Sunday December 16th, 2018 1:00AM

Gates turns attention toward poverty, growing inequity in US

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

KIRKLAND, Wash. (AP) — Bill and Melinda Gates, as the world's top philanthropists, are rethinking their work in America as they confront what they consider their unsatisfactory track record on schools, the country's growing inequity and a president they disagree with more than any other.

In an interview with The Associated Press, the couple said they're concerned about President Donald Trump's "America first" worldview. They've made known their differences with the president and his party on issues including foreign aid, taxes and protections for immigrant youth in the country illegally.

And they said they're now digging into the layers of U.S. poverty that they haven't been deeply involved with at the national level, including employment, race, housing, mental health, incarceration and substance abuse.

"We are not seeing the mobility out of poverty in the same way in the United States as it used to exist," Melinda Gates said.

The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is studying these topics with no plans yet for any particular initiatives, though it has done related work at home in Washington state on a much smaller scale. Last year, it funded a grant for the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities to look into state and federal policies that can reduce poverty.

Once the world's richest man, Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates has marked a decade since transitioning away from the tech giant to focus on philanthropy. He said he's had two meetings with Trump, where they discussed innovation in education, energy and health — including vaccines, which Trump has voiced skepticism about.

"I got, both times, to talk about the miracle of vaccines and how those are good things," Bill Gates said.

Melinda Gates, who left her job at Microsoft to raise their three children before turning to the foundation full-time, has lately embraced her role as a public figure more boldly. She called out Trump's behavior, saying the president has a responsibility to be a good role model when he speaks and tweets, and that his verbal attacks don't belong in the public discourse.

"You just have to go look in Twitter to see the disparaging comments over and over and over again about women and minorities," Melinda Gates said. "That's just not what I believe. It's not the world that I see."

Trump has said he's a counterpuncher who goes after people when they go after him, only 10 times harder.

Taking a more reflective review of their work than in years past, the couple in their annual letter published Tuesday also answered 10 questions critics often ask them. They acknowledge it's unfair that they have so much wealth and influence but reject the notion that they're imposing their values on other cultures.

"Behind the scenes, these are the tough, tough questions that people are asking us, and yeah, we have to wrestle with them ourselves," Melinda Gates said in the Feb. 1 interview.

Since 2000, the Seattle-based private foundation has amassed an endowment worth over $40 billion, which includes a large portion of billionaire investor Warren Buffett's fortune. The Gates Foundation has given money to various programs in more than 100 countries, as well as in all 50 states and Washington, D.C.

Their approach to giving has shifted the philanthropy world as a whole. They've been criticized for prescribing how the money is spent and then expecting tangible proof their investments work.

About 75 percent of the foundation's resources are dedicated to global health and development. Bill Gates said they're proudest of their efforts to help eradicate polio and curb the number of child deaths, calling those global health improvements a miracle.

But he concedes the same level of progress didn't happen in the U.S. with their strategy of chasing equity through education reform. U.S. education initiatives are a distant second funding priority for the foundation, but the $450 million the Gateses spend annually on the issue makes them the top funders of schools reform in America.

They've been major supporters of charter schools and also pushed Common Core education standards, teacher evaluation systems that factored in student test scores and a smaller schools model — highly polarizing education policy reforms that didn't dramatically change student outcomes but made the Gateses deeply unpopular in some communities.

"It's in taking all of those lessons and saying, 'OK, but did they reach the majority of the school districts? Did they scale and change the system for low-income and minority kids writ large, at scale?' And the answer when we looked at it, it was no," Melinda Gates said.

Christopher Lubienski, an education policy expert who studies philanthropy, said he found the couple's honesty refreshing but noted their foundation's overall approach means it will continue to systematically influence education reform.

Lubienski, who said he has not sought nor received money from Gates, also noted that by turning their attention to poverty, the Gateses are tackling the "really big elephant in the room" when it comes to student achievement.

"It's also a much bigger, more expensive and politically stickier area to attack than simply changing the structure of schools," Lubienski said.

The Gateses say they're going in a less prescriptive direction on U.S. education by funding efforts through regional networks of schools, which will lean more heavily on educators at the local level. They also intend to support new curriculum development and charters catering to students with special needs.

The foundation will spend $1.7 billion on education over the next five years, as K-12 will remain their primary focus in the U.S. But as they take stock of the country — from the West Coast's growing income gap to the generations of racial inequities in the American South — the Gateses say they're looking at myriad problems that hinder children in the classroom.

"Poverty is like education, where there's not enough philanthropic resources to take on responsibility, but if you can show how to have a lot more impact, then the policies will benefit from that," Bill Gates said.


Follow Sally Ho at

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Small Business, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Powerball winner who demands anonymity to get money
A New Hampshire woman who won a $559.7 million Powerball jackpot is likely to get the money in the coming days as her demand to remain anonymous make their way through the courts
1:23PM ( 52 seconds ago )
Gates turns attention toward poverty, growing inequity in US
The world's foremost philanthropists, Bill and Melinda Gates, say they're turning some of their attention to American poverty issues
1:13PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Westminster show dogs have some unusual food faves
Westminster Kennel Club owners and handlers know how to cater to the eclectic tastes of show dogs competing this week.
1:11PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Slain doctor's body may have been in home for months
A scientist is charged with beating her husband, a University of Connecticut doctor, to death, and the body may have been left inside their home for months
12:48PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Russia: Human error, faulty sensor behind deadly plane crash
Investigators say that the crash of a Russian passenger plane that killed all 71 people on board may have been caused by the pilots' failure to activate heating for pressure measurement equipment, resulting in flawed speed data
12:47PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Judge to decide whether Powerball winner can stay anonymous
A judge has taken under advisement the case of a New Hampshire woman who won a $559.7 million Powerball jackpot and wishes to stay anonymous
12:32PM ( 52 minutes ago )
AP National News
Experts: What states can do to secure their elections
Experts: What states can do to secure their elections
11:51AM ( 1 hour ago )
Federal vote-protection efforts lag ahead of first primaries
Federal efforts to secure elections against Russian meddling have lagged ahead of the first 2018 primaries
11:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
Egypt orders ban on SNL Arabia over 'sexual expressions'
Egypt orders ban on the Arabic version of US satirical show Saturday Night Live for allegedly using "sexual expressions."
11:31AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Grand Canyon copter crashed on tribal land with fewer rules
A helicopter crash that killed three British tourists and left four others critically injured happened on tribal land in the Grand Canyon where air tours are not as highly regulated as those inside the national park
9:42PM ( 15 hours ago )
Seattle eyes taller, denser in affordable housing proposal
Seattle officials want to add more affordable housing, and they're looking to taller, denser buildings.
5:32PM ( 19 hours ago )
Critics worry housing plan will wreck Seattle's character
A proposal aimed at easing Seattle's housing crunch is stirring up tensions over how dense the city's neighborhoods should be.
1:24PM ( 23 hours ago )
AP Business - Small Business
NIMBY vs. YIMBY: Housing battle brews in booming Seattle
Seattle's booming tech industry has brought a massive influx of new residents with big wallets to the city, but a housing shortage has meant skyrocketing rents and home prices that have strained the finances of middle- and working-class families
1:41AM ( 1 day ago )
At last minute, Russia scrubs cargo launch to space station
Russia has scrubbed the planned launch of an unmanned cargo spacecraft that was to have delivered tons of supplies to the International Space Station
9:14AM ( 2 days ago )
Drones grounded at opening ceremony _ but not on tape delay
An army of high-flying drones expected to light up the sky at the opening ceremony of the Olympics was grounded
6:16PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Technology News
Westminster show dogs have some unusual food faves
Westminster Kennel Club owners and handlers know how to cater to the eclectic tastes of show dogs competing this week.
1:11PM ( 12 minutes ago )
South Africa's ruling party finally turns against Zuma
South Africa's ruling party orders President Jacob Zuma to resign, disowning the leader after sticking with him through years of scandals
1:08PM ( 15 minutes ago )
'LOVE' returns: Philadelphia park gets its sculpture back
Robert Indiana's "LOVE" sculpture is returning to its home Tuesday in Philadelphia after undergoing a year of repairs
12:56PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Slain doctor's body may have been in home for months
A scientist is charged with beating her husband, a University of Connecticut doctor, to death, and the body may have been left inside their home for months
12:48PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Kitchen was closed, but Robert Plant got a whole lotta love
Robert Plant and his backing band get a whole lotta love in North Carolina, despite the closed kitchen at a top eatery
12:47PM ( 36 minutes ago )