Friday October 19th, 2018 12:48AM

Notre Dame president rips NCAA's denial of Notre Dame appeal

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Notre Dame's president ripped the NCAA's decision to deny the school's appeal to restore 21 vacated football victories from an academic misconduct violation, saying the association "perverted" the notion that universities determine how they police academics.

The NCAA denied Notre Dame's appeal Tuesday, wiping off the books all 12 wins from the Fighting Irish's 2012 national championship game run under coach Brian Kelly.

In a letter to Notre Dame alumni , University President Fr. John Jenkins says the penalty was unprecedented considering who was involved in the misconduct, and the school was being punished for rigorously enforcing its honor code. He called the ruling unfair, referencing the recent North Carolina case in which the NCAA did not punish the school after an investigation of athletes taking irregular courses.

The appeals committee was not swayed and upheld the penalty passed down in November 2016 by the committee on infractions.

Notre Dame agreed to accept certain NCAA findings and acknowledged cheating involving several football players and a student athletic trainer, but appealed only the penalty that vacated victories.

The NCAA also fined the school $5,000 and placed it on one years' probation after finding academic misconduct orchestrated by the trainer.

The NCAA said the trainer was employed by the athletic department from the fall of 2009 through the spring of 2013 and "partially or wholly completed numerous academic assignments for football student-athletes in numerous courses" from 2011 into 2013.

It said she did substantial coursework for two players and gave impermissible help to six others in 18 courses over two academic years.

In all, the NCAA said, three athletes ended up playing while ineligible, one during the 2012 season, which ended with a lopsided loss to Alabama in the BCS championship game, and the other two the following season, when the Irish went 9-4.

In his letter, Jenkins said the players were retroactively declared ineligible after Notre Dame investigated the misconduct in 2014 and recalculated the students' grades.

Jenkins said had Notre Dame merely expelled the students instead of recalculating grades, had a statute of limitations for past offenses or chose not to punish the students, an NCAA penalty would not have been imposed.

"The NCAA has not chosen to ignore academic autonomy; it has instead perverted it by divorcing it from its logical and necessary connection to the underlying educational purpose," Jenkins wrote.

The vacation of victories was a discretionary penalty. Notre Dame objected to the penalty, noting all previous NCAA academic misconduct cases that resulted in victories being vacated involved an administrator, coach, or person who served in an academic role.

"This is more disturbing given that, in 2016, the member institutions of the NCAA amended the academic misconduct rules to make clear that students who serve in roles identical to the student in our case would not be considered institutional representatives," Jenkins wrote.

The appeals committee said in its report that the committee on infractions did not abuse its discretion when it determined the student trainer was an institutional employee.

"When reviewing infractions cases, the Committee on Infractions uses the bylaws and interpretations contemporaneous to the conduct being reviewed," the appeals committee wrote. "Therefore, under the bylaws in place at the time of the violations, a student trainer would be considered an institutional employee."

In its report, The appeals committee confirmed that at the time of the violations, the athletic training student was considered a university employee under NCAA rules.

Jenkins didn't name the North Carolina case but referred to a "recent high profile academic misconduct case in which the NCAA Committee on Infractions chair explained that even though certain classes 'more likely than not' were used to keep athletes eligible with fraudulent credits, the legitimacy of those classes was beyond the jurisdiction of the NCAA's enforcement process precisely because that question must be left to the determination of the university in the exercise of its academic autonomy.

"The notion that a university's exercise of academic autonomy can under NCAA rules lead to exoneration — or to a severe penalty — without regard to the way it which it is used defies logic and any notion of fundamental fairness," Jenkins said.


For more AP college football coverage: and

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, College Sports, AP Sports - College Football
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Premier League bubble bursts as UK TV rights sold for $6B
The Premier League's inflationary bubble burst when the $6 billion sale of British television rights saw a slump in revenue from broadcasters
3:31PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Notre Dame president rips NCAA's denial of Notre Dame appeal
The NCAA has denied Notre Dame's appeal of the committee on infraction's decision to vacate 21 victories, including all 12 from the school's 2012 national championship game run, because of academic misconduct
3:21PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Winners and losers under Medicare drug plan in Trump budget
President Donald Trump's plan to bring down drug costs would create winners and losers
3:19PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Yu Darvish, Cubs finalize $126 million, 6-year contract
Yu Darvish and the Chicago Cubs have finalized their $126 million, six-year contract, by far the largest deal in a slow-moving free agent market
2:42PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Jeter: Marlins 'in a good spot' as spring training begins
Derek Jeter is heading to his first spring training since his final season with the New York Yankees in 2014.
2:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
Giant schnauzer aims for giant prize at Westminster dog show
Big steps for giant schnauzer could lead to dogdom's mighty prize at Westminster
1:40PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
10 Things to Know for Today
Among 10 Things to Know: Fiscal conservatives lash out at Republican spending binge; Some win, some lose under Medicare drug plan in Trump budget; Israeli army court closes doors on Palestinian teen's trial
6:28AM ( 9 hours ago )
10 Things to Know for Tuesday
Among 10 Things to Know: Trump's budget balloons deficits; wind, ice and cold are making Olympics too wintry; popular crooner Vic Damone dies at 89.
8:11PM ( 19 hours ago )
Bar brawl? McConnell, Schumer at odds over the best bourbon
Add bourbon to the list of things Sens. Mitch McConnell and Chuck Schumer can't agree on
2:19PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Football
TCU going for 5th College World Series appearance in a row
TCU looks to become 1st program to make five straight College World Series appearances since NCAA went to current tournament format in 1999
3:23AM ( 12 hours ago )
Smith, Thompson headline Women's hoops Hall of Fame class
Katie Smith, Tina Thompson and Chamique Holdsclaw headline the Women's Basketball Hall of Fame class for 2018
10:03PM ( 17 hours ago )
Kennedy out as Mississippi basketball coach after season
Coach Andy Kennedy and Mississippi are parting ways after 12 seasons
5:45PM ( 21 hours ago )
College Sports
New Mexico football coach appealing 30-day suspension
New Mexico football coach Bob Davie says he will appeal a 30-day suspension in connection with following multiple investigations involving misconduct
3:35PM ( 4 days ago )
New Mexico football coach faces heat over slur allegations
The University of New Mexico head football coach Bob Davie continues to face questions after a report says witnesses reported him using racial slurs
1:46PM ( 4 days ago )
New Mexico suspends football coach amid misconduct probe
The University of New Mexico has announced it is suspending head football coach Bob Davie for 30 days in connection alleged physical abuse of football players
7:45PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Premier League bubble bursts as UK TV rights sold for $6B
The Premier League's inflationary bubble burst when the $6 billion sale of British television rights saw a slump in revenue from broadcasters
3:31PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Winners and losers under Medicare drug plan in Trump budget
President Donald Trump's plan to bring down drug costs would create winners and losers
3:19PM ( 16 minutes ago )
The Latest: Mulvaney backtracks comment on Trump budget
White House budget director Mick Mulvaney says he would vote for President Donald Trump's budget after all.
3:07PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Federal vote-protection efforts lag ahead of first primaries
Federal efforts to secure elections against Russian meddling have lagged ahead of the first 2018 primaries
3:04PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Uzbek Stockholm truck attacker had pledged allegiance to IS
Prosecutors in Sweden say an Uzbek man who carried out a deadly attack on Stockholm last year swore allegiance to the Islamic State group in a video and wrote that he wanted "to scare the infidels and leave my life."
3:01PM ( 34 minutes ago )