clear
Monday October 22nd, 2018 2:53PM

$300M health care system cost to protect religious rights

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump's new effort to protect the rights of health workers who object to participating in abortions and other procedures will cost the health care system more than $300 million to set up, according to a government estimate.

More than 40 complaints have been filed since Trump's election, alleging violations of conscience and religious rights. An estimated 18 million people work in the nation's health care system.

"This is looking for a problem," said critic Susan Berke Fogel, a lawyer who directs reproductive health work for the nonprofit National Health Law Program.

But enforcement of federal laws that are supposed to protect religious and conscience rights has long been a priority for social conservatives, a steadfast constituency for Trump represented in the White House by Vice President Mike Pence.

"For too long, conscience and religious freedom were treated as second-class rights," Roger Severino, director of the Health and Human Services civil rights office, said in an interview. "They're getting the proper focus they deserve."

A new division of Severino's office will focus on cases where clinicians object to participating in abortion, euthanasia and other procedures because it would violate their conscience or religious beliefs.

Hospitals, nursing homes, state health programs, pharmacies and other service providers would face costs of $311 million in the first year to meet new requirements such as posting employee notices, drafting policies and maintaining documentation, according to a government estimate. Costs would average $125 million a year thereafter.

The government's own cost is estimated at $900,000 a year.

Severino said the industry requirements are "standard civil rights stuff" similar to other anti-discrimination laws.

"We're trying to make the burden as light as possible," said Severino, a lawyer who's worked for conservative groups as well as the Justice Department's civil rights office.

But LGBT and women's groups fear the administration will provide cover for clinicians to use religion as a pretext for denying needed care to some patients.

Before Trump was elected, the number of conscience and religion complaints filed with the office averaged about one per year.

The Family Research Council, National Right to Life and other social conservative groups have pushed hard for government-wide enforcement of conscience protections.

Critics question whether it's necessary.

"The reality is that health care delivery facilities generally work these things out," said Fogel, the National Health Law Program lawyer. "This is in many ways a dog whistle to encourage people to complain as opposed to resolving any issues they might have."

Operating room nurse Cathy DeCarlo said things didn't get worked out at her New York City hospital after she objected to participating in a late-term abortion in 2009. DeCarlo said her employer was aware of her religious scruples but nonetheless she was forced to take part.

She said it took several years for the federal Health Department to investigate her complaint. It was ultimately upheld, and her employer had to change its policies. But DeCarlo said the long wait was harrowing. Co-workers who supported her were scared to come forward because nothing seemed to be happening.

"If they can force me to do what I don't believe in, they can force you to do what you don't believe in," DeCarlo said. "My rights were violated and I had no recourse. I am glad the government is putting a spotlight on people's conscience rights so they don't have to choose between their job and their conscience."

The health care industry is reacting cautiously.

Representing Catholic hospitals and nursing homes, the Catholic Health Association released a statement reaffirming its opposition to abortion and euthanasia, while adding "there is no one who is not welcome for the care that we do provide in our hospitals."

The statement urged restraint: "This is a moment where the decency and integrity of the American people should frame the discussion. One more polarized and politicized argument is not going to serve the people of this nation well."

Health economist Michael Cannon of the libertarian Cato Institute says the government has a reasonable interest in protecting the rights of conscience objectors. But that can't result in denying some patients access to medical care at facilities that receive taxpayer dollars.

"You can't have someone claiming that their religion tells them that they should discriminate," said Cannon.

At the Health Department, Severino says his agency will address all complaints. "If somebody identifies as LGBT that doesn't mean that they are somehow put in a box where their complaints are excluded."

He added: "The founders of our nation knew that a nation that respects conscience rights is more diverse and more free, and the HHS Office for Civil Rights is helping make that vision a reality for all Americans."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Rangers give 44-year-old Bartolo Colon a minor league deal
Bartolo Colon has agreed to a minor league contract with the Texas Rangers, and the 44-year-old right-hander will attend big league spring training.
3:18PM ( 15 minutes ago )
$300M health care system cost to protect religious rights
$300M health system cost for Trump administration effort to protect rights of clinicians who object to abortion
3:11PM ( 22 minutes ago )
The Latest: Iraqi spokesman confirms US forces drawing down
The Latest: Iraqi government spokesman confirms drawdown of US forces from Iraq has started following victory over IS
3:07PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
House Republicans working to plan to avert another shutdown
House Republican leaders are working on legislation to avert another government shutdown at midnight on Thursday
2:50PM ( 44 minutes ago )
The Latest: Democrats seek to release their Russia memo
Democrats are seeking to push back against a classified memo released by Republicans last week questioning the methods used by the FBI to apply for a surveillance warrant on a onetime associate of the Trump campaign
2:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Maldives declares emergency, soldiers reportedly storm court
An opposition lawmaker in the Maldives says soldiers have forced their way into the Supreme Court building just hours after the country declared a 15-day state of emergency amid a deepening political crisis in the Indian Ocean nation
2:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
British officials condemn Trump remarks on UK health care
British officials are reacting angrily to President Donald Trump's stark criticism of the U.K. health care system, which he says is breaking down
11:35AM ( 3 hours ago )
New report details misuse of antipsychotics in nursing homes
U.S. nursing homes have significantly reduced the use of powerful antipsychotic drugs among their elderly residents; advocacy groups are pressing for further reductions
10:01AM ( 5 hours ago )
Not just boy and girl; more teens identify as transgender
New research suggests that far more U.S. teens are transgender or gender nonconforming than previously thought
1:18AM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Health
Dow Jones industrials drop 500 as stock market losses deepen
The Dow Jones industrial average dropped 500 points, bringing it back just below 25,000 points, a level it first crossed a month ago.
2:42PM ( 51 minutes ago )
SpaceX 'Starman' at wheel of sports car flying on new rocket
A SpaceX "Starman" is aboard the company's new rocket that's set to make its launch debut Tuesday
1:26PM ( 2 hours ago )
US economy still fundamentally strong despite falling stocks
US economy remains fundamentally strong despite tumbling stock prices
1:20PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Doctor-victim tells Nassar he's a 'disgrace'
A doctor who specializes in gynecology says Larry Nassar molested her at age 11 at a camp for elite gymnasts
11:54AM ( 3 days ago )
Irish health minister defends abortion ban referendum
Ireland's health minister defends abortion referendum, says Irish women are terminating pregnancies despite near-total constitutional ban
11:59AM ( 6 days ago )
California Senate approves medication abortion on campuses
California public universities would be required to offer medication abortion on all 34 campuses under legislation approved in the state Senate
8:59PM ( 6 days ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Stocks slip further as banks sink; Wells Fargo plunges
After their worst week in two years, stocks are slightly lower as banks and energy companies decline
11:41AM ( 3 hours ago )
After a bad week, US stock indexes slip again, led by banks
After their worst week in two years, stocks are falling again in early trading, with sharp losses for banks and energy companies
10:17AM ( 5 hours ago )
Powell sworn in as 16th chairman of Federal Reserve
Jerome Powell sworn in as 16th chairman of Federal Reserve succeeding Janet Yellen
9:33AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Tax overhaul charge hands Merck 4Q loss despite higher sales
Drug sales rise but Merck posts 4th-quarter loss of $872 million due to $2.6 B charge related to the U.S. tax overhaul
10:42AM ( 3 days ago )
Merck reports 4Q loss
Merck posts 4th-quarter loss of $872 million. Its adjusted results topped Wall Street's expectations.
7:20AM ( 3 days ago )
Can 3 business titans cure the US health care system?
Can a legendary investor, the king of on-line retail and a Wall Street financier find a cure for what ails America's health care system?
3:32PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Rangers give 44-year-old Bartolo Colon a minor league deal
Bartolo Colon has agreed to a minor league contract with the Texas Rangers, and the 44-year-old right-hander will attend big league spring training.
3:18PM ( 16 minutes ago )
The Latest: Iraqi spokesman confirms US forces drawing down
The Latest: Iraqi government spokesman confirms drawdown of US forces from Iraq has started following victory over IS
3:07PM ( 27 minutes ago )
$300M health system cost to comply with religious rights
$300M health system cost for Trump administration effort to protect rights of clinicians who object to abortion
3:01PM ( 32 minutes ago )
The Latest: Google spinoff and Uber trade jabs in court
The Latest: Google spinoff Waymo and Uber trade jabs in court
3:01PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Police: Inquiry is last push to resolve Natalie Wood's death
A Los Angeles County homicide detective says he's hoping renewed interest in the 1981 death of actress Natalie Wood in the ocean off Southern California will produce more witnesses to shed light on what happened
2:57PM ( 37 minutes ago )