Sunday March 18th, 2018 1:33PM

New fantasy sports game revives sports betting concerns

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BOSTON (AP) — A new daily fantasy sports game that lets users hone in on a single NFL playoff game has some gambling experts wondering if the contest inches the industry closer to the territory of sports betting that remains illegal in most of the United States.

The "Showdown" variant offered by leading fantasy sports company DraftKings allows users to pick six athletes from two teams playing against each other in a real-life football game, racking up fantasy points based on stats like touchdowns, receptions and yards passing, rushing or receiving. That means users playing "Showdown" this weekend can wager on performances in the Jaguars-Steelers game Sunday without having to wait for the Saints-Vikings game to play out several hours later.

The 2006 federal law that effectively banned online gambling but gave rise to daily fantasy sports requires daily fantasy contests to be based on the performances of athletes in "multiple real-world" sporting events — not just single games. That detail is leading some advocates to question how DraftKings and regulators operate.

"This new game continues the industry trend of trying to get as close as possible to single game betting," said Keith Whyte, executive director of the National Council on Problem Gambling, which is neutral on legalized gambling but pushes for strong regulations and consumer protections.

Whyte said the games "further blur the largely fictional line between daily fantasy sports and sports betting."

DraftKings says the federal law — the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act — only applies if there's an underlying violation of state gambling statutes first, and, so far, no state has objected to the competition.

State laws vary widely, but policymakers in 18 states responded to the industry's popularity by legalizing and regulating daily fantasy sports. Many of those regulations were developed with heavy lobbying from DraftKings and other industry leaders. Daily fantasy companies largely avoid another 10 states where laws are worded in ways that make it more difficult to operate.

"This act is basically irrelevant. Everything defaults to state law now," said Anthony Cabot, the company's outside legal counsel, referring to the federal law that the industry has long cited for justifying its existence. "If it's not in violation of state law, then there's no violation of the federal act. It's a big red herring."

The Boston-based company has also offered contests for other one-off events like NASCAR races and golf tournaments since 2015, without any complaints from regulators, he added.

Daniel Etna, a New York sports lawyer who closely follows the sports gambling industry, said the game appears to comply with most if not all new state laws approved in recent years to legalize and regulate daily fantasy sports.

"Contests like these push the very fine line between fantasy sports contests and general sports wagering," said Jay McDaniel, deputy director of the Mississippi Gaming Commission. "It does, however, fall within our law's definition of a fantasy contest."

In New York, the state Gaming Commission determined in December that the contest was legal because it's based off how individual players perform in the game, and not the "score, point spread or team's performance," said commission spokesman Brad Maione.

One key is that "Showdown" requires users to pick at least one player from each team in a single game. So fans choosing from the Titans-Patriots game on Saturday can't just stack their lineup with Tom Brady, Rob Gronkowski and other New England stars without any Tennessee players.

Jeffrey Ifrah, a Washington-based attorney specializing in online gambling, isn't convinced there's much appetite to enforce the laws, even if there was a conflict. Many of the new fantasy sports laws don't even require states to approve new contests.

"None of these states really thought about this," he said. "They were given these laws to pass and they did it. There wasn't a lot of legislative debate."

The U.S. Supreme Court is also weighing a bid by New Jersey to overturn the sports betting ban in effect in all but four states (Delaware, Montana, Nevada and Oregon). A favorable ruling this year could make handwringing over daily fantasy sports moot.

"We would only look into a particular game if we received a complaint about it, which we have not in this case," said Edward Grewach, general counsel for the Missouri Gaming Commission.

"We do not require review of every new game, so no, we have not looked into it," said Elaine Lidholm, a spokeswoman for Virginia's Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, which oversees the industry.

The single-game format could have implications beyond the early rounds of the NFL playoffs, where eight teams play in each of the first two weeks and four teams play during the conference championships. DraftKing's chief rival, New York-based FanDuel, says it has "exciting plans" for the Super Bowl, the most gambled on single game in the world.

If successful during the NFL playoffs, variants like "Showdown" could extend into the regular season next year and even potentially be offered for single games in other sports.


Follow Philip Marcelo at His work can be found at


More AP NFL: and

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP Business, AP Sports - NFL
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump's own words revive debate over whether he's racist
Trump's own words revive debate over whether he's racist
4:17PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Trump's words rip open the debate over whether he's racist
Trump's words rip open the debate over whether he's racist
4:05PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Trump hands nuke deal 'last chance,' waives Iran sanctions
President Donald Trump has extended waivers on Iran nuclear sanctions
4:03PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Atlanta's Matt Ryan aims for happy homecoming in Philly
Falcons quarterback Matt Ryan has another shot at a happy homecoming when team hosts Eagles in divisional playoff
3:43PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Saudi stadiums open for women in a first to watch soccer
Saudi women allowed for the first time into stadiums to watch soccer in the kingdom
2:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
Patriots chase 7th straight AFC title berth against Titans
Patriots eyeing 7th consecutive conference championship game berth against underdog Titans
2:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
Bears hire ex-Oregon coach Helfrich as offensive coordinator
The Chicago Bears hire former Oregon coach Mark Helfrich as their offensive coordinator
10:08AM ( 6 hours ago )
10 Things to Know for Today
Among 10 Things to Know: Trump dismisses Haiti, African countries with vulgarity; Trump poised for first medical check-up as president; Bill Cosby's next trial will carry the weight of the 'MeToo' movement
6:26AM ( 10 hours ago )
Life around football prepares Gutekunst for Packers GM job
A life around football has prepared Brian Gutekunst for his new job as the general manger of the Green Bay Packers
2:48AM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online Football
Lawmakers to Justice Department: Keep online gambling legal
Federal lawmakers from both parties in New Jersey are asking the U.S. Justice Department to keep internet gambling legal
3:37PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Who'd prefer their country to Trump's US? Norwegians would
President Donald Trump says the U.S. should take in more Norwegians, but that sentiment is unlikely to trigger a rush of immigration from the wealthy Nordic country
3:34PM ( 54 minutes ago )
Spain, UK hold first talks on Brexit's fallout in Gibraltar
Britain and Spain say they held their first informal Brexit-related talks this week in Madrid touching on how future departure accords with the European Union could apply to Gibraltar
3:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Cindy Crawford recreates iconic Super Bowl ad 26 years later
Cindy Crawford is heading back to the Super Bowl: The model has recreated her iconic 1992 Super Bowl ad for Pepsi, now featuring her 18-year-old son
11:27AM ( 1 day ago )
AP source: Panthers interviewing Turner for coordinator spot
A person familiar with the situation says the Carolina Panthers are interviewing Norv Turner for their vacant offensive coordinator position
11:13AM ( 1 day ago )
Amazon looks to build on 1st season of NFL streaming
Amazon had a mostly successful debut into live streaming of major sports events with increased audience and an improved viewing experience in its first season showing NFL games
10:01AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Sports - NFL
Trump's own words revive debate over whether he's racist
Trump's own words revive debate over whether he's racist
4:17PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Trump's words rip open the debate over whether he's racist
Trump's words rip open the debate over whether he's racist
4:05PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Trump hands nuke deal 'last chance,' waives Iran sanctions
President Donald Trump has extended waivers on Iran nuclear sanctions
4:03PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Kentucky is first to get OK for Medicaid work requirement
Kentucky has become the first state to win approval from the Trump administration requiring many of its Medicaid recipients to work to receive coverage
4:03PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Mormon president remembered for devotion to poor, needy
Mormon leaders say deceased church President Thomas S. Monson will be remembered for helping the church grow over more than a half-century and for his devotion to the poor and needy
4:02PM ( 25 minutes ago )