Thursday February 22nd, 2018 9:41AM

Arizona flash flood kills 9 relatives celebrating birthday

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

TONTO NATIONAL FOREST, Ariz. (AP) — The flash flood that killed nine people in an Arizona river canyon began its deadly descent as an impressive but avoidable surge of churning water, black with cinders from a recent wildfire and choked with tumbling tree trunks and limbs.

By the time it reached a rocky swimming hole several miles downstream, it was a roaring torrent 6 feet (1.8 meters) high, and an extended family celebrating a birthday while seeking refuge from the summer heat had no warning — and no chance to escape.

The bodies were found up to 2 miles (3 kilometers) away. Five other people were rescued, some of them clinging desperately to trees, and were treated for hypothermia and released.

As rescuers searched Monday for a 27-year-old man still missing about 100 miles (160 kilometers) northeast of Phoenix, authorities identified the victims, who ranged in age from 2 to 60.

Among them were three generations of a family. Five of the dead were children.

The victims had been lounging Saturday in the swimming hole, where rocks create pools and a series of small waterfalls. There the river narrows, squeezing the flow of water and increasing its deadly force.

The river roared to life after a thunderstorm had dumped up to 1.5 inches (3.8 centimeters) of rain in an hour, prompting a flash-flood warning from the National Weather Service.

Though the service sent out a flash-flood warning over cellphone networks, service in the remote area is patchy at best. Unless they had a weather radio, the swimmers would have been unaware.

"They had no warning. They heard a roar, and it was on top of them," said Fire Chief Ron Sattelmaier of the Water Wheel Fire and Medical District.

Carrie Templin, a spokesman for the Tonto National Forest, said people headed to the forest should check weather alerts ahead of time to determine whether it's safe. It is hard to predict where rain will fall in the desert Southwest, and people should know that heavy downpours can cause flash flooding, Templin said.

One hiker who was stranded by the flood said she can't get the sound of the rushing water out of her head.

Nancy Coto, 17, said she was stuck for four hours on a slab of rock with her boyfriend and his family before they were able to walk out.

"We're all just saying that we got blessed, but I don't like to use that word because other families weren't blessed," Coto said. "Children died."

About 40 volunteer workers and four search dogs looked for the missing man, whom authorities identified as Hector Garnica.

The search was suspended late Monday afternoon by an approaching thunderstorm, but was scheduled to resume at dawn Tuesday weather-permitting.

Detective David Hornung of the Gila County Sheriff's Office said more dogs and crews from around the state would be joining the search.

There still is hope Garnica would be found alive, he said. "I've seen miracles happen before," Hornung said.

Garnica had come to celebrate his wife's birthday with their three children and other family. All were among those killed.

Authorities and a family member identified the dead as 2-year-old Erica Raya-Garcia; Emily Garnica, 3; Mia Garnica, 5; Danial Garnica, 7; and Jonathan Leon, 13. Also killed were Javier Raya-Garcia, 19; Celia Garcia Castaneda, 60; Maribel Raya-Garcia, 24; and 26-year-old Maria Raya-Garcia, Hector Garnica's wife.

The group went up the mountain early Saturday, said Tom Price, the general manager at The Horny Toad, a restaurant where Hector Garnica worked.

Garnica's parents were eating at the restaurant in a Phoenix suburb Saturday night when they got a call that something had happened, Price said.

"Very tight knit," he said of the family. "They're just extremely close."

About 5 miles up the mountain from where the family was relaxing Saturday, Scott Muller spotted the water rumbling down the nearly dry East Verde River.

Muller was spending the day with a dozen other members of AZ Krawlers, a volunteer group of Jeep owners that was checking dirt roads and trails for dangerous erosion and missing signs.

It was an area where a June wildfire burned 11 square miles of the Tonto National Forest. Flooding is worse after a wildfire because the scorched land repels water and the lack of vegetation makes soil unstable.

Muller began making a video with his phone from the river bed, and comfortably scampered to the bank before water clogged with debris whooshed past. The river was wide enough that the water was not the inescapable wall it became downstream.

"We had no idea how fast and big it was going to be," Muller said.

Muller and the others rushed down the mountain on a fire control road to get another look at a phenomenon notorious in the West which they had not seen. Flash floods killed seven hikers in Utah in 2015; 11 hikers died in Arizona in 1997 after a wall of water swept through a narrow, twisting series of walls on Navajo land.

Emerging onto a paved road, the group drove up to a bridge that was about a mile below where the waters would sweep through the swimming hole.

There, Muller said, they warned a couple with two young children playing in the placid river to get out because the river would soon become a monster.

Several minutes later, he said, it did.

Neither Muller nor the group's leader, Ken Maki, said they knew of the swimming hole.

They didn't learn of the deaths until that night.


Hartounian reported from Phoenix. Contributing were Justin Pritchard and Michael Balsamo in Los Angeles, Clarice Silber in Cave Creek, Arizona, Angie Wang in Tonto National Forest and Jacques Billeaud in Phoenix.


This story has been corrected to show that the victims ranged in age from 2 to 60, not 3 to 57.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Basketball, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, College Sports, AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Arizona flash flood kills 9 relatives celebrating birthday
Authorities say nine members of an extended family killed by a flash flood at an Arizona swimming hole had no warning until the wall of water was upon them
9:03PM ( 6 minutes ago )
The Latest: Cousin fondly remembers flood-victim couple
The 17-year-old relative of the husband-and-wife victims of flash flooding in Arizona as warm and generous with their money and time
8:34PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Arizona flash flood killed large family celebrating birthday
Authorities say nine people killed by a flash flood at a swimming hole along an Arizona canyon had almost no warning
8:30PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Relatives demand answers in fatal Minnesota police shooting
Relatives and neighbors of an Australian woman who was fatally shot by Minneapolis police over the weekend demanded answers Monday about her death
7:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
LEADING OFF: Kershaw, Dodgers roll, Colon makes Twins debut
LEADING OFF: Kershaw, Dodgers roll, Colon makes Twins debut
7:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
Pirates OF Starling Marte humbled in return from suspension
Starling Marte insists he still isn't sure exactly how the illegal steroid that cost the Pittsburgh Pirates outfielder an 80-game suspension got into his system
6:56PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Sports
Flood victims 'heard a roar, and it was on top of them'
Authorities say the nine people killed by a flash flood at a swimming hole along an Arizona canyon had almost no warning
5:12PM ( 3 hours ago )
New Knicks regime open to moving on with or without Carmelo
The New York Knicks' new regime is ready to move on with or without Carmelo Anthony
4:14PM ( 4 hours ago )
5 children among 9 relatives killed in Arizona flash flood
Five children were among the nine people killed during the weekend in a flash flood at a swimming hole in Arizona's Tonto National Forest and all were part of an extended family
3:46PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Basketball
Ex-Texas officer indicted on murder charge in teen's death
Former police officer indicted on murder charge in shooting death of black teenager who was leaving a party in suburban Dallas
7:39PM ( 1 hour ago )
Anti-abortion-rights activist found in contempt over videos
A federal judge has found an anti-abortion activist known for clandestine videos of abortion-rights supporters in contempt of court
7:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Search suspended for man missing in floodwaters
The search for a 27-year-old man still missing after a flash flood in central Arizona has been suspended due to a severe thunderstorm moving into the area
7:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Health plan hinges on the young, but they're a tough sell
Young and healthy, Julian Senn-Raemont isn't convinced he needs to buy health insurance when he loses coverage under his dad's plan in a couple of years
5:52PM ( 3 hours ago )
Afghan girls robotics team competes after visa obstacles
A robotics team of six girls from Afghanistan is competing in an international competition in Washington, after clearing visa obstacles that prompted intervention from President Donald Trump
5:24PM ( 3 hours ago )
White House briefing is off-camera again
A must-see event of the early Trump administration, the White House briefing, is off-camera again
5:15PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Riley's 'whirlwind' to youngest FBS head coach with Sooners
Lincoln Riley's 'whirlwind' to youngest FBS head coach with Sooners
4:13PM ( 4 hours ago )
Bowlsby feels good about Big 12 despite negative perceptions
Big 12 Commissioner Bob Bowlsby feels good about what the 10-team Power Five league is doing
1:37PM ( 7 hours ago )
Key events in OJ Simpson's fall from sports hero, movie star
O.J. Simpson's story represents one of the most dramatic falls from grace in the history of American pop culture
12:21PM ( 8 hours ago )
College Sports
Hall of Fame coach assists cast in play about recruiting
Jim Calhoun has gone from walking the hardwood of a basketball court to treading the boards at the Eugene O'Neill Theater Complex, not as an actor, but as a technical adviser
11:53AM ( 5 days ago )
Miller forming Indiana schedule after Big Ten decision
Archie Miller's trickiest summer job might be piecing together Indiana's schedule
7:18PM ( 6 days ago )
Gordon Hayward chooses Celtics over Jazz, Heat
Gordon Hayward has chosen to sign with the Boston Celtics, and leave the Utah Jazz after seven seasons
8:59PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
The Latest: Cousin fondly remembers flood-victim couple
The 17-year-old relative of the husband-and-wife victims of flash flooding in Arizona as warm and generous with their money and time
8:34PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Arizona flash flood killed large family celebrating birthday
Authorities say nine people killed by a flash flood at a swimming hole along an Arizona canyon had almost no warning
8:30PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Venezuela opposition calls strike, Trump threatens 'actions'
Venezuelan opposition leaders are calling for a nationwide strike after more than 7 million people rejected a government plan to rewrite the constitution and consolidate its power
8:24PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Qatar: Alleged UAE hacking 'unfortunate,' violation of law
Qatar says the reported involvement of the United Arab Emirates in hacking its government news site in May is "unfortunate" and a breach of agreements among the Gulf countries
8:17PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Brexit talks begin in earnest with citizens' rights in focus
The European Union and Britain kick off their first full session of their divorce proceedings with both sides bent on seeking a quick breakthrough on unraveling ties that have bound them for decades
8:16PM ( 54 minutes ago )