration's decision to stop defending in court the Obama health law's popular protections for consumers with pre-existing conditions could prove risky for Republicans in the midterm elections — and nudge premiums even higher.

The Justice Department said in a court filing late Thursday that it will no longer defend key parts of the Affordable Care Act, beginning with the unpopular requirement that people carry health insurance, but also including widely-supported provisions that guarantee access for people with medical problems and limit what insurers can charge older, sicker adults.

Friday, the insurance industry warned in stark terms of "harm that would come to millions of Americans" if such protections are struck down, causing premiums "to go even higher for older Americans and sicker patients."

Weighing in on a Texas challenge to the health law, the Justice Department argued that legally and practically the popular consumer protections cannot be separated from the unpopular insurance mandate, which Congress has repealed, effective next year.

That argument is likely to be lost on consumers, said Robert Blendon, a polling expert at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health — particularly in the heat of an election that will determine control of Congress.

"The pre-existing condition thing is what the ads will be run on," said Blendon. "Pre-existing conditions have gotten to be an issue that people walking on the streets understand ... it's very emotional."

Some Democratic politicians didn't waste much time.

"Democrats will not allow Republicans to get away with quietly trying to strip away pre-existing conditions protections for millions of Americans through a legal backdoor," said Rep. Frank Pallone, D-N.J., a spokesman for his party on health care.

Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer of New York urged President Donald Trump to reverse the decision.

Administration officials at the departments of Health and Human Services and Treasury would not comment, instead pointing to the Justice Department filing, which said other parts of the health law would continue to stand, including its Medicaid expansion covering about 12 million low-income people. HHS and Treasury administer the health law's coverage and subsidies.

Loosening the health law's rules on pre-existing conditions and on charging more to older adults is a key goal for the Trump administration. Partly that's because those consumer protections also raise premiums across the board, as the cost of covering the sick is spread among all customers, including healthier people who previously benefited from lower rates.

Indeed, people who pay the full cost of their individual health plans and aren't eligible for subsidies under the health law have been clamoring for relief from several years of double-digit premium increases.

Economist Gail Wilensky, who's advised Republicans, said she's not sure about the timing of the administration's action.

"You can definitely assume Democrats will use it to whip up their side," said Wilensky, administrator of Medicare under former President George H.W. Bush. "For the people not affected by the ACA, or not particularly supportive, I don't know that it will matter much."

The issues in the court case are unlikely to be resolved quickly, but some experts said the added uncertainty could prompt insurers to seek higher premiums in 2019 for health plans sold to individuals.

"Insurance companies hate uncertainty, and when they face uncertainty they tend to increase premiums and hedge their bets," said Larry Levitt of the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation.

America's Health Insurance Plans, the main industry trade group, bemoaned the Justice Department's stance, saying it could upset a market that is becoming "more steady" for most consumers.

"Zeroing out the individual mandate penalty should not result in striking important consumer protections," the group said. It will lead to "renewed uncertainty in the individual market" and a "patchwork of requirements in the states" and make it more challenging to offer coverage next year.

The lawsuit, filed in February by Texas and other GOP-led states, is in many ways a replay of the politically divided litigation that ended with the Supreme Court upholding the health care overhaul in 2012. In this case, California is leading a group of Democrat-led states in defending the law.

The Trump administration's stance is a rare departure from the Justice Department's practice of defending federal laws in court.

Attorney General Jeff Sessions said in a letter to Congress that Trump, who campaigned on repealing the law and nearly did so his first year in office, approved the legal strategy.

Donald Verrilli Jr., President Barack Obama's top Supreme Court lawyer who defended the law, called the decision "a sad moment."

"I find it impossible to believe that the many talented lawyers at the department could not come up with any arguments to defend the ACA's insurance market reforms, which have made such a difference to millions of Americans," Verrilli said.

Shortly before the government's court filing Thursday, three career lawyers at the Justice Department withdrew from the case and were replaced by two political appointees, according to court filings.


Associated Press writer Mark Sherman contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump signals support for legislation easing US ban on pot
President Donald Trump says he's inclined to support a bipartisan effort in Congress to ease the U.S. ban on marijuana
4:05PM ( 2 minutes ago )
GOP risks fallout from Justice Department move on health law
GOP risks political fallout from Justice Department's move on health law protections for pre-existing conditions
4:04PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Trump barrels into G-7 summit, ready to fight US allies
Trump says 'let Russia back in' to G-7 industrialized nations
4:00PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Trump, G-7 leaders hold summit working session
President Donald Trump and his world counterparts have opened the first working session of a meeting of major industrialized nations in Canada
3:30PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Singapore summit site run by family with Trump-like ambition
The Singapore coastal hotel where President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un plan to meet is headed by a wealthy Singapore family whose real estate development firm is pushing into the upscale resort world where Trump's company operates
3:23PM ( 45 minutes ago )
House Republican factions hunt for immigration deal
House Republicans are searching for an immigration compromise that has eluded them for decades
3:09PM ( 59 minutes ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Doubts on all sides in US as Trump-Kim summit looms
The self-proclaimed master dealmaker is facing doubts from multiple corners as he prepares to negotiate with Kim Jong Un
2:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Ex-Senate aide charged with lying about reporter contacts
A former employee of the Senate intelligence committee has been indicted on charges of lying to the FBI about contacts with reporters
1:52PM ( 2 hours ago )
Greece govt presents final creditor-mandated reforms
Greece's left-led government has presented to parliament a final raft of creditor-mandated economic and market reforms, with less than three months to go until the end of its massive bailout program
1:32PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Sheryl Sandberg uses Facebook's woes as lesson for MIT grads
Facebook executive Sheryl Sandberg says MIT's graduating class should use technology as a "force for good" but warned that others will use it for harm
3:21PM ( 47 minutes ago )
Kia recalls over 500K vehicles; air bags may not inflate
Kia is recalling over a half-million cars and minivans in the U.S. because the air bags may not work in a crash
3:14PM ( 54 minutes ago )
Trade tremors: How tariffs, tough talk has unsettled markets
Stocks have traded erratically since late February as investors try to size up the impact of trade tensions between the US and major trading partners including China, Europe, Canada and Mexico
2:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Putin: Cooperation with China at "unprecedented level"
Russian President Vladimir Putin has told his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping, that cooperation between their countries has reached an "unprecedented level," underscoring how pressure from the West has brought the sides closer
7:04AM ( 9 hours ago )
World stock markets fall ahead of tense G-7 summit
Global stock markets are down ahead of a Group of Seven summit that promises to be tense as leaders confront U.S. President Donald Trump over tariffs he is imposing.
7:02AM ( 9 hours ago )
Global shares fall ahead of G7 summit, central bank meetings
Global shares are as investors await the Group of Seven summit, continuing into the weekend, and European Central Bank and Federal Reserve meetings next week
4:04AM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Asian stocks higher after Wall Street gains
Asian stock markets are rising following a Wall Street rally as remarks by a European Central Bank official eased worries about the new Italian government's plans
3:19AM ( 1 day ago )
Banks jump as stocks post their fourth straight gain
US stocks rise for the fourth day in a row as banks jump along with interest rates
4:54PM ( 1 day ago )
Malaysia's central bank governor quits amid land deal furor
Malaysia's central bank governor has become the latest senior official to resign just a month after national elections amid a corruption probe of the former government that appointed them.
7:39AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
Home equity boosts US household wealth 1 pct. to $100.8T
Pricier homes lifts US household wealth to $100.8 trillion for first time
1:52PM ( 1 day ago )
US long-term mortgage rates fall; 30-year at 4.54 percent
US long-term mortgage rates fall; average 30-year mortgage at 4.54 percent
10:31AM ( 1 day ago )
Chart a course for a low-hassle destination wedding
The better prepared you are to navigate the variables of a destination wedding abroad, the easier it will be to bring your vision of the big day to life
9:55AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Trump barrels into G-7 summit, ready to fight US allies
Trump says 'let Russia back in' to G-7 industrialized nations
4:00PM ( 8 minutes ago )
US mayors push to curb gun violence, help immigrants
A bipartisan coalition of U.S. mayors have called for policies to curb gun violence and pledged to support immigrant communities as it kicked off a four-day gathering in Boston to discuss issues impacting cities
3:57PM ( 11 minutes ago )
APNewsBreak: US won't prosecute Alaska gray whale kill
APNewsBreak: Federal officials have decided not to prosecute the killing of a protected gray whale by Native hunters in Alaska
3:56PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Italian economist: Markets will judge Italy's spending plans
The economist who tried to form an Italian government amid political gridlock says he's worried about the new populist leaders' enacting measures that will swell the national debt.
3:54PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Trump: First lady had 'big operation,' can't fly for a month
President Donald Trump has added to the intrigue surrounding his wife, Melania's, recent absence from the public eye following kidney treatment.
3:50PM ( 18 minutes ago )