partlycloudy
Thursday December 13th, 2018 5:57AM

Defense cross of Cosby accuser reflects change in strategy

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NORRISTOWN, Pa. (AP) — Bill Cosby's lawyers have changed the way they talk about his chief accuser and her relationship with him.

At Cosby's first sexual-assault trial, the defense argued that Andrea Constand, a former Temple University women's basketball administrator, and the 80-year-old married comedian were lovers having an affair. A mistrial was declared when jurors couldn't reach a verdict after six days of deliberations.

At the retrial, Cosby's new lawyer, Tom Mesereau, has called Constand a "con artist" who baited Cosby by feigning romantic interest in him and wound up with a $3.4 million civil settlement after she leveled a false claim of sexual molestation.

Mesereau's cross-examination of Constand, which ended Monday, reflected this change in strategy.

Like last time, though, the defense team hit a brick wall when it asked Constand about a key figure in the case, Marguerite Jackson, who says Constand spoke about fabricating sexual-assault allegations against a celebrity to file suit. After Constand denied knowing Jackson at the first trial, a judge barred her from testifying for the defense. The judge has tentatively ruled that Jackson can take the stand at the retrial, but that could change because Constand, for a second time, has denied knowing her.

Here's a glimpse at each defense team's cross-examination of Constand.

ON CONSTAND'S DINNER WITH COSBY

First trial: Cosby lawyer Angela Agrusa suggested Constand once enjoyed a romantic dinner at Cosby's home.

"And the room was dark and there was a nice mood in the room, correct?" Agrusa asked.

"I don't know what that means," Constand replied.

"The lights were dimmed, and the fire was going, right?" the lawyer continued.

"I don't really remember how dim the lights were, but I did have to eat my dinner," Constand said.

Second trial: Mesereau didn't ask about the dinner.

ON THE 'PONZI SCHEME'

First trial: The defense didn't ask Constand about emails she had sent that promised big returns for a risk-free $65 investment — what the defense at the second trial has called a "Ponzi scheme."

Second trial: Mesereau asked Constand about the emails, seeking to bolster his claim that she's a con artist. During cross-examination, Constand struggled to remember why she'd sent them but said she was only trying to help out a friend.

ON MARGUERITE JACKSON

First trial: Agrusa asked Constand, "When you traveled to the away games while you were director of basketball operations, did you know or work with a woman named Margo Jackson?"

Constand replied, "Her name sounds familiar, but I don't really remember her. ... I don't know her."

Second trial: Constand testified she doesn't "recall ever having a conversation with" Jackson.

ON CONSTAND'S CIVIL SETTLEMENT

First trial: Agrusa ran through a list of personal-injury lawyers whom Constand called after the alleged assault and referred to her police statement in which she said she had contacted an attorney who "specializes in sexual assault lawsuits." Constand said a lawsuit "was not my intention." Due to a ruling from the judge, Agrusa was barred from questioning Constand about her $3.4 million civil settlement with Cosby.

Second trial: This time, the defense was allowed to ask her about the 2006 settlement.

Mesereau suggested Constand violated a confidentiality provision of the settlement by cooperating with prosecutors when they reopened the criminal investigation in 2015. He asked if she offered to give the money back and wondered, "Didn't you think when Mr. Cosby paid you this large sum of money he was hoping it would all go away?"

Constand agreed, saying she wanted it to go away, too.

"I was glad it was over," she said.

___

Rubinkam contributed to this story from northeastern Pennsylvania.

___

This story has been corrected to show jurors at the first trial deliberated for six days, not five.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Basketball, College Sports, AP Entertainment, AP Online TV News, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Sports - Women's College Basketball
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Times, New Yorker win Pulitzer for Weinstein scandal
The New York Times and The New Yorker have won the Pulitzer Prize for public service for their reporting on Harvey Weinstein and sexual misconduct that galvanized the #MeToo movement
7:08PM ( 12 minutes ago )
US says California rejects proposed border duties for troops
The Trump administration has said California Gov. Jerry Brown rejected plans for the National Guard's initial Mexican border deployment
7:00PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Defense cross of Cosby accuser reflects change in strategy
Bill Cosby's lawyers have changed the way they talk about his chief accuser and her relationship with him
6:55PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Watchdog: Zinke charter flight approved without full info
An internal watchdog says a $12,000 charter flight by Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke was reviewed and approved by department ethics officials without complete information
5:51PM ( 1 hour ago )
Carroll equalizes late as West Ham holds Stoke to 1-1 in EPL
Andy Carroll scored a 90th-minute equalizer soon after coming off the bench to earn West Ham a 1-1 draw against Stoke, which was denied a vital win in its bid to escape relegation from the English Premier League
5:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
Busch passes Larson to win rain-delayed race at Bristol
Kyle Busch won the Cup Series race at Bristol Motor Speedway
5:43PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
Bill Cosby's accuser denies framing him, knowing key witness
Bill Cosby's chief accuser at his suburban Philadelphia sexual-assault retrial has denied knowing or ever speaking with a woman who's expected to be a key witness for the defense
3:54PM ( 3 hours ago )
Cosby accuser denies framing Cosby or knowing key witness
Bill Cosby's chief accuser denies knowing or ever speaking with a woman who's expected to be a key witness for the defense
1:56PM ( 5 hours ago )
Bill Cosby lawyer paints accuser as unrequited lover
Bill Cosby's lawyer is trying to paint the chief accuser in the comedian's sex-assault case as an unrequited lover who called him twice on Valentine's Day after she says he drugged and molested her
12:44PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Basketball
Oklahoma President Boren has minor stroke at Stoops ceremony
Oklahoma President Boren suffers minor stroke at Stoops statue dedication ceremony
7:22PM ( 1 day ago )
Oklahoma president Boren leaves Stoops ceremony on stretcher
Oklahoma president Boren leaves Stoops ceremony on stretcher
6:53PM ( 2 days ago )
Chief Cosby accuser says she was too weak to 'fight him off'
Bill Cosby's chief accuser has taken the witness stand for the second time to tell a story of molestation and broken trust
7:57PM ( 2 days ago )
College Sports
Hannity shares world view with Trump, and lawyer, too
Fox News star Sean Hannity is revealed as a client of Trump attorney Michael Cohen in a New York court hearing
6:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
What's in those seized records? Trump's biggest new worry
President Donald Trump and his allies have hit a new level of anxiety after the raid on his personal attorney's office,
6:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
Music Pulitzer goes to rapper Lamar; fiction prize to 'Less'
The Pulitzers have awarded rapper Kendrick Lamar its music prize, a sharp departure from the classical and jazz artists who have traditionally won the honor
5:55PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Entertainment
Eccentric heir Robert Durst faces key hearing in murder case
Prosecutors are trying to show that New York real estate heir Robert Durst should go to trial in the shooting death of his best friend
1:39PM ( 5 hours ago )
Starbucks CEO hopes to meet with men arrested in Philly shop
The CEO of Starbucks was in Philadelphia on Monday and said he hoped to meet with two black men who were arrested when the coffee chain's employees called 911 to say they were trespassing
11:19AM ( 8 hours ago )
The Latest: Starbucks CEO hopes to meet with arrested men
The CEO of Starbucks is in Philadelphia, hoping to meet with the two black men were arrested after store employees called 911 to say they were trespassing
10:16AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Online TV News
Busch captures rain-delayed Cup Series race at Bristol
Kyle Busch won the Cup Series race at Bristol Motor Speedway
4:06PM ( 3 hours ago )
Prosecutor wants Meek Mill's drug and gun convictions tossed
Philadelphia's district attorney says all charges should be dropped against rapper Meek Mill and he needs to have a new trial
4:03PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Greer's 'Less' wins fiction Pulitzer Prize
Rapper Kendrick Lamar has become the first non-classical or jazz performer to win the Pulitzer Prize for music
3:26PM ( 3 hours ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Constand to confront Cosby after parade of women take aim
Bill Cosby's chief accuser is set to take the witness stand at his sexual assault retrial
5:19AM ( 3 days ago )
Ogunbowale puts stamp on thrilling women's hoops season
Arike Ogunbowale put an exclamation point on a thrilling women's college basketball season
5:57PM ( 2 weeks ago )
Most in Cosby jury pool have made up minds, know of #MeToo
More than half of the 120 potential jurors being questioned in Bill Cosby's sexual assault retrial say they've already formed an opinion about the comedian's guilt or innocence
5:19PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Sports - Women's College Basketball
Times, New Yorker win Pulitzer for Weinstein scandal
The New York Times and The New Yorker have won the Pulitzer Prize for public service for their reporting on Harvey Weinstein and sexual misconduct that galvanized the #MeToo movement
7:08PM ( 12 minutes ago )
US says California rejects proposed border duties for troops
The Trump administration has said California Gov. Jerry Brown rejected plans for the National Guard's initial Mexican border deployment
7:00PM ( 19 minutes ago )
ABC makes unusual decision to release all of Comey talk
ABC's unusual decision to release full transcript of George Stephanopoulos' interview with former FBI Director James Comey has turned into a hit for network's website
6:54PM ( 26 minutes ago )
White House says Russia sanctions still under consideration
The White House scrambled Monday to walk back U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley's weekend announcement that new economic sanctions against Russia are imminent, but stressed the penalties are still being considered
6:52PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Heavy rains ease, rescue efforts improve after Hawaii storm
Heavy rains on Kauai are allowing emergency workers to better rescue people stranded by flooding
6:45PM ( 34 minutes ago )