Friday February 22nd, 2019 9:29AM

Phoenix legal defeat prompts FAA to address noise concerns

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

PHOENIX (AP) — Nearly 100 people strolled through the high school cafeteria throughout the evening, studying colored graphs of flight takeoffs and jotting down comments for officials.

More than three years after they awoke to find window-rattling flights rerouted in an airborne highway above their homes, residents of Phoenix's downtown historic districts said they finally felt the Federal Aviation Administration was listening.

A court victory by Phoenix and neighborhood groups over the FAA last year has prompted the agency to be more responsive to residents as it continues to beat back noise complaints around the United States over the air traffic modernization plan known as "NextGen."

While challenges by residents of Washington's Georgetown neighborhood and other jurisdictions are still being heard in court, people in other affected areas such as Santa Cruz, California, have not sued the agency because they believe their complaints are being considered. Phoenix residents said they appreciated the FAA's current approach.

"They are being transparent now," Opal Wagner, a resident of the vintage Willo district and vice president of the Phoenix Historic Neighborhoods Coalition, said at the first of three FAA public workshops held last week. She and others expressed disappointment that a fourth one wasn't scheduled downtown where most noise complaints originated.

"I think that it's good that they are now dialoguing with the public," Wagner said. "Maybe if they had done this in the beginning, there wouldn't have been a lawsuit."

The historic districts and the city sued the agency after the FAA changed Phoenix Sky Harbor's flight routes in September 2014, bringing airplane noise to public parks and the quiet neighborhoods of charming bungalows, ranch houses and Spanish revival homes, some dating to the 1920s and earlier. About 2,500 households were affected. The noise got so bad for some, they sold their homes and moved.

The FAA started revising flight paths and procedures around the United States in 2014 under the NextGen plan, which uses more precise, satellite-based navigation to save time, increase how many planes airports can handle, and reduce fuel burn and emissions. Noise complaints poured in from Orange County, California, to Washington, D.C., as flights took off at lower altitudes, in narrower paths and on more frequent schedules.

The rollout of the procedures in Phoenix initially represented NextGen's "most problematic implementation," said Chris Oswald, vice president of safety and regulatory affairs with Airports Council International-North America, a trade association that represents commercial airports in the U.S. and Canada. He said he was cautiously optimistic about the FAA's more open approach.

In the Phoenix case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on Aug. 29 agreed with the city and historic districts that the FAA was "arbitrary and capricious" in its flight procedure revisions in that area. The court said by leaving people in the dark, the agency made it impossible for the public to express views on the project's potential effects — something the FAA is especially required to do for historic places and parks.

Phoenix residents said they received no forewarning about the flight changes after FAA officials determined they would have no adverse impact and claimed a "categorical exclusion."

Following the court ruling, Phoenix and the FAA on Nov. 30 announced a joint plan aimed at resolving the dispute. Under the plan filed with the appellate court, the FAA agreed to reach out to residents while temporarily resuming the previous departure routes starting April 1.

In a second step, it will develop satellite-based procedures for the original routes, seeking community feedback throughout the process.

"I think we will get a considerable amount of relief with the return of the flights to their previous paths," said Brent Kleinman, president of the Encanto-Palmcroft Historic Preservation Association in central Phoenix.

"But the majority of the work is going to be in the second part of the process," he said, which will decide the final flight paths.

During last week's workshops, Phoenix residents received printed material and mingled with FAA environmental experts and the airspace designers who fashion flight paths.

"This is a format that we've used at other workshops, and it works really well," said Ian Gregor, public affairs manager for the FAA's Pacific Division, who attended all three sessions. "The people who have actually designed these procedures are on hand to answer questions."

Phoenix isn't the only place where people say the FAA didn't explain new routes or give them an opportunity to comment.

In the Washington metro area, Georgetown University and neighborhood groups have said the agency left them out of the loop about changes at Ronald Reagan National Airport. In nearby Maryland, residents objected to aircraft noise from both Reagan National and Baltimore-Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport.

But in Santa Cruz County, residents who initially complained about noise from planes headed to San Francisco said the FAA has been responsive to their worries. A dozen residents chosen by members of Congress in the three affected districts met with FAA representatives weekly throughout much of 2016 to come up with less obtrusive flight approach procedures.

A new approach to the airport that is at least as quiet as it was before NextGen should take effect in August, said Denise Stansfield, founder of the Save our Skies citizen group. Technical problems temporarily increased noise for some residents recently, but once that pathway is permanently adopted, "you're going to see the biggest celebration ever," Stansfield said.


Anita Snow on Twitter: https://twitter.com/asnowreports

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
First lady brings Valentine's Day cheer to kids in hospital
Melania Trump has brought some Valentine's Day cheer to children receiving medical treatment at a private facility on the campus of the National Institutes of Health
5:45PM ( 1 minute ago )
Phoenix legal defeat prompts FAA to address noise concerns
A legal defeat by the Federal Aviation Administration last year has prompted the agency to be more responsive to Phoenix and its neighborhood groups as it continues to beat back noise complaints around the U.S. over an air traffic modernization plan
5:42PM ( 3 minutes ago )
No officials charged in Arizona football players abuse case
An Arizona prosecutor says metro Phoenix high school officials accused of not notifying authorities about the sexual and physical abuse of football players won't be charged with crimes
5:34PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Sheriff confirms shooter was former student, 18
Parents describe scene of chaos as children rush out of Florida high school in frantic minutes after shooting
5:11PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Climber's death on popular Oregon peak underscores dangers
A fatality and an hours-long rescue effort to bring other climbers off Oregon's tallest peak as a storm approached Tuesday underscore the dangers of a mountain that's soared in popularity due to its proximity to Portland
5:08PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Suspect in Chicago police death charged with murder
Chicago Police say a man with a long criminal history that includes a conviction for armed robbery has been charged with first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of a Chicago police commander.
5:06PM ( 40 minutes ago )
AP National News
Soda on children's menus could fizz out in New Hampshire
New Hampshire restaurants would no longer be allowed to offer soda as a beverage choice for children's meals under a bill before a House committee
4:48PM ( 58 minutes ago )
Warren: 'Never used' Native American claim to advance career
Sen. Elizabeth Warren says President Donald Trump is disrespecting Native Americans by referring to her as "Pocahontas."
4:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: South Africa's ANC welcomes Zuma's departure
The Latest: South Africa's ANC welcomes Zuma's departure, urges support for acting president
4:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Zimbabwe opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai dies at 65
Zimbabwe opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai dies at age 65, party spokesman says
4:56PM ( 49 minutes ago )
Stocks climb again as investors shake off inflation worries
U.S. stocks rise for the fourth day in a row Wednesday as banks jump along with interest rates
4:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
Uber's net loss widens to $4.5 billion for tumultuous 2017
Ride-hailing giant Uber's full-year net loss widened to $4.5 billion in 2017 as the company endured a tumultuous year that included multiple scandals and the replacement of its CEO
4:08PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
No officials charged in Arizona football players abuse case
An Arizona prosecutor says metro Phoenix high school officials accused of not notifying authorities about the sexual and physical abuse of football players won't be charged with crimes
5:34PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Golfer not seriously injured in crash that kills his driver
The manager of golf pro Bill Haas says he is withdrawing from the Genesis Open after a rollover crash in Los Angeles on Tuesday that killed the driver of the Ferrari he was riding in and injured another driver
5:33PM ( 13 minutes ago )
The Latest: Sheriff: Official IDs suspect as Nicolas Cruz
A federal official identifies Florida school shooting suspect as Nicolas Cruz; sheriff says he was former student
5:32PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Ohtani begins with Angels to great fanfare, expectations
Shohei Ohtani emerged from the clubhouse and tipped his cap to the swarm of Japanese countrymen capturing his every move, cameras clicking a mile a minute
5:26PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Offshore drilling foes, denied microphone, hold rallies
New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy has message for President Donald Trump: 'You will not drill off our precious shores!'; environmentalists, denied mic at hearings, stage boisterous rallies beforehand
5:16PM ( 30 minutes ago )