Thursday February 21st, 2019 11:53PM

Fear spreads over tainted eggs despite low risk to consumers

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

AMSTERDAM (AP) — Experts say the risk of getting sick from eating an egg tainted with insecticide is low. But that hasn't stopped stores in Germany and the Netherlands from stripping them from supermarket shelves, or prevented other European food safety agencies from issuing warnings.

The story about the illegal use of the insecticide Fipronil in spray to rid hens of ticks, fleas and lice has gained traction across Europe. Fears about the safety of an everyday food staple along with some less-than-optimal public information have combined to cast a shadow of suspicion over the humble egg.

Amsterdam shopper Karla Spreekmeester said Friday that she only buys eggs from stores selling organic food products.

"I take it seriously," she said of the Dutch warning. "I'm not scared that I'll collapse if I eat the wrong egg, but if you can prevent something ..."

Fipronil is commonly used by veterinarians to treat fleas and ticks in pets, but is banned by the European Union for treating animals like chickens that are part of the human food chain.

The EU said contaminated eggs have been found at producers in Belgium, France, Germany and the Netherlands. It's believed the Fipronil got into the food chain when it was illegally added to a product used to spray poultry.

The impact for egg producers has been staggering.

Since July 20, Dutch farmers have destroyed millions of unsellable eggs and culled about 1 million hens, said Hennie de Haan of the Dutch union of poultry farmers.

But nobody has been reported to have fallen ill as a result of eating the tainted eggs.

"People are very susceptible to negative information," said Jan-Willem van Prooijen, a social psychologist at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. "People are very attuned to perceive and respond emotionally to negative information such as potential health hazards or other threatening stimuli."

In recent days, Dutch authorities blocked sales from about 180 infected farms treated by a company suspected of illicitly using Fipronil.

Almost all lab tests show that only very low levels of Fipronil — seven to 10 times lower than the maximum permitted — have been detected in eggs from the treated chickens, although one test in Belgium was above the European limit. Poisoning by small doses has few effects and requires little treatment. Heavy and prolonged exposure can damage the kidneys and liver or cause seizures.

Dutch authorities warned that eggs from only one farm should not be eaten and said children should not eat eggs from dozens of other farms.

That sent consumers to their refrigerators to check the small codes printed in red ink on the shells of eggs to see if they are from one of the affected farms. Stores have pulled eggs from contaminated farms off their shelves.

The European Union said Friday that tainted eggs have been found so far in 15 EU countries, plus Switzerland and Hong Kong.

In Germany, some supermarkets stopped selling all Dutch eggs regardless of whether they came from infected farms. British authorities issued a warning about a small number of ready-made salads, sandwiches and spreads containing contaminated eggs.

The precautions came despite food safety experts being nearly unanimous in their opinion that the health risk from eating Fipronil-tainted eggs is very low.

"Even when taken deliberately at 10,000 times the maximum amount likely to be consumed from contaminated eggs, the individuals survived with no long-term harm," Alan Boobis, professor of biochemical pharmacology, Imperial College London, said in a statement.

"Based on the extent of contamination found and the number of such eggs that have reached the U.K. market, there is no reason for consumers to be concerned," he added.

So why are consumers concerned?

"Bad is stronger than good," said Van Prooijen, citing a time-honored maxim among psychologists. "And that means human beings pay more attention to negative things than positive things, because negative things can harm you."

Some farmers say the Netherlands' food safety watchdog last week fanned such fears.

The acting inspector-general of the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority, Freek van Zoeren, said on a Dutch TV news show that, "if somebody says 'I can live without eggs until Sunday,' I'd advise that."

Dutch Health Minister Edith Schippers acknowledged on another show Thursday night that the statement was ill-judged.

Van Zoeren "made comments that, indeed, did not increase the clarity," Schippers said.

Anja Visscher, whose 110,000 white hens lay about 100,000 eggs each day, quickly took to Facebook and the internet to reassure customers after Van Zoeren's comment.

"There are companies whose eggs are OK, so eat an egg," was the message she and other farmers spread. "You want the market to remain OK."

On Thursday, authorities arrested two men in the Netherlands who were directors of the company involved in spraying poultry barns, saying they endangered public health. Their identities have not been released while a criminal investigation continues.

Farmers have said they were unaware the spray contained Fipronil and see themselves as unwitting victims. In the Netherlands, they also blame the food safety watchdog for not acting fast enough after receiving an anonymous tip about possible Fipronil use in November 2016.

Some industry groups say the scandal should be a wake-up call.

"Citizens want something cleaner, better, and we have been working on that," said Philippe Duvivier, president of FUGEA, a Belgian farmers' group working for sustainable agriculture. "We have to call the whole sector into question now. Perhaps it's time to go to a whole other kind of agriculture."


Associated Press writer Lorne Cook in Brussels and videographer Aleksandar Furtula in Barneveld, the Netherlands, contributed.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Agriculture, AP Business - Poultry & Egg
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Fear spreads over tainted eggs despite low risk to consumers
Fears over tainted eggs spread across Europe despite experts saying health risks are low
1:24PM ( 6 minutes ago )
The Latest: Report: Egg scandal suspect denies involvement
Dutch media are reporting that a suspect in Europe's contaminated egg scandal
12:57PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Los Angeles poised to take another step toward 2028 Games
The city appears poised to take another step toward bringing the 2028 Olympics to Los Angeles, despite questions about future costs
12:57PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
APNewsBreak: Beyond bluster, US, NKorea in regular contact
Beyond the bluster, the U.S. has been quietly engaged in ongoing diplomatic communications with North Korea over the last several months, The Associated Press has learned.
12:28PM ( 1 hour ago )
Investigator in Trump tax return case is taken into custody
A Louisiana private investigator accused of trying to illegally obtain Donald Trump's tax returns before last year's presidential election has been arrested again, this time being accused violating conditions of his pretrial release
12:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump warns US 'locked and loaded' as North readies missiles
President Donald Trump tweets that the U.S. military is "locked and loaded" as he warns North Korea against threatening the U.S.
11:56AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
EU plans talks as egg scandal hits 17 countries
The EU is planning an extraordinary meeting next month over the tainted egg scandal as products contaminated with an insecticide spread to 17 countries
9:03AM ( 4 hours ago )
10 Things to Know for Today
Among 10 Things to Know: Poll shows most favor fixing, not scrapping, 'Obamacare'; Taylor Swift takes stand at sex assault trial; Jordan Spieth rebounds after shaky start at PGA Championship.
8:37AM ( 4 hours ago )
What does North Korea really want? Its playbook offers clues
Pushing the envelope when the heat is on is what North Korea does best _ but what, ultimately, is Pyongyang trying to accomplish?
8:17AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Snap stock hits lowest level since IPO after paltry earnings
Shares of Snap Inc. are down sharply following paltry earnings results
11:52AM ( 1 hour ago )
The TV-streaming paradox: Why you may miss the cable bundle
The future of TV may well be a mishmash of streaming packages that wind up costing pretty close to a $100 cable bundle but are more difficult to use
11:35AM ( 1 hour ago )
JC Penney results extend a gloomy week for retailers
Sales at established JC Penney stores faded again during its most recent quarter, capping a gloomy week for U.S. retailers.
11:34AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
The Latest: Romania incinerates eggs yolks amid scandal
Romania's food safety chief says there aren't any indications of more pesticide-tainted eggs in Romania, hours after officials incinerated a ton of suspect pasteurized yolks
9:27AM ( 4 hours ago )
JC Penney extends a gloomy week for retailers
Sales at established JC Penney stores faded again during its most recent quarter, capping a gloomy week for U.S. retailers.
8:47AM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: 2 Austria firms recall eggs bound for eateries
Upper Austria's provincial government says two companies have recalled eggs possibly tainted with Fipronil and food control agents are conducting additional spot checks of eggs for evidence of the insecticide
8:29AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
North Korea tensions continue to weigh on global stocks
Global stock markets have slumped as President Donald Trump's bellicose remarks on North Korea prompted investors to unload shares in companies that have been on the rise
8:31AM ( 4 hours ago )
Downward dog meet jumping goat: Goats invade yoga classes
Yoga classes are inserting curious and silly goats into normally calm yoga sessions
7:02AM ( 6 hours ago )
Trump administration urged to avoid salmon protection rules
Pro-industry environmental decisions by the Trump administration are giving hope to a group that represents farmers in the Pacific Northwest
5:31PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
The Latest: Possibly tainted eggs found in more countries
Reports of possibly tainted eggs linked to the pesticide scandal in the Netherlands and Belgium are cropping up in several countries
10:33AM ( 1 day ago )
Extreme heat in Europe decimating crops and stoking drought
Authorities and experts are warning that extremely hot and dry summer this year in the Balkans has decimated crops, dried rivers and hurt the animal world
10:16AM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: More possibly tainted eggs found in Britain
British food safety authorities say far more eggs tainted with the pesticide Fipronil have been imported to the United Kingdom than previously thought, but say the number is a tiny fraction of the number of eggs consumed each year in the country
9:38AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Agriculture
Egg executives in salmonella case must report to prison
A father and son whose Iowa-based egg production company caused a massive 2010 salmonella outbreak have exhausted their appeals and a federal judge has ordered them to begin serving prison sentences
12:59PM ( 1 month ago )
Tyson adopting video checks, animal rights groups want more
Tyson Foods has unveiled a plan to stop abuses down on the farm, but an animal rights group says monitoring slaughterhouses with video cameras won't stop other cruelty that exists within the poultry industry
6:00PM ( 1 month ago )
China, US reach agreement on beef, poultry and natural gas
China and US reach agreement on beef, poultry and liquefied natural gas
5:25AM ( 2 months ago )
AP Business - Poultry & Egg
The Latest: Report: Egg scandal suspect denies involvement
Dutch media are reporting that a suspect in Europe's contaminated egg scandal
12:57PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Los Angeles poised to take another step toward 2028 Games
The city appears poised to take another step toward bringing the 2028 Olympics to Los Angeles, despite questions about future costs
12:57PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Lions, tigers, bears from war-torn Syria evacuated to Jordan
Animals trapped in harsh conditions in zoo in war-torn Syrian city of Aleppo evacuated to a wildlife reserve in Jordan
12:56PM ( 34 minutes ago )
The Latest: Dem wants legislation prohibiting nuclear strike
A Democratic congressman wants the House to reconvene from its summer recess to consider legislation prohibiting a pre-emptive nuclear strike against North Korea.
12:54PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Resistance leaders play long game, dismiss impeachment talk
The anti-Trump resistance movement leaders say they have little interest in clamoring for the president's impeachment over his campaign's ties to Russia
12:45PM ( 45 minutes ago )