cloudy
Sunday December 9th, 2018 2:29PM

More deaths seen for less invasive cervical cancer surgery

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

New evidence about a cancer operation in women finds a higher death rate for the less invasive version, challenging standard practice and the "less is more" approach to treating cervical cancer.

The unexpected findings are prompting changes at some hospitals that perform radical hysterectomies for early-stage disease.

The more rigorous of the two studies was conducted at more than 30 sites in a dozen countries. It found women who had the less invasive surgery were four times more likely to see their cancer return compared to women who had traditional surgery. Death from cervical cancer occurred in 14 of 319 patients who had minimally invasive surgery and 2 of 312 patients who had open surgery.

Results were published online Wednesday by the New England Journal of Medicine.

Radical hysterectomy is standard treatment for women with early-stage cervical cancer. Rates are declining because of widespread screening. The number of operations has fallen, too, to several thousand a year in the United States. Some women with early-stage cervical cancer are choosing fertility-sparing techniques, treatments not included in the new research.

In both studies, researchers compared two methods for radical hysterectomy, an operation to remove the uterus, cervix and part of the vagina. The surgery costs around $9,000 to $12,000 with the minimally invasive version at the higher end.

Traditional surgery involves a cut in the lower abdomen. In a newer method, a surgeon makes small incisions for a camera and instruments. Patients recover faster, so laparoscopic surgery, which has been around for more than a decade, gained popularity despite a lack of rigorous long-term studies.

It's not clear why it failed to measure up. Experts suspect there may be something about the tools or technique that spreads the cancer cells from the tumor to the abdominal cavity.

Some hospitals went back to traditional hysterectomy after the results were presented at a cancer meeting in March.

"We immediately as a department changed our practice and changed completely to the open approach," said Dr. Pedro Ramirez of the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston.

Ramirez led the more rigorous study, which randomly assigned 631 patients to one of two surgeries. After 4½ years, the rate of those still living without disease was 86 percent with less invasive surgery and 96 percent with traditional surgery.

The experiment was halted early last year when the higher death and cancer recurrence rates showed up. The original plan was to enroll 740 patients in the study, which was funded in part by surgical device maker Medtronic.

For 33-year-old Alicia Ackley, who was diagnosed with cervical cancer in July, the recommendation for traditional surgery came as a surprise, but she followed the advice of her doctor at MD Anderson after hearing about the research. Tests following her September operation show no signs of cancer.

"I'm very glad I went that route," Ackley said. "The open hysterectomy got everything."

The other study looked at 2,461 women with cervical cancer who had radical hysterectomies from 2010 through 2013. It found a 9.1 percent death rate after four years among women who got minimally invasive surgery compared to 5.3 percent for traditional surgery.

"We're rethinking how we approach patients," said study co-author Dr. Jason Wright of New York-Presbyterian Hospital. "There's a lot of surprise around these findings."

The research is "a great blow" to the technique and the findings are "alarming," said Dr. Amanda Fader of Johns Hopkins Kimmel Cancer Center. She said Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore has stopped doing less invasive hysterectomies for cervical cancer until there is more data.

While some patients with small tumors might do as well with minimally invasive surgery, "surgeons should proceed cautiously" and discuss the new information with patients, Fader wrote in an accompanying editorial.

___

AP video journalist Federica Narancio contributed to this report from Washington, D.C.

___

Follow AP Medical Writer Carla K. Johnson on Twitter: @CarlaKJohnson

___

The Associated Press Health & Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
More deaths seen for less invasive cervical cancer surgery
New evidence about a cancer operation in women finds a higher death rate for the less invasive version
5:52PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Official: Mafia hit man suspected in Whitey Bulger's slaying
A former federal investigator says a Mafia hit man is a suspect in the prison slaying of former Boston crime boss James "Whitey" Bulger
5:52PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Parade fetes Red Sox; trophy, manager Cora hit by beer cans
Confetti rained down on Boston Red Sox fans on a crisp autumn day as the World Series-winning team was given a parade.
5:42PM ( 22 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Trump: Pledge for more career opportunities helped 6 million
President Donald Trump says over 160 companies and organizations are pledging to provide new career opportunities for more than 6 million Americans
5:36PM ( 28 minutes ago )
South Sudan opposition leader returns as part of peace deal
For the first time since fleeing South Sudan more than two years ago, opposition leader Riek Machar returned on Wednesday to take part in a nationwide peace celebration
5:31PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Cop accused of telling teen: 'Welcome to white man's world'
A federal indictment alleges that two police officers in Springfield, Massachusetts, used excessive force in arresting two Latino teenagers in 2016
5:29PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Radical plans, risks in foreign policy of Brazil's Bolsonaro
Brazilian President-elect Jair Bolsonaro has proposed a radical overhaul of foreign policy, which experts risk could ultimately isolate and hurt Brazil
4:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump: Number of troops sent to border could reach 15,000
President Donald Trump says the number of military troops deployed to the U.S.-Mexican border could go as high as 15,000
4:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
Weary migrant caravan rests in south Mexico, asks for buses
Thousands of weary Central American migrants in a caravan that has advanced 250 miles (410 kilometers) into Mexico but remains far from the U.S. border hope they won't have to walk anymore, at least for a while
4:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Migrants to rest, hope to win mass transport to Mexico City
Thousands of Central American migrants in a caravan traveling through Mexico plan to rest at least a day or longer in the southern city of Juchitan, hoping to organize mass transport northward after days of hard walking in tropical temperatures
1:51PM ( 4 hours ago )
Pakistan court frees Christian on death row for blasphemy
Pakistan's highest court has acquitted a Christian woman who has been on death row for eight years under the country's divisive blasphemy law
1:49PM ( 4 hours ago )
Turkish prosecutor says Saudi writer strangled, dismembered
A top Turkish prosecutor says Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi was strangled as soon as he entered the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul and his body was dismembered before it was removed
1:43PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Candidates trade barbs in race for sole House seat in Alaska
Candidates trade barbs over effectiveness, handshake in race for sole House seat in Alaska
2:03PM ( 4 hours ago )
Law enforcement faces dilemma in assessing online threats
Law enforcement around the country is facing a dilemma in assessing the risk of people making online rants at a time when social media has become so ubiquitous.
12:58PM ( 5 hours ago )
Duck boats roll in Boston for Red Sox victory parade
The duck boats are rolling as Boston salutes the Red Sox on their fourth World Series title in 15 years
11:23AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
America's gender, racial divides on display in House races
Perhaps nowhere is the choice facing voters more vivid than in the battle for control of the House, where Democrats are fielding more women and minority candidates than ever while Republicans are trying to hold the majority with mostly white men
1:30PM ( 4 hours ago )
Gone to pot: Marijuana shortages plague Canada
Demand has outstripped limited supply in the two weeks since Canada legalized recreational pot, sending some consumers back to the black market
1:02PM ( 5 hours ago )
Lion Air crash search finds debris, belongings on seafloor
An Indonesian official says the search for a crashed Lion Air plane has found aircraft debris and passenger belongings on the seafloor but the object thought to be the fuselage is still eluding it
10:32AM ( 7 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Stable premiums, more options as health law sign-ups begin
'Obamacare' sign-ups begin Thursday amid stabilizing premiums and more choice
11:25AM ( 6 hours ago )
Halloween can be deadly for pedestrians, traffic study says
Trick-or-treaters beware: Halloween can be deadly for pedestrians and children face the greatest danger
11:07AM ( 1 day ago )
Gum, bottled water, pizza bagels want to be called 'healthy'
Chewing gum, bottled water and maybe even pizza bagels are hoping to call themselves "healthy"
10:01AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Health
USC agrees to pay $215M to settle doctor sex abuse claims
The University of Southern California says it will pay $215 million to settle claims of sexual abuse and harassment by a school gynecologist
8:41PM ( 1 week ago )
$215M settlement proposed in alleged USC gynecologist abuse
The University of Southern California has announced an agreement in principle for a $215 million class-action settlement of claims involving alleged sexual harassment and abuse by a gynecologist who treated students for years
2:50PM ( 1 week ago )
Indian temple priests turn back women, defying court ruling
Hindu priests have joined conservative protesters to block women of menstruating age from temple, defying a ruling from India's top court to let them enter
9:17AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Official: Mafia hit man suspected in Whitey Bulger's slaying
A former federal investigator says a Mafia hit man is a suspect in the prison slaying of former Boston crime boss James "Whitey" Bulger
5:52PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Parade fetes Red Sox; trophy, manager Cora hit by beer cans
Confetti rained down on Boston Red Sox fans on a crisp autumn day as the World Series-winning team was given a parade.
5:42PM ( 23 minutes ago )
The Latest: 10 states to dispatch troops to US-Mexico border
Troops from 10 states are set to be dispatched to the border in response to a caravan of Central American migrants that is largely composed of families with children and is weeks from reaching the U.S.-Mexico border
5:26PM ( 40 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump: Up to 15K troops could be sent to border
President Donald Trump says the number of military troops deployed to the U.S.-Mexican border could go as high as 15,000
4:24PM ( 1 hour ago )
Suspect in grocery store shooting indicted on murder charges
The man accused in the shooting deaths of two grocery store patrons in Kentucky has been indicted on two counts of murder
4:06PM ( 2 hours ago )