clear
Thursday October 18th, 2018 12:08PM

Justices side with Colorado baker on same-sex wedding cake

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court ruled for a Colorado baker who wouldn't make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple in a limited decision that leaves for another day the larger issue of whether a business can invoke religious objections to refuse service to gay and lesbian people.

The justices' decision Monday turned on what the court described as anti-religious bias on the Colorado Civil Rights Commission when it ruled against baker Jack Phillips. The justices voted 7-2 that the commission violated Phillips' rights under the First Amendment.

The case had been eagerly anticipated as, variously, a potentially strong statement about the rights of LGBT people or the court's first ruling carving out exceptions to an anti-discrimination law. In the end, the decision was modest enough to attract the votes of liberal and conservative justices on a subject that had the potential for sharp division.

Justice Anthony Kennedy said in his majority opinion that the larger issue "must await further elaboration" in the courts. Appeals in similar cases are pending, including one at the Supreme Court from a florist who didn't want to provide flowers for a same-sex wedding.

The disputes, Kennedy wrote, "must be resolved with tolerance, without undue disrespect to sincere religious beliefs, and without subjecting gay persons to indignities when they seek goods and services in an open market."

The same-sex couple at the heart of the case, Charlie Craig and Dave Mullins, complained to the Colorado commission in 2012 after they visited Phillips' Masterpiece Cakeshop in suburban Denver and the baker quickly told them he would not create a cake for their wedding celebration. They were married in Massachusetts because same sex marriage was not yet legal in Colorado.

Colorado law prohibits discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, and the commission concluded that Phillips' refusal violated the law, despite Phillips' argument that he is opposed to same-sex marriage on religious grounds. Colorado state courts upheld the determination.

But when the justices heard arguments in December, Kennedy was plainly bothered by comments by a commission member that the justice said disparaged religion. The commissioner seemed "neither tolerant nor respectful of Mr. Phillips' religious beliefs," Kennedy said in December.

That same sentiment coursed through his opinion Monday. "The commission's hostility was inconsistent with the First Amendment's guarantee that our laws be applied in a manner that is neutral toward religion," he wrote.

Liberal justices Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan joined the conservative justices in the outcome. Kagan wrote separately to emphasize the limited ruling.

Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor dissented. "There is much in the court's opinion with which I agree," Ginsburg wrote of Kennedy's repeated references to protecting the rights of gay people. "I strongly disagree, however, with the court's conclusion that Craig and Mullins should lose this case."

The Trump administration intervened in the case on Phillips' behalf, and Attorney General Jeff Sessions praised the decision. "The First Amendment prohibits governments from discriminating against citizens on the basis of religious beliefs. The Supreme Court rightly concluded that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission failed to show tolerance and respect for Mr. Phillips' religious beliefs," Sessions said.

President Donald Trump was unusually vague about the decision, simply tweeting, "Big Supreme Court ruling for Baker just out!" — more than 11 hours later.

Kristen Waggoner, the Alliance Defending Freedom senior counsel who argued Phillips' case, said the court was right to condemn the commission's open antagonism toward Phillips' religious beliefs about marriage.

Waggoner said Phillips is willing to sell ready-made products to anyone who enters his store. But, "he simply declines to express messages or celebrate events that violate his deeply held beliefs," she said.

Phillips was at his shop Monday morning, where he was busy answering the phone and getting congratulations from his supporters in person, including his pastor. One woman brought him balloons and others hugged him.

The American Civil Liberties Union, which represented the couple in its legal fight, said it was pleased the court did not endorse a broad religion-based exemption from anti-discrimination laws.

"We read this decision as a reaffirmation of the court's longstanding commitment to civil rights protections and the reality that the states have the power to protect everyone in America from discrimination, including lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people," said James Esseks, director of the ACLU LGBT & HIV Project.

Waggoner and Esseks disagreed about the ruling's effect on Phillips' wedding cake business. Waggoner said her client can resume his refusal to make cakes for same-sex marriages without fear of a new legal fight. But Esseks said that if another same-sex couple were to ask Phillips for a wedding cake, "I see no reason in this opinion that Masterpiece Cakeshop is free to turn them away."

Craig, one of the plaintiffs, said Monday night he will continue to fight against discrimination. He told supporters during a rally at the Colorado Capitol that he and his partner brought the case "because no one should have to face the shame, embarrassment and humiliation of being told 'we don't serve your kind here.'"

Several other legal disputes are pending over wedding services, similar to the Phillips case. In addition to florists, video producers and graphic artists are among business owners who say they oppose same-sex marriage on religious grounds and don't want to participate in same-sex weddings.

Barronelle Stutzman, a florist in Richland, Washington, has appealed a state Supreme Court ruling that found she violated state law for refusing to provide the wedding flowers for two men who were about to be married.

The justices could decide what to do with that appeal by the end of June.

___

Associated Press writers P. Solomon Banda, Nicholas Riccardi and Thomas Peipert contributed to this report from Denver.

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, U.S. News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Basketball, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, College Sports, AP Entertainment, AP Business, AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Justices side with Colorado baker on same-sex wedding cake
The Supreme Court is setting aside a Colorado court ruling against a baker who wouldn't make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple
10:27AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Gains for technology companies lead US stocks higher
Technology companies including Apple, Microsoft and Alphabet are rising in early trading as US stock indexes gain ground
10:13AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Ronaldo begins World Cup preparations amid Madrid doubts
Surrounded by doubts about his future at Real Madrid, Cristiano Ronaldo is bringing some unwanted distraction to Portugal's national team ahead of the World Cup
10:10AM ( 34 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump says he has 'absolute right' to pardon himself
President Donald Trump declares on Monday that he has the "absolute right" to pardon, but adds he's done nothing wrong
9:55AM ( 48 minutes ago )
Feds: Skimping can't save seniors from rising med cost
Feds: Government report finds seniors scrimp on brand-name drugs but have to spend more anyway
9:49AM ( 55 minutes ago )
Serena Williams pulls out of French Open with injury
Serena Williams has called off her Grand Slam comeback, pulling out of the French Open because of a chest injury before she was supposed to play Maria Sharapova
9:41AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Curry dazzles from deep, Warriors take 2-0 NBA Finals lead
Stephen Curry hit an NBA Finals-record nine 3-pointers and scored 33 point, leading the Golden State Warriors to a 122-103 win over the Cleveland Cavaliers for 2-0 lead
5:12AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP News Guide: What to know about the year-old Qatar crisis
AP News Guide: What to know about the Qatar diplomatic crisis as 4 Arab nations maintain their year-old boycott
2:51AM ( 7 hours ago )
Fallon to Parkland students: 'Don't let anything stop you'
Jimmy Fallon urges Parkland students: 'Don't let anything stop you'
1:06AM ( 9 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Giuliani: Trump could pardon himself, but why?
Trump lawyer plays down chance president would pardon himself, saying that would invite impeachment proceedings and Trump has done no wrong
6:24AM ( 4 hours ago )
APNewsBreak: Skimping can't save seniors from upped med cost
APNewsBreak: Government report finds seniors scrimp on brand-name drugs but have to spend more anyway
6:10AM ( 4 hours ago )
Immigration fight, tension on tariffs await Congress' return
Congress returns to work Monday to face a House showdown over immigration while Senate Republicans are trying to stop an all-out trade war after Trump's decision to impose import tariffs on close U.S. allies
5:35AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Ronaldo begins World Cup preparations amid Madrid doubts
Surrounded by doubts about his future at Real Madrid, Cristiano Ronaldo is bringing some unwanted distraction to Portugal's national team ahead of the World Cup
10:10AM ( 34 minutes ago )
No showdown: Injured Serena Williams out of French Open
Serena Williams calls off her Grand Slam comeback because of a chest muscle injury
10:08AM ( 36 minutes ago )
UN nuclear chief says work in N. Korea could resume quickly
The head of the U.N. nuclear watchdog says his agency could resume work in North Korea "within weeks" to verify any possible agreement between Washington and Pyongyang
9:57AM ( 46 minutes ago )
The Latest: Nadal advances to French Open quarterfinals
Defending champion Rafael Nadal has again reached the French Open quarterfinals in his bid for a record-extending 11th title at Roland Garros
9:57AM ( 47 minutes ago )
Trump says he has 'absolute right' to pardon himself
President Donald Trump declares on Monday that he has the "absolute right" to pardon, but adds he's done nothing wrong
9:55AM ( 48 minutes ago )