clear
Saturday April 21st, 2018 2:57PM

Wisconsin professor says firing shows anti-conservative bias

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

MILWAUKEE (AP) — A dispute between a conservative professor and the university that fired him is going before the Wisconsin Supreme Court, which will hear arguments this week on whether the firing was the result of a provocative blog post or his conduct.

Former Marquette University professor John McAdams sued the private Catholic school in 2016, arguing that he lost his job for exercising his freedom of speech by expressing his disapproval of what he believes was a teacher's attempt to shut down a discussion about opposition to gay marriage.

However, the school has always said that it was not what the professor wrote that led to his firing, but rather his "doxing" of a graduate student instructor in a blog post . Doxing is the practice of publicizing someone's personal identifying information online to subject them to harassment.

"Had he written the exact same blog post and not included the student-teacher's name and contact information he would not have been disciplined," said Ralph Weber, Marquette's attorney. "He's being disciplined for his conduct, not any viewpoint."

McAdams' attorney, Rick Esenberg, said the doxing argument is "fundamentally dishonest" and that all McAdams did was link to publicly available information.

The state Supreme Court will hear arguments Thursday.

The case is significant to conservatives, who see universities as liberal havens that stifle their viewpoints, and to private businesses that want control over how employees can be disciplined.

In the November 2014 blog post, McAdams described an interaction between a conservative student and a graduate student instructor of philosophy. The student claimed the instructor refused to allow discussion about opposition to gay marriage during a class and provided McAdams with a recording he secretly made of a conversation with the teacher after the class.

That formed the basis for McAdams' post, in which he argued that the students' experience was another example of liberals silencing people whose opinions they disagree with or find offensive. The post included the student-teacher's name, a link to her personal website and her email address, and it led to a flood of hateful messages and threats against her. The threats were bad enough that the university posted a security officer outside of her classroom and she noticeably lost weight.

McAdams published his post on his personal website, "Marquette Warrior," which he has used for more than a decade to condemn political correctness and the silencing of ideas that might be hurtful to protected classes, according to his lawsuit against the school.

McAdams stirred up several controversies in his thousands of blog posts over the years and the university went out of its way not to punish him for them, according to a March 2016 report from a faculty committee that recommended a one-year suspension for the tenured professor. The committee noted that McAdams had been advised previously, in 2011, not to mention a student's name on his blog.

"One of the more important obligations that professors have is to take care not to cause harm, directly or indirectly, to members of the university community," wrote the committee, which also criticized McAdams for inaccurately portraying the interaction between the student and instructor.

The graduate student McAdams named in his blog eventually moved to another university, where she had to repeat three semesters and revise her PhD thesis.

McAdams was given the chance to return to work after his suspension, provided he write a letter apologizing for his conduct, acknowledging his post "was reckless and incompatible with the mission and values of Marquette University" and promising to follow to those values in the future. The letter was to be shared confidentially with the student instructor but McAdams refused to write it, saying during a talk radio appearance that he would do so "when hell freezes over."

Esenberg said McAdams didn't write the letter because it would have been admitting he did something wrong and he doesn't think that's the case.

"What Marquette is doing is they're forcing him to make a Soviet-style confession," Esenberg said.

A Milwaukee County Circuit Court judge ruled in favor of Marquette before the case went to trial last year, saying the school's disciplinary proceedings were fair and not a violation of McAdams' academic freedom. The Wisconsin Supreme Court, which has a conservative majority, can affirm the decision, return the case to Milwaukee County for a jury trial or refer it to the Wisconsin Court of Appeals. It also could find that Marquette violated the portion of its contract with McAdams guaranteeing academic freedom.

The Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce and National Association of Manufacturers have filed briefs in support of Marquette. The Thomas More Society and the National Association of Scholars, both conservative groups, are supporting McAdams, as well as the American Association of University Professors and the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, which are nonpartisan.

___

Follow Ivan Moreno on Twitter: https://twitter.com/IvanJourno

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Arab leaders meet to unify ranks with eye on Iran, Jerusalem
Saudi Arabia used its perch as host of an annual gathering of Arab leaders on Sunday to push for a unified stance against rival Iran as the regional powerhouses vie for the upper hand in wars in Syria and Yemen
10:24AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Ted Cruz runs for re-election as though it's still 2016
Ted Cruz is largely ignoring Trump and is sticking to the surprisingly effective conservative playbook he used when running for president in 2016, hoping it will carry him to re-election in the Senate and possibly another presidential run
10:21AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Wisconsin professor says firing shows anti-conservative bias
A dispute between a conservative professor and the university that fired him is going before the Wisconsin Supreme Court to decide whether the teacher's termination was the result of a blog post or his conduct
10:10AM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
France urges Russia to join peace push after Syria strike
France is urging Russia to join in renewed peace efforts after a wave of Western missile strikes aimed at punishing Syria for an alleged chemical weapons attack
9:23AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump defends 'mission accomplished' after strike on Syria
Trump defends use of "mission accomplished" in aftermath of missile strike launched against Syria by U.S. and allies France and Britain
9:16AM ( 1 hour ago )
In Peru for summit, Pence offers support for Syrian strike
Vice President Mike Pence has wrapped up his trip to a summit of Latin American leaders
8:46AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
The Latest: Aide: Pence left Summit before Cuban FM spoke
Vice President Mike Pence's office says the vice president walked out of the Summit of the Americas when Cuba's foreign minister was recognized to speak after him
2:06AM ( 8 hours ago )
The Latest: Syrian-Americans express anger over missiles
Syrian-Americans have expressed anger at the missile strike on their homeland as they celebrated their country's independence a rally in Pennsylvania
9:44PM ( 12 hours ago )
Certain of gas attack, allies struck Syria before UN report
The United States, Britain and France decided to strike Syria for its apparent use of chemical weapons without waiting for a report from U.N. inspectors
9:07PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Arab leaders meet to unify ranks with eye on Iran, Jerusalem
Saudi Arabia used its perch as host of an annual gathering of Arab leaders on Sunday to push for a unified stance against rival Iran as the regional powerhouses vie for the upper hand in wars in Syria and Yemen
10:24AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Ted Cruz runs for re-election as though it's still 2016
Ted Cruz is largely ignoring Trump and is sticking to the surprisingly effective conservative playbook he used when running for president in 2016, hoping it will carry him to re-election in the Senate and possibly another presidential run
10:21AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Spring storm keeps central US in icy grip, hampering travel
Flights canceled, roadways treacherous as deadly storm system stretching from Gulf Coast to Great Lakes hits central US with heavy snow, wind and rain
10:02AM ( 30 minutes ago )
Kim Jong Un meets high-ranking Chinese diplomat in Pyongyang
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un has met with a high-ranking Chinese diplomat in Pyongyang, amid a flurry of diplomacy following Kim's recent surprise visit to Beijing
9:49AM ( 42 minutes ago )
Rain postpones Blue Jays-Indians again; May 3 doubleheader
Blue Jays-Indians postponed by rain for second straight day. Teams will play traditional doubleheader on May 3 at 1:10 p.m. at Progressive Field. Toronto ended Cleveland's five-game winning streak with an 8-4 victory on Friday night
9:45AM ( 46 minutes ago )