clear
Saturday November 25th, 2017 6:10AM

GOP report accuses watchdog of going easy on Wells Fargo

By The Associated Press

NEW YORK (AP) — The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau could have fined Wells Fargo in excess of $10 billion for its illegal sales practices but instead settled for $100 million, according to the agency's internal documents released by Congressional Republicans this week.

The CFPB also had evidence that the bank's sales problems went back to at least 2006 — far earlier than the 2011 to 2016 timetable that Wells Fargo originally admitted to, the documents show.

"The bank knew since at least 2006 that its employees were gaming its incentive compensation program, yet failed to take actions sufficient to stop it," CFPB employees wrote in a 2016 confidential memo.

The documents were released as part of a politically charged report by the staff of House Financial Services Committee Chairman, Rep. Jeb Hensarling of Texas. Hensarling is a critic of the CFPB who along with other House Republicans has called for the firing of its director, Richard Cordray, an appointee of President Barack Obama, as well as for new laws to curtail the bureau's authority over the financial services industry.

It would take months for Wells Fargo to acknowledge publicly that its sales practices problems, in which employees trying to reach unrealistic sales goals opened accounts without customers' permission, dated earlier than 2011. At first, then-Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf agreed to expand its internal investigation to 2009. But when testifying in front of the Senate Banking Committee in late September 2016, he was reluctant to go back further than that.

Eventually Wells Fargo would admit the sales practices problems as early as 2002 in a report issued by the bank's board of directors earlier this year, roughly seven months after the CFPB's fine.

It is not clear why the CFPB chose 2011 as the original cut-off date for getting Wells Fargo to admit its sales practices problems. A Wells Fargo spokeswoman declined to comment on the date issue, but said the bank is reviewing the report.

CFPB employees estimated that based on the 2 million fake accounts that Wells Fargo's employees had opened, the penalty against the bank could be in excess of $10 billion before taking into account mitigating factors. That's according to a confidential memo written to Cordray in July 2016 that outlined potential sanctions the bureau could take against the bank.

CFPB employees ultimately recommended a $100 million fine against Wells Fargo — representing the largest fine ever levied in the CFPB's history at the time — to "sufficiently deter similar violations" by the bank and its competitors. That amount was adopted by the agency when it publicly announced its order against Wells Fargo in September.

The San Francisco-based bank also paid another $83 million in fines to the Los Angeles Attorney's Office and the federal bank regulator the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency for its sales practices violations, for a total of $183 million.

The report and publicly disclosed documents are meant to imply that the CFPB went easy on Wells Fargo. However, Cordray accused House Republicans of "Monday-morning quarterbacking."

"The fact is that the CFPB worked effectively with our partners to expose the Wells Fargo scandal and put a public spotlight on their practice of secretly opening unauthorized accounts," Cordray said in a statement. "In response, we levied our largest fine ever and secured broad, nationwide relief for consumers."

The Los Angeles City Attorney's Office, which has been credited with starting the first investigation into Wells Fargo back in 2013, did not agree with Republicans' argument that the CFPB was asleep at the wheel regarding Wells Fargo.

"The CFPB was integral to our collective work holding Wells Fargo accountable for fake accounts, including assuring Wells' customers across the nation got relief," said City Attorney Mike Feuer.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Mexico quake rescuers race to free girl, other survivors
The wiggling fingers of a young girl trapped in the rubble of her collapsed school in Mexico City have raised the hopes of hundreds of quake rescuers working furiously to try to free her
5:54PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Defense: Man accused terror plot was 'idiot,' not fighter
A prosecutor and defense attorney have painted starkly different pictures of a Massachusetts man accused of participating in a plot to behead a conservative blogger who angered Muslims when she organized a Prophet Muhammad cartoon contest in Texas
5:50PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Man's path from Eagle Scout to alleged killer baffles family
Relatives of a 23-year-old white man accused of gunning down two black men say they are baffled by his path from Eagle Scout to murder suspect
5:47PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
New fight in California water wars: How to update old system
California must decide what's next for upgrading its outdated water supply system after a key player rejected Gov. Jerry Brown's $16 billion plan to build two giant tunnels
5:28PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Watchdog: Airfares for many travelers rise due to bag fees
A government watchdog says travelers who check at least one bag are paying more overall to fly than they did before airlines began unbundling fares in 2008
5:27PM ( 36 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump says GOP health care law has 'good chance'
President Donald Trump is offering strong support for the last-ditch GOP effort to repeal "Obamacare." Trump said Wednesday that the legislation by Sens. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Bill Cassidy of Louisiana has a "very good chance."
5:14PM ( 49 minutes ago )
AP Business
New lawsuits, gestures to customers in Equifax data breach
New lawsuits, gestures to customers in Equifax data breach
6:42PM ( 1 week ago )
Millions who buy health insurance brace for sharp increases
Millions who buy health insurance without ACA help brace for sharp increases
3:50AM ( 2 weeks ago )
Texas law easing insurer penalties takes effect amid Harvey
A new Texas law that took effect a week after Harvey made landfall lowers the penalty for insurers that take too long to pay a claim
1:24PM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
Mexico quake rescuers race to free girl, other survivors
The wiggling fingers of a young girl trapped in the rubble of her collapsed school in Mexico City have raised the hopes of hundreds of quake rescuers working furiously to try to free her
5:54PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Defense: Man accused terror plot was 'idiot,' not fighter
A prosecutor and defense attorney have painted starkly different pictures of a Massachusetts man accused of participating in a plot to behead a conservative blogger who angered Muslims when she organized a Prophet Muhammad cartoon contest in Texas
5:50PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Man's path from Eagle Scout to alleged killer baffles family
Relatives of a 23-year-old white man accused of gunning down two black men say they are baffled by his path from Eagle Scout to murder suspect
5:47PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Trump to award Medal of Honor to Alabama veteran
The White House says President Donald Trump will award the Medal of Honor to a retired Army medic from Alabama who risked his life several times to provide medical care to his comrades during the Vietnam War.
5:46PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Ivanka Trump discusses her postpartum depression
Ivanka Trump is talking about her experience with postpartum depression in a new interview
5:42PM ( 21 minutes ago )