clear
Wednesday October 17th, 2018 7:42PM

Plot twist: Opera 'Carmen' altered in anti-violence protest

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

FLORENCE, Italy (AP) — Carmen, the opera heroine, gets to live instead of being slain — thanks to a bold twist to the finale of the Georges Bizet work by some who believe it's time to say enough to violence against women.

The production of "Carmen" this month at the Maggio Musicale Fiorentino theater in Florence is the talk of the town, and seats are sold out through the last performance on Jan. 18.

In the classic opera, first performed in Paris in 1875, the feisty gypsy Carmen is murdered by Don Jose in a fit of jealousy. But those in the cast thought the time was ripe for a new finale given Italy's recent, burgeoning movement to combat male violence against female partners or relatives. And so this production's ending has the heroine shooting to death Don Jose.

"It's a way to say to all, men and women, 'enough of the violence,'" soprano Veronica Simeoni told The Associated Press before Wednesday's performance. "In this case, there's a precise message against violence targeting women, a plague that has concerned all of us always, and in this moment is before the eyes of everybody."

The reaction from opera-goers and on social media was mixed. Luca Paoletti, who was in the audience, was lukewarm about the ending.

"I do not consider it a great idea, but it can be useful for talking about the issue of violence on women. It takes the risk to open the door to interpretation that can twist the real spirit of the opera, but we can accept it as a provocation," he said.

Opera reviewer Alberto Matteoli of La Stampa thought the production fell short of the revolution that it hoped to provoke.

"It is legitimate to do everything on the stage, but the politically correct does not have retroactive value," Matteoli wrote.

News of the scene change sparked a flurry of protests on Twitter, with some tweeting with the hashtags #FakeEndings and #CarmenNonMuore (CarmenDoesntDie).

Simeoni, the soprano, said the reactions were understandable, given the often traditional approach to opera.

"The opera buff wants to go to the opera and see the scene exactly as it was, as seen for so many years at home or on their own video cassettes or DVDS and or maybe they have seen it so many years ago, and makes a fuss," Simeoni said.

The theater's superintendent, Cristiano Chiarot, told the Italian news agency ANSA earlier this week that the production is sold out. He said the production as it is now will stay in the theater's repertory for the next two or three years, and will be back on the program in fall 2018.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Entertainment, AP Online Recordings News
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Tattoos lead Thai police to arrest Japanese gang member
Thai police have arrested a 72-year-old Japanese fugitive who was recognized when his full-body tattoos were circulated online.
5:39AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Another GOP governor seeks exclusion from drilling proposal
Another Republican governor is asking the Trump administration to exclude his state from a plan to open more U.S. coastal waters to offshore oil drilling
5:39AM ( 16 minutes ago )
EU backs under-fire Iran nuclear pact at Brussels talks
EU foreign ministers say that a key agreement curbing Iran's nuclear ambitions must be preserved as U.S. President Donald Trump weighs whether to pull out of the pact
5:07AM ( 48 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
N Korea: Popularity of 'Fire and Fury' foretells Trump's end
North Korea has found good material to attack U.S. President Donald Trump: Michael Wolff's bombshell new book, "Fire and Fury"
3:37AM ( 2 hours ago )
Thomas returns at Sony Open and scene of scoring records
On The Tee: Justin Thomas defends his record win at Sony Open while Ernie Els starts 30th year in South Africa
2:46AM ( 3 hours ago )
Amazon looks to build on 1st season of NFL streaming
Amazon had a mostly successful debut into live streaming of major sports events with increased audience and an improved viewing experience in its first season showing NFL games
2:23AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Tattoos lead Thai police to arrest Japanese gang member
Thai police have arrested a 72-year-old Japanese fugitive who was recognized when his full-body tattoos were circulated online.
5:39AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Another GOP governor seeks exclusion from drilling proposal
Another Republican governor is asking the Trump administration to exclude his state from a plan to open more U.S. coastal waters to offshore oil drilling
5:39AM ( 16 minutes ago )
EU backs under-fire Iran nuclear pact at Brussels talks
EU foreign ministers say that a key agreement curbing Iran's nuclear ambitions must be preserved as U.S. President Donald Trump weighs whether to pull out of the pact
5:07AM ( 48 minutes ago )
Global shares steady after Wall Street rally fizzles
Global stock markets steady after Wall Street posts first losses of 2018
5:01AM ( 54 minutes ago )
German economy grew in 2017 at fastest pace in 6 years
Official data show that the German economy, Europe's biggest, accelerated last year to grow by 2.2 percent
4:51AM ( 1 hour ago )