Saturday July 21st, 2018 4:02AM

Public shaming likely but GOP wary of new laws after Equifax

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Prospects are good for a public shaming in the Equifax data breach, but it's unlikely Congress will institute sweeping new regulations after hackers accessed the personal information of an estimated 143 million Americans.

Since early this year, President Donald Trump and the Republican-led Congress have strived to curb government's influence on businesses, arguing that regulations stifle economic growth. Lawmakers have repealed more than a dozen Obama-era rules and the House voted in June to roll back much of Dodd-Frank, the landmark banking law created after the 2008 economic crisis that was designed to prevent future meltdowns.

Several bills unveiled after Equifax are so far missing a key ingredient for success: Republican co-sponsors.

And most important, there is history. Despite numerous high-profile security breaches over the past decade at companies such as Target, Yahoo, Neiman Marcus and Home Depot, legislation that would toughen standards for storing customer data has failed to gain the necessary traction.

Jessica Rich, a vice president at Consumer Reports, said she has questioned over the years what event it would take for lawmakers to impose tougher data security regulations.

"I'm hoping this is the final wake-up call for Congress," Rich said.

Consumer advocacy groups seek legislation that would enhance the standards for companies that store consumer data and require prompt notification to affected Americans when breaches do occur. They also seek tough civil penalties for those who break the law. But, so far, Congress has opted to let states handle the issue.

Business groups are also worried that federal regulation will stifle innovation.

"When it comes to security, attempts to regulate today will become outdated tomorrow," said a new report from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

Senate and House Republicans say they are in fact-gathering mode before moving on any legislation. Separate hearings are scheduled the first week in October, with Equifax Chairman and CEO Richard Smith slated to testify — and likely to get a public thrashing from lawmakers.

Rep. Greg Walden, the Republican chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, said he's not ruling out new regulations as a result of the data breach at the credit agency, "but first we've got to get the facts."

Democrats will be watching closely.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., described the Equifax breach as a test, asking on the Senate floor will "we act quickly to protect American consumers, or are we going to cave in to firms like Equifax who have spent millions of dollars lobbying to Congress for weaker rules?"

Democrats have introduced several bills. One would require credit reporting companies to place a freeze on a consumer's credit report without charge if that company is hacked. Currently, all 50 states have laws allowing consumers to place a security freeze on their credit report, but the freeze often comes with a fee.

Chi Chi Wu, an attorney at the National Consumer Law Center, said such freezes are the single most important step consumers can take to prevent new accounts from being opened in their name.

Democrats are also using the Equifax breach to reprise more longstanding concerns about the work of credit reporting companies like Equifax, Experian and TransUnion.

Rep. Steve Cohen of Tennessee and 30 Democratic co-sponsors are backing legislation that would protect prospective employees from being forced to disclose their credit history as part of a job application process.

Wu said credit checks are used as warning flags about potential employees.

"A lot of people have impaired credit, black marks on their credit report because something bad happened to them," Wu said. "It was not because they were bad or irresponsible people. They were unlucky."

Meanwhile, Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Calif., is taking another crack at legislation designed to help consumers correct entries in their credit report.

Under her bill, creditors who send negative information to a reporting agency must also give a heads-up to the consumer. Credit reporting companies would also have to dedicate sufficient resources to handling consumers' appeals. The appeals staff would have to meet minimum training and certification requirements.

Waters' bill would also reduce the time that most adverse credit information may remain on reports. The time period would drop from seven to four years.

The bill reflects frequent consumer angst about the information on their credit report. Last year, Americans submitted about 54,000 complaints with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau about credit reporting issues. Three-quarters of those complaints alleged incorrect information in credit reports.

Even if the Equifax breach fails to bring about the passage of new legislation, it has scuttled one bill in the works. On the day of Equifax's announcement, a House subcommittee examined legislation that would have decreased the potential consequences when consumer reporting agencies falsely malign someone. Such mistakes can haunt consumers for years.

The bill would have eliminated punitive damages for violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The bill's sponsor, Rep. Barry Loudermilk, R-Ga., said the legislation was aimed at curbing frivolous lawsuits and would not have granted any immunity to Equifax for the data breach. "Nevertheless, given the unfounded attacks on me and the rampant misinformation circulating about this legislation, the Financial Services Committee has not scheduled further action on any bill at this time."

Wu, who testified against Loudermilk's bill, said she believes that legislation providing for the free credit freeze probably has the best chance of passage.

"I'm skeptical this particular Congress will be up for wholesale reform," Wu said.


On Twitter, reach Kevin Freking at

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Business - Economy
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Kurd leader says referendum will go forward
President of Iraq's Kurdish region says controversial referendum on independence will go forward, despite increasingly urgent calls from international community to delay
11:35AM ( 2 minutes ago )
Spain to send extra police to try to halt Catalan referendum
Spain says it will deploy police reinforcements to the northeastern region of Catalonia to maintain order and take action if a referendum on independence pledged by the Catalan government but deemed illegal by Spain should take place
11:33AM ( 5 minutes ago )
Kim fires off insults at Trump and hints at weapons test
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un lobs crude insults at Trump and hints at frightening new weapons test
11:30AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Heading to Mexico? Busiest US crossing closing this weekend
The busiest border crossing in the United States will close this weekend to the more than 40,000 cars that pass through it daily to Mexico
10:00AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump: Russia probe a 'hoax,' media was 'greatest influence'
President Donald Trump is calling allegations of Russian election meddling a "hoax," insisting the media was the 'greatest influence' on the 2016 campaign.
9:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump piles on new economic sanctions against North Korea
President Donald Trump has authorized stiffer new sanctions against North Korea
8:21AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
After humdrum German campaign, Merkel hopes for fourth term
Chancellor Angela Merkel appears all but certain to win a fourth term when Germans vote on Sunday, but with a weaker mandate as more voters turn to smaller parties, including the anti-immigrant and euroskeptic Alternative for Germany
5:16AM ( 6 hours ago )
US Senate contender has history of provocative comments
The firebrand jurist who is close to snagging the state's Republican nomination for U.S. Senate in Alabama has a history of provocative comments
4:37AM ( 7 hours ago )
AP FACT CHECK: Kimmel's take on health care harder to refute
AP FACT CHECK: Considering all the arguments, TV host Jimmy Kimmel's take on the Republican health care bill is harder to refute
3:20AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Theresa May: UK seeks 2-year transition period after Brexit
British Prime Minister Theresa May will try to revive foundering Brexit negotiations, proposing a two-year transition period after the country formal departure in 2019 to ensure Britain's departure from the European Union goes smoothly
11:02AM ( 36 minutes ago )
NASA's asteroid chaser swings by Earth on way to space rock
NASA's asteroid-chasing spacecraft, Osiris-Rex, swings by Earth on Friday on its way to a space rock
10:42AM ( 56 minutes ago )
The Latest: UK's May: Irish border won't see new barriers
British Prime Minister Theresa May says Britain is committed to protecting the Good Friday peace accord in Northern Ireland, pledging that even after Britain leaves the EU there will be no physical customs infrastructure at that border with Ireland
10:34AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Watchdog: Airfares for many travelers rise due to bag fees
A government watchdog says travelers who check at least one bag are paying more overall to fly than they did before airlines began unbundling fares in 2008
7:50PM ( 1 day ago )
New lawsuits, gestures to customers in Equifax data breach
New lawsuits, gestures to customers in Equifax data breach
6:42PM ( 1 week ago )
Millions who buy health insurance brace for sharp increases
Millions who buy health insurance without ACA help brace for sharp increases
3:50AM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
World shares fall on North Korea concerns, China rate cut
World stock markets fall as investors turn cautious following new U.S. sanctions targeting North Korea, China credit rating downgrade
4:57AM ( 6 hours ago )
The Latest: Kim says Trump will 'pay dearly' for threat
North Korea leader Kim Jong Un issues a rare statement, branding Trump as "deranged" and warning he will "pay dearly" for his threat to "totally destroy" the North if it attacks
3:40AM ( 7 hours ago )
US beefs up NKorea sanctions, Kim Jong Un insults Trump
President Donald Trump has pivoted away from military threats against North Korea to his administration's strategy of economic pressure, signing an order to enable increased sanctions on the nuclear-armed nation
2:18AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
The Latest: EU lawmaker: May's speech leaves him worried
The leader of the biggest bloc in the European Parliament says British Prime Minister Theresa May's latest Brexit speech has him more worried than ever about whether a deal can be done
11:20AM ( 17 minutes ago )
The Latest: Rand Paul responds to Trump's tweet
Sen. Rand Paul says despite President Donald Trump's attacks on him for opposing the new GOP health care bill, the measure is a "fake" and he won't support it.
11:13AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Puerto Rico faces weeks without electricity after Maria
The eye of Hurricane Maria is nearing the Turks and Caicos early Friday as Puerto Rico tries to recover from the storm's devastation
11:04AM ( 34 minutes ago )
Lawyer: Hacker in Spanish custody sought by US, Russia
Russian authorities are fighting in Spain the extradition to the United States of an alleged Russian hacker, the suspect's lawyer said Friday, in the latest move by Moscow to block prosecution in the U.S. of suspected Russian cybercriminals
11:03AM ( 35 minutes ago )
Theresa May: UK seeks 2-year transition period after Brexit
British Prime Minister Theresa May will try to revive foundering Brexit negotiations, proposing a two-year transition period after the country formal departure in 2019 to ensure Britain's departure from the European Union goes smoothly
11:02AM ( 36 minutes ago )