rain
Saturday December 15th, 2018 12:29AM

Judge leans toward asserting right to rule on border wall

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN DIEGO (AP) — A judge who was berated by Donald Trump during the presidential campaign said Friday he was inclined to conclude he can decide a lawsuit that challenges the president's proposed border wall with Mexico but gave no indication how he'll rule.

U.S. District Judge Gonzalo Curiel said during 2½ hours of arguments that he was leaning toward deciding he has jurisdiction in a lawsuit that alleges the Trump administration overreached in waiving dozens of laws that require environmental and other reviews. The administration argues he doesn't have jurisdiction.

Curiel asked the administration and wall opponents for additional briefings by the end of Tuesday. He said he planned to decide within days after that whether to dismiss the lawsuit by the state of California and environmental advocates or let it proceed, but cautioned that "there's a lot of work here."

At the start of his first hearing on the case, Curiel acknowledged "keen interest" and told everyone in his wood-paneled courtroom to behave respectfully. Then both sides delved into detailed discussion on a 2005 law that gave the Homeland Security secretary broad authority to waive environmental reviews to build border barriers.

Trump repeatedly attacked Curiel as the judge presided over 2016 lawsuits alleging fraud at the now-closed Trump University neared trial, suggesting that the Indiana-born judge's Mexican heritage exposed a bias because of Trump's stands on immigration and border security. Trump settled the case for $25 million shortly after winning the election, without admitting wrongdoing.

Curiel, who was forced out of his home and needed around-the-clock protection when he prosecuted Mexican drug kingpins in the 1990s, was unfazed by Trump's criticism during the campaign, said Gregory Vega, a former U.S. attorney in San Diego and longtime friend.

"He's had a credible threat made on his life. I don't think when he was called names, I don't think that really bothered him," said Vega.

The Center for Biological Diversity was first to sue over the wall. Three other groups — Sierra Club, Defenders of Wildlife and the Animal Legal Defense Fund — later filed a lawsuit. California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, a Democrat, then filed another lawsuit and Curiel consolidated all three cases into one.

The 2005 law granted powers to waive the National Environmental Policy Act, Clean Air Act, Endangered Species Act and other laws that require time-consuming reviews and are subject to prolonged legal challenges.

The Trump administration has issued three waivers since August, two to build barriers in parts of California and one in part of New Mexico. President George W. Bush's administration issued the previous five waivers, clearing the way for the government to extend barriers to its current 654 miles (1,046 kilometers) of the 2,054-mile (3,286-kilometer) border with Mexico.

Legal challenges to border barriers have failed over the years amid national security concerns. The Congressional Research Service said in a report last year for members of Congress that it saw no legal impediments to construction if deemed appropriate for controlling the border.

On Friday, Michael Cayaban, California deputy attorney general, characterized the administration's position as "waiving any law, anywhere along the border without limitation" and called it "a case of extreme overreach by the executive branch."

The judge showed little interest in California's argument that the 2005 law limits waivers to areas with high numbers of illegal crossings and that California doesn't qualify. Curiel said such discussions were "going into the weeds" and could lead to litigation that Congress sought to avoid in 2005.

Curiel questioned both sides extensively on requirement for the Homeland Security secretary to consult federal agencies, state and local governments, Indian tribes, and property owners "to minimize the impact on the environment, culture, commerce, and quality of life." He asked both sides for additional briefings on the topic.

Galen Thorp, an attorney for the administration, said consultations are made to limit impacts but that allowing them to delay construction could lead to protracted litigation that Congress didn't want.

Trump has insisted on $25 billion for border security measures as part of an immigration deal that would include a path to citizenship for 1.8 million people. A proposal by Customs and Border Protection calls for spending $18 billion over 10 years to extend barriers to nearly half the 2,054-mile (3,286-kilometer) border.

One of the administration's environmental waivers is for San Diego, where private contractors recently built eight imposing prototypes to guide designs for future construction. Another is in the town of Calexico, where construction is scheduled to begin Feb. 15.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Judge leans toward asserting right to rule on border wall
A judge who was berated by Donald Trump during the presidential campaign says he's inclined to conclude he can decide a lawsuit that challenges the president's proposed border wall but gave no gave no indication how he'll rule
10:07PM ( 3 minutes ago )
The Latest: Shiffrin a definite for slalom and giant slalom
American Mikaela Shiffrin comes to the Pyeongchang Games with a chance to become the first skier to win the gold in slalom twice in a row at the Olympics
9:57PM ( 13 minutes ago )
S. Korean president hosts lunch for Kim Jong Un's sister
South Korean President Moon Jae-in is hosting lunch for senior North Korean officials including leader Kim Jong Un's sister in the most significant diplomatic encounter between the rivals in years
9:47PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: US announces lineup for team skating events
The U.S. will send out siblings Maia and Alex Shibutani in the ice dance and Bradie Tennell in the women's short program when the team competition resumes Sunday at Gangneung Ice Arena
9:13PM ( 56 minutes ago )
Man in US illegally guilty of killing 2 California deputies
Jurors have convicted a man in the United States illegally of killing two Northern California deputies in a case that helped fuel the national immigration debate
9:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
US stocks swing back to gains, Dow up 330 on turbulent day
Wall Street caps day of wild swings with a rally; Dow climbs 330 points
9:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Trump 'weighing his options' on releasing Democratic memo
The White House says President Donald Trump is "weighing his options" as he decides whether to release a classified memo drafted by Democrats that counters GOP allegations that the FBI abused U.S. government surveillance powers in its Russia probe
8:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
All sides claim budget win; immigration fight looks tougher
Chalk up one extensive budget agreement with wins for President Donald Trump, congressional Republicans and Democrats alike
7:30PM ( 2 hours ago )
Pennsylvania Republicans: We've revised gerrymandered map
Republican leaders of the Pennsylvania Legislature say they've agreed to a proposed new map of congressional districts to replace one thrown out last month
7:07PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Utah taxpayers paid for hotel linked to prostitute report
Utah legislative leaders say they're not sure yet if the House will ask a Republican lawmaker to return taxpayer money for hotel rooms he's accused of using to meet up with a prostitute
4:59PM ( 5 hours ago )
Zuma drama overshadows South Africa's Mandela commemorations
President's drama overshadows South African commemorations of 100 years since Mandela's birth
10:30AM ( 11 hours ago )
Obama-backed committee targeting races in 11 states
A Democratic group backed by former President Barack Obama plans to invest millions of dollars in state-level elections in a dozen states this year, with its heaviest focus on Ohio
6:39AM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Elections
Venezuela sets April 22 for election after talks break down
Venezuelan officials have moved swiftly to call an April 22 presidential election, acting hours after a breakdown in talks between the government and opposition over how to conduct the vote
7:27PM ( 2 days ago )
Dems head to midterms with energized base, unsettled agenda
Democrats are heading into the November elections with an energized party base, an unpopular president and a wave of GOP retirements. But they must figure out how to balance a positive economic agenda while keeping up criticism of President Donald Trump
7:15PM ( 2 days ago )
Venezuela talks break down as presidential vote looms
Negotiations between Venezuela's government and opposition are hanging by a thread after they failed to reach an agreement to hold presidential elections
6:34PM ( 2 days ago )
General Presidential Election News
First hotel in new Trump chain seeks Mississippi tax breaks
A Trump hotel under development in Mississippi has applied for millions of dollars of state tax breaks
7:34PM ( 2 hours ago )
YouTube suspends ads from video star Logan Paul's channels
YouTube says it has temporarily suspended all ads from video star Logan Paul's channels after what it calls a "pattern of behavior" that makes his channel unsuitable for advertisers
7:31PM ( 2 hours ago )
Citing fraud, LL Bean imposes limits on its return policy
L.L. Bean is tightening its generous return policy by imposing a one-year limit on most returns to reduce abuse and fraud
6:48PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
On Trump's desk: Dems' classified memo on Russia probe
President Donald Trump has met with a top Justice Department official to review a classified Democratic memo on the Russia investigation
8:20PM ( 3 days ago )
House votes to overhaul system for reporting harassment
The House has passed legislation that will overhaul the system by which members of Congress and their staffs report sexual harassment on Capitol Hill
4:54PM ( 3 days ago )
On Trump's desk: Democratic memo on Russia probe
President Donald Trump will decide whether the public will be allowed to read a memo written by House Democrats on its Russia probe.
3:16PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
The Latest: Shiffrin a definite for slalom and giant slalom
American Mikaela Shiffrin comes to the Pyeongchang Games with a chance to become the first skier to win the gold in slalom twice in a row at the Olympics
9:57PM ( 13 minutes ago )
S. Korean president hosts lunch for Kim Jong Un's sister
South Korean President Moon Jae-in is hosting lunch for senior North Korean officials including leader Kim Jong Un's sister in the most significant diplomatic encounter between the rivals in years
9:47PM ( 22 minutes ago )
The Latest: Smiling S. Korean leader welcomes N. Koreans
South Korean television is showing a smiling President Moon Jae-in entering a reception room and shaking hands with North Korean delegates, including leader Kim Jong Un's sister.
9:40PM ( 30 minutes ago )
A budget the likes of which the Pentagon has never seen
It's a bigger budget than the Pentagon has ever seen: $700 billion
9:36PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Mideast messes await Rex Tillerson on visit to region
Middle East messes await Secretary of State Rex Tillerson as he embarks on a five-nation tour of the region this weekend.
9:33PM ( 36 minutes ago )