clear
Saturday November 17th, 2018 1:49AM
4:57PM ( 8 hours ago ) Weather Alert

Court urged to end rule that erased Hernandez's conviction

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BOSTON (AP) — A legal principle that erased former New England Patriots player Aaron Hernandez's murder conviction after he killed himself in prison is outdated, unfair and should not stand, a Massachusetts prosecutor told the state's highest court Thursday.

It doesn't make sense the former New England Patriots tight end is now innocent in the eyes of the law just because he died before his appeal could be heard, Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III said. Quinn is urging the court to reinstate Hernandez's conviction and do away with the legal principle for future cases.

"He goes through a full trial, a jury who speaks for the public convicts him and because he dies, in this case commits suicide, the whole thing is wiped out like it never happened? It's not fair or just and should be changed," Quinn told reporters after the hearing.

Hernandez was found guilty in 2015 of killing semi-professional football player Odin Lloyd. Two years later, the 27-year-old was found dead in his prison cell days after being acquitted of most charges in a separate double-murder case.

A judge threw out Hernandez's conviction last year, citing the legal principle that holds that a defendant convicted at trial who dies before an appeal is heard should no longer be considered guilty in the eyes of the law, thereby returning the case to its pretrial status.

Legal experts say the doctrine, rooted in centuries of English law, requires a conviction not be considered final until an appeal can determine whether mistakes were made that deprived the defendant of a fair trial.

John Thompson, Hernandez's appellate attorney, told the Supreme Judicial Court that there's nothing wrong with the doctrine and that the alternatives floated by Quinn are problematic.

"The jury's decision is not the end-all be-all," Thompson said. "It is an opinion arrived at by 12 people followed by a process that is subject to defect."

The Supreme Judicial Court typically takes several months to issue a decision.

How other states handle cases such as Hernandez's varies widely. Some states, like Massachusetts, toss the convictions, while others dismiss the defendant's appeal and the conviction stands. Other states allow appellate courts to consider a dead defendant's case, prosecutors say.

Quinn wants court to allow a defendant's estate to pursue an appeal, if they wish, otherwise the verdict would stand.

Several justices appeared interested in an approach crafted by the Alabama Supreme Court, which directed the state simply to note in the court record the conviction was neither affirmed nor reversed because the defendant died while the appeal was pending.

But others seemed puzzled over what to do.

"I'm struggling with this because we don't have any good options," said Ralph Gants, chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.

Quinn pointed to other high-profile Massachusetts criminals who had their convictions erased after their death, including John Salvi, who was convicted of killing two abortion clinic workers and wounding five other people during a shooting rampage in Brookline in 1994.

Roman Catholic priest John Geoghan, a key figure in the clergy sex abuse scandal that rocked the Boston archdiocese and spread across the globe, also had his child molestation conviction vacated after he was beaten to death in 2003 in his cell at the same Massachusetts maximum-security prison where Hernandez died.

___

Follow Alanna Durkin Richer on Twitter at http://twitter.com/aedurkinricher .

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Entertainment, APOnline Celebrity News, AP Sports - NFL
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Court urged to end rule that erased Hernandez's conviction
A Massachusetts prosecutor says a legal principle that erased former New England Patriots player Aaron Hernandez's murder conviction after he killed himself in prison is outdated, unfair and should not stand
7:15PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Tens of thousands flee fast-moving Northern California fire
Tens of thousands of people flee fast-moving Northern California wildfire
7:13PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Hundreds demonstrate to protect Russia investigation
A protest in New York City has drawn several hundred people calling for the protection of special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation into potential coordination between Russia and President Donald Trump's campaign
7:08PM ( 18 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Appeals court hears argument that Mueller probe is invalid
Judges on a federal appeals court are weighing whether to invalidate the Russia investigation over arguments made a former aide to longtime Trump confidante Roger Stone that the special counsel's appointment was unconstitutional
6:49PM ( 37 minutes ago )
US immigration officials move to restrict asylum at border
The Trump administration says it will deny asylum to migrants who enter the country illegally
6:45PM ( 41 minutes ago )
After Kansas loss, Kobach could join Trump administration
After failed bid for Kansas governor, Kobach could land next job in Trump administration
6:30PM ( 56 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump triggers massive midterm turnout
Not on the ballot, but Trump triggers massive midterm turnout
6:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Mayfield hopes NFL officials find consistency on helmet hits
Browns rookie quarterback Baker Mayfield wishes NFL officials were more consistent on helmet-to-helmet hits
5:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
APNewsBreak: Govt Olympic funds not usable for abuse probes
APNewsBreak: Government Olympic funds cannot be used for sex-abuse investigations
5:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
AP sources: Notre Dame QB Wimbush to start for ailing Book
AP sources: No. 3 Notre Dame will start QB Brandon Wimbush vs Florida State for injured Book
1:52PM ( 5 hours ago )
Police: Steelers Antonio Brown pulled over for going 100 mph
Police say Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver Antonio Brown was stopped for speeding over 100 mph in his Porsche, just hours before the team's game against the Carolina Panthers
12:58PM ( 6 hours ago )
Acting attorney general has questioned Mueller investigation
New acting attorney general is GOP loyalist from Iowa who called for limiting special counsel
10:59PM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Online Football
Women split vote as GOP gets Tennessee's 1st female senator
Women voters were split on electing Republican Marsha Blackburn as Tennessee's first female U.S. senator
6:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: 2 California universities shaken by shooting
Two Southern California universities have been shaken by the mass shooting at a popular bar's weekly "College Country Night."
5:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Neighbors: Shooter frequently argued with mother
A couple living behind the house of the California mass shooting suspect says he frequently had loud and aggressive arguments with his mother
5:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Entertainment
The Latest: Actress Tamera Mowry-Housley says niece missing
"Sister Sister" actress Tamera Mowry-Housley and her husband are looking for their missing niece following the mass shooting at the Southern California bar
12:28PM ( 6 hours ago )
Joni Mitchell thrills concert audience just by showing up
Joni Mitchell celebrated her 75th birthday by ending an absence from public life, thrilling the crowd by appearing at an all-star concert in her honor featuring James Taylor, Chaka Khan and Emmylou Harris.
11:09AM ( 8 hours ago )
Former WFAN radio host Craig Carton convicted of fraud
The former co-host of a sports radio show with ex-NFL quarterback Boomer Esiason has been convicted of fraud charges
5:02PM ( 1 day ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Jets' Darnold has strained foot, could miss game vs. Bills
New York Jets rookie quarterback Sam Darnold has strained right foot and is not practicing, leaving status for team's game against Buffalo on Sunday in doubt
5:11PM ( 1 day ago )
AP source: Saints sign ex-Cowboys wide receiver Dez Bryant
A person familiar with the situation says free agent Dez Bryant and the Saints have agreed on contract terms that will add the former Dallas Cowboys star to one of the NFL's top offenses in New Orleans
1:59PM ( 1 day ago )
Jets' Darnold has injured foot, could miss game vs. Bills
New York Jets rookie quarterback Sam Darnold has boot on right foot and is not practicing, leaving status for team's game against Buffalo on Sunday in doubt
1:54PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Sports - NFL
Tens of thousands flee fast-moving Northern California fire
Tens of thousands of people flee fast-moving Northern California wildfire
7:13PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Hundreds demonstrate to protect Russia investigation
A protest in New York City has drawn several hundred people calling for the protection of special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation into potential coordination between Russia and President Donald Trump's campaign
7:08PM ( 19 minutes ago )
California bar shooter had been a Marine, lived with his mom
The gunman who shot and killed 12 people at a country music bar in Southern California had joined the Marines and gotten married young
6:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
Justice Ginsburg in hospital after fracturing 3 ribs in fall
The Supreme Court says 85-year-old Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg fractured three ribs in a fall in her office at the court and is in the hospital
6:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Shooting survivor lived through Vegas massacre
Brendan Kelly found himself in a terrifying and familiar scene when bullets started flying at Southern California bar on Wednesday night
6:01PM ( 1 hour ago )