cloudy
Monday October 15th, 2018 11:03AM

Is Facebook regulation 'inevitable'? Not so fast

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg told lawmakers that regulation of his company is "inevitable," but still came to Capitol Hill prepared to defend against proposals he thought went too far.

He rarely had to. After about 10 hours of hearings on Tuesday and Wednesday, markets rallied and privacy advocates were disappointed at the prospect that Facebook appeared to emerge unscathed, left to its own devices to manage how it collects vast amounts of personal data and handles user privacy.

"This is still very much an uphill battle for privacy reforms," said Alvaro Bedoya, who directs Georgetown University's Center on Privacy and Technology. "Yes, right now we have the wind at our backs, but unless people around the country stay on this, this can very quickly devolve into a giveaway for tech."

Some legislators touted their various proposals for privacy protections, including bills introduced this week responding to the privacy scandal involving some 87 million Facebook users whose data was swept up by the political data-mining firm Cambridge Analytica.

Increased regulation "is a very real possibility," said Oregon Republican Rep. Greg Walden, chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, which held Wednesday's hearing. But after it was over, Walden acknowledged there's little consensus.

"There's a division, I think, and I think still people want to know more about what the companies themselves can do," Walden said.

Zuckerberg often professed his willingness to work with lawmakers on legislative ideas or said he'd get back to them. He made few commitments and promised that Facebook could protect users on its own with better algorithms and advances in artificial intelligence.

The top Democrat on the panel, New Jersey Rep. Frank Pallone, said after the hearing that he thinks the Democrats "made it quite clear that we need some comprehensive legislation on privacy and data," but didn't say exactly what that would look like.

"The biggest concern I have right now, and I think it could be addressed legislatively, is that he wasn't willing to make any changes with the privacy default settings," Pallone said. "So the problem always is that you go on, and unless you affirmatively decide to protect yourself, then they just take everything. I think that needs to be changed."

Pallone, however, said he is "pessimistic that it happens with the Republican majority."

It's not that Zuckerberg wasn't peppered with some tough questions from both parties about his company and its business model. Asked by Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham on Tuesday if Facebook was a monopoly, Zuckerberg quipped, "certainly doesn't feel like that to me." Just a few moments earlier, though, he had struggled to name direct competitors.

Under U.S. antitrust law, corporations deemed an illegal monopoly can be broken up into smaller parts by federal regulators. No one asked Zuckerberg about that, though his notes, which an Associated Press photographer spotted on his desk, showed he was prepared for the question.

"Break up FB?" said a bullet item in the written talking points. "US Tech companies key asset for America; break up strengthens Chinese companies."

While it became clear this week that Congress has no unifying idea about how to tame Facebook's power in a useful way, neither do many of the privacy and consumer advocates calling for heightened regulation.

"I think the interesting regulatory approach is not a breakup or more privacy, but rather an unbundling of Facebook," said Chris Hoofnagle, a professor at UC Berkeley's Center for Law and Technology.

He said it could happen the same way the Federal Communications Commission forced AOL to unbundle its instant messaging service by making it compatible with the systems used by rival internet firms. The unbundling agreement was a condition of the deal that allowed AOL to merge with Time Warner.

"Imagine if competition authorities forced Facebook to open its walled garden and allow third party apps to interoperate without all the invasive properties of the Facebook app," Hoofnagle said.

What happens next is unclear, but Bedoya said he hopes Congress can focus on a package of specific reforms, such as protections that forbid tracking individuals by location or facial recognition without their consent. Such measures should also strengthen the Federal Trade Communication, which has a 2011 consent decree against Facebook that remains one of the U.S. government's most powerful protections against future privacy abuses.

Walden, noting that Facebook is already regulated by the FTC, said the company will face hefty fines if it violates those regulations on a second offense.

"What I worry about is someone trying to pass a super-broad general privacy law that the lobbyists can eat alive," Bedoya said. "Industry outspends consumer advocates on Capitol Hill and in statehouses, hand over fist."

___

For complete coverage of the Facebook privacy scandal, visit https://apnews.com/tag/FacebookPrivacyScandal

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Is Facebook regulation 'inevitable'? Not so fast
Is Facebook regulation 'inevitable'? Not so fast
5:34PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens decries 'political witch hunt'
Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens says a state House panel's report on an investigation into his extramarital affair with his hairdresser will be "full of lies."
5:32PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Azerbaijan: Aliyev wins 7-year term on top of 15 served
The president of the oil-rich Caspian Sea nation of Azerbaijan heads toward landslide win that will add seven more years to his 15-year rule
5:28PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Greitens talking to media ahead of investigative report
Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens is set to talk to the media about an hour before a legislative committee releases findings from an investigation related to his extramarital affair with his hairdresser
5:13PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Vermont's Republican governor signs new gun restrictions
Republican Vermont Gov. Phil Scott has signed a package of bills that raise the age to buy firearms, ban high-capacity magazines and make it easier to take guns from people who pose a threat
5:13PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Speaker Ryan will leave behind new tax code, busted budget
Paul Ryan spent a career talking about reining in government spending but then pushed policies that sent the deficits soaring
4:22PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Facebook users now being told if data taken
Mark Zuckerberg says his Facebook data was included in the personal information sold to malicious third parties, a reference to the Cambridge Analytica scandal that has rocked his company over the past several weeks
3:17PM ( 2 hours ago )
Florida congressman adds name to list of GOP retirements
A Republican congressman from Florida, Dennis Ross, says he'll retire when his fourth term ends in January and he wants to return to practicing law
2:57PM ( 2 hours ago )
On witness stand, accuser calls Bill Cosby a 'serial rapist'
First accuser to testify at Cosby's retrial describes him as 'a serial rapist'
2:47PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Dodger Stadium to host 2020 All-Star Game
Baseball's All-Star Game is returning to Dodger Stadium in 2020 for the first time since 1980, thanks in large part to the upgrades made by the team's ownership in recent years
4:53PM ( 49 minutes ago )
Drug testing plan considered for some food stamp recipients
Trump administration is considering a plan that would allow states to require certain food stamp recipients to undergo drug testing
4:34PM ( 1 hour ago )
Banks and technology stocks fall; oil rises to 3-year high
US stock indexes finish mostly lower as banks and technology and health care companies fall, but energy companies rise as oil prices hit a three-year high
4:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Mulvaney says consumer watchdog is still doing its job
Republicans are praising Mick Mulvaney's leadership of the nation's consumer financial watchdog, while Democrats are raising concerns that he's done more to protect financial companies than consumers
12:55PM ( 4 hours ago )
Republicans, Democrats reverse roles in hearing on CFPB
Republicans are praising Mick Mulvaney's leadership of the nation's consumer financial watchdog, while Democrats are raising concerns that he's done more to protect financial companies than consumers
11:58AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Mulvaney seeks to change way CFPB is referred to
Along with the many changes in direction of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau under Trump appointee Mick Mulvaney, the bureau's name itself is being reconsidered.
10:46AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens decries 'political witch hunt'
Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens says a state House panel's report on an investigation into his extramarital affair with his hairdresser will be "full of lies."
5:32PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Azerbaijan: Aliyev wins 7-year term on top of 15 served
The president of the oil-rich Caspian Sea nation of Azerbaijan heads toward landslide win that will add seven more years to his 15-year rule
5:28PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Judge weighs arguments in ex-Army couple's resentencing
A judge is weighing prosecution and defense arguments at the resentencing of an ex-Army couple convicted of abusing their young foster children
5:27PM ( 15 minutes ago )
The Latest: 3rd accuser testifies, says Cosby gave her pills
A third accuser has taken the witness stand at Bill Cosby's sexual-assault retrial in suburban Philadelphia
5:24PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Arenado charges mound, swings away, Rockies and Padres brawl
Colorado Rockies star Nolan Arenado charged the mound after a fastball from San Diego starter Luis Perdomo sailed behind him, setting off a wild brawl that resulted in five ejections during a testy series at Coors Field
5:22PM ( 19 minutes ago )