clear
Thursday August 16th, 2018 10:09AM

Iowa abortion suit won't have easy path to US Supreme Court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — Supporters of the nation's strictest abortion law are hoping a lawsuit filed against the Iowa measure will bring the issue back before the U.S. Supreme Court, but constitutional experts say that's unlikely because of a legal maneuver by abortion-rights groups.

The Iowa affiliates of the American Civil Liberties Union and Planned Parenthood filed a lawsuit this week challenging the constitutionality of a law set to go in effect on July 1 that would prohibit most abortions in the state once a fetal heartbeat is detected. That's around six weeks of pregnancy.

However, the groups filed their complaint in state court in Des Moines, and it focuses on alleged violations of Iowa's constitution rather than federal constitutional law.

The distinction is important, said Columbia Law School professor Katherine Franke. It complicates the legal avenue for challenging Roe v. Wade, the landmark 1973 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that established a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy until a fetus is viable.

"The Iowa Supreme Court is the court of last resort on how to interpret the Iowa Constitution," she said. "They're raising it exclusively as a state constitutional issue for obvious reasons. They don't want to be baited into having this case be the opportunity for the U.S. Supreme Court to revise Roe. It's a smart strategy."

Rita Bettis, legal director for the ACLU of Iowa, said during a press conference that the Iowa Supreme Court has previously recognized a woman's right to an abortion when it struck down an effort by a state medicine board to ban telemedicine abortions. The practice continues to allow women in rural areas to get abortion pills without the need for an in-office consultation in a city clinic.

"We think that that's a clear indication of what we already know, which is that the Iowa Constitution robustly protects exactly these fundamental individual rights that include a woman's right to access a safe and legal abortion," she said.

The makeup of the Iowa Supreme Court remains mostly the same. Bruce Zager, an appointee of former Republican Gov. Terry Branstad, will retire in September. New Gov. Kim Reynolds, Branstad's former lieutenant governor, will fill the vacancy.

Justice Daryl Hecht, an appointee of former Democratic Gov. Tom Vilsack, has missed hearing some cases recently as he undergoes treatment for melanoma, a form of skin cancer. But court officials say he'll continue to participate as treatment allows.

Iowa Republican lawmakers who passed the abortion ban this year believe the state courts strategy isn't foolproof. Rep. Steven Holt, a Republican from the small western Iowa city of Denison, said he believes the court case will raise enough federal questions that it will provide an avenue for questions before the U.S. Supreme Court.

"None of us have a crystal ball," he said. "The only thing that I can say is that numerous state laws that are challenged end up before the United States Supreme Court."

Todd Pettys, a professor at the University of Iowa College of Law, said that comes down primarily to whether the Iowa Supreme Court makes a ruling on the lawsuit that relies on federal law.

"If this case does wind up in front of the United States Supreme Court, it's going to be because the Iowa Supreme Court decided intentionally to write an opinion that left open that possibility, and I doubt that they would do that," he said.

Such an appeal would likely be in the form of a petition asking the U.S. Supreme Court to directly hear the case. Franke said there is a chance a group of women or other party opposing abortion could file a federal constitutional challenge to the law just to get it into federal court.

"It would be a staged challenge but I wouldn't be surprised to see that," she said.

The legal strategy for the state is still being sorted out. Iowa's longtime attorney general, Democrat Tom Miller, said in a letter after the lawsuit was announced that he would not defend the law based on a belief that the measure "would undermine rights and protections for women."

Chuck Hurley, chief counsel for the Family Leader, a faith-based group in Iowa that opposes abortion, said there are legal motions the state could make to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to step in and review the case. He said he has discussed such strategy with the Thomas More Society, a conservative Chicago-based law firm, which has agreed to defend the law for free. A spokesman for the firm didn't respond to a request for comment.

Hurley acknowledged the odds are against the high court doing so, but he said it will come down to more conservative-leaning justices getting on the bench, which he believes is possible as the lawsuit makes its way through the court system.

"That's the biggest element by far," he said. "Frankly, the only element."

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Jailed man said Paddock railed about government
A man who met Las Vegas mass shooter Stephen Paddock less than a month before the Oct. 1 attack told authorities that Paddock had ranted against the government and warned that law enforcement and the military would start confiscating guns
8:58PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Inmate executed for San Antonio lovers' lane killing
A Texas inmate who insisted he wasn't involved in a San Antonio "lovers' lane" killing in 2003 has been executed for the slaying.
8:54PM ( 20 minutes ago )
British cyber expert's attorney says FBI deceived him
Attorneys for a British cybersecurity expert credited with stopping a worldwide computer virus last year told a federal judge Wednesday that the FBI agents who arrested him for allegedly creating malware used deception when interrogating him
8:52PM ( 22 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Trump disclosure of Cohen payment raises new legal questions
President Donald Trump reveals in his financial disclosure that he reimbursed personal attorney Michael Cohen as much as $250,000 for unspecified "expenses"
9:04PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Liberal tilt in some primaries a sign of Democratic fervor
Democratic voters are choosing decidedly liberal candidates in some primary elections for House races viewed as key to the congressional majority
8:58PM ( 16 minutes ago )
House OKs expansion of private care at VA, budget crisis fix
House votes to give veterans more freedom to see doctors outside the Veterans Affairs health system
8:33PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Iowa abortion suit won't have easy path to US Supreme Court
Constitutional law experts say an Iowa abortion law considered the nation's strictest likely will not have an easy path to the U.S. Supreme Court, where supporters had hoped it would help end legalized abortion
6:39PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Pence reports pension plan, football tickets
Vice President Mike Pence has released his annual financial disclosure, reporting a pension plan from the state of Indiana worth between $500,000 and $1 million
6:38PM ( 2 hours ago )
FDA approves 1st nonopioid drug to ease withdrawal symptoms
FDA approves 1st nonopioid treatment to ease withdrawal symptoms
6:21PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Police: Tulsa mom stabbed eldest daughter up to 70 times
Police say a Tulsa mother stabbed her eldest daughter 50 to 70 times, struck her head with a pickaxe then set their home on fire, before fleeing the scene with the youngest of her three daughters
5:21PM ( 3 hours ago )
State to defend California law allowing life-ending drugs
Advocates say the terminally ill may suffer unnecessarily after a judge threw out a California law that allows adults to obtain a prescription for life-ending drugs
5:20PM ( 3 hours ago )
Plume of volcanic ash lingers over Hawaii's Kilauea volcano
Plume of volcanic ash lingers over Hawaii's Kilauea volcano, prompts warnings for pilots
5:08PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Vegas Strip shooting witnesses described chaos, compassion
Witness accounts of gunfire, chaos, blood, heartbreak and survival have emerged in police reports made public seven months after a Las Vegas Strip shooting that was deadliest event of its kind in modern U.S. history
5:17PM ( 3 hours ago )
Man pleads guilty to killing 4; cousin rejects plea deal
A man has pleaded guilty to murder charges in the gruesome killings of four young men whose bodies were found buried on a suburban Philadelphia farm
5:10PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Nassar victims to get ESPYS courage award
Larry Nassar's victims will receive the Arthur Ashe Courage Award at this year's ESPYS
4:23PM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Hamas says most slain Gaza protesters were its members
Hamas says that most protesters killed by Israeli fire were its members, deepening divide between Israeli-Palestinian narrative
3:58PM ( 5 hours ago )
In veiled shot at Trump, Tillerson warns democracy at risk
In veiled shot at Trump, Tillerson warns American freedom, democracy at risk
3:34PM ( 5 hours ago )
Mom of 10 tortured kids in custody, bail almost $500,000
Bail for a California mother of 10 children who officials say suffered long-term abuse was set at nearly $500,000 after the judge said she remains a danger to the kids
2:30PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Judge to decide Florida ban on smokable medical marijuana
A Florida circuit court judge will soon decide if patients approved to use medical marijuana will be allowed to smoke it
6:57PM ( 2 hours ago )
House OKs expansion of private care at VA, fix budget crisis
House votes to give veterans more freedom to see doctors outside the Veterans Affairs health system
6:47PM ( 2 hours ago )
Pennsylvania governor gets to know imposing new ticket mate
Pennsylvania's governor is getting to know his new running mate better, a day after Democrats voted to replace the incumbent lieutenant governor with the mayor of an economically struggling steel mill town
6:11PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
EPA's Pruitt faces senators' questions on spending, security
Environmental Protection Agency chief Scott Pruitt says he doesn't remember asking his security detail to use lights and sirens to speed his government-owned SUV through traffic, even as Democratic senators disclose an internal email saying he did
2:43PM ( 6 hours ago )
Virginia Republicans at odds - and throats - in Trump era
The vicious tenor of the 2016 GOP presidential primary is being matched by Virginia's raucous congressional primaries
2:12PM ( 7 hours ago )
Zuckerberg to meet EU officials _ dodging public grilling
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has accepted to come explain his company's recent privacy issues with and allegations that it misused personal data at the European Parliament, the legislature's president says
1:20PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Sports betting ruling has ripples for US tribes with casinos
American Indian tribes welcome opportunity to offer sports betting in potentially hundreds of casinos across country
11:07AM ( 10 hours ago )
Tribes welcome opportunity to add sports book to casinos
American Indian tribes welcome opportunity to offer sports betting in potentially hundreds of casinos across country
1:53AM ( 19 hours ago )
1st appeals court to weigh Trump's decision to end DACA
The Trump administration will try to convince a U.S. appeals court that it was justified in ending an Obama-era immigration policy that shielded hundreds of thousands of young immigrants from deportation
3:12AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
The Latest: Jailed man said Paddock railed about government
A man who met Las Vegas mass shooter Stephen Paddock less than a month before the Oct. 1 attack told authorities that Paddock had ranted against the government and warned that law enforcement and the military would start confiscating guns
8:58PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Inmate executed for San Antonio lovers' lane killing
A Texas inmate who insisted he wasn't involved in a San Antonio "lovers' lane" killing in 2003 has been executed for the slaying.
8:54PM ( 21 minutes ago )
British cyber expert's attorney says FBI deceived him
Attorneys for a British cybersecurity expert credited with stopping a worldwide computer virus last year told a federal judge Wednesday that the FBI agents who arrested him for allegedly creating malware used deception when interrogating him
8:52PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Michigan State agrees to pay $500M to settle Nassar claims
Michigan State agrees to pay $500M to settle abuse claims against sports doctor
8:32PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Signs of bomb found at site of deadly California explosion
Officials say an explosion that rocked a California medical building, killing the owner of a day spa and seriously injuring two patrons, is being investigated as a crime after federal officials found remnants of an explosive device inside the spa
8:29PM ( 46 minutes ago )