clear
Sunday September 24th, 2017 1:42PM

Judge opens door for lawsuit over girl declared brain dead

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — A California judge ruled that a teen girl who was declared brain dead more than three years ago after a tonsillectomy may technically still be alive, allowing a malpractice lawsuit against the hospital to move forward and possibly setting up the family to have her care paid for if they succeed.

Alameda County Judge Stephen Pulido ruled Tuesday that it's up to a jury to determine whether Jahi McMath is alive, which would increase the damages jurors could award if they determine doctors at Children's Hospital in Oakland botched a routine operation to remove the girl's tonsils.

In California, non-economic damages such as pain and suffering are capped at $250,000 for medical malpractice. But juries can award unlimited economic damages far above that cap for ongoing medical care, which Jahi's family could not claim if she were declared dead.

Jahi's case has been at the center of national debate over brain death since the girl's mother refused to remove her daughter from life support after doctors declared the then-13-year-old dead after surgery in December 2013.

Doctors say she had irreversible brain damage from a lack of oxygen and suffered cardiac arrest. A coroner signed a death certificate the following month.

The girl is connected to a ventilator and receives medical care in New Jersey, the only U.S. state that accommodates religions that don't recognize brain death.

Chris Dolan, who represents the family in a federal lawsuit seeking to rescind Jahi's death certificate, said the family was "overjoyed" with the judge's ruling.

"It's literally a matter of life and death," said Dolan, who is seeking the unprecedented verdict from a jury so the family can move the girl back to California, where doctors would be compelled to care for her.

Bruce Brusavich, a lawyer representing the family in the malpractice case, didn't return a phone message Thursday seeking comment. A lawyer for the hospital, Thomas Still, didn't return a phone call.

Hospital lawyers have argued that the family has not subjected Jahi to tests accepted by the American Medical Association to determine whether someone is brain dead.

Dolan argues that technological advances such as brain scans have made obsolete traditional tests that doctors rely on to diagnose brain death.

Jahi's case reignited the debate over brain death 15 years after the family of Terry Schiavo fought a bitter, drawn-out legal battle starting in 1998 over whether to remove the Florida woman's feeding tube.

In Jahi's case, her mother acknowledges that the girl's brain is severely and irreparably damaged, Dolan said. But Latasha Spears Winkfield said her daughter is still alive and her Christian beliefs compel her fight to keep her daughter on life support, Dolan said.

Winkfield has released video clips of Jahi's fingers twitching and toes wiggling. Several doctors, including two hired by a California court, have said brain-dead patients can still twitch and move slightly.

Court records show that New Jersey's Medicaid program has picked up some of the girl's health costs. The family also has received financial contributions from an online fundraising campaign.

In ordering the case to trial, Alameda County Judge Stephen Pulido relied on the testimony of a well-known critic of the way experts diagnose brain death, Dr. Alan Shewmon.

The retired neurologist said in court documents filed in July that videos recorded by McMath's family from 2014 to 2016 showed the teen was still alive.

The images, some made public by the girl's relatives, show Jahi twitching her fingers and reacting to odors that Shewmon and her relatives said were noxious without providing more specifics. Shewmon said Jahi's body has not deteriorated as expected.

A doctor who examines the girl every three months for the family has testified that Jahi had reached puberty. Shewmon says Jahi is in a "minimally responsive state."

___

This story has been corrected to show that calls for comment were made to lawyers on Thursday, not Wednesday.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Health
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
AP Exclusive: Most Florida flood zone property not insured
With Hurricane Irma bearing down on Florida, an Associated Press analysis shows that the number of federal flood insurance policies written in the state has fallen by 15 percent
6:42PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Judge opens door for lawsuit over girl declared brain dead
A California judge has ruled that a teen girl who was declared brain dead more than three years ago after a tonsillectomy may technically still be alive
6:40PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Prosecutors: Minnesota girl held 29 days, tied up and raped
A Minnesota teenager who was held captive for 29 days had been locked in a closet, raped, bound by zip ties and shoved into a duffel bag as captors moved her to another location
6:38PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Trump briefed on Hurricane Irma preparations
The White House says President Donald Trump has been briefed on preparations for Hurricane Irma and the federal government's planned response to the storm
6:04PM ( 41 minutes ago )
It's a 'great thing' to deal with Democrats, Trump now says
Frustrated with Republican congressional leadership he believes has steered him into defeats, President Donald Trump is relishing a suddenly cozier relationship with Democrats
6:03PM ( 42 minutes ago )
Navy says tight budget, stress on fleet don't excuse crashes
A senior U.S. Navy officer says the hectic pace of military operations and a constrained military budget don't excuse warship accidents that killed 17 American sailors
5:58PM ( 47 minutes ago )
AP National News
Detective: Cousins went for cheesesteaks after 4 men killed
A detective who took a statement from one of two cousins charged in the deaths of four men found buried on a Pennsylvania farm says the suspect told him he and his cousin went out for cheesesteaks after the killings
5:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Nearly 540,000 ordered to flee Georgia coast ahead of Irma
Georgia governor orders 540,000 coastal residents to evacuate ahead of Irma
5:03PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP NewsBreak: Nevada wants out of Superfund listing at mine
Documents obtained by The Associated Press say Nevada wants to back out of an agreement to designate a toxic mine a priority U.S. Superfund site _ a move critics warn could leave state taxpayers on the hook for hundreds of millions of dollars
4:51PM ( 1 hour ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
AP Exclusive: Most Florida flood zone property not insured
With Hurricane Irma bearing down on Florida, an Associated Press analysis shows that the number of federal flood insurance policies written in the state has fallen by 15 percent
6:42PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Prosecutors: Minnesota girl held 29 days, tied up and raped
A Minnesota teenager who was held captive for 29 days had been locked in a closet, raped, bound by zip ties and shoved into a duffel bag as captors moved her to another location
6:38PM ( 7 minutes ago )
US not disputing NKorea's claim to have tested H-bomb
President Donald Trump has reiterated that military action is "certainly" an option against North Korea
6:31PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Oklahoma lawmaker charged with forcibly kissing Uber driver
An Oklahoma state senator has been charged with sexual battery after an Uber driver accused him of grabbing her head and kissing her neck while she was driving him to a bar in June
6:26PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Late season US wildfires choke cities, towns with smoke
The 2017 wildfire season is shaping up to be one of the worst in U.S. history for land burned
6:26PM ( 19 minutes ago )