clear
Thursday September 20th, 2018 12:37PM

House rejects GOP bill easing use of unproven drugs

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — The House rejected legislation Tuesday easing how experimental drugs are provided to people with terminal illnesses, as Democrats calling the bill risky and misleading overcame support from President Donald Trump and emotional arguments by Republican lawmakers and ailing constituents.

The vote for the measure was 259-140, but that fell short of the two-thirds majority the GOP needed to prevail under special procedures. Since the Senate approved similar legislation last August, Republicans could revisit the legislation under rules that would require only a simple majority for passage, perhaps after reworking the measure.

"The House will not let this be the end," said Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif.

Republicans brought patients with fatal diseases to the House chamber, including Jordan McLinn, 7, of Indianapolis, a muscular dystrophy sufferer who sat beside Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Greg Walden, R-Ore. McLinn appeared two years ago with then Indiana Gov. Mike Pence, now vice president, as Pence signed state legislation reducing restrictions.

Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick, R-Pa., cited a message from fellow Pennsylvanian Matthew Bellina, a Navy veteran diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, also called Lou Gehrig's disease. Bellina's message was, "A vote against this is essentially a vote to kill me."

All but two voting Republicans backed the measure while Democrats were opposed by a margin exceeding 4-to-1.

Democrats, backed by scores of patients' and research organizations, said the bill would achieve little since the federal Food and Drug Administration already approves 99 percent of the 1,000 requests it receives annually for an existing program that lets patients use unproven treatments. They said the proposal would create risks by rolling back the FDA's oversight role in the process and noted that most experimental drugs don't work.

"The last thing I want to do is give patients false hope and to put them at risk" by reducing the FDA's powers, said Rep. Frank Pallone of New Jersey, top Democrat on the Energy and Commerce panel.

GOP lawmakers rejected that argument.

"There is no such thing as false hope. You either have hope or you have no hope," said Rep. Andy Biggs, R-Ariz.

"If I had a terminal diagnosis, I'd even consider injecting monkey urine if I thought it would give me a few more months, a few more years with my children," said Rep. Morgan Griffith, R-Va.

Under the "Right to Try" legislation, the FDA would no longer need to sign off if a doctor and pharmaceutical maker agree that a patient with no other options should try an experimental treatment.

The agency would have to be notified after treatment begins, manufacturers would have to report if problems arose and drug makers and doctors would be broadly shielded from legal liability. Manufacturers would still not be required to provide their pharmaceuticals.

More than 70 patient and research groups sent a letter of opposition Monday to House leaders saying the bill "would not increase access to promising therapies" and "is still less safe" that the FDA's existing process.

Critics said the measure misleadingly suggests the FDA is the bottleneck to providing the experimental treatments. They say the more common hurdle is manufacturers, which often prefer to use their limited quantities of early-stage drugs for clinical trials needed to gain final FDA approval for wide-spread sales or worry that a setback could damage the product's marketability.

Scott Gottlieb, FDA commissioner and a Trump appointee, told Congress in October that 70 percent of the experimental drugs his agency currently lets seriously ill patients use are never approved.

"The vast majority of people" granted access to unproven treatments "are using a drug that doesn't work," he said.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Trump travels to Los Angeles for fundraiser
President Donald Trump is spending his evening in Los Angeles at a high-dollar fundraiser hosted by the co-chairman of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
7:26PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Zinke defends plan to raise park fees amid flap over travel
Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke bristles under questioning about his spending on travel as the Trump administration seeks deep cuts to conservation programs and fee increases at national parks.
7:19PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Dog dies after airline worker has it placed in overhead bin
A passenger's dog has died on a United Airlines flight from Houston to New York after a flight attendant ordered the animal be put in the plane's overhead bin
7:16PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Tillerson's exit won't affect the deal he struck with Exxon
Rex Tillerson spent just over a year as America's chief diplomat, but he'll continue to benefit from an arrangement he crafted with his former employer, energy giant Exxon Mobil, that could generate millions of dollars in tax savings
6:48PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Trump axes Tillerson, names CIA's Pompeo chief US Diplomat
Trump fires Tillerson as secretary of state, plans to name CIA's Pompeo to replace him
6:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
Pompeo, a hawkish pick, could give State Department new life
Mike Pompeo will take the helm of a State Department that has been badly demoralized by 14 months of budget cuts and staffing reductions
6:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Trump's CIA pick is career spymaster, oversaw secret prison
President Donald Trump's pick to be the next _ and first female _ director of the CIA has conflicting public reputations
4:41PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump: 'Great relationship' with Mexico's leader
President Donald Trump says he has a "great relationship" with Mexican President Enrique Pena Nieto
4:22PM ( 3 hours ago )
Former aide to Gov. Cuomo convicted in bribery case
A former top-aide to New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo has been convicted of accepting hundreds of thousands of dollars in bribes.
4:17PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Britain could be paying into EU coffers until 2064
The agency that compiles forecasts for Britain's government says the country is set to pay into the European Union's coffers for another 50-odd years
6:47PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Ropes, phone lights used in rescue after deadly bus plunge
The crash of a charter bus carrying a high school band from Florida to Texas left a driver dead and about three dozen people injured in south Alabama
6:06PM ( 1 hour ago )
Student walkouts planned across US to protest gun violence
Students at schools across the country are organizing walkouts to protest gun violence on the one-month anniversary of a school shooting in Parkland, Florida
5:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Trump replaces Tillerson with Pompeo in dramatic shakeup
Trump fires Tillerson as secretary of state, plans to name CIA's Pompeo to replace him
3:13PM ( 4 hours ago )
For the tech industry, a red flag on megadeals?
Trump decision to scuttle a hostile takeover by Singapore's Broadcom of the U.S. chipmaker Qualcomm caught some on Wall Street off guard
1:45PM ( 5 hours ago )
Dick's shares take a hit on disappointing holiday sales
Dick's Sporting Goods shares are sliding in early trading after the company reported some disappointing holiday sales numbers
12:43PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
China merges bank, insurance regulators to tackle risk
China plans to merge its banking and insurance regulators into a more powerful agency to control scandal-plagued finance industries that are struggling with debt
2:10AM ( 17 hours ago )
Ag Department kills animal welfare rule for organic meat
The Trump administration is withdrawing a federal rule that would have required organic meat and egg producers to abide by stricter animal welfare standards
7:17PM ( 1 day ago )
Amid Trump visit, it's business as usual for border towns
As Donald Trump visits the U.S.-Mexico border, the daily commute from Mexico to California farms is a reminder of how little has changed despite heated rhetoric in Washington
7:11PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Industries
Trump promising consumers digital-age health care approach
Smartphone app, more access to online cost comparisons among consumer-friendly changes on health care promised by Trump administration
12:10AM ( 1 day ago )
Trump uses page from 'smart policymaking 101' on health care
The Trump administration is taking a pragmatic new tack on health care with officials promising consumer friendly changes and savings in areas from computerized medical records to prescription drugs
6:23PM ( 3 days ago )
Study: Cholesterol drug lowers risk of death, heart attack
A newer type of cholesterol drug modestly lowered heart risks and deaths in a big study
10:40AM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
The Latest: Trump travels to Los Angeles for fundraiser
President Donald Trump is spending his evening in Los Angeles at a high-dollar fundraiser hosted by the co-chairman of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
7:26PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Zinke defends plan to raise park fees amid flap over travel
Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke bristles under questioning about his spending on travel as the Trump administration seeks deep cuts to conservation programs and fee increases at national parks.
7:19PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Dog dies after airline worker has it placed in overhead bin
A passenger's dog has died on a United Airlines flight from Houston to New York after a flight attendant ordered the animal be put in the plane's overhead bin
7:16PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Roma beats Shakhtar 1-0 to reach CL quarterfinals
Roma overcame a dismal first-half performance and a first-leg deficit, to beat Shakhtar Donetsk 1-0 and reach the quarterfinals of the Champions League on the away goals rule
7:04PM ( 27 minutes ago )
The Latest: Governors from Alabama, Texas speak after crash
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration records: Company that owns tour bus that crashed in Alabama was involved in four other crashes in the past two years, one involving a fatality
7:01PM ( 31 minutes ago )