clear
Tuesday December 18th, 2018 6:33PM

Eccentric heir Robert Durst faces key hearing in murder case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LOS ANGELES (AP) — It's been more than three years since the arrest of eccentric New York real estate heir Robert Durst in the execution-style shooting of his best friend years earlier in Los Angeles.

Prosecutors could move closer to bringing him to trial if they can show probable cause at a hearing beginning Monday that Durst killed Susan Berman to silence her from revealing what she knew about the death of the multimillionaire's first wife.

Durst, 75, has pleaded not guilty. With all that has emerged about him publicly from an HBO documentary series and a string of unusual court hearings, it seems likely a Los Angeles Superior Court judge will order the case to trial.

Prosecutors have started recording testimony over the past year of older witnesses who might not be available if there is a trial. Some of the testimony includes strong evidence against Durst, who already has been cleared in an unrelated 2003 Texas killing.

One of his closest friends, Nathan "Nick" Chavin, who also was close with Berman, testified that Durst essentially acknowledged killing her, saying, "It was her or me, I had no choice."

Chavin and other friends of Berman said she told them Durst had killed his first wife, Kathleen, who disappeared in 1982 in suburban New York and has never been found.

Berman, a writer and daughter of a Las Vegas mobster, said she helped Durst cover his tracks and told one friend that if anything ever happened to her, Durst would be the culprit.

In the HBO documentary, "The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst," he is heard muttering to himself on a live microphone: "You're caught! What the hell did I do? Killed them all, of course."

The challenge, however, will be getting any of that evidence before a jury.

"All kinds of evidentiary issues are going to be a battle in this case," said Stanley Goldman, a professor at Loyola Law School.

Durst's defense team, who didn't reply to messages seeking comment, has fought or is expected to challenge every bit of evidence that implicates him, including Berman's numerous hearsay statements to friends.

Deputy District Attorney John Lewin said Durst forfeited the right to challenge the hearsay statements because he killed Berman to prevent her from telling police what she knew about Kathleen Durst's death.

"His attempt to prohibit the jury from learning what she said about him killing his wife is the most recent chapter in the defendant's 36-year quest to evade responsibility for the heinous crimes he has committed," Lewin said.

The motive for Berman's death and a subsequent killing were covering up Kathleen Durst's death, Lewin said. He intends to present evidence that Robert Durst roughed up his wife to show he tried to control her through fear and had the capacity for violence that escalated.

Goldman said the judge will have to evaluate the relevance of the evidence, whether hearsay is permissible and if the proof offered by testimony outweighs the bias it could create against Durst.

"He's not being tried for killing his wife," Goldman said. "But it's part of the story. To flesh out the entire story without it, you don't know the motive. How far does the judge let the prosecutor go back to prove that he did those things?"

For example, it's not certain if the judge will allow evidence that Durst fatally shot and dismembered neighbor Morris Black, 71, in Galveston, Texas, nine months after Berman was killed.

Durst moved there and posed as a mute woman to hide from investigators who wanted to talk to him after reopening the investigation into Kathleen Durst's disappearance. He was acquitted of murder after testifying he killed Black in self-defense.

Durst was arrested in the Berman killing in 2015, just before the climactic final episode of "The Jinx" aired, in which he is heard muttering about the killings.

He acknowledged in a three-hour interrogation by Lewin that he was in the process of fleeing.

"I was the worst fugitive the world has ever met," Durst said, according to a transcript of the interview.

The defense also wants to bar those statements from trial.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Entertainment, AP Online TV News
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Eccentric heir Robert Durst faces key hearing in murder case
Prosecutors are trying to show that New York real estate heir Robert Durst should go to trial in the shooting death of his best friend
1:39PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Judge tells Italy to release aid group's migrant rescue boat
An Italian judge has ordered Italy to release a Spanish aid group's rescue ship that was impounded for taking 218 migrants to Italy, finding that the ship was operating in an emergency when it launched the rescue
1:37PM ( 6 minutes ago )
UK sorry for 'appalling' treatment of Caribbean immigrants
The British government apologized Monday for its "appalling" treatment of some immigrants from the Caribbean, as reports of law-abiding long-term residents being threatened with deportation overshadowed a meeting of leaders from the 53-nation Commonwealth
1:37PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Desi Linden wins Boston Marathon, 1st US woman since '85
Desiree Linden splashed her way through icy rain and a near-gale headwind to a Boston Marathon victory on Monday, the first American woman to win the race since 1985
1:15PM ( 29 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump's personal attorney arrives at courthouse
President Donald Trump's personal attorney, Michael Cohen, has arrived at a New York City courthouse for a hearing over an FBI search of his files.
1:13PM ( 30 minutes ago )
The Latest: Authorities release names of slain inmates
Authorities have released the names of the seven inmates killed by fellow prisoners during a riot at a South Carolina maximum-security prison
1:13PM ( 30 minutes ago )
AP National News
Indians donate $37,000 for hurricane relief in Puerto Rico
The Cleveland Indians have donated an additional $37,000 to help hurricane recovery
12:47PM ( 56 minutes ago )
DA wants Meek Mill conviction tossed, but he remains jailed
Philadelphia's district attorney says all charges should be dropped against Meek Mill and the rapper needs to have a new trial
12:10PM ( 1 hour ago )
Starbucks CEO hopes to meet with men arrested in Philly shop
The CEO of Starbucks was in Philadelphia on Monday and said he hoped to meet with two black men who were arrested when the coffee chain's employees called 911 to say they were trespassing
11:19AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Comey: 'Possible' that Russians have leverage over Trump
Former FBI Director James Comey says he thinks it's possible the Russians have compromising information on President Donald Trump and that there is "some evidence of obstruction of justice" in the president's actions
12:37AM ( 13 hours ago )
Comey: "Possible" that Russians have leverage over Trump
President Donald Trump took to Twitter to unload on James Comey over his forthcoming memoir, calling him "slippery," suggesting he should be in jail and labeling him "the WORST FBI Director in history, by far!"
11:10PM ( 14 hours ago )
Eagles release cornerback Daryl Worley after his arrest
The Philadelphia Eagles have released cornerback Daryl Worley, hours after he was arrested
6:34PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Online TV News
Judge tells Italy to release aid group's migrant rescue boat
An Italian judge has ordered Italy to release a Spanish aid group's rescue ship that was impounded for taking 218 migrants to Italy, finding that the ship was operating in an emergency when it launched the rescue
1:37PM ( 6 minutes ago )
UK sorry for 'appalling' treatment of Caribbean immigrants
The British government apologized Monday for its "appalling" treatment of some immigrants from the Caribbean, as reports of law-abiding long-term residents being threatened with deportation overshadowed a meeting of leaders from the 53-nation Commonwealth
1:37PM ( 6 minutes ago )
S. Carolina inmate: Bodies stacked up during riot; 7 slain
An inmate who witnessed a riot inside a South Carolina prison says he saw bodies stacking up on each other and correctional officers didn't do anything to stop the violence or check on the injured
1:31PM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: Russia praises Syrian air defenses after strikes
The Russian military says Syria's Russian-made air defense systems proved highly efficient in fending off missile strikes by the U.S. and its allies
1:29PM ( 14 minutes ago )
The Latest: Residents of Syria town describe chemical attack
Associated Press journalists have visited the Syrian town of Douma and spoken to residents who described a terrifying gas attack on April 7. Residents say those most affected in the attack, near Douma's Martyrs Square, were children and elderly people
1:24PM ( 19 minutes ago )