Sunday July 22nd, 2018 5:59PM

First safe repair of disease-causing gene in human embryos

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — Altering human heredity? In a first, researchers safely repaired a disease-causing gene in human embryos, targeting a heart defect best known for killing young athletes — a big step toward one day preventing a list of inherited diseases.

In a surprising discovery, a research team led by Oregon Health and & Science University reported Wednesday that embryos can help fix themselves if scientists jump-start the process early enough.

It's laboratory research only, nowhere near ready to be tried in a pregnancy. But it suggests that scientists might alter DNA in a way that protects not just one baby from a disease that runs in the family, but his or her offspring as well. And that raises ethical questions.

"I for one believe, and this paper supports the view, that ultimately gene editing of human embryos can be made safe. Then the question truly becomes, if we can do it, should we do it?" said Dr. George Daley, a stem cell scientist and dean of Harvard Medical School. He wasn't involved in the new research and praised it as "quite remarkable."

"This is definitely a leap forward," agreed developmental geneticist Robin Lovell-Badge of Britain's Francis Crick Institute.

Today, couples seeking to avoid passing on a bad gene sometimes have embryos created in fertility clinics so they can discard those that inherit the disease and attempt pregnancy only with healthy ones, if there are any.

Gene editing in theory could rescue diseased embryos. But so-called "germline" changes — altering sperm, eggs or embryos — are controversial because they would be permanent, passed down to future generations. Critics worry about attempts at "designer babies" instead of just preventing disease, and a few previous attempts at learning to edit embryos, in China, didn't work well and, more importantly, raised safety concerns.

In a series of laboratory experiments reported in the journal Nature, the Oregon researchers tried a different approach.

They targeted a gene mutation that causes a heart-weakening disease, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, that affects about 1 in 500 people. Inheriting just one copy of the bad gene can cause it.

The team programmed a gene-editing tool, named CRISPR-Cas9, that acts like a pair of molecular scissors to find that mutation — a missing piece of genetic material.

Then came the test. Researchers injected sperm from a patient with the heart condition along with those molecular scissors into healthy donated eggs at the same time. The scissors cut the defective DNA in the sperm.

Normally cells will repair a CRISPR-induced cut in DNA by essentially gluing the ends back together. Or scientists can try delivering the missing DNA in a repair package, like a computer's cut-and-paste program.

Instead, the newly forming embryos made their own perfect fix without that outside help, reported Oregon Health & Science University senior researcher Shoukhrat Mitalipov.

We all inherit two copies of each gene, one from dad and one from mom — and those embryos just copied the healthy one from the donated egg.

"The embryos are really looking for the blueprint," Mitalipov, who directs OHSU's Center for Embryonic Cell and Gene Therapy, said in an interview. "We're finding embryos will repair themselves if you have another healthy copy."

It worked 72 percent of the time, in 42 out of 58 embryos. Normally a sick parent has a 50-50 chance of passing on the mutation.

Previous embryo-editing attempts in China found not every cell was repaired, a safety concern called mosaicism. Beginning the process before fertilization avoided that problem: Until now, "everybody was injecting too late," Mitalipov said.

Nor did intense testing uncover any "off-target" errors, cuts to DNA in the wrong places, reported the team, which also included researchers from the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in California and South Korea's Institute for Basic Science. None of the embryos was allowed to develop beyond eight cells, a standard for laboratory research.

Genetics and ethics experts not involved in the work say it's a critical first step — but just one step — toward eventually testing the process in pregnancy, something currently prohibited by U.S. policy.

"This is very elegant lab work," but it's moving so fast that society needs to catch up and debate how far it should go, said Johns Hopkins University bioethicist Jeffrey Kahn.

And lots more research is needed to tell if it's really safe, added Britain's Lovell-Badge.

"What we do not want is for rogue clinicians to start offering treatments" that are unproven like has happened with some other experimental technologies, he stressed.

Among key questions: Would the technique work if mom, not dad, harbored the mutation? Is repair even possible if both parents pass on a bad gene?

Mitalipov is "pushing a frontier," but it's responsible basic research that's critical for understanding embryos and disease inheritance, noted University of Pittsburgh professor Kyle Orwig.

In fact, Mitalipov said the research should offer critics some reassurance: If embryos prefer self-repair, it would be extremely hard to add traits for "designer babies" rather than just eliminate disease.

"All we did is un-modify the already mutated gene."


This Associated Press series was produced in partnership with the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Health - Children's Health, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Hundreds show up for jobs at Amazon warehouses in US cities
Hundreds of people are showing up Wednesday for a chance to pack and ship products to Amazon customers, as the e-commerce company holds a giant job fair at nearly a dozen U.S. warehouses.
1:20PM ( 1 minute ago )
Trump signs 'seriously flawed' Russia sanctions bill
White House officials say that President Donald Trump has signed a bill to impose new sanctions on Russia
1:09PM ( 13 minutes ago )
The Latest: 2 US troops killed in Afghanistan convoy attack
The Pentagon says two U.S. service members were killed in an attack on a NATO convoy near Kandarhar in southern Afghanistan
1:06PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Election company says manipulation in Venezuela vote turnout
The CEO of the voting technology company Smartmatic says results of Venezuela's election for an all-powerful constituent assembly were tampered with and off by at least 1 million votes
12:33PM ( 49 minutes ago )
The Latest: Venezuela congress chief calls for vote probe
The president of Venezuela's opposition-controlled National Assembly says the legislature will call for a probe of claims that the official turnout figure in Sunday's election was tampered with and there was a discrepancy of at least 1 million votes
12:24PM ( 58 minutes ago )
Sessions: US prosecutors will help addiction-ravaged cities
Attorney General Jeff Sessions says the Justice Department will dispatch 12 federal prosecutors to cities ravaged by addiction
12:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Lawsuit: Investigator claims Fox News made up quotes
A new lawsuit lays out a conspiracy that allegedly involved Trump allies, the White House and Fox News
10:47AM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Italy seizes rescue boat in immigration probe
Italian authorities are holding a German group's migrant rescue boat suspected of aiding "clandestine immigration"
10:44AM ( 2 hours ago )
Poland eyes demanding WWII reparations from Germany
A ruling party official says Poland is analyzing whether to demand reparations from Germany for the massive losses inflicted on Poland during World War II
10:22AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Court complicates Trump's threat to cut 'Obamacare' funds
President Trump's bold threat to push 'Obamacare' into collapse may get harder to carry out after a new court ruling
12:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
German automakers to give 5 million diesel cars new software
Germany's transport minister says the country's automakers have committed to fit over 5 million diesel cars in the country with updated software to reduce harmful emissions and to finance incentives for drivers to trade in older models
12:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
After health vote, governor calls Maine senators 'dangerous'
Maine Gov. Paul LePage has some choice words for the state's senators after their health care vote, calling fellow Republican Susan Collins and independent Angus King "dangerous."
12:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Health
Top Senate Dem: Trump threat against health funds 'childish'
The Senate's top Democrat is accusing President Donald Trump of petty and childish behavior for threatening to halt federal payments that help millions afford health coverage
12:43PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Dem says Trump insurer payment threat childish
The Senate's top Democrat says President Donald Trump's threats to block federal payments to insurers are "not frankly what an adult does" and would boost consumers' premiums
12:04PM ( 1 day ago )
Mets agree to send reliever Reed to Red Sox for 3 prospects
The Mets have agreed to trade reliever Addison Reed to the Boston Red Sox for three 22-year-old right-handed pitching prospects, a deal contingent on the teams approving medical records of the players involved
2:13PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Health - Children's Health
Burr-Hamilton? Angry lawmaker singles out 'female senators'
A Republican congressman says his comments about wanting to duel female senators who oppose health care reform were intended to be tongue in cheek.
7:06PM ( 1 week ago )
The Latest: Lawmaker blames female senators for failed bill
A Texas Republican congressman is blaming "some female senators from the Northeast" for blocking the GOP health care bill.
1:32PM ( 1 week ago )
The Latest: GOP lawmaker singles out 'some female senators'
A Texas Republican congressman is blaming "some female senators from the Northeast" for blocking the GOP health care bill.
1:24PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Trump signs 'seriously flawed' Russia sanctions bill
White House officials say that President Donald Trump has signed a bill to impose new sanctions on Russia
1:09PM ( 13 minutes ago )
The Latest: 2 US troops killed in Afghanistan convoy attack
The Pentagon says two U.S. service members were killed in an attack on a NATO convoy near Kandarhar in southern Afghanistan
1:06PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Ken Wilkinson, Battle of Britain Spitfire pilot, dies at 99
Ken Wilkinson, one of the last surviving Spitfire pilots who flew in the Battle of Britain, has died
1:03PM ( 18 minutes ago )
St. Louis officer unique in opting for trial without a jury
The fate of a former St. Louis police officer accused of killing a suspect rests with a judge, not a jury of his peers, and experts say that given the public scrutiny of police shootings, Jason Stockley's decision to opt for a bench trial makes sense.
1:03PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Romania observes deaths of thousands of Roma in Holocaust
Romania has commemorated the Roma Holocaust to mark the deaths of thousands of Gypsies at a Nazi concentration camp
12:47PM ( 35 minutes ago )