Friday October 19th, 2018 9:55AM

China's modern Silk Road hits political, financial hurdles

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BEIJING (AP) — China's plan for a modern Silk Road of railways, ports and other facilities linking Asia with Europe hit a $14 billion pothole in Pakistan.

Pakistan's relations with Beijing are so close that officials call China their "Iron Brother." Despite that, plans for the Diamer-Bhasha Dam were thrown into turmoil in November when the chairman of Pakistan's water authority said Beijing wanted an ownership stake in the hydropower project. He rejected that as against Pakistani interests.

China issued a denial but the official withdrew the dam from among dozens of projects being jointly developed by the two countries.

From Pakistan to Tanzania to Hungary, projects under President Xi Jinping's signature "Belt and Road Initiative" are being canceled, renegotiated or delayed due to disputes about costs or complaints host countries get too little out of projects built by Chinese companies and financed by loans from Beijing that must be repaid.

In some places, Beijing is suffering a political backlash due to fears of domination by Asia's biggest economy.

"Pakistan is one of the countries that is in China's hip pocket, and for Pakistan to stand up and say, 'I'm not going to do this with you,' shows it's not as 'win-win' as China says it is," said Robert Koepp, an analyst in Hong Kong for the Economist Corporate Network, a research firm.

"Belt and Road," announced by Xi in 2013, is a loosely defined umbrella for Chinese-built or -financed projects across 65 countries from the South Pacific through Asia to Africa and Europe. They range from oil drilling in Siberia to construction of ports in Southeast Asia, railways in Eastern Europe and power plants in the Middle East.

Other governments welcomed the initiative in a region the Asian Development Bank says needs more than $26 trillion of infrastructure investment by 2030 to keep economies growing. Nations including Japan have given or lent billions of dollars for development, but China's venture is bigger and the only source of money for many projects.

Governments from Washington to Moscow to New Delhi are uneasy Beijing is trying to use its "Belt and Road" to develop a China-centered political structure that will erode their influence.

China's significance to Pakistan as a source of financing increased following U.S. President Donald Trump's Jan. 5 decision to suspend security assistance to Islamabad in a dispute over whether it was doing enough to stop Afghan militants.

"Belt and Road" is a business venture, not aid. A Cabinet official, Ou Xiaoli, told The Associated Press in April that lending will be on commercial terms. Beijing wants to attract non-Chinese investors, though that has happened with only a handful of projects, he said.

Among projects that have been derailed or disrupted:

—Authorities in Nepal canceled plans in November for Chinese companies to build a $2.5 billion dam after they concluded contracts for the Budhi Gandaki Hydro Electric Project violated rules requiring multiple bidders.

—The European Union is looking into whether Hungary violated the trade bloc's rules by awarding contracts to Chinese builders of a high-speed railway to neighboring Serbia without competing bids.

—In Myanmar, plans for a Chinese oil company to build a $3 billion refinery were canceled in November due to financing difficulties, the newspaper Myanmar Times reported.

There is no official list of projects, but consulting firm BMI Research has compiled a database of $1.8 trillion of infrastructure investments announced across Asia, Africa and the Middle East that include Chinese money or other involvement.

Many are still in planning stages and some up to three decades in the future, according to Christian Zhang, a BMI analyst.

"It's probably too early to say at this point how much of the overall initiative will actually be implemented," said Zhang.

The U.S. and Japanese governments express interest in building contracts or other potential "Belt and Road" opportunities for their companies. But they also are trying to develop alternative initiatives.

In November, the U.S. government's Overseas Private Investment Corp. signed an agreement with Japanese partners to offer "infrastructure investment alternatives in the Indo-Pacific region," according to a White House statement.

The following month, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said Japan can "cooperate greatly" with China.

The stumbles for one of the world's most ambitious infrastructure ventures could help temper concerns Beijing will increase its strategic influence.

"There is a big possibility that China is going to have a lot of disagreements and misunderstandings," said Kerry Brown, a specialist in Chinese politics at King's College London. "It's hard to think of a big, successful project the 'Belt and Road Initiative' has led to at the moment."

Even Pakistan, one of China's friendliest neighbors, has failed to agree on key projects.

The two governments are developing facilities with a total cost of $60 billion including power plants and railways to link China's far west with the Chinese-built port of Gwadar on the Indian Ocean.

A visit by a Chinese assistant foreign minister in November produced no agreement on railway projects in the southern city of Karachi valued at $10 billion and a $260 million airport for Gwadar.

The same month, the chairman of the Pakistan Water and Power Development Authority announced the Diamer-Bhasha Dam would be withdrawn from joint development. The site is in Gilgit-Baltistan in Pakistan's far north, part of the Kashmir region, which also is claimed by India.

"Chinese conditions for financing the Diamer-Bhasha Dam were not doable and against our interests," the official, Muzammil Hussain, told legislators, according to Pakistani news reports.

The Chinese Cabinet agency overseeing "Belt and Road," the National Development and Reform Commission, denied in a written statement that it asked for an ownership stake. It said the two sides had held only preliminary talks about the project.

A Pakistani Cabinet official who spoke on condition he not be identified further said the Chinese side asked for clarification of the ownership status of the dam site because Gilgit-Baltistan has yet to be formally made part of a Pakistani province. The water authority didn't respond to requests to clarify its chairman's comments.

"Belt and Road" is interwoven with official efforts to export Chinese rail, hydropower and other technology and steel, aluminum and other industrial goods.

In Thailand, work on a $15 billion high-speed railway was suspended in 2016 following complaints too little business went to Thai companies.

After more talks over costs, technology sharing and land ownership, Thai leaders announced a new plan in July for a first line to be built from Bangkok to the country's northeast. Building contracts went to Thai companies while China will supply technology.

In Tanzania, the government has reopened negotiations with China and another investor, the government of the gulf nation of Oman, over ownership of a planned $11 billion port in the city of Bagamoyo. The Tanzanian government failed to raise $28 million for its contribution, leaving it unclear what share the government might get.

Tanzania wants to make sure its people get more than just taxes collected from the port, said the director of the Tanzania Ports Authority, Deusdedit Kakoko.

"Land is for Tanzanians, and as the government we're ensuring they get a share," Kakoko said in an interview.

Despite such setbacks, Chinese officials say most "Belt and Road" projects are moving ahead with few problems.

Work on pipelines to deliver oil and gas from Russia and Central Asia is making "steady progress," said a deputy commerce minister, Li Chenggang, at a Nov. 21 news conference.

"We have a lot of room for further cooperation," said Li.

The state-run China Development Bank announced in 2015 it had set aside $890 billion for more than 900 projects across 60 countries in gas, minerals, power, telecoms, infrastructure and farming. The Export-Import Bank of China said it would finance 1,000 projects in 49 countries.

Acting as banker gives Beijing leverage to require use of Chinese builders and technology. But it can lead to complaints host countries fail to negotiate hard enough.

In Sri Lanka, the government sold an 80 percent stake in a port in the southern city of Hambantota to a Chinese state-owned company on Dec. 9 after falling behind in repaying $1.5 billion borrowed from Beijing to build it. That prompted complaints the deal was too favorable to Beijing.

"There is the perception of a Chinese incursion into their sovereignty by taking over the port," said BMI's Zhang.


Ahmed reported from Islamabad and Domasa from Dodoma, Tanzania. AP Writer Mari Yamaguchi in Tokyo contributed.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Asian shares mixed after Wall Street rally fizzles
Asian stock markets mixed after Wall Street posts first losses of 2018
2:53AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Thomas returns at Sony Open and scene of scoring records
On The Tee: Justin Thomas defends his record win at Sony Open while Ernie Els starts 30th year in South Africa
2:46AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Hundreds search for victims of California mudslide
Hundreds of searchers continued the grueling work Thursday of hunting for survivors and digging up bodies in the sea of mud and wreckage left by flash flooding in this wealthy coastal enclave
2:44AM ( 33 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Residents didn't heed voluntary evacuation before mudslide
Residents of the area hit the hardest by the deadly flash floods in Southern California didn't heed a voluntary evacuation
2:25AM ( 52 minutes ago )
Amazon looks to build on 1st season of NFL streaming
Amazon had a mostly successful debut into live streaming of major sports events with increased audience and an improved viewing experience in its first season showing NFL games
2:23AM ( 54 minutes ago )
Michelin star boosts chef at outdoor Thai kitchen to stardom
A Thai chef who has spent over 30 years wielding her wok in an unassuming outdoor, coal-fired kitchen has been awarded a Michelin star, propelling her to global culinary stardom
2:19AM ( 59 minutes ago )
AP National News
Joe Arpaio points to political traits he shares with Trump
Former Sheriff Joe Arpaio has pointed to the political qualities his shares with President Donald Trump a day after announcing his plans for a Senate campaign
12:11AM ( 3 hours ago )
Toyota-Mazda plant: Alabama bids to become a major auto hub
Alabama enters fast lane in bid to become major auto making hub in the South, landing mammoth $1.6 billion joint venture plant of Toyota and Mazda
11:39PM ( 3 hours ago )
Immigration agents descend on 7-Eleven stores in 17 states
Immigration agents descend on dozens of 7-Eleven convenience stores to check immigration compliance
11:29PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
People familiar with deal: Mets, Bruce agree at $39M, 3 yrs
Two people familiar with the negotiations say free-agent outfielder Jay Bruce is set to return to the New York Mets after agreeing to a $39 million, three-year contract
11:55PM ( 3 hours ago )
Norway's PM makes business case of 'green economy' to Trump
Norway's prime minister is telling President Donald Trump that her country remains committed to the Paris climate agreement, making the business case of the "green economy" to the real estate developer-turned president
9:01PM ( 6 hours ago )
'Fire and Fury' sales top 29,000 in first weekend
Michael Wolff's "Fire and Fury" sold more than 29,000 hardcover copies in its first days of publication, NPD BookScan tells The Associated Press
8:30PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business
New Toyota-Mazda plant will bring 4,000 jobs to Alabama
Toyota and Mazda have chosen Southern U.S. state of Alabama as site of new $1.6 billion joint-venture plant
6:44PM ( 8 hours ago )
Got batteries? Outage stalls giant tech show in Las Vegas
Thousands of attendees of the world's biggest consumer technology show got a chance to test the battery life of the latest gadgets when some showrooms and hallways went dark
6:03PM ( 9 hours ago )
As companies give bonuses, prospect of pay gains still hazy
As some companies award bonuses in wake of corporate tax cut, prospect of pay gains still hazy
5:57PM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Honduras next in line for US decision on protected migrants
News that the Trump administration is ending Temporary Protected Status for 200,000 migrants from El Salvador is also rattling nerves in Honduras, which faces a July decision on the fate of more than 50,000 of its compatriots living in the United States
4:38PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump says US-Norway ties 'robust'
President Donald Trump says the economic ties between the United States and Norway are "robust and growing"
3:29PM ( 11 hours ago )
Sears raises $100M in new financing, eyes $200M in cost cuts
Sears is raising $100 million in new financing, will seek twice that from other sources, and will attempt $200 million in additional cost cuts this year
2:28PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Dems say Trump action on Florida drilling guided by politics
Opposition to the Trump administration's plan to expand offshore drilling mounts
7:20PM ( 7 hours ago )
Coal baron's action plan became Trump policy initiatives
The head of one of America's largest coal companies sent a four-page "action plan" to the White House calling for rollbacks of key environmental and mine safety regulations
5:16PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Oil companies dispute climate lawsuit claims
Oil companies say lawsuits not the answer to addressing global warming following suit filed by NYC
2:25PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Politically important Florida gets a pass on drilling plan
The Trump administration's plan to open up U.S. coastline for offshore drilling is making room for an exception _ the state of Florida
12:47AM ( 1 day ago )
NYC taking steps to divest pension funds of fossil fuels
New York City officials are citing climate change as their motivation to join a growing number of entities divesting themselves of financial interest in fossil fuels
12:24AM ( 1 day ago )
Trump administration says no oil drilling off Florida coast
The Trump administration says it will not allow oil drilling off the coast of Florida
7:36PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Thomas returns at Sony Open and scene of scoring records
On The Tee: Justin Thomas defends his record win at Sony Open while Ernie Els starts 30th year in South Africa
2:46AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Hundreds search for victims of California mudslide
Hundreds of searchers continued the grueling work Thursday of hunting for survivors and digging up bodies in the sea of mud and wreckage left by flash flooding in this wealthy coastal enclave
2:44AM ( 33 minutes ago )
Greitens acknowledges affair, denies blackmail allegations
Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens acknowledges he was "unfaithful" in his marriage but denies allegations that he blackmailed the woman he had an extramarital affair with to stay quiet
2:39AM ( 39 minutes ago )
Young college try: Boeser, Keller impress as NHL rookies
College products Brock Boeser and Clayton Keller are impressing as NHL rookies
2:37AM ( 41 minutes ago )
Gruff Alaska lawmaker now in charge of civility in US House
A gruff, no-nonsense Alaska lawmaker who once told a female colleague she didn't know what she was talking about is now in charge of ensuring civility in the U.S. House
2:33AM ( 45 minutes ago )