cloudy
Friday December 14th, 2018 2:44AM

Supreme Court could limit execution of people with dementia

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court appeared willing Tuesday to extend protection from capital punishment to people with dementia who can't recall their crime or understand the circumstances of their execution.

The eight justices heard arguments in the case of Alabama death row inmate Vernon Madison, who killed a police officer in 1985 but has suffered strokes that his lawyers say have left him with severe dementia.

The high court has previously said the constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment means that people who are insane, delusional or psychotic cannot be executed.

A ruling for Madison probably would mean a new hearing in state court over whether his condition renders him ineligible for execution.

Chief Justice John Roberts and the court's four liberal justices seemed most willing to rule for Madison. The other three justices, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas, are unlikely to side with Madison because they voted to allow his execution to proceed when their colleagues blocked it in January, setting up the current case.

In a reflection of the changed dynamics on the court, Roberts' vote would appear to be decisive since a 4-4 split would leave in place a state court ruling against Madison and allow Alabama to try again to execute him. The high court is down one justice, following Anthony Kennedy's retirement in July and a delay in a vote to confirm Brett Kavanaugh so that the FBI can investigate allegations against him of sexual misconduct.

Kennedy had been the conservative justice most likely to vote with the liberals on death penalty cases. The court agreed to hear the appeal while Kennedy was on the bench. He had been a key voice in limiting capital punishment, having voted to bar the execution of people under 18, the intellectually disabled and those who lack a rational understanding of why they are to be put to death.

The chief justice was a dissenter in that last case, in 2007.

Under questioning from Roberts and others, Bryan Stevenson, Madison's lawyer, conceded that memory loss about the crime alone would not be enough to stave off execution. "We recognize that it's too easy for any defendant to say, 'I don't remember,'" Stevenson said.

But Stevenson said Madison has shown a steady decline in his mental faculties following two strokes that also have left him confused about the seasons, month and day. "He can't recite the alphabet past G," he said.

On the other side of the case, Alabama Deputy Attorney General Thomas Govan provided his own concession. "Yes, yes, if someone has vascular dementia or any other mental illness, if it precludes them from having a rational understanding of their punishment," then the inmate can't be executed, Govan said.

But Govan said courts have found Madison does understand why he is to be executed.

Roberts said that the only point of dispute is whether Madison could be executed. That suggests that Roberts is willing to embrace the view the court should treat dementia the same way it treats insanity when considering whether a death sentence may be carried out. In such an outcome, a state court probably would be ordered to apply the high court's ruling to Madison's situation.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Health - Senior Health
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Supreme Court could limit execution of people with dementia
The Supreme Court appears willing to extend protection from capital punishment to people with dementia who can't recall their crime or understand the circumstances of their execution
12:44PM ( 3 minutes ago )
APNewsBreak: EPA says a little radiation may be healthy
Is a little radiation damage actually good for you _ like a little bit of sunlight? The Trump administration is quietly trying to weaken radiation rules
12:36PM ( 11 minutes ago )
McConnell: Democrats are aiming 'mud and muck' at Kavanaugh
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says Democrats are opening "the flood gates of mud and muck" against Brett Kavanaugh
12:30PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Concussions drop in Ivy League football with kickoff change
Concussions plunged in Ivy League football after 'most dangerous play' rule change
9:20PM ( 15 hours ago )
Discoveries that revolutionized cancer care win Nobel Prize
Two researchers from the U.S. and Japan have won the Nobel Prize in medicine for discoveries that have revolutionized cancer care and opened an entirely new way to treat tumors
5:14PM ( 19 hours ago )
Medicare upgrades its website ahead of sign-up season
Medicare modernizes its website ahead of annual open enrollment season
4:37PM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Health
Groups say Medicare discounts threatened in opioids bill
Consumer groups say Medicare discounts for seniors with high prescription bills threatened in opioids bill
4:08PM ( 1 week ago )
Alzheimer's opera 'Sky on Swings' opens in Philadelphia
Alzheimer's disease is explored in Lembit Beecher's 'Sky on Swings,' starring 73-year-old mezzo-soprano Frederica von Stade and commissioned by Opera Philadelphia for the first night of its season-opening O18 festival
3:51PM ( 1 week ago )
State says seniors were abandoned during California wildfire
A state investigation has found that staff at two senior care facilities abandoned residents during an evacuation as wildfires swept through Northern California last October
10:43PM ( 3 weeks ago )
AP Health - Senior Health
APNewsBreak: EPA says a little radiation may be healthy
Is a little radiation damage actually good for you _ like a little bit of sunlight? The Trump administration is quietly trying to weaken radiation rules
12:36PM ( 11 minutes ago )
McConnell: Democrats are aiming 'mud and muck' at Kavanaugh
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says Democrats are opening "the flood gates of mud and muck" against Brett Kavanaugh
12:30PM ( 17 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump heads to Philly to promote trade, economy
President Donald Trump is set to promote his new North American trade agreement and the nation's economic performance in Philadelphia on Tuesday, a day after he heralded the agreement in a Rose Garden press conference
12:28PM ( 19 minutes ago )
World Economic Forum hosts Balkan leaders in Switzerland
The head of the World Economic Forum says its move to bring together leaders from four western Balkan countries and regional powers aims to fight "complacency" in a region facing lingering tensions on a route used by migrants into Europe
12:27PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Melania Trump opens Africa tour with wave and baby in arms
With a wave, a smile and a baby in her arms, Melania Trump on Tuesday opened her first solo international trip as U.S. first lady, aiming to promote child welfare during a five-day tour of Africa
12:26PM ( 21 minutes ago )