cloudy
Saturday February 24th, 2018 5:32AM

Oroville crisis drives harder look at aging US dams

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — One year after the worst structural failures at a major U.S. dam in a generation, federal regulators who oversee California's half-century-old, towering Oroville Dam say they are looking hard at how they overlooked its built-in weaknesses for decades.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is telling owners of the 1,700 other hydroelectric dams it regulates nationally that it expects them to look equally hard at their own organizations and aging dams, in the wake of the sudden collapse of much of first one, then both spillways last February at the 770-foot-tall (235-meter-tall) Oroville Dam, the nation's tallest.

Given that the average dam in the United States is in its 50s, like Oroville, it's critical that owners and monitors of America's 90,580 dams act on a main lesson of the near-disaster, dam officials nationally say: Is the way a dam was built in the Cold War-era or earlier good enough to protect lives in 2018 and beyond?

The crisis in California, a state that had been recognized nationally for its dam-safety program, "makes very clear that just because a project has operated successfully for a long period of time, does not guarantee that it will continue to do so," the federal dam regulators wrote late last month in an unusual, blunt open letter to U.S. dam operators.

"We are focusing on how to improve our program to identify and prevent incidents, regardless of magnitude, that could result from similar dam safety and organizational factors that contributed to the Oroville incident," regulators wrote. "We expect our regulated dam owners to have similar internal discussions."

Last Feb. 12, residents across parts of three counties in the Sierra Nevada foothills fled their homes. Authorities warned the chain reaction of structural failures at the Oroville Dam complex could send a wall of water gushing through their nearby Gold Rush-era towns within the hour.

Despite evacuation orders for nearly 200,000 people, however, the feared uncontrolled release of massive amounts of Oroville's reservoir did not happen. California's repair bills for the near-disaster have neared $1 billion. Residents downstream have filed more than $1 billion more in claims.

Last month, two national dam-safety organizations focused the blame on the dam's overseers. California's Department of Water Resources, which owns Oroville; regulators; and consultants had focused on satisfying routine regulatory requirements for the dam — which anchors a water system that supplies more than half of California's people — but never took stock of whether the dam complex was built well enough in the 1960s to stand up over time, their independent probe concluded.

Oroville shows "we got a little complacent with what we were doing" as an industry, "and now need to re-examine and identify some of the more subtle and latent problems," John France, a Colorado-based dams expert who led the probe, says now.

California's Department of Water Resources declined to make an official available to comment for this article, but said in an email it is implementing changes called for by France's team.

The 19,000 residents of Oroville, the town that would have been first in the path of water from the reservoir, watch the year-round repairs at the dam in the hills behind them, uneasy still.

"I'm not sure how much we trust DWR, but that's out of our hands," said Julie Jackson, owner of a downtown Oroville flower store.

"It was pretty devastating," Jackson said of the fear that overrode tens of thousands of people stuck on evacuation-clogged roads as they tried to save families from what authorities said could be imminent disaster.

"All our family members and friends we knew were in the path."

For Lori Spragens, executive director of the national Association of State Dam Safety Officials, the Oroville spillway collapses were the biggest structural failures at a major U.S. dam of her career.

The last comparable one was the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation's Teton Dam in Idaho, which broke apart in 1976, killing 11 people. Teton was less than half the height of Oroville, at 305 feet (93 meters). Other U.S. dam failures since the 1970s involved dams that were just fractions of Oroville's size, but killed multiple people.

Oroville Dam, by contrast, is the height of a 70-story skyscraper. Its size, and the deep, snaking canyon that opened below it took France's breath away when he drove to the foot of the dam after the spillways' collapse.

"I can't report exactly what I said without expletives," the dam-safety expert said of his reaction. "It's an enormous structure. The erosion was massive."

Dam safety officials, regulators and watchdog groups call Oroville a wake-up call. Most say it's being heard.

"Absolutely it's changed things," said Kevin Colburn, a national director of American Whitewater, which works on policy issues affecting rivers nationally.

"If I lived downstream of a dam, I'd be glad Oroville happened," Colburn said.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which oversees Oroville and the nation's other hydroelectric dams, said it's too early to detail whether the post-Oroville reviews it ordered nationally have led to changes at other dams, and declined to make a dam regulator available for interview.

For some dam owners, however, Oroville's immense size might make them think lessons there don't apply to ordinary dams, said Jonathan Garton, president of the Association of State Dam Safety Officials and a dam regulator for Iowa.

So might the fact that no one died, Garton said.

"Definitely from a dam-safety community perspective, it was a wake-up call," he said. But "in terms of owners saying, 'Gosh, that scares me,' I haven't seen that."

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
'Fifty Shades Freed' commands $38.8 million to top charts
"Fifty Shades Freed" has topped the North American box office in its first weekend in theaters
12:04PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Oroville crisis drives harder look at aging US dams
One year after the worst structural failures at a major U.S. dam in a generation, federal regulators who oversee California's half-century-old, towering Oroville Dam say they're looking hard at how they overlooked its built-in weaknesses for decades
11:44AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Dogged: Badly wrecked, German shepherd shows at Westminster
A German shepherd that was badly injured in a highway accident a few years ago will be among the nearly 2,900 dogs taking part in the Westminster Kennel Club show that begins Monday in New York
11:09AM ( 1 hour ago )
U.S. News
Mourinho hoodoo continues as United stunned by Newcastle 1-0
Jose Mourinho tripped up again at St. James' Park as his Manchester United team was beaten 1-0 by Newcastle on Sunday for a second loss in its last three Premier League games
11:51AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Airliner crashes near Moscow after takeoff; 71 presumed dead
A Russian passenger plane carrying 71 people crashed near Moscow shortly after taking off from one of the city's airports Sunday
11:49AM ( 26 minutes ago )
Red alert: Gerard wins United States' 1st gold of games
Red Gerard won the United States' first gold medal of the games by overcoming a blustery win in the men's slopestyle event in the snowboarding competition on the second day of full competition at the Pyeongchang Olympics
11:24AM ( 52 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
South Africa's Ramaphosa says power transfer to be finalized
South Africa's deputy president consolidates control of the government, promising to conclude a power transition in which he would succeed President Jacob Zuma
11:07AM ( 1 hour ago )
UK official warns Oxfam to hand over all info on sex case
British official warns Oxfam that it may lose government funding if the anti-poverty charity doesn't hand over all the information it has about a sexual misconduct scandal in Haiti.
10:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
As Olympics shift to sports, what on Earth just happened?
Let's review: A very odd political weekend in Pyeongchang comes to an end, and the actual Olympics take center stage _ for now, at least
10:36AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Police: 2 officers killed responding to 911; suspect held
Police in Ohio say two officers have been fatally shot at a home in a Columbus suburb, and a suspect is in custody
11:18PM ( 12 hours ago )
Indiana county records 4 deaths in 48 hours from moving snow
A county near Chicago has recorded four deaths related to moving snow in the 48 hours following a major winter storm.
9:37PM ( 14 hours ago )
Utah billionaire Jon Huntsman remembered as kind, devoted
Billionaire and philanthropist Jon Huntsman Sr. was remembered Saturday inside a University of Utah basketball arena bearing his name as a generous and kind man devoted to his faith, family and community
7:54PM ( 16 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
South African ruling party leaders to meet amid Zuma limbo
Key committee of South Africa's ruling party will hold an emergency meeting on Monday as the nation awaits word on whether President Jacob Zuma will resign soon
6:50AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump explains refusal to declassify Dems' memo
President Donald Trump explains decision not to declassify a Democratic memo, saying it is "very political"
5:35AM ( 6 hours ago )
Trump accuses Democrats of playing politics with memo
President Donald Trump accuses Democrats of playing politics with classified information
5:34AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
India's Modi in UAE to boost ties with Gulf Arab states
India's Modi in second UAE visit seeking stronger economic, cultural ties with big-spending Gulf Arab states
9:33AM ( 2 hours ago )
At last minute, Russia scrubs cargo launch to space station
Russia has scrubbed the planned launch of an unmanned cargo spacecraft that was to have delivered tons of supplies to the International Space Station
9:14AM ( 3 hours ago )
Iran marks anniversary of Islamic Revolution after protests
Iranians mark anniversary of 1979 Islamic Revolution, just weeks after anti-government protests across the country
8:16AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
'Fifty Shades Freed' commands $38.8 million to top charts
"Fifty Shades Freed" has topped the North American box office in its first weekend in theaters
12:04PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Mourinho hoodoo continues as United stunned by Newcastle 1-0
Jose Mourinho tripped up again at St. James' Park as his Manchester United team was beaten 1-0 by Newcastle on Sunday for a second loss in its last three Premier League games
11:51AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Airliner crashes near Moscow after takeoff; 71 presumed dead
A Russian passenger plane carrying 71 people crashed near Moscow shortly after taking off from one of the city's airports Sunday
11:49AM ( 26 minutes ago )
Red alert: Gerard wins United States' 1st gold of games
Red Gerard won the United States' first gold medal of the games by overcoming a blustery win in the men's slopestyle event in the snowboarding competition on the second day of full competition at the Pyeongchang Olympics
11:24AM ( 52 minutes ago )
White House grappling with fallout from aide's resignation
The White House tries to stem the fallout from how it handled a senior aide's resignation after allegations of spousal abuse
11:23AM ( 52 minutes ago )