clear
Tuesday October 16th, 2018 3:57AM

DOJ's lawsuit may delay California's new net neutrality law

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — A U.S. Department of Justice lawsuit could delay the rollout of California's toughest-in-the country net neutrality law, which is set to take effect Jan. 1.

Advocates hope California's new law to stop internet providers from favoring certain content or websites will push Congress to enact national rules or encourage other states to create their own.

But legal experts say it's possible a judge will put the law on hold while the litigation plays out. If that happens, the delay could be significant because the issue appears destined for the U.S. Supreme Court.

California Gov. Jerry Brown signed a law Sunday that prohibits internet service providers from blocking or slowing data based on content or from favoring websites or video streams from companies that pay extra. It also bans "zero rating," in which internet providers don't count certain content against a monthly data cap — generally video streams produced by the company's own subsidiaries and partners.

The U.S. Department of Justice sued immediately, arguing that the federal government has exclusive authority to regulate the internet.

Stanford University law professor Barbara van Schewick said the law adopts the same nationwide rules the Federal Communications Commission repealed in June. The constitutionality of California's law — and whether other states can adopt their own net neutrality rules — depends heavily on the outcome of a pending case in a Washington, D.C., federal appeals court, van Schewick said.

When the FCC repeated the Obama-era rules last year that prevented companies from exercising more control over what people watch and see on the internet, it also barred states from crafting their own rules like the California law by Democratic Sen. Scott Wiener.

Net neutrality advocates worry that without rules, internet providers could create fast lanes and slow lanes that favor their own sites and apps or make it harder for consumers to see content from competitors.

In response, the California attorney general and 21 other state attorneys general filed a lawsuit in January in the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals seeking to invalidate the FCC rollback.

The appeals court has yet to rule and van Schewick and other legal analysts expect an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, which will likely guide the outcome of the latest lawsuit.

The DOJ and California are wrangling over the legal notion of "pre-emption" and whether the FCC is the sole regulator of net neutrality.

Marc Martin, a former FCC staffer who is now chairman of communications practice at the law firm Perkins Coie, said typical "pre-emption" lawsuits filed by the federal government seek to bar states from ignoring properly enacted federal regulations such as the Voting Rights Act.

But with net neutrality, Martin said the FCC insists it remains the sole regulatory authority despite its deregulatory actions.

Martin said it's a rare pre-emption argument, but it's not novel. A federal agency tasked with setting airline routes and fares was abolished in the 1970s, but states are still not permitted to adopt their own airline rules.

Nonetheless, Martin and other legal analysts say California also has a strong legal argument.

"California could argue net neutrality laws are consumer protection laws," he said.

"It is well established that states have the authority to protect the health, welfare and safety of their own residents, that's why they have their own police forces, national guard, state attorney general and their own consumer protection laws, Martin said. "California could argue net neutrality laws are consumer protection laws."

Regardless of the eventual outcome, Martin also believes a federal judge in California will stop the state's law from taking effect while the lawsuit remains unresolved.

Boston College of Law professor Dan Lyons said federal lawmakers are key to settling the argument between the FCC and California and other states seeking to set up their own rules.

"The only way the issue will go away completely is if Congress passes a statute over net neutrality," Lyons said. "Congress has not made clear what role if any the FCC should have regulating the internet."

Lyons wasn't optimistic that was occurring any time soon.

"The only lasting settlement would be bipartisan congressional legislation," he said. "I don't see it happening in the near future."

___

Anderson contributed from New York. Associated Press writer Jonathan J. Cooper in Sacramento, California, also contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Concussions drop in Ivy League football with kickoff change
Concussions plunged in Ivy League football after 'most dangerous play' rule change
9:20PM ( 4 hours ago )
Company wants some Missouri boat death lawsuits dropped
The company that owns the Ride the Ducks operation in Branson is asking a judge to dismiss some of the lawsuits filed after one of its boats sank on a Missouri lake, killing 17 people
9:16PM ( 4 hours ago )
Mother says it's a miracle her son survived shark attack
The mother of a 13-year-old boy who suffered a large shark bite while lobster fishing in California says it's a miracle her son survived
9:12PM ( 4 hours ago )
U.S. News
The Latest: Australia donates quake aid, discusses more
Australia's government has given financial aid to help victims of Indonesia's earthquake and tsunami and was talking with Indonesian authorities about sending more
1:28AM ( 12 minutes ago )
Nobel Prize in physics to be announced Tuesday
Nobel Prize in physics to be announced Tuesday
1:14AM ( 26 minutes ago )
Dominant debut for No. 1 pick Ayton in Suns' exhibition game
Deandre Ayton might be the NBA's next great man in the middle
1:12AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
White House tells FBI it can talk to anyone about Kavanaugh
White House clears FBI agents to interview anyone they want to as they investigate Kavanaugh
12:29AM ( 1 hour ago )
Democrats question Kavanaugh's credibility, temperament
In a switch in tactics, Democrats raise questions about Kavanaugh's truthfulness when he testified to Congress
12:28AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump predicts havoc if Democrats take over Congress
Trump is predicting national havoc if Democrats gain control of Congress in midterm elections next month
12:28AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Vegas memorial: 'Pain that never really goes away'
A year after Jann Blake and two friends survived the gunfire at a country music festival in Las Vegas, the trio returned to the city Monday to mark the 12 months that have passed since the deadliest mass shooting in the nation's modern history
8:19PM ( 5 hours ago )
DOJ's lawsuit may delay California's new net neutrality law
A U.S. Department of Justice lawsuit could delay the rollout of California's new net neutrality law, which is set to go into effect Jan. 1. Legal experts say it's possible a judge will put the law on hold while the litigation plays out
7:31PM ( 6 hours ago )
Sarah Palin's son, Track, accused of hitting woman in head
Court documents say former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin's oldest son hit a woman in the head after telling her that she couldn't leave his house
7:20PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
In Tennessee, Trump says Democrats trying to sink Kavanaugh
As the fate of his Supreme Court pick hangs in the balance, President Donald Trump has barnstormed for a Republican Senate candidate locked in a tight race in Tennessee and accused Democrats of trying to sink his nominee
10:31PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump declares Blackburn would be 'true fighter'
President Donald Trump is barnstorming for the Republican Senate candidate locked in a tight race in Tennessee
10:01PM ( 3 hours ago )
White House gives FBI freer rein in Kavanaugh investigation
The White House has given the FBI clearance to interview anyone it wants to by the end of the week as part of the investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct against Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh
9:59PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Major GOP group cuts Kansas City-area congressman loose
The National Republican Congressional Committee is dropping its support for a congressman facing a difficult re-election in a suburban Kansas City district won by Hillary Clinton
6:28PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP FACT CHECK: Kobach didn't call schools 'overfunded'
AP FACT CHECK: Kansas gubernatorial candidate Kris Kobach criticizes school spending but didn't directly say schools are 'overfunded'
6:13PM ( 7 hours ago )
Trump hails NAFTA revamp, Trudeau calls it 'win-win-win'
President Donald Trump is celebrating a revised North American trade deal with Canada and Mexico as a return of the United States to a "manufacturing powerhouse."
5:55PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Asian markets fall on US-China trade worries
Asian markets fall on US-China trade worries
12:00AM ( 1 hour ago )
Passenger's body found in Pacific lagoon after plane crash
A passenger's body has been found in the Pacific lagoon where a plane crash-landed last week near an island runway in Micronesia
8:36PM ( 5 hours ago )
GE, seeking path forward as a century-old company, ousts CEO
John Flannery out at General Electric after a year of jolts as century-old company seeks path forward
5:43PM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Business
Facebook says 50M user accounts affected by security breach
Facebook says it recently discovered a security breach affecting nearly 50 million user accounts
12:08AM ( 3 days ago )
Uber agrees to $148M settlement with states over data breach
Uber has agreed to pay $148 million and take steps to tighten data security after the ride-hailing company failed for a year to notify drivers that hackers had stolen their personal information, Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan announced Wednesday
6:18PM ( 5 days ago )
A US privacy law could be good for Google - but bad for you
A US privacy law could be good for Facebook and Google - but bad for you
4:49PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
The most dangerous celebrity online is revealed
Ruby Rose has played some dangerous characters but the actress herself is now officially dangerous, crowned the most dangerous celebrity on the internet by cybersecurity firm McAfee
12:23AM ( 1 hour ago )
The most dangerous celebrity online is revealed for 2018
Ruby Rose has played some dangerous characters but the actress herself is now officially dangerous, crowned the most dangerous celebrity on the internet by cybersecurity firm McAfee
12:20AM ( 1 hour ago )
Supreme Court won't hear case over California beach access
The Supreme Court is refusing to hear an appeal from a California billionaire who doesn't want to open a road on his property so that the public can access a beach
12:19PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Technology News
Concussions drop in Ivy League football with kickoff change
Concussions plunged in Ivy League football after 'most dangerous play' rule change
9:20PM ( 4 hours ago )
Company wants some Missouri boat death lawsuits dropped
The company that owns the Ride the Ducks operation in Branson is asking a judge to dismiss some of the lawsuits filed after one of its boats sank on a Missouri lake, killing 17 people
9:16PM ( 4 hours ago )
Mother says it's a miracle her son survived shark attack
The mother of a 13-year-old boy who suffered a large shark bite while lobster fishing in California says it's a miracle her son survived
9:12PM ( 4 hours ago )
Brown shows governing philosophy in final bill action
Gov. Jerry Brown is known for pushing California to new frontiers of liberal policies then using his veto pen to pump the breaks
9:02PM ( 4 hours ago )
Nevada gubernatorial candidate under fire amid arrest report
Republican gubernatorial candidate Adam Laxalt says he was a "reckless and foolish" teen when he was arrested for assaulting a police officer more than 20 years ago in Virginia
8:47PM ( 4 hours ago )